Using the hairless mouse screening model presented in the companion paper(1) the aim of this study was to assess two skin decontaminating systems: Fuller's earth (FE) and Reactive Skin Decontamination Lotion (RSDL) against two extremely toxic chemical warfare agents that represent a special percutaneous hazard, sulphur mustard (SM) and O-ethyl-S-(2[di-isopropylamino]ethyl)methyl-phosphonothioate (VX). Five minutes after being exposed on the back to either 2 µL of neat sulphur mustard or 50 µg.kg(-1) of diluted VX, mice were decontaminated. Both systems were able to reduce blisters 3 days after SM exposure. However, RSDL was found to be more efficient than FE in reducing the necrosis of the epidermis and erosion. In the case of VX exposure, RSDL, whatever the ratio of decontaminant to toxicant used (RSDL 10, 20, 50), was not able to sufficiently prevent the inhibition of plasma cholinesterases taken as a surrogate marker of exposure and toxicity. Only FE reduced significantly the ChE inhibition. Some of these observations are different from our previous results obtained in domestic swine and these changes are thus discussed in the perspective of using SKH-1 hairless mice for the initial in vivo screening of decontaminants.
Exposure to lethal chemical warfare agents (CWAs) is no longer only a military issue due to the terrorist threat. Among the CWAs of concern are the organophosphorus nerve agent O-ethyl-S-(2[di-isopropylamino]ethyl)methyl-phosphonothioate (VX) and the vesicant sulfur mustard (SM). Although efficient means of decontamination are available, most of them lose their efficacy when decontamination is delayed after exposure of the bare skin. Alternatively, CWA skin penetration can be prevented by topical skin protectants. Active research in skin protection and decontamination is thus paramount. In vivo screening of decontaminants or skin protectants is usually time consuming and may be expensive depending on the animal species used. We were thus looking for a suitable, scientifically sound and cost-effective model, which is easy to handle. The euthymic hairless mouse Crl: SKH-1 (hr/hr) BR is widely used in some skin studies and has previously been described to be suitable for some experiments involving SM or SM analogs. To evaluate the response of this species, we studied the consequences of exposing male anaesthetized SKH-1 mice to either liquid VX or to SM, the latter being used in liquid form or as saturated vapours. Long-term effects of SM burn were also evaluated. The model was then used in the companion paper (Taysse et al. 1 ).
The mechanisms of epileptogenesis remain largely unknown and are probably diverse. The aim of this study was to investigate the role of focal cholinergic imbalance in epileptogenesis. To address this question, we monitored electroencephalogram (EEG) activity up to 12 weeks after the injection of a potent cholinesterase (ChE) inhibitor (soman) at different doses (0.53, 0.75, 1, 2, 2.8, 4 and 11 nmol) into the right dorsal hippocampus of C57BL/6 mice. Different parameters were used to choose the dose for a focal model of epileptogenesis (mainly electrographic patterns and peripheral ChE inhibition). The pattern of neuronal activation was studied by Fos immunohistochemistry (IHC). Brain damage was evaluated by hemalun-phloxin, neuronal nuclei antigen IHC and silver staining. Glial fibrillary acidic protein IHC was used to evaluate astroglial reaction. Finally, long-term behavioral consequences were characterized. At the highest dose (11 nmol), soman quickly evoked severe signs, including initial seizures and promoted epileptogenesis in the absence of tissue damage. With lower doses, late-onset seizures were evidenced, after 1-4 weeks depending on the dose, despite the absence of initial overt seizures and of brain damage. Only a weak astroglial reaction was observed. Following injection of 1 nmol, Fos changes were first evidenced in the ipsilateral hippocampus and then spread to extrahippocampal areas. A selective deficit in contextual fear conditioning was also evidenced two months after injection. Our data show that focal hypercholinergy may be a sufficient initial event to promote epilepsy and that major brain tissue changes (cellular damage, edema, neuroinflammation) are not necessary conditions.
