Seizures are complex electrophysiological disturbances affecting one or more populations of brain neurons. Seizures following test article (TA) exposure pose significant challenges in drug development. This paper considers the diverse neurological manifestations, mechanisms, and functional and structural assessments needed to investigate TA-related seizure liabilities, with a particular focus on nonclinical species. Accurate discrimination of seizures from convulsions (irregular involuntary body and/or limb movements) and the nuanced presentation of different seizure types (partial vs. general) and phases (prodromal, ictal, and postictal) are essential for discerning their clinical implications. In nonclinical safety testing, the most direct evaluation method to confirm existence of seizures is electroencephalography (EEG) while clinical endpoints (e.g., functional observational batteries [FOB], comprehensive neurological examinations) and neuropathological findings (e.g., neuronal necrosis in tissue sections, raised biomarker levels in cerebrospinal fluid or serum) can indicate a seizure liability and provide additional guidance to identify the origin, frequency, and severity of seizures needed to align nonclinical effects with clinical relevance. In general, the regulatory perspective is that seizures identified in nonclinical species as well as potential risk management strategies (e.g., safety margin considerations, dosing paradigms, and clinical monitoring) translate effectively for purposes of clinical risk assessment.
The central (CNS) and peripheral (PNS) nervous systems of vertebrates represent divisions of a continuous, body-wide communication grid based on conserved principles of structural organization. Discrete neuroanatomic regions within this grid are associated with specific neural functions, so distinct patterns of neurological dysfunction ("problems") can provide guidance regarding neural regions to evaluate beyond those in published sampling schemes or institutional standard operating procedures. Each neurological problem or syndrome (i.e., a group of in-life signs indicating that a given neuroanatomic region is damaged) is associated with a particular list of differential diagnoses and causes. Vulnerability of neural cells and tissues is influenced by intrinsic tissue properties (e.g., high metabolic rates of neurons, presence of blood:tissue barriers, degree of collateral vascular supply) and extrinsic factors (bone protuberances and connective tissue partitions impinging on neural surfaces, fluid flow patterns in the cerebroventricular system and meninges, etc.). In the toxicologic pathology setting, expansion (when warranted) of routine neural sampling protocols to collect additional anatomic regions correlated to a specific neurological problem improves the likelihood that a neuropathological evaluation will identify lesions and causes responsible for neurological conditions as well as detect findings related to potential test item-related neurotoxicity.
The first session of the 2025 European Society of Toxicologic Pathology (ESTP) Congress reviewed routine and specialized methods for microscopic evaluation of neural tissues during nonclinical studies. Three longer presentations reviewed brain sampling approaches in safety assessments, including an example to accentuate topographical analysis and integration of toxicology data; specific brain and spinal cord sampling for molecular and protein analyses; and an overview of technical aspects of intraparenchymal drug delivery. Four shorter talks discussed the uses, advantages, disadvantages, and interpretation of several special neurohistological techniques (stains and immunohistochemical markers) for assessing test item-associated responses. Common special methods used (when warranted) for nonclinical studies include Fluoro-Jade or silver stains for detecting neuronal death, Luxol fast blue (LFB) for examining myelin, anti-glial fibrillary acidic protein (GFAP) to demonstrate reactive astrocytes, and anti-ionized calcium-binding adaptor molecule 1 (IBA1) to highlight reactive microglia and macrophages, though alternatives methods were described. The last presentation discussed artificial intelligence as an aid in detecting subtle toxicant-induced lesions during digital pathology analyses (using the Olney lesion [acute neuronal vacuolation and necrosis in the cerebral cortex] as an example). Taken together, talks in this session provided a cohesive overview of traditional and innovative approaches to facilitate microscopic evaluation for potential neurotoxicity in nonclinical studies.
Historically, safety and efficacy assessment of medical devices began and has continued as standards under the International Organization for Standardization (ISO) rather than under regulatory agency guidelines applied to developing other biomedical product classes. These parallel and unequal pathways have led to multiple and substantive differences in methods and endpoints to determine adverse biological responses among therapeutic classes. Toxicologic pathologists with medical device experience consider standardized nomenclature and diagnostic criteria for medical devices and device-containing combination products as a critical unmet need for nonclinical pathology evaluations. The International Harmonization of Nomenclature and Diagnostic Criteria for Lesions (INHAND) initiative has established globally accepted terminology for proliferative and nonproliferative lesions in various laboratory animal species. Experienced pathologists have identified that some existing INHAND terms for rodents and particularly nonrodents are already used or can be modified for use in medical device studies, but new terms for diagnostic features unique to medical device studies are needed to close gaps in existing INHAND nomenclature. The best approach to establishing appropriate INHAND terms for medical devices (and by extension, device-containing combination products) will be to develop and implement suitable terminology (modified and new, as warranted) to address unmet needs for this distinctive therapeutic class.
