The discovery of tubulysins sparked considerable interest due to their high cytotoxic activity against multidrug resistant tumors. Total synthesis of these complex natural products—peptidic metabolites from myxobacteria Archangium gephyra and Angiococcus disciformis —demonstrated the power of organic chemistry and paved the way for the development of simpler, more stable, and selective derivatives. Despite these significant achievements, tubulysins are not used as stand‐alone drugs due to their toxic side effects. In this study, we outline the design, synthesis, and evaluation of photoswitchable tubulysin analogues, which could be starting points for development of photopharmacological therapies aimed at addressing the toxicity challenges associated with tubulysins. The cytotoxic activity of one of the key analogues was shown to be light‐controllable. For the first time, we provide a comparative analysis of the crystal structures of both photoisomers of a diarylethene‐containing compound complexed with target proteins. This comparison enables a mechanistic explanation for the experimentally observed differences in the target binding efficiency and respective activity between the two photoisomers of the photoswitchable tubulysin analogue.
Proteolysis targeting chimeras (PROTACs) are heterobifunctional molecules that induce the degradation of proteins of interest (POIs) via the ubiquitin-proteasome pathway by recruiting E3 ligases to form a ternary complex with the POI. In this study, we rationally designed and synthesized PROTACs targeting the αβ-tubulin heterodimer, the building block of microtubules (MTs) that are essential for numerous cellular functions and represent important therapeutic targets in cancer and neurodegenerative diseases. Maytansinol, a known MT-destabilising agent, was selected as the POI ligand, functionalised and conjugated to linkers bearing cereblon or Von Hippel-Lindau ligands as E3 ligase recruiters. Four compounds were synthesized and characterized through structural, biophysical and cell biology studies to evaluate their ability to form degradation-prone tubulin-PROTAC-E3 ligase ternary complexes. We confirmed that the PROTACs effectively bind tubulin and recruit E3 ligases. Remarkably, two PROTACs exhibited cellular degradation activity, representing an important advancement in chemically inducing tubulin-E3-ligase interactions. This work integrates rational design, biophysical and structural validation, and cell-based studies to establish a robust framework for developing tubulin-targeting PROTACs, offering significant implications for basic research and therapeutic developments. ### Competing Interest Statement The authors have declared no competing interest. H2020-MSCA-ITN-2019 860070 TUBINTRAIN Swiss National Science Foundation, https://ror.org/00yjd3n13, 310030_192566
Microtubule-targeting agents (MTAs) represent a pivotal class of therapeutic compounds designed to disrupt microtubule dynamics, leading to cell cycle arrest and apoptosis in malignant cells. Nevertheless, their off-target effects on healthy, rapidly dividing cells result in significant neurotoxicity and myelosuppression. Ongoing research aims to enhance their specificity and identify novel active scaffolds to minimize adverse effects and fight drug resistance. Searching for new potential tubulin binders with a pharmacophore screening method, we identified glycybridin B as a promising natural product. Here, we report the first total synthesis of this compound via a five-step route, involving a key chalcone intermediate, along with its biological evaluation.
Cytotoxic payloads for drug conjugates suitable for directed tumor therapy need to be highly potent and require a functional group for conjugation with the homing device (antibody, peptide, or small molecule). Cryptophycins are cyclodepsipeptides that stand out from the realm of natural products due to their extraordinarily high cytotoxicity. However, the installation of a suitable conjugation handle without compromising the toxicity is highly challenging. The unit D, natively 2-hydroxyisocaproic acid (leucic acid), was envisaged as a promising attachment site based on structural information from X-ray analysis. A versatile, scalable and efficient synthetic route towards conjugable cryptophycins with modification in unit D was developed and an array of new cryptophycin analogues was synthesized. Several derivatives, especially those containing lipophilic groups with low steric demand such as alkylated amino groups, exhibit low picomolar cytotoxicity often combined with efficacy against multidrug-resistant tumor cells. The newly established cryptophycin analogues comprise a broad range of relevant functional groups used as conjugation handles, among them amino, hydroxy, carboxy, as well as sulfur-containing derivatives. X-ray crystallographic analysis of a tubulin-bound cryptophycin together with quantitative structure activity relationship manifested rationales for the synthesis of most potent cryptophycin derivatives and further confirmed the suitability of modifications in unit D.
