Many microtubule-associated proteins (MAPs) function under mechanical loads. Among them, motor proteins and passive couplers link microtubules with other cytoskeletal filaments, membranous structures and diverse scaffolds to enable cell shape changes, locomotion and other important processes. A key kinetochore complex, NDC80, transmits forces from microtubule disassembly to chromosome motion during cell division. Recently, this complex has been shown to detach from microtubules more easily when pulled toward the minus-end of the microtubule than when pulled in the plus-end direction. Here, we used coarse-grained molecular dynamics and Brownian dynamics simulations to explain the asymmetric effect of the directional load on the unbinding of the NDC80 complex from microtubules and then generalized our findings to other MAPs. We found that the lever arm created by the stiff stalk of NDC80 tilted toward the plus-end of the microtubule is critical for asymmetric unbinding of this complex, similar to that of dynein. In contrast, EB-proteins, the microtubule crosslinker PRC1, and kinesins are predicted to lack pronounced unbinding asymmetry, either due to their almost perpendicular anchorage to the microtubule wall or due to the high flexibility of their linker regions proximal to the microtubule-binding domains. Thus, our study highlights some of the design principles of MAPs, explaining how their distal parts can impart, modulate or eliminate the dependence of unbinding on the direction of external loads. This information deepens our understanding of the load-bearing properties and functions of diverse MAPs and may guide the design of synthetic protein systems with predefined mechanical characteristics. ### Competing Interest Statement The authors have declared no competing interest.
Tubulins are among the most successful targets for cancer chemotherapy. However, the emergence of drug resistance stimulates the continuous search for novel chemotherapeutics. Here, we discover that coumarin-30, a widely available laser dye, binds to the colchicine site of tubulin and inhibits microtubule dynamics and cancer cell division at submicromolar concentrations. By combining coumarin-30 as a fluorescent probe with the microscale thermophoresis approach, we develop a versatile assay for detecting tubulin–ligand interactions and simultaneously sorting ligands into binders of the colchicine site versus other protein pockets. The assay’s performance is demonstrated on a wide panel of compounds. Using this methodology, we identify several potent tubulin polymerization inhibitors and determine their binding sites. The results are verified with studies of microtubule dynamics in vitro and the cell cycle in cancer cell culture. Thus, the coumarin-30-based assay is a fast, accurate, and cost-effective method for characterizing tubulin ligands with diverse binding pockets.
Tubulins are among the most successful targets for cancer chemotherapy. However, the emergence of drug resistance stimulates the continuous search for novel chemotherapeutics. We discovered that coumarin‐30, a widely available laser dye, binds to the colchicine site of tubulin, inhibiting microtubule dynamics and cancer cell division at submicromolar concentrations. Exploiting the excellent fluorescent properties of coumarin‐30, we developed a fast, accurate, and cost‐effective coumarin‐30‐based microscale thermophoresis (C‐MST) assay as an express method for detecting tubulin–ligand interactions and discriminating colchicine site binders from ligands targeting other protein pockets. Using this assay, we identified several potent tubulin polymerization inhibitors associating with the colchicine site and validated them through in vitro microtubule dynamics and cell cycle assays in cancer cells. Furthermore, the C‐MST assay was demonstrated to detect ligands targeting a novel binding site on tubulin, recently established through crystallographic fragment screening. We confirmed detection of a small‐molecule ligand targeting that site and further designed and characterized a series of its analogs. The ability of the C‐MST assay to detect tubulin binders regardless of their binding site or their effect on microtubule dynamics opens new avenues for developing unconventional modulators of tubulin–tubulin and tubulin–effector interactions thereby facilitating anticancer drug discovery.
Centrioles are microtubule-based organelles required for the formation of centrosomes and cilia. Centriolar microtubules, unlike their cytosolic counterparts, are stable and grow very slowly, but the underlying mechanisms are poorly understood. Here, we reconstituted in vitro the interplay between the proteins that cap distal centriole ends and control their elongation: CP110, CEP97, and CPAP/SAS-4. We found that whereas CEP97 does not bind to microtubules directly, CP110 autonomously binds microtubule plus ends, blocks their growth, and inhibits depolymerization. Cryo-electron tomography revealed that CP110 associates with the luminal side of microtubule plus ends and suppresses protofilament flaring. CP110 directly interacts with CPAP, which acts as a microtubule polymerase that overcomes CP110-induced growth inhibition. Together, the two proteins impose extremely slow processive microtubule growth. Disruption of CP110-CPAP interaction in cells inhibits centriole elongation and increases incidence of centriole defects. Our findings reveal how two centriolar cap proteins with opposing activities regulate microtubule plus-end elongation and explain their antagonistic relationship during centriole formation.