Hematoxylin and eosin (H&E) staining is a suitable approach for detecting substantial structural changes in neural tissues but is less sensitive for identifying subtle alterations to subcellular structures and various chemical constituents, including myelin. Neurohistological methods to better evaluate myelin integrity by light microscopy include acidophilic dyes (eg, eriochrome cyanine R, toluidine blue [used with hard plastic sections]); lipoprotein-binding dyes (eg, Luxol fast blue [LFB], Weil's iron hematoxylin); lipid impregnation with metals (eg, Marchi's, which uses osmium tetroxide for en bloc staining before embedding); and immunohistochemical (IHC) methods to highlight various antigens (eg, myelin basic protein [MBP] and peripheral myelin protein 22 [PMP22]). Some IHC methods reveal enhanced marker expression in damaged myelin (eg, matrix metalloproteinase-9 [MMP9], S100). In neuropathology investigations, H&E is the first-tier screening method, whereas myelin stains (often LFB alone or in combination with dyes that highlight other structural elements) are second-tier procedures performed in combination with other neurohistological procedures to examine neuroaxonal injury and/or glial responses. The choice of myelin method depends on such considerations as cost, institutional preference, the procedure (fixation and embedding medium), and the study objective.
Managing conflicts of interest (COIs) in scientific decision-making is important for minimizing bias and fostering public trust in science. Proper management of COIs has added significance when scientists are making decisions that impact public policy, such as assessing substances for carcinogenicity. The International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) organizes expert working groups to identify putative carcinogens and determine whether or not the hazard is likely to present significant potential harm to humans. While IARC has policies for managing COIs, prior professional experience with the substance being assessed is not defined as a COI. Indeed, IARC working group members are chosen based on subject matter expertise, including prior publication on the substance under review. However, a person's prior experience with a substance poses a significant potential COI by equipping them with strong pre-existing views about the substance's toxicity and carcinogenicity. To minimize the risk of bias in IARC working groups, participants with voting powers should be independent scientific experts with sufficient professional experience to review carcinogenicity data but with no substantial prior experience with the substance under review. A related IARC practice restricting data review by working groups to selected publications is another significant COI. Instead, all accessible data should be available for consideration by working groups in assessing the carcinogenic hazard of substances. Another recommendation to reduce potential bias would be to reinstate the option of "probably not carcinogenic to humans".
Aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases (aaRSs) charge tRNAs with their cognate amino acids, ensuring accurate translation of the genetic code from mRNA to protein. During eukaryotic evolution, aaRSs acquired additional domains with unclear functions, including the WHEP domain, a two-helix bundle found in several eukaryotic aaRSs such as glycyl-tRNA synthetase (GlyRS, encoded by GARS1 ). We generated Gars1 ΔWHEP mutant mice lacking exon 2, which disrupts most of the WHEP domain. Homozygous Gars1 ΔWHEP/ΔWHEP mice exhibited late embryonic or neonatal lethality, with delayed lung development, characterized by reduced airway dilation (inflatability), and increased vascular leakage. Disruption of the WHEP domain did not impair tRNA aminoacylation but inhibited the free release of GlyRS from cells. Instead, GlyRSΔWHEP was found in the membrane fractions and showed a stronger interaction with the extracellular region of neuropilin 1 (Nrp1) receptor compared to full-length GlyRS. This aberrant interaction enhanced Nrp1’s endocytic activity and significantly reduced the localization of the Nrp1 interactor VE-cadherin at the adherens junctions of endothelial cells. A heterozygous knockout of Nrp1 in the Gars1 ΔWHEP/ΔWHEP mice partially rescued body weight and vascular permeability defects. This study establishes a physiological role for the GlyRS WHEP domain in lung development and its regulation of GlyRS-Nrp1 interaction and vascular permeability. ### Competing Interest Statement The authors have declared no competing interest. National Institutes of Health, GM139627 Ministero dell’Istruzione, dell’Università e della Ricerca, PRIN 2020EK82R5 AIRC under IG 2023 - ID. 28763 National Foundation for Cancer Research, https://ror.org/04v83ky93
Due to the prevalence of hematoxylin and eosin (H&E) staining in routine histological preparations, understanding the factors that impact stain color characteristics is vital to attain consistently high-quality stains. In the last decade, increased use of digital pathology and image analysis (specifically by optical density [OD] measures) has provided new ways of assessing staining precision. This paper combines data from two studies that tracked H&E staining quality in both nuclear and cytoplasmic components of 12 tissues (11 human and 1 porcine) by OD after overuse of H&E staining reagents from 5 vendors. Both studies showed a decrease in eosin stain intensity by OD and visual inspection (by a histologist) with reagent overuse. This trend varied in degree by tissue type and reagent vendor. Nonetheless, staining quality for H&E staining from all vendors and for all organs remained acceptable (but not always optimal) for microscopic evaluation by the College of American Pathologists (CAP) and National Society for Histotechnology (NSH) staining criteria when stained sections were reviewed by a board-certified veterinary pathologist.