Microtubule-targeting agents are an important class of anti-cancer drugs; their full potential is however not realized because of significant myelotoxicity and neurotoxicity. We here report 3-nitropyridine analogues as a novel group of microtubule-targeting agents with potent anti-cancer effects against a broad range of cancer types. We show that these 3-nitropyridines induce cell cycle arrest in the G2-M phase and inhibit tubulin polymerization by interacting with tubulin. Determination of the tubulin-4AZA2996 structure by X-ray crystallography demonstrated that this class of compounds binds to the colchicine-site of tubulin. Furthermore, the anti-cancer effect was demonstrated both in vitro and in vivo in a murine heterotopic xenograft model of colon cancer. When administered intravenously, 4AZA2891 effectively inhibited cancer growth. Whereas 3-nitropyridine compounds do not induce myelotoxicity at pharmacological doses, the neurotoxicity associated with microtubule-targeting agents is still present.
Cryptophycins are microtubule-targeting agents (MTAs) that belong to the most potent antimitotic compounds known to date; however, their exact molecular mechanism of action remains unclear. Here, we present the 2.2 & Aring; resolution X-ray crystal structure of a potent cryptophycin derivative bound to the cC(3-tubulin heterodimer. The structure addresses conformational issues present in a previous 3.3 & Aring; resolution cryoelectron microscopy structure of cryptophycin-52 bound to the maytansine site of (3-tubulin. It further provides atomic details on interactions of cryptophycins, which had not been described previously, including ones that are in line with structure-activity relationship studies. Interestingly, we discovered a second cryptophycin-binding site that involves the T5-loop of (3-tubulin, a critical secondary structure element involved in the exchange of the guanosine nucleotide and in the formation of longitudinal tubulin contacts in microtubules. Cryptophycins are the first natural ligands found to bind to this new "(3T5-loop site" that bridges the maytansine and vinca sites. Our results offer unique avenues to rationally design novel MTAs with the capacity to modulate T5-loop dynamics and to simultaneously engage multiple (3-tubulin binding sites.
Microtubule-targeting agents (MTAs) have demonstrated remarkable efficacy as antitumor, antifungal, antiparasitic, and herbicidal agents, finding applications in the clinical, veterinary, and agrochemical industry. Recent advances in tubulin and microtubule structural biology have provided powerful tools that pave the way for the rational design of innovative small-molecule MTAs for future basic and applied life science applications. In this mini-review, we present the current status of the tubulin and microtubule structural biology field, the recent impact it had on the discovery and rational design of MTAs, and exciting avenues for future MTA research.