Soman, an irreversible organophosphorus cholinesterase inhibitor, induces status epilepticus and, in sensitive brain areas, seizure-related brain damage (e.g. brain edema and neuronal loss). The brain metabolic disturbances associated with these events are ill known. In the present study, we thus evaluated these changes in a murine model of soman-induced status epilepticus up to 7 days after intoxication. Mice, protected by HI-6 and atropine methyl nitrate, were poisoned with soman (172μg/kg) and then sacrificed at set time points, from 1h to 7 days. Brain biopsies from the piriform cortex (Pir) and cerebellum (Cer) were analyzed by 1H HRMAS NMR spectroscopy. Spectra were then analyzed using both a supervised multivariate analysis and the QUEST procedure of jMRUI for the quantification of 17 metabolites. The multivariate analysis clearly showed the metabolic differences between a damaged structure (Pir) and a structure with less prominent changes (cerebellum) and helped to globally assess the time course of metabolic changes. Analysis of the individual metabolites showed that the major changes took place in the piriform cortex but that cerebellum was not change-free. The most prominent changes in the former were an early (1–4h) increase in alanine and acetate, a delayed increase in lactate, glycerophosphocholine and glutamine as well as a delayed decrease in myo-inositol and N-acetylaspartate. A week after poisoning, some metabolic disturbances were still present. Further research will be necessary to clarify what could be the involvement of these metabolites in physiological processes and how they might become useful surrogate markers of brain damage and repair.
Quantitation of High Resolution Magic Angle Spinning (HRMAS) Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) signals enables establishing reference metabolite profiles of ex vivo tissues. Signals are often contaminated by a background signal originating mainly from macromolecules and lipids and by residual water which hampers proper quantitation. We show that automatic quantitation of HRMAS signals, even in the presence of a background, can be achieved by the semi‐parametric algorithm QUEST based on prior knowledge of a metabolite basis‐set. The latter was quantum‐mechanically simulated with NMR‐SCOPE and requires accurate spin parameters. The region of interest of spectra is a small part of the full spectral bandwidth. Reducing the computation time inherent to the large number of data‐points is possible by using ER‐Filter in a preprocessing step. Through Monte‐Carlo studies, we analyze the performances of quantitation without and with ER‐Filtering.
Organophosphorus chemical warfare agents (nerve agents) are to be feared in military operations as well as in terrorist attacks. Among them, VX (O-ethyl-S-[2-(diisopropylamino)ethyl] methylphosphonothioate) is a low volatility liquid that represents a percutaneous as well as an inhalation hazard if aerosolized. It is a potent irreversible cholinesterase (ChE) inhibitor that causes severe signs and symptoms, including respiratory dysfunction that stems from different mechanisms. VX-induced pulmonary oedema was previously reported in dogs but mechanisms involved are not well understood, and its clinical significance remains to be assessed. An experimental model was thus developed to study VX-induced cardiovascular changes and pulmonary oedema in isoflurane-anaesthetized swine. In the course of this study, we observed a fast and unexpected rebound of plasma ChE activity following inhibition provoked by the intravenous injection of 6 and 12μgkg−1 of VX. In whole blood ChE activity, the rebound could stay unnoticed. Further investigations showed that the rebound of plasma esterase activity was neither related to spontaneous reactivation of ChE nor to VX-induced increase in paraoxonase/carboxylesterase activities. A bias in Ellman assay, haemoconcentration or severe liver cytolysis were also ruled out. All in all, these results suggest that the rebound was likely due to the release of butyrylcholinesterase into the blood stream from ChE producing organs. Nature of the organ(s) and mechanisms involved in enzyme release will need further investigations as it may represent a mechanism of defence, i.e. VX scavenging, that could advantageously be exploited.
