
Jhering's intellectual transformation from formalism to realism - manifested as a methodological transition from his early adherence to `conceptual jurisprudence' to his later advocacy of `teleological jurisprudence' - constitutes a profound response to the political and social upheavals of nineteenth-century Germany. In his early thought, Jhering maintained that legal formalism could effectively resist political arbitrariness and safeguard individual liberty, thereby providing the foundation for a lawful liberal state. He sought to replace the absence of constitutional governance with a systematic and autonomous science of private law that would secure a `system of freedom'. However, amid the unification wars and Bismarck's Realpolitik, Jhering came to recognize that rigid legal forms often proved inadequate to address the complexities of social and political reality. Consequently, he began to emphasize the role of `powerful personalities' and political decision-making, contending that in states of emergency, necessary acts of will could compensate for the limitations of legal form. Nevertheless, Jhering did not abandon his earlier ideals; he remained acutely wary of unchecked political power and insisted that such decisions must be justified and strictly constrained. Throughout his oeuvre, Jhering sought to reconcile form and will by advocating the institutionalization of political decision-making within a normative legal order. He underscored that freedom must be realized through the law and called upon political actors to embody classical virtues to ensure the legitimacy and moral integrity of their decisions.
In the shadow of Paris, Belgian publishers built a remarkable industry: the mass reprinting of French literary and legal works. This article examines the phenomenon of Belgian contrefacon-the systematic reprinting of French works between 1815 and 1854. In the absence of international copyright conventions, Belgian publishers lawfully reproduced French texts, selling them at a fraction of Parisian prices across Europe and the Americas. The article distinguishes reprinting (r & eacute;impression) from counterfeiting in the criminal sense, demonstrating that Belgian practice operated within the legal framework of the era. Drawing on the works of Dopp, Hen, Hellemans, and Verbeke, the study analyses the industry's institutional structure, its patronage by Belgium's political and judicial elite, and its suppression through the bilateral convention of 22 August 1852. The article identifies a significant gap in existing scholarship: the extent to which Belgian editorial modifications to reprinted French legal treatises may have influenced the transnational reception of French legal thought.
D. 9,2,51 Iul. 86 dig. is one of the best known texts in Justinian's Digest, appearing near to the end of title 9,2 on the lexAquilia concerning damage to property. In it, the jurist Julian poses a hypothetical case in which two assailants each mortally wound a slave in separate incidents, culminating in the slave's death. The question arises concerning the attackers' liability under chapter one of the lex Aquilia for wrongful killing (`occi-dere'). Julian's ruling is that both should be liable to the direct statutory action. At the end of the text, he goes on to state that many solutions have been accepted by the civil law, contrary to dialectical argumentation (`contra rationem disputandi') for the common good (`pro utilitate communi'). This contribution situates Julian's approach to this problem in the context of Hellenistic philosophy, especially the branch of philosophy called dialectic that covered the field of formal logic and contained within it specific problems concerning the truth value of statements. My general thesis is that the positions taken by Julian in D. 9,2,51 and related texts are internally consistent if understood through the lens of dialectic, particularly the ancient theories concerning the truth value of statements.
It is generally assumed the text of CJ 1,4,7, a law on episcopal adjudication, was issued by Arcadius as part of a larger legislative action on the 27th of July AD 398 at Mnizus. Paul Kruger's critical edition of Justinian's Code is primarily responsible for this assumption gaining traction. Through an exploration of the (lacking) manuscript evidence and earlier humanist editions of the Code, notably that of Gregorius Haloander, this article stresses both the place Mnizus and promulgation by Arcadius are in fact assumptions. Similarly, Kruger's claim that CJ 1,4,7 was also part of the Theodosian Code lacks direct evidence. With an investigation of the sources the article seeks to highlight the as of yet unresolved textual problems and strengthen the basis for further legal analysis.
The notion that public legislation existed during the obscure period preceding the Twelve Tables is a subject of intense debate in Roman legal and historical scholarship. This paper seeks to explore the existence of public statutes during the fifth and sixth centuries BCE. It does not aim to examine the individual, often enigmatic, figures of Rome's early kings or the specific laws attributed to them, but rather the general concept and plausibility of written legislation predating the Twelve Tables.