Abstract Our previous work showed that the prenylated hydroxy-stilbene AUS_001 exerts a strong safety profile and potent anti-proliferative responses, as assessed in 30 types of cancer cell lines, stemming from its microtubule destabilization activity. The aim of the current study was to delineate the molecular mechanism of microtubule destabilization by AUS_001 and to provide insight into its high potency and low toxicity. Surface plasmon resonance (SPR) experiments revealed the direct interaction of AUS_001 with tubulin with an apparent equilibrium dissociation constant, Kd, of 2.13 × 10−5M. Size exclusion competition assays and an X-ray crystal structure of the tubulin-AUS_001 complex at 2.1 Å resolution establish ligand binding within the colchicine site on tubulin. Since colchicine-site ligands are well known to inhibit the curved-to-straight conformational transition of tubulin, which is an essential process for microtubule formation, these results readily explain the microtubule-destabilizing activity of the compound. Notably, while both combretastatin A4 (CA-4) and AUS_001 are both colchicine-site stilbene ligands, CA-4 binds in the cis configuration, while AUS_001 maintains a trans configuration leading to a substantially different pocket engagement. Comparison of the tubulin-AUS_001 complex structure with the ones of tubulin-colchicine and tubulin-plinabulin revealed that AUS_001 elicits different rearrangements in the T7 loop of β-tubulin versus colchicine and occupies a different zone of the pocket relative to plinabulin, further elaborating its unique binding properties. Interestingly, AUS_001 exhibits a higher relative affinity than colchicine itself, as assessed by i) an ultrafiltration-based tubulin-ligand release assay and ii) a radioligand colchicine competition assay. However, fitting steady state SPR data for AUS_001 binding to tubulin revealed fast association and dissociation rates and was indicative of reversible binding. The latter finding is corroborated by AUS_001-triggered reverse biological effects including morphological alterations, cell cycle G2/M arrest, and by a decrease of cell viability upon discontinuation of the drug treatment in glioma and pancreatic cancer cells. Conversely, colchicine, CA-4 or paclitaxel administered at the same doses as those applied for AUS_001 failed to reverse the drug-induced phenotypes upon removal resulting in sustained cytotoxicity. In conclusion, we fully characterized the unique binding mode of AUS_001 to the colchicine site of tubulin and elucidated the reversible nature of the target engagement. AUS_001 features a distinctive and reversible molecular interaction with tubulin which provides a plausible explanation for its favorable safety profile compared to other microtubule targeting agents. Citation Format: Herman Lelie, Yao-Chieh Chou, Alastair J. King, Zlata Boiarska, Andrea E. Prota, Michel O. Steinmetz, Marina Koutsioumpa. The novel microtubule-destabilizing compound AUS_001 maintains unique binding to the colchicine site of tubulin and elicits reversible cellular effects relative to other anti-tubulin agents [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the American Association for Cancer Research Annual Meeting 2024; Part 1 (Regular Abstracts); 2024 Apr 5-10; San Diego, CA. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Cancer Res 2024;84(6_Suppl):Abstract nr 7141.
Paclitaxel (Taxol) is a taxane and a chemotherapeutic drug that stabilizes microtubules. While the interaction of paclitaxel with microtubules is well described, the lack of high-resolution structural information on a tubulin-taxane complex precludes a comprehensive description of the binding determinants that affect its mechanism of action. Here, we solved the crystal structure of baccatin III the core moiety of paclitaxel-tubulin complex at 1.9 Å resolution. Based on this information, we engineered taxanes with modified C13 side chains, solved their crystal structures in complex with tubulin, and analyzed their effects on microtubules (X-ray fiber diffraction), along with those of paclitaxel, docetaxel, and baccatin III. Further comparison of high-resolution structures and microtubules' diffractions with the apo forms and molecular dynamics approaches allowed us to understand the consequences of taxane binding to tubulin in solution and under assembled conditions. The results sheds light on three main mechanistic questions: (1) taxanes bind better to microtubules than to tubulin because tubulin assembly is linked to a βM-loopconformational reorganization (otherwise occludes the access to the taxane site) and, bulky C13 side chains preferentially recognize the assembled conformational state; (2) the occupancy of the taxane site has no influence on the straightness of tubulin protofilaments and; (3) longitudinal expansion of the microtubule lattices arises from the accommodation of the taxane core within the site, a process that is no related to the microtubule stabilization (baccatin III is biochemically inactive). In conclusion, our combined experimental and computational approach allowed us to describe the tubulin-taxane interaction in atomic detail and assess the structural determinants for binding.
Microtubules are highly dynamic polymers of α,β-tubulin dimers which play an essential role in numerous cellular processes such as cell proliferation and intracellular transport, making them an attractive target for cancer and neurodegeneration research. To date, a large number of known tubulin binders were derived from natural products, while only one was developed by rational structure-based drug design. Several of these tubulin binders show promising in vitro profiles while presenting unacceptable off-target effects when tested in patients. Therefore, there is a continuing demand for the discovery of safer and more efficient tubulin-targeting agents. Since tubulin structural data is readily available, the employment of computer-aided design techniques can be a key element to focus on the relevant chemical space and guide the design process. Due to the high diversity and quantity of structural data available, we compiled here a guide to the accessible tubulin-ligand structures. Furthermore, we review different ligand and structure-based methods recently used for the successful selection and design of new tubulin-targeting agents.