Organophosphate (OP) nerve agents are amongst the most toxic chemicals. One of them, soman, can induce severe epileptic seizures and brain damage for which therapy is incomplete. The present study shows that pretreatment with flunarizine (Flu), a voltage-dependent calcium channel blocker, when used alone, does not produce any beneficial effect against the convulsions, neuropathology and lethality induced by soman. Flu was also tested in combination with atropine sulfate and diazepam. In this case, although only some results-reach statistical significance, an encouraging general trend toward an improvement of the anticonvulsant, neuroprotective and antilethal capacities of this classical anti-OP two-drug regimen is constantly observed. In the light of these findings, it seems premature to definitely reject (or recommend) Flu as a possible adjuvant medication against soman poisoning. Further studies are required to determine its real potential interest.
We investigated the time course of both MAP2 (microtubule-associated protein 2) levels and its phosphorylation degree in the rat hippocampus during the first 90 min following the onset of soman-induced seizures. The quantitative immunoblot analysis of hippocampal extracts revealed that MAP2 increased significantly in response to a sustained epileptic activity (from 60 min of seizure duration). In addition, intense MAP2 dephosphorylation was also observed 60 to 90 min after the onset of seizures. The possible neuropathological consequences of these two early MAP2 changes are discussed in relation to the both excessive stimulation of glutamate receptors and subsequent dendritic spine alterations occurring in hippocampal neurons soon after soman intoxication.
Crotoxin (CACB complex) is a convulsant heterodimeric neurotoxic phospholipase A(2) (PLA(2)). The role of phospholipid hydrolysis in its epileptogenic properties remains unresolved. We, thus, studied the effect of manoalide (MLD), a PLA(2) inhibitor, on the toxin catalytic activity and its central and peripheral toxicity. Incubation of crotoxin with MLD fully and irreversibly inactivated its enzymatic activity. Interestingly, crotoxin also lost its central neurotoxicity after intracerebroventricular injection and peripheral toxicity after intravenous administration. MLD-treated crotoxin prevented the high affinity binding of [125I]-radiolabeled crotoxin on rat cortex synaptic plasma membranes. Further analysis of MLD-treated crotoxin by non-denaturing PAGE and surface plasmon resonance indicated that the crotoxin complex was dissociated after MLD treatment. Although the loss of MLD-treated crotoxin peripheral neurotoxicity could not be attributed to this dissociation, the presence of free CA subunit might explain the observed competition in binding experiments. In conclusion, the dissociation of the crotoxin complex by MLD, as demonstrated in this study, did not permit to specify the role of the enzymatic activity in crotoxin epileptogenic properties. Other approaches would be required to resolve this question.
Effects of subchronic administration of huperzine A, a cholinesterase inhibitor, on spatial memory were studied in guinea pig. Spatial memory was appreciated by the Morris water maze test. At a dose of 0.25 microgram/h, inhibiting 36% of blood AChE and 14-20% of central AChE, no effect on spatial learning was found. At a dose of 1 microgram/h, inhibiting 20% of blood AChE and 14-20% of central AChE, no memory impairment was found, on the other hand, a memory enhancing effect, limited to the first day was shown. It thus appears that subchronic administration of huperzine A did not induce deleterious effects on spatial memory.
Organophosphonate (OP) nerve agents, such as soman, are potent irreversible inhibitors of central and peripheral acetylcholinesterases (AChEs). Pre-treatment of OP poisoning relies on the subchronic administration of a reversible AChE inhibitor. In the present limited study, the protective effects against soman toxicity of such compounds, i.e., the current pre-treatment pyridostigmine and huperzine, a proposed pre-treatment, are compared in primates. This is the first time primates are used to study the potential of pre-treatment with huperzine. Indeed, previous studies with huperzine used nonprimate models which are not the most appropriate for pre-treatment in humans. Each medication is given via a subcutaneous mini-osmotic pump for 6 days at a delivery rate providing about 20% inhibition of red cell AChE activity. In this trial with only four primates, huperzine selectively inhibits red cell AChE activity whereas pyridostigmine also inhibits plasma butyrylcholinesterase (BuChE). This latter may act as endogenous scavenger of OP compounds helping to confer additional protection against OPs. During intoxication, the cumulative dose of soman needed to produce convulsions and epileptic activity is 1.55-fold higher in the animals pre-treated with huperzine compared to those pre-treated with pyridostigmine. Thus, replacing PYR by HUP for a subchronic pre-treatment of primates gives them better tolerance to the epileptic effects of soman.