Here we explored new 1,5-disubstituted pyrrolidin-2-ones 1, 2 and 5-aryl-3,3a,4,5-tetrahydropyrrolo[1,2-a]quinoline-1(2H)-ones 3 as inhibitors of tubulin polymerization. We evaluated their effects on microtubule dynamics in vitro and on the proliferation of A549 cells, using flow cytometry-based cell cycle analysis. The results were verified with phase-contrast microscopy in three cancer cell lines: A549, HeLa and MCF-7. Guided by molecular modeling of the interactions between tubulin and the most active of the identified compounds, we designed, synthesized, and tested the 3-hydroxyphenyl-substituted compound 3c. This compound was further shown to bind to the colchicine site of tubulin and reduce microtubule growth rates in vitro. Moreover, compound 3c arrested division of the A549 cells in the low micromolar range (IC50 = 5.9 μM) and exhibited cytotoxicity against four different cell lines in the MTT assay for cell proliferation. Our findings demonstrate that 5-aryltetrahydropyrrolo[1,2-a]quinoline-1(2H)-one is a promising scaffold for the development of novel tubulin polymerization inhibitors.
Tubulins are essential proteins, which are conserved across all eukaryotic species. They polymerize to form microtubules, cytoskeletal components of paramount importance for cellular mechanics. The microtubules combine an extraordinarily high flexural rigidity and a non-equilibrium behavior, manifested in their intermittent assembly and disassembly. These chemically fueled dynamics allow microtubules to generate significant pushing and pulling forces at their ends to reposition intracellular organelles, remodel membranes, bear compressive forces, and transport chromosomes during cell division. In this article, we review classical and recent studies, which have allowed the quantification of microtubule-generated forces. The measurements, to which we owe most of the quantitative information about microtubule forces, were carried out in biochemically reconstituted systems in vitro. We also discuss how mathematical and computational modeling has contributed to the interpretations of these results and shaped our understanding of the mechanisms of force production by tubulin polymerization and depolymerization.
This special issue of Biophysical Reviews contains the materials presented at the VII Congress of Biophysicists of Russia, held from 17 to 23 April in Krasnodar. We believe that we have managed to prepare a selection of articles that well reflects the current state of biophysical science in Russia and its place in the world science. The VII Russian Congress on Biophysics was held in Krasnodar in April 2023, continuing the tradition of the series of biophysics conferences held every 4 years. The congress discussed physical principles and mechanisms of biological processes occurring at different life levels—from molecular to cellular and population levels. The results of fundamental and applied research in molecular biophysics, cell biophysics, and biophysics of complex systems were presented at plenary, sectional, and poster sessions. The works in the field of medical biophysics and neurobiology were especially widely presented. The structure and dynamics of biopolymers and fundamental mechanisms underlying the effects of physicochemical factors on biological systems, membrane, and transport processes were actively discussed. Much attention was paid to new experimental methods of biophysical research, methods of bioinformatics, computer, and mathematical modeling as necessary tools of the research at all levels of living systems. Along with fundamental problems of studying biophysical mechanisms of regulation of processes at the molecular, subcellular, and cellular levels, much attention was paid to applied research in the field of biotechnology and environmental monitoring. The Congress has formed the National Committee of Russian biophysicists.
Molecular dynamics (MD) simulation is a useful tool for understanding biological systems at the level of individual molecules and atoms. However, studying such massive biological systems as microtubules and even their constituent components (tubulin protofilaments) takes an enormous amount of processing power. In this paper, using MD calculations of individual microtubule protofilaments, we demonstrate how computational architecture and calculation options affect computing performance. When using the "GPU-resident" option in the GROMACS MD package, you may gain a fantastic computation acceleration by using the newest high-end graphics processing unit (GPU), even in conjunction with a rather outdated central processing unit (CPU). For instance, MD of the biomolecular system containing a tubulin protofilament in an explicitly specified solvent consisting of more than 300 thousand atoms can be investigated with performance of 171 ns/day at time step 2 fs when using a single-node computer with the latest CPU and GPU generation architecture (Intel Core i9-13900K and Nvidia RTX4090 respectively). Nevertheless, high performance computing platforms (e.g., the volta2 partition of "Lomonosov-2" supercomputer) can be very suitable for simulation experiments with a large number of independent calculations, such as the umbrella sampling technique. Obtained results allow one to choose the best price-performance solution to study molecular dynamics of biological systems.