Work with the elements of nature: Our building block, maytansinol, represented as a constellation of stars, is the main protagonist of the story. A ray of light coming out from it demonstrates how different moieties can be attached to it, opening new horizons. As maytansinoids show a destabilising effect on microtubules, we represent the latter by trees. The tree trunk is a microtubule, from which the tubulins are disassembling into the leaves. The TubInTrain logo in the corner represents the H2020-MSCA-ITN-2019 network that made this interdisciplinary investigation possible. More information can be found in the Research Article by S. Pieraccini, D. Passarella and co-workers. (DOI: 10.1002/chem.202203431). Created with BioRender.com.
Invited for the cover of this issue are the groups of Professors Passarella and Pieraccini at the University of Milan, in collaboration with some of the members of TubInTrain consortium. The image depicts work with the elements of nature, in particular the destabilising effect of maytansinol (the constellation) on microtubules (the trees). Read the full text of the article at 10.1002/chem.202203431.
Microtubules (MTs) are dynamic filaments of the cytoskeleton, which are formed by the polymerization of their building block tubulin. Perturbation of MT dynamics by MT-targeting agents (MTAs) leads to cell cycle arrest or cell death, a strategy that is pursued in chemotherapy. We recently performed a combined computational and crystallographic fragment screening approach and identified several tubulin-binding fragments. Here, we sought to capitalize on this study with the aim to demonstrate that low affinity tubulin-binding fragments can indeed be used as valuable starting points for the development of active, lead-like antitubulin small molecules. To this end, we report on a new, rationally designed series of 2-aminobenzimidazole derivatives that destabilize MTs by binding tubulin at the colchicine-binding site (CBS). We applied a fragment growing strategy by combining X-ray crystallography and computer-aided drug design. Preliminary structure-activity-relationship studies afforded compound 18 that inhibits HeLa cell viability with a submicromolar activity (IC50 of 0.9 mu M). X-ray crystal-lography confirmed the compound pose in the CBS, while immunostaining experiments suggested a molecular mechanism of action alike classical CBS ligands with antimitotic and antitumor activity associated with MTs destabilization. This promising outcome underpins that our previously performed combined computational and crystallographic fragment screening approach provides promising starting points for developing new MTAs binding to the CBS of tubulin and, eventually, to further tubulin pockets.
Maytansinol is a valuable precursor for the preparation of maytansine derivatives (known as maytansinoids). Inspired by the intriguing structure of the macrocycle and the success in targeted cancer therapy of the derivatives, we explored the maytansinol acylation reaction. As a result, we were able to obtain a series of derivatives with novel modifications of the maytansine scaffold. We characterized these molecules by docking studies, by a comprehensive biochemical evaluation, and by determination of their crystal structures in complex with tubulin. The results shed further light on the intriguing chemical behavior of maytansinoids and confirm the relevance of this peculiar scaffold in the scenario of tubulin binders.
Taxanes are microtubule-stabilizing agents used in the treatment of many solid tumors, but they often involve side effects affecting the peripheral nervous system. It has been proposed that this could be related to structural modifications on the filament upon drug binding. Alternatively, laulimalide and peloruside bind to a different site also inducing stabilization, but they have not been exploited in clinics. Here, we use a combination of the parental natural compounds and derived analogs to unravel the stabilization mechanism through this site. These drugs settle lateral interactions without engaging the M loop, which is part of the key and lock involved in the inter-protofilament contacts. Importantly, these drugs can modulate the angle between protofilaments, producing microtubules of different diameters. Among the compounds studied, we have found some showing low cytotoxicity and able to induce stabilization without compromising microtubule native structure. This opens the window of new applications for microtubule-stabilizing agents beyond cancer treatment.