OP nerve agents, such as soman, are potent irreversible inhibitors of central and peripheral acetylcholinesterases. Pretreatment of OP poisoning relies on the subchronic administration of a reversible acetylcholinesterase inhibitor. In the present study, the protective effects against soman toxicity of such compounds i.e. pyridostigmine, physostigmine (alone or associated with scopolamine) or huperzine are compared in guinea-pigs instrumented for EEG recording. Each medication is given via a subcutaneous mini-osmotic pump for 6 days at a delivery rate providing about 30% maximal inhibition of red cell acetylcholinesterase activity. The animals then receive iterative injections of soman (1/3 LD50) every 10 min. With pyridostigmine, reflecting a decreased overall tolerance to the poisoning, the cumulative doses of soman producing either tremors and convulsions or seizures are lower than those found in non-pretreated intoxicated controls. On the other hand. physostigmine does not afford satisfactory protection against the early mortality after intoxication. On this specific point, physostigmine + scopolamine and huperzine. although they do not prevent the appearance of seizures, give best results. The effects of each pretreatment on acetylcholinesterase, butyrylcholinesterase and carboxylesterase (these two latter enzymes may act as endogenous scavengers of OP compounds) are also examined in vitro and in the blood of each animal during subchronic administration. Huperzine appears as a selective inhibitor of red cell acetylcholinesterase activity while pyridostigmine or physostigmine additionally inhibit plasmatic butyrylcholinesterase. Considerations about huperzine or physostigmine + scopolamine as the most appropriate candidate for the pretreatment of OP poisoning are given.
PYR, a reversible AChE inhibitor, is the current pretreatment against OP intoxication. However, PHY in the presence or absence of SCO on one side, and HUP on the other side, could be considered as potential substitutes for PYR. In the present study, the effects of the subchronic administration of these different current or potential pretreatments on the BBB permeability for blood-borne albumin and on the activity of the blood and central cholinesterases are comparatively evaluated in guinea-pigs. Altogether, although some marginal disruptions of BBB are detected, the different current or potential pretreatments studied seem to have a total innocuousness on the permeability of the BBB for proteins. Finally, at the light of its particular inhibitory effects on blood and central cholinesterases, HUP, compared to the other drugs, seems to be the optimal candidate to be used as pretreatment against OP poisoning.
The capacity of thienylcyclohexylpiperidine (TCP), a non-competitive blocker of the N-methyl-d-aspartate (NMDA) receptor, to counteract the convulsant, lethal, and neuropathological effects of 2 × LD50 of soman (an irreversible inhibitor of cholinesterase) was investigated in guinea-pigs treated by pyridostigmine and atropine sulphate. The effects of a weak dose of TCP (1 mg/kg) used in the present study globally reproduced those previously obtained with a higher dose (2.5 mg/kg; [Neurotoxicology 15 (1994) 837]): TCP was again most protective when given curatively within the first hour of soman-induced seizures. In this condition, (a) paroxysmal activity ceased in 10–20 min, (b) all the animals survived, (c) the majority of them recovered remarkably well and did not show any brain damage 24 h after the intoxication, and (d) the minimal duration of seizure activity normally required for producing soman-induced brain damage in other pharmacological environments was increased from 10 to 40 min to 80 min. Strikingly, when TCP was given 120 min after seizure onset, it failed to show any anticonvulsant activity but still provided neuroprotection in the hippocampus. The present study also gives additional evidence (see [Neurotoxicology 21 (4) (2000) 521]) that in soman poisoning, (a) the development of brain damage depends on the occurrence of ECoG seizures, (b) the topographical distribution of lesions depends on seizure duration, and (c) an increase of the relative power in the lowest (delta) frequency band might be a reliable marker of neuronal degradation. All these findings confirm that (a) glutamatergic NMDA receptors are involved in the mechanisms of soman-induced seizures and brain damage, (b) non-competitive antagonists of NMDA receptors might be promising candidates for post-treatment of soman poisoning, and (c) ECoG parameters from ECoG tracings and power spectrum might serve as useful external predictors for soman-induced neuropathological changes.
