Thermocline thermal-energy storage (TES) suffers from so-called thermocline degradation, which refers to the flattening of temperature gradients in the TES with successive charging-discharging cycles. Thermocline degradation increases the variations of the heat-transfer fluid (HTF) outflow temperatures, decreases storage utilization factors, and increases specific TES material costs. Methods that prevent or reduce thermocline degradation by changing the operation of the storage are called thermocline-control (TCC) methods. The assessment of TCC methods is the main objective of this work. Three TCC methods that were chosen for this assessment are described in this paper. Two methods, based on either extracting or injecting HTF through ports, were derived from previously published methods while the third method, based on mixing multiple HTF streams, one of which is extracted through a port, is novel. In a companion paper (Geissbühler et al., Solar Energy, submitted 2018), the three TCC methods are assessed for air and molten salt as HTF using simulations of stand-alone storages as well as storages integrated into a concentrated solar power plant.

Three thermocline-control (TCC) methods are assessed through numerical simulations for a thermal-energy storage (TES) filled with a packed bed of rocks. Two previously suggested methods are based on extracting or injecting heat-transfer fluid (HTF) through ports, while the third is a novel method based on mixing HTF streams. The assessment was carried out using simulations with a model that resolves the packed bed in one dimension. Simulations of stand-alone TES with maximum allowed outflow temperature differences of 10% at quasi-steady conditions showed that the mixing method with three ports led to the largest utilization factors - the fraction of the maximum storage capacity that is actually utilized of - 90.8% and 85.1% for molten salt (MS) and compressed air (CA) as HTF, respectively. These represent relative improvements of 38.8% and 73.4% compared to the baseline configurations without TCC. The increased utilization factors come at the expense of small decreases in the cycle exergy efficiency. For the mixing method with three ports, the exergy efficiencies were 97.3% and 95.6% for MS and CA, respectively. Simulations of a TES with MS as HTF integrated into a CSP plant operating on a Rankine steam cycle showed that TCC increases the annually averaged plant efficiency and the annual net electricity generated solely from thermal energy supplied by the TES. These results suggest that the small decreases in the exergy efficiency of the TES are outweighed by the large increases in the utilization factor.