Conventional methods of gene transfer lead to inconsistent transgene expression within cells. This variability can be problematic, particularly in conditions like Rett syndrome (RTT), a neurological disorder caused by mutations in the MECP2 (methyl-CpG binding protein 2) gene, because overexpression of MECP2 can also cause adverse effects. To address these challenges, we devised a gene regulation system called Expression Attenuation via Construct Tuning (EXACT), which uses a self-contained, microRNA-based feed-forward loop that not only ensures more consistent transgene expression but also protects against excessive expression. Through cell-based screening assays, we demonstrated the ability of the EXACT circuit to modulate the expression of full-length human MeCP2. Compared with a conventional construct, an EXACT-MECP2 construct exhibited a narrower range of cellular protein abundance. Furthermore, the degree of regulation by the EXACT circuit increased with higher transgene doses in vitro and in wild-type mice and mice modeling RTT. On the basis of cellular and in vivo testing, we identified an optimal configuration for the adeno-associated virus serotype 9 (AAV9) construct for self-regulated MECP2 gene therapy, designated NGN-401. Delivery of NGN-401 to neonatal male Mecp2-/y hemizygous mice via intracerebroventricular injection resulted in prolonged survival and amelioration of RTT-like phenotypes compared with vehicle-treated animals. NGN-401 was also well tolerated by female Mecp2+/- mice and healthy juvenile nonhuman primates, in contrast with a conventional construct, which caused toxicity. The results from these studies underpin a first-in-human pediatric trial of NGN-401 in RTT (ClinicalTrials.gov, NCT05898620).
Nonclinical studies of test articles (TAs) in nonhuman primates are often designed to assess both biodistribution and toxicity. For this purpose, studies commonly use intravenous perfusion of ice-cold (2°C-8°C) saline to facilitate measurements of TA-associated nucleic acids and proteins, after which tissues undergo later fixation by immersion for histological processing and microscopic evaluation. Intriguingly, minimal apoptosis/single cell necrosis (A/SCN) of randomly distributed neural cells is evident in the cerebral cortex and less often the hippocampus in animals from all groups, including vehicle-treated controls. Affected cells exhibit end-stage features such as cytoplasmic hypereosinophilia, nuclear condensation or fragmentation, and shape distortions, so their lineage(s) generally cannot be defined; classical apoptotic bodies are exceedingly rare. In addition, A/SCN is not accompanied by glial reactions, leukocyte infiltration/inflammation, or other parenchymal changes. The severity is minimal in controls but may be slightly exacerbated (to mild) by TA that accumulate in neural cells. One plausible hypothesis explaining this A/SCN exacerbation is that cold shock (perhaps complicated by concurrent tissue acidity and hypoxia) drives still-viable but TA-stressed cells to launch a self-directed death program. Taken together, these observations indicate that A/SCN in brain processed by cold saline perfusion with delayed immersion fixation represents a procedural artifact and not a TA-related lesion.
Test article (TA)-induced seizures represent a major safety concern in drug development. Seizures (altered brain wave [electrophysiological] patterns) present clinically as abnormal consciousness with or without tonic/clonic convulsions (where “tonic” = stiffening and “clonic” = involuntary rhythmical movements). Neuropathological findings following seizures may be detected using many methods. Neuro-imaging may show a structural abnormality underlying seizures, such as focal cortical dysplasia or hippocampal sclerosis in patients with chronic epilepsy. Neural cell type-specific biomarkers in blood or cerebrospinal fluid may highlight neuronal damage and/or glial reactions but are not specific indicators of seizures while serum electrolyte and glucose imbalances may induce seizures. Gross observations and brain weights generally are unaffected by TAs with seizurogenic potential, but microscopic evaluation may reveal seizure-related neuron death in some brain regions (especially neocortex, hippocampus, and/or cerebellum). Current globally accepted best practices for neural sampling in nonclinical general toxicity studies provide a suitable screen for brain regions that are known sites of electrical disruption and/or display seizure-induced neural damage. Conventional nonclinical studies can afford an indication that a TA has a potential seizure liability (via in-life signs and/or microscopic evidence of neuron necrosis), but confirmation requires measuring brain electrical (electroencephalographic) activity in a nonclinical study.
The developmental neuropathology examination in juvenile toxicity studies depends on the nature of the product candidate, its intended use, and the exposure scenario (eg, dose, duration, and route). Expectations for sampling, processing, and evaluating neural tissues differ for developmental neurotoxicity studies (DNTS) for chemicals and juvenile animal studies (JAS) for pediatric pharmaceuticals. Juvenile toxicity studies typically include macroscopic observations, brain weights, and light microscopic evaluation of routine hematoxylin and eosin (H&E)-stained sections from major neural tissues (brain, spinal cord, and sciatic nerve) as neuropathology endpoints. The DNTS is a focused evaluation of the nervous system, so the study design incorporates perfusion fixation, plastic embedding of