The organophosphorus (OP) compound soman is known to produce long-lasting epileptic seizure activity and associated brain damage. The present paper reviews the findings of five recent studies that tentatively established correlations between the development of soman-induced neuropathology and some subtle changes in the electrocortigraphic (ECoG) power spectrum. It is important to note that the reported experiments have been performed independently by three different teams (France, The Netherlands, USA) in various animal models (rat, guinea-pig, cynomolgus monkey) through different protocols of intoxication, pharmacological environments, and methods for ECoG spectral analysis. Despite these disparities, the five studies show that a sustained shift of ECoG power toward the lowest frequency range, i.e. the delta band, occurs within the first hours of soman-induced seizures. This early ECoG spectral change is concurrent with the first neuropathological changes in brain and is almost constantly followed, days or weeks later, by at least minimal neuropathology. Moreover, the relative contribution of delta activity to the ECoG power spectrum still remains abnormally high for 1–3 days after seizure onset, i.e. within the phase of damage maturation. On the other hand, soman-induced neuropathology was not observed in non-seizuring animals in which the delta activity was not increased above the pre-soman baseline. Similarly, no brain damage was ever shown in seizuring subjects in which the initial delta change eventually normalized after the curative administration of efficient anticonvulsant drugs such as the non-competitive antagonists of the NMDA receptor. These results, in agreement with previously published observations, strongly suggest that an increase of the relative power in the delta band might be a real-time marker of the ongoing development of soman-induced, seizure-related cerebral lesions and a reliable predictor for the final neuronal losses to come. Therefore, the monitoring of delta activity during the 24–72 h period that follows soman exposure may potentially be a useful tool to follow "on-line" the progression of brain damage and to control the neuroprotective activity of a medication. Moreover, since the method is non-invasive in man and since the above-presented results have been partly found in primates, the applicability of spectral analysis as a prognostic means in human OP poisoning ought to be seriously considered.
The present study describes the effects of pyridostigmine (PYR; 0.2 mg/kg) and atropine sulphate (AS; 5 mg/kg) on guinea-pigs intoxicated by a high dose (2xLD50) of the organophosphate compound, soman, an irreversible inhibitor of acetylcholinesterase. The medication was shown to counteract the acute respiratory distress and lethality normally produced by the intoxication. Moreover, due to the central activity of AS, soman-induced electrocorticographic (ECoG) seizure activity was either totally prevented, or reduced in duration and overall intensity. In addition, as established in the 24-hr survivors, seizure-related neuropathology was either prevented, or reduced in topographical extent and severity. An attempt to correlate our electrographic and morphological findings gives evidence that (a), the occurrence of seizure activity is the primary factor necessary for the development of acute neuropathology; (b), the duration of ECoG seizures is a secondary factor, on which the topographical distribution of brain damage finally depends; (c), the minimal duration of seizures necessary to produce 24 hr-damage in the most sensitive areas (e.g. the amygdala) is less than 70 min; (d), the overall intensity/power of epileptiform discharges is a tertiary factor which influences the severity of damage; (e), in addition, ECoG power spectral analysis suggested that an acute increase of relative power in the lower (delta) frequency band might be a real-time external marker of the starting cerebral lesions and is thus predictive for their future installation. All these data confirm the tight relationships which exist between seizure activity and neuropathology in soman poisoning, and suggest that refined, standardized analysis of electrographic parameters drawn from ECoG tracings and power spectrum might serve as a useful tool to predict the presence, localization, and severity of soman-induced brain damage.