Maytansinoids are a successful class of natural and semisynthetic tubulin binders, known for their potent cytotoxic activity. Their wider application as cytotoxins and chemical probes to study tubulin dynamics has been held back by the complexity of natural product chemistry. Here we report the synthesis of long-chain derivatives and maytansinoid conjugates. We confirmed that bulky substituents do not impact their high activity or the scaffold's binding mode. These encouraging results open new avenues for the design of new maytansine-based probes.
Abstract In this study, we capitalized on our previously performed crystallographic fragment screen and developed the antitubulin small molecule Todalam with only two rounds of straightforward chemical synthesis. Todalam binds to a novel tubulin site, disrupts microtubule networks in cells, arrests cells in G2/M, induces cell death, and synergizes with vinblastine. The compound destabilizes microtubules by acting as a molecular plug that sterically inhibits the curved‐to‐straight conformational switch in the α‐tubulin subunit, and by sequestering tubulin dimers into assembly incompetent oligomers. Our results describe for the first time the generation of a fully rationally designed small molecule tubulin inhibitor from a fragment, which displays a unique molecular mechanism of action. They thus demonstrate the usefulness of tubulin‐binding fragments as valuable starting points for innovative antitubulin drug and chemical probe discovery campaigns.
α-synuclein protein aggregates are the major constituent of Lewy bodies, which is a main pathogenic hallmark of Parkinson's disease. Both lipid membranes and Cu2+ ions can bind to α-synuclein and modulate its aggregation propensity and toxicity. However, the synergistic effect of copper ions and lipid membranes on α-synuclein remains to be explored. Here, we investigate how Cu2+ and α-synuclein simultaneously influence the lipidic structure of lipidic cubic phase(LCP) matrix by using small-angle X-ray scattering. α-Syn proteins destabilize the cubic-Pn3m phase of LCP that can be further recovered after the addition of Cu2 ions even at a low stoichiometric ratio. By using circular dichroism and nuclear magnetic resonance, we also study how lipid membranes and Cu2+ ions impact the secondary structures of α-synuclein at an atomic level. Although the secondary structure of α-synuclein with lipid membranes is not significantly changed to a large extent in the presence of Cu2+ ions, lipid membranes promote the interaction between α-synuclein C-terminus and Cu2+ ions. The modulation of Cu2+ ions and lipid membranes on α-synuclein dynamics and structure may play an important role in the molecular pathogenesis of Parkinson's disease.
Lymphomas are among the ten most common cancers, and, although progress has been achieved in increasing survival, there is still an unmet need for more effective therapeutic approaches, including better options for patients with refractory tumors that initially respond but then relapse. The lack of effective alternative treatment options highlights the need to develop new therapeutic strategies capable of improving survival prospects for lymphoma patients. Herein, we describe the identification and exploration of the SAR of a series of [1,2]oxazolo [5,4-e]isoindoles as potent small molecules that bind to the colchicine site of tubulin and that have promise for the treatment of refractory lymphomas. Exploration of the chemical space of this class of compounds at the pyrrole moiety and at the [1,2]oxazole ring highlighted two compounds bearing a 3,5-dimethoxybenzyl and a 3,4,5-trimethoxybenzyl group as potent candidates and showed that structural modifications at the isoxazole moiety are generally not favorable for activity. The two best candidates showed efficacy against different lym-phoma histotypes and displayed 88 and 80% inhibition of colchicine binding fitting well into the colchicine pocket, as demonstrated by X-ray crystallography T2R-TTL-complexes, docking and thermodynamic analysis of the tubulin-colchicine complex structure. These results were confirmed by transcriptome data, thus indicating [1,2]oxazolo[5,4-e]isoindoles are promising candidates as antitubulin agents for the treatment of refractory lymphomas.
Since the first moderate resolution, structural description of Taxol bound to tubulin by electron crystallography in 1998, several tubulin crystal systems have been developed and optimized for the high-resolution analysis of tubulin-ligand complexes by X-ray crystallography. Here we describe three tubulin crystal systems that have allowed investigating the molecular mechanisms of action of a large number of diverse anti-tubulin agents.