Cecropin B is a small antibacterial peptide from the giant silkmoth Hyalophora cecropia. To reveal the potential of this peptide for engineering bacterial disease resistance into crops, several cecropin B gene constructs were made either for expression in the cytosol or for secretion. All constructs were cloned in a plant expression vector and introduced in tobacco via Agrobacterium tumefaciens. A cDNA-derived cecropin B gene construct lacking the amino-terminal signal peptide was poorly expressed in transgenic plants at the mRNA level, whereas plants harbouring a full-length cDNA-derived construct containing the insect signal peptide, showed increased cecropin B-mRNA levels. Highest expression was found in plants harbouring a construct with a plant-gene-derived signal peptide. In none of the transgenic plants could the cecropin B peptide be detected. This is most likely caused by breakdown of the peptide by plant endogenous proteases, since a chemically synthesized cecropin B peptide was degraded within seconds in various plant cell extracts. This degradation could be prevented by the addition of specific protease inhibitors and by boiling the extract prior to adding the peptide. In addition, anionic detergents, in contrast to cationic, zwitter-ionic or non-ionic detergents, could prevent this degradation. Nevertheless, transgenic tobacco plants were evaluated for resistance to Pseudomonas solanacearum, the causal agent of bacterial wilt of many crops, and P. syringae pv. tabaci, the causal agent of bacterial wildfire, which are highly susceptible to cecropin B in vitro. No resistance was found. These experiments indicate that introduction and expression of cecropin B genes in tobacco does not result in detectable cecropin B protein levels and resistance to bacterial infections, most likely due to degradation of the protein by endogenous proteases.

The amino acid sequences necessary for entomocidal activity of the CryIA(b) protoxin of Bacillus thuringiensis were determined. Introduction of stop codons behind codons Arg601, Phe604 or Ala607 showed that amino acid residues C-terminal to Ala607 are not required for insecticidal activity and that activation by midgut proteases takes place distal to Ala607. The two shortest polypeptides, deleted for part of the highly conserved β-strand, were prone to proteolytic degradation, explaining their lack of toxicity. Apparently, this β-strand is essential for folding of the molecule into a stable conformation. Proteolytic activation at the N-terminus was investigated by removing the first 28 codons, resulting in a translation product extending from amino acid 29 to 607. This protein appeared to be toxic not only to susceptible insect larvae such as Manduca sexta and Heliothis virescens, but also to Escherichia coli cells. An additional mutant, encoding only amino acid residues 29–429, encompassing the complete putative pore forming domain, but lacking a large part of the receptor-binding domain, was similarly toxic to E. coli cells. This suggests a role for the N-terminal 28 amino acids in rendering the toxin inactive in Bacillus thuringiensis, and indicates that the cytolytic potential of the pore forming domain is only realized after proteolytic removal of these residues by proteases in the insect gut. In line with this hypothesis are results obtained with a mutant protein in which Arg28 at the cleavage site was replaced by Asp. This substitution prevented the protein from being cleaved by trypsin in vitro, and reduced its toxicity to M. sexta larvae.

Hordothionins (HTHs) are small anti-bacterial proteins present in barley endosperm which are processed from larger precursor proteins, consisting of an amino-terminal signal peptide (SP), the mature highly basic HTH and a carboxy-terminal acidic peptide (AP). Different HTH precursor proteins were expressed in tobacco to study the effects of the pre-sequences (SP) and pro-sequences (AP) on expression, processing, sorting and biological activity and hence the feasibility of engineering bacterial disease resistance into crops which lack these proteins. Maximum HTH expression levels of approximately 0.7% (11 mu mol/kg) of total soluble protein in young tobacco leaves were obtained using a semi-synthetic gene construct encoding a complete chimaeric HTH precursor protein. Tenfold lower HTH expression levels (maximum 1.3 mu mol/kg) were obtained using synthetic gene constructs without the AP-coding sequence and no expression was found in plants containing synthetic HTH gene constructs without SP-and AP-coding sequences. In both cases where expression was found, the precursors were apparently correctly processed, although the HTH produced in plants containing a construct without AP sequence appeared to be slightly modified. No effect on plant phenotype was observed. Localization studies indicated that the HTH was in identical fractions of plants expressing the two different precursors, albeit at a different ratio, and was not secreted into the intercellular spaces of leaves or culture medium by protoplasts. Our results indicated that the AP is not involved in sorting and suggested that it might facilitate transport through membranes. The in vitro toxicity of HTH isolated from transgenic tobacco plants expressing the two different precursor proteins for the bacterial plant pathogen Clavibacter michiganensis subsp. michiganensis appeared similar to that of the HTH purified from barley endosperm.

