
The subject of fare-free transit has long been of interest and its efficacy remains debated today in communities both large and small. While experiments with free fares conducted in Trenton, New Jersey; Denver, Colorado; and Austin, Texas in the late 1970s and late 1980s did not result in permanent establishment of such policies in those jurisdictions, a surprising number of fare-free transit systems (at least 39) operate in the United States today. This paper identifies and classifies the communities that operate completely fare-free transit systems and summarizes the experiences these communities have had with such systems. These transit systems invariably are located in one of three types of communities: 1. Small urban areas 2. Resort communities and 3. University-dominated communities. Fare-free transit agencies have done well in these settings where a good business case can be made for offering such service, regardless of what end of the political spectrum these communities might represent. These communities have experienced ridership increases ranging from 21% to over 200% and most regard their fare-free transit systems as vital community assets. However, the largest community in the United States to offer completely fare-free service has a population of only 175,000. Larger cities that have explored instituting such a fare policy have not been able to identify a reliable source of funds to replace the fares collected.
The objective of this synthesis was to document the state of the practice in terms of experiences related to the application of proof-of-payment (PoP) on transit systems in North America and internationally, updating the information provided in the 2002 TCRP Report 80, Toolkit for Self-Service, Barrier-Free Fare Collection. The subject is more complex than evasion rates. It involves related subjects such as inspection rates, enforcement techniques, duties of fare inspection personnel, adjudication processes, and the kinds of penalties involved for evasion. In addition, there is the need for acquiring capital equipment and, perhaps, handheld verification devices if smartcards are used. PoP fare collection has evolved to where it can be found on bus rapid transit, regular bus service, heavy rail transit, streetcars, passenger ferries, and commuter rail. A literature review, organized into five issue groupings related to PoP fare collection, is provided, as well as the results of a selected, on-line survey of transit agencies in the United States and Canada that yielded a 100% response rate (33 of 33 responses). Seven case studies offer detailed reviews of transit agency PoP fare collection experiences in Buffalo and New York City, New York; Dallas, Texas; Los Angeles and San Francisco, California; Minneapolis, Minnesota; and Phoenix, Arizona. Six areas deserving future study are identified as well.
This synthesis updates TCRP Synthesis of Transit Practice 4, Integration of Bicycles and Transit. Since that report's publication in 1994, there has been significant growth in bicycle and transit services. Therefore, this synthesis reflects the additional knowledge gained by transit agencies in the past 10 years about integrating bicycles and transit. It documents many different types of transit agencies in the United States and Canada. This topic is of interest to transit agencies of all sizes and locations; state, regional, and local transportation policymakers; and elected officials. It is also of interest to bicycle and transit planners and advocates. The experiences that are documented can help transit agencies improve existing services and assist other communities in developing new bicycle and transit services. An online survey was conducted to gather feedback from transit agencies that currently offer or are considering providing bicycle services. Follow-up interviews were done to gather additional information about one or more of their transit services. Based on this detailed information, topical case studies were developed and included throughout the report.
This report of the Transportation Research Board will be of interest to transit staff concerned with implementing diversity training initiatives at their agencies. Both established and newer agencies might use the synthesis to review efforts underway in both the public and private sectors. The purpose is to document the experiences of selected public transportation agencies, as well as experiences in other industries. This synthesis offers examples of initiatives underway. Appendices detail specific transit agency survey responses and examples of training documents. This document integrates information from a search of available literature with survey responses obtained from staff at 22 transit agencies across the country. Case study information was collected from 10 agencies.
This synthesis will be of interest to transit agency professionals and the consultants who work with them in dealing with flexible funding opportunities. The purpose is to provide greater familiarity with emerging techniques in the use of flexible funding, and to point out issues that may need further attention. It is intended to provide a review of how current flexible funding provisions are being used to support transit investment and to examine, through a limited number of specific experiences, lessons that may have the broadest relevance throughout the transit industry. The scope of the synthesis includes references to summary Federal Transit Administration (FTA) data from FY 1992-2000, spanning the entire life of the Intermodal Surface Transportation Efficiency Act (ISTEA) legislation and the first 3 years of the Transportation Equity Act for the 21st Century (TEA-21). This document integrates information from a literature and database review with survey responses and telephone interview responses of key staff at the U.S. Department of Transportation, and a limited sample of state departments of transportation, regional Metropolitan Planning Organizations, and transit authorities. The survey and telephone responses are intended to provide qualitative information about the process, experience, and barriers encountered in exercising flexible funding provisions that is not obvious in other available data.