Microtubules are essential cytoskeletal polymers, which exhibit stochastic transitions between assembly and disassembly, known as catastrophes and rescues. Understanding of catastrophes, rescues, and their control by drugs and microtubule associated proteins (MAPs) has been informed by in vitro reconstitutions of microtubule dynamics. In such experiments microtubules are typically observed on a flat surface of the coverslip. In contrast, we have recently proposed a modified setup in which microtubules assemble from stabilized seeds, overhanging from microfabricated pedestals, so that their dynamic extensions are fully isolated from contact with the coverslip. This assay allows to eliminate potential artifacts, which may substantially affect the frequency of microtubule rescues in vitro. Here we use the pedestal assay to study the sensitivity of microtubules to paclitaxel, one of the best-known inhibitors of microtubule dynamics. By comparing observations in the conventional and the pedestal assays, we find that microtubule dynamics are substantially more sensitive to paclitaxel when the polymers can contact the coverslip. We interpret this as a consequence of the coverslip-induced microtubule assembly perturbation, leading to formation of lattice with defects, and thereby enhancing the efficiency of paclitaxel binding to microtubules in the conventional assay. To test this idea, we use vinblastine, another small-molecule inhibitor, which had been previously shown to cause microtubule growth perturbations. We find that in the pedestal assay vinblastine sensitizes microtubules to paclitaxel to the level, observed in the conventional assay. Interestingly, a minimal fragment of MAP called CLASP2, a previously characterized rescue factor, has a strong effect on microtubule rescues, regardless of the type of assay. Overall, our study underscores the role of microtubule damage in promoting rescues and highlights the utility of the in vitro pedestal assay to study microtubule dynamics modulation by tubulin inhibitors and MAPs.
We announce a call for contributions to a Special Issue of Biophysical Reviews associated with the VII Congress of Russian Biophysicists (to be held in Krasnodar, Russia, 17–23 April 2023). The Congress is the main biophysical meeting held within Russia and is organized every four years. The Congress will focus on both the physical principles and mechanisms of biological processes occurring at different levels of structural organization, from molecular to cellular to organism and to population levels. The Special Issue will accept reviews on topics from molecular biophysics, structure and dynamics of biopolymers, biophysics of the cell, energy transformation mechanisms, biophotonics, ecological biophysics, and medical biophysics, following the sections of the Congress. The VII Congress of Russian Biophysicists is supported by International Union of Pure and Applied Biophysics (IUPAB). Here we describe main topics and sections of the coming event, the paper types for the journal issue, and the key deadline dates.
The brutal attack on Ukraine by the Russian Federation has shocked the world. While the world works to end the violence and help refugees, as a scientific journal, our thoughts are also with those in the scientific community who are directly or indirectly impacted by the war. We have been inspired by and applaud the labs around the world that have opened their doors to displaced scientists and remain committed to supporting scientists, whoever and wherever they are. Because science requires collaboration and trust, we urge the scientific community to continue efforts like this and to remain united, especially in times as difficult as these. In this Voices piece, we feature short comments from scientists from Ukraine and scientists from Russia. This small sampling is far from exhaustive, but our sincere thanks go to those scientists who were willing to share their thoughts on this volatile and emotionally charged situation; the views expressed are those of the contributors alone. We join the world in hoping for a swift resolution to the conflict, for the good of humanity.