Crystal proteins of Bacillus thuringiensis are known for their insecticidal specificity. This specificity is, to a large extent, determined by the interaction of the proteins with high-affinity binding sites on the epithelial membrane of the midgut of sensitive insects. In particular, domain II of the three domains of the toxic moiety has been implicated in specificity. To determine which sequences of the protein are involved in binding, loops of domain II which terminate in the molecular apex of CryIA(b) were replaced by the corresponding regions of CryIE, a protein with different binding characteristics and insect specificity. In contrast to expression of the wild-type genes, expression of the mutant alleles in Escherichia coli resulted in the formation of biologically inactive, insoluble aggregates. Although these aggregates could be solubilized in vitro using urea, in contrast to the wild-type CryIA(b), the mutant proteins did not correctly refold as is shown by their increased protease sensitivity and lack of biological activity. The results indicate that engineering CryI proteins, based on the CryIIIA structure, is likely to prove difficult, particularly since the conformation of CryIIIA and CryI proteins might differ in domain II.

Wounding of plants by insects is often mimicked in the laboratory by mechanical means such as cutting or crushing, and has not been compared directly with other forms of biotic stress such as virus infection. To compare the response of plants to these types of biotic and abiotic stress, trypsin inhibitor (TI) activity induced locally and systemically in mature tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum L.) and tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum L.) plants was followed for 12 days. In tobacco, cutting, crushing and insect feeding all induced comparable levels of TI activity of approx. 5 nmol·(mg leaf protein)−1 in wounded leaves, while tobacco mosaic virus (TMV) infection of tobacco induced 10-fold lower amounts in the infected leaves. In tomato, feeding by insects also led to the induction of a level of TI activity of 5 nmol·(mg leaf protein)−1. In contrast, both cutting and crushing of tomato leaves induced 10-fold higher amounts. These data show that biotic stress, in the form of insect feeding and TMV infection, and abiotic stress, in the form of wounding, have different effects on local levels of induced TI activity in mature tobacco and tomato plants. Irrespective of the type of wounding, in neither tobacco nor tomato could systemic induction of TI activity be observed in nearby unwounded leaves, which suggests that systemic induction of TI activity in mature tobacco and tomato plants is different from systemic TI induction in seedlings. Wounding of tobacco leaves, however, did increase the responsiveness to wounding elsewhere in the plant, as measured by an increased induction of TI activity.

Tobacco and tomato plants were generated exhibiting insect resistance due to the introduction of modified cryIA(b) and cryIC genes of Bacillus thuringiensis. Limited modifications at selected regions of the coding sequences of both genes are sufficient to obtain plants resistant against Spodoptera exigua, Heliothis virescens and Manduca sexta. The criteria used to modify both genes demonstrate that the removal of sequence motifs potentially resulting in premature polyadenylation and transcript instability causes increased insect resistance of plants. The expression of a cryIC‐cryIA(b) fusion resulting in protection against S. exigua, H. virescens and M. sexta demonstrates the potential of expressing translational fusions, not only to broaden the insect resistance of transgenic plants, but also simultaneously to employ different gene classes in resistance management strategies.

Tobacco and tomato plants were generated exhibiting insect resistance due to the introduction of modified cryIA(b) and cryIC genes of Bacillus thuringiensis. Limited modifications at selected regions of the coding sequences of both genes are sufficient to obtain resistance against Spodoptera exigua, Heliothis virescens and Manduca sexta. The criteria used to modify both genes demonstrate that the removal of sequence motifs potentially resulting in premature polyadenylation and transcript instability causes increased insect resistance. The expression of a cryIC-cryIA(b) fusion resulting in protection against S. exigua, H. virescens and M. sexta demonstrates the potential of expressing translational fusions, not only to broaden the insect resistance of transgenic plants, but also to simultaneously employ different gene classes in resistance management strategies.

Genetically engineered resistance against viruses via a biotechnological approach has recently been established in plants by the expression of part of the viral genome which codes for the viral coat protein. Accumulation of the coat protein in plants has been shown to result in reduction or absence of disease symptoms and virus accumulation after virus infection. This strategy has been called ‘coat protein-mediated resistance’. It is not yet clear how viral coat protein accumulation confers this resistance, however it is most likely that it interferes with several stages of disease development. Genetically engineered tolerance to a phytopathogenic bacterium via a biotechnological approach has also been reported. The protection is based on the inactivation of the bacterial toxin causing the disease symptoms. A potentially more promising approach to confer bacterial resistance is by the expression of bactericidal toxins and lytic enzymes which interfere with bacterial multiplication and viability in plants.

Purothionins (PTHs) and hordothionins (HTHs) were purified by cation-exchange chromatography from petroleum-ether extracts of wheat and barley flour respectively. The HTHs could be separated into two fractions, HTH-1 and HTH-2. Radial diffusion assays and micro-plate broth dilution assays with a number of plant pathogenic bacteria showed that these proteins were toxic forClavibacter michiganensis subsp.michiganensis, the causal agent of bacterial canker on tomato,C. m. subsp.sepedonicus, the causal agent of ring rot on potato, andXanthomonas campestris pv.vesicatoria, the causal agent of a spot disease on tomato and pepper. Only minor differences in toxicity between PTHs and HTHs, and between HTH-1 and HTH-2, were detected. Minor differences in toxicity of these thionins were also detected for different strains of these bacteria. The use of these plant proteins for engineering bacterial disease resistance into solanaceous crops will be discussed.

Thus far theories dealing with the response of plants to wounding do not differentiate between different types of wounding like crushing and cutting. Upon wounding tobacco leaves, however, we found that the PI induction was almost absent when crushing, but normally present when cutting the leaves. The recently discovered peptide plant hormone systemin is considered to mediate the plant’s PI response to insect damage and wounding. However the properties of this wound hormone do not coincide with the properties of PI induction that we observe upon cutting tobacco and tomato plants.

Relatively little is known about the endogenous proteinase inhibitors induced in tobacco in response to insect herbivory, despite several reports on insect resistance based on transgenic tobacco, constitutively expressing trypsin inhibitors (Hilder et al., 1987). No reference has been made to potential changes in the inhibitor level during the 5–7 days of infestation with insects. A report by Walker-Simmons & Ryan (1977) surveyed wound-induced accumulation of trypsin inhibitor activities in several plant genera. They described that tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum L.) induces inhibitors to higher levels than tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum Miller) in response to crude elicitors from plants. In our experiments we found that after an insect attack of seven days very high levels of endogenous trypsin, chymotrypsin and subtilisin inhibitors were induced in tobacco (N. tabacum cv. Petit Havana SR1). These endogenous levels exceeded the reported transgenic inhibitor levels. This apparent major endogenous inhibitor contribution should be taken into account when considering the total inhibitor levels required in planta to reduce insect growth. We decided to investigate how these inhibitors are regulated in response to a simulated insect attack in tobacco (N. tabacum cvs Samsun NN and Petit Havana SR1) and tomato (L. esculentum cv. Moneymaker). For studies of insect resistance in plants it is necessary to know the differential as well as the overall inhibitor level at which insect larval growth is affected. As far as we know no one has followed overall inhibitor activity levels for any length of time. We developed a quantitative assay to monitor overall inhibitor activity levels against trypsin, chymotrypsin and subtilisin, which allows rapid estimation of inhibitor levels in large numbers of samples.

Engineering resistance against various diseases and pests is hampered by the lack of suitable genes. To overcome this problem we started a research program aimed at obtaining resistance by transfecting plants with genes encoding monoclonal antibodies against pathogen specific proteins. The idea is that monoclonal antibodies will inhibit the biological activity of molecules that are essential for the pathogenesis. Potato cyst nematodes are chosen as a model and it is thought that monoclonal antibodies are able to block the function of the saliva proteins of this parasite. These proteins are, among others, responsible for the induction of multinucleate transfer cells upon which the nematode feeds. It is well documented that the ability of antibodies to bind molecules is sufficient to inactivate the function of an antigen and in view of the potential of animals to synthesize antibodies to almost any molecular structure, this strategy should be feasible for a wide range of diseases and pests.

Baculoviruses are insect pathogens with a relatively slow speed of action, and this has limited their use as control agents of insect pests. Introduction into baculoviruses of genes which code for proteins interfering specifically with insect metabolism or metamorphosis, such as toxins, hormones, and enzymes, may enhance the pathogenicity of these viruses. The complete insecticidal crystal protein gene cryIA(b) of Bacillus thuringiensis subsp. aizawai 7.21 was engineered into the nuclear polyhedrosis virus of Autographa californica (AcNPV) in place of the polyhedrin gene. In infected Spodoptera frugiperda cells, the cryIA(b) gene was expressed at a high level without interference with AcNPV production. The crystal protein was found in the cytoplasm of S. frugiperda cells, mainly as large crystals with an ultrastructure similar to that of B. thuringiensis crystals. Infected-cell extracts inhibited feeding of the large cabbage white Pieris brassicae. The toxicity of the crystal protein expressed by AcNPV recombinants was comparable with that of the crystal protein expressed by a corresponding Escherichia coli recombinant.

25 different strains of Bacillus thuringiensis, belonging to 18 different serotypes were screened by Southern hybridization analysis for the presence of nucleotide sequences of four different gene types coding for crystal proteins showing different insecticidal spectra. Many but not all strains showed sequences homologous to any of the probes used. Homology with sequences of the gene type present in strain kurstaki HD1 occurred in all positive strains, whereas the other gene types were much less abundant. Sequences homologous to those of gene type VI, coding for a Spodoptera-specific crystal protein, appeared only in strains of serotypes aizawai and entomocidus.