Microtubules are essential cytoskeletal polymers that exhibit stochastic switches between tubulin assembly and disassembly. Here, we examine possible mechanisms for these switches, called catastrophes and rescues. We formulate a four-state Monte Carlo model, explicitly considering two biochemical and two conformational states of tubulin, based on a recently conceived view of microtubule assembly with flared ends. The model predicts that high activation energy barriers for lateral tubulin interactions can cause lagging of curled protofilaments, leading to a ragged appearance of the growing tip. Changes in the extent of tip raggedness explain some important but poorly understood features of microtubule catastrophe: weak dependence on tubulin concentration and an increase in its probability over time, known as aging. The model predicts a vanishingly rare frequency of spontaneous rescue unless patches of guanosine triphosphate tubulin are artificially embedded into microtubule lattice. To test our model, we used in vitro reconstitution, designed to minimize artifacts induced by microtubule interaction with nearby surfaces. Microtubules were assembled from seeds overhanging from microfabricated pedestals and thus well separated from the coverslip. This geometry reduced the rescue frequency and the incorporation of tubulins into the microtubule shaft compared with the conventional assay, producing data consistent with the model. Moreover, the rescue positions of microtubules nucleated from coverslip-immobilized seeds displayed a nonexponential distribution, confirming that coverslips can affect microtubule dynamics. Overall, our study establishes a unified theory accounting for microtubule assembly with flared ends, a tip structure–dependent catastrophe frequency, and a microtubule rescue frequency dependent on lattice damage and repair.
The importance of intramolecular constraints in cyclic transition-state geometries is especially pronounced in n-endo-tet cyclizations, where the usual backside approach of a nucleophile to the breaking bond is impossible for the rings containing less than eight atoms. Herein, we expand the limits of endo-tet cyclizations and show that donor-acceptor cyclopropanes can provide a seven-membered ring via a genuine 6-endo-tet process. Substrates containing a N-alkyl-N-arylcarbamoyl moiety as an acceptor group undergo Lewis acid-induced cyclization to form tetrahydrobenz[b]azepin-2-ones in high yields. The reaction proceeds with the inversion of the configuration at the electrophilic carbon. In this process, a formally six-membered transition state yields a seven-membered ring as the pre-existing cycle is merged into the forming ring. The stereochemistry of the products can be controlled by the reaction time and by the nature of Lewis acid, opening access to both diastereomers by tuning of the reaction conditions.
Electron cryo-microscopy (Cryo-EM) is a powerful method for visualizing biological objects with up to near-angstrom resolution. Instead of chemical fixation, the method relies on very rapid freezing to immobilize the sample. Under these conditions, crystalline ice does not have time to form and distort structure. For many practical applications, the rate of cooling is fast enough to consider sample immobilization instantaneous, but in some cases, a more rigorous analysis of structure relaxation during freezing could be essential. This difficult yet important problem has been significantly under-reported in the literature, despite spectacular recent developments in Cryo-EM. Here we use Brownian dynamics modeling to examine theoretically the possible effects of cryo-immobilization on the apparent shapes of biological polymers. The main focus of our study is on tubulin protofilaments. These structures are integral parts of microtubules, which in turn are key elements of the cellular skeleton, essential for intracellular transport, maintenance of cell shape, cell division and migration. We theoretically examine the extent of protofilament relaxation within the freezing time as a function of the cooling rate, the filament's flexural rigidity, and the effect of cooling on water's viscosity. Our modeling suggests that practically achievable cooling rates are not rapid enough to capture tubulin protofilaments in conformations that are incompletely relaxed, suggesting that structures seen by cryo-EM are good approximations to physiological shapes. This prediction is confirmed by our analysis of curvatures of tubulin protofilaments, using samples, prepared and visualized with a variety of methods. We find, however, that cryofixation may capture incompletely relaxed shapes of more flexible polymers, and it may affect Cryo-EM-based measurements of their persistence lengths. This analysis will be valuable for understanding of structures of different types of biopolymers, observed with Cryo-EM.
Microtubules are non-covalent polymers of αβ-tubulin dimers. Posttranslational processing of the intrinsically disordered C-terminal α-tubulin tail produces detyrosinated and Δ2-tubulin. Although these are widely employed as proxies for stable cellular microtubules, their effect (and of the α-tail) on microtubule dynamics remains uncharacterized. Using recombinant, engineered human tubulins, we now find that neither detyrosinated nor Δ2-tubulin affect microtubule dynamics, while the α-tubulin tail is an inhibitor of microtubule growth. Consistent with the latter, molecular dynamics simulations show the α-tubulin tail transiently occluding the longitudinal microtubule polymerization interface. The marked differential in vivo stabilities of the modified microtubule subpopulations, therefore, must result exclusively from selective effector recruitment. We find that tyrosination quantitatively tunes CLIP-170 density at the growing plus end and that CLIP170 and EB1 synergize to selectively upregulate the dynamicity of tyrosinated microtubules. Modification-dependent recruitment of regulators thereby results in microtubule subpopulations with distinct dynamics, a tenet of the tubulin code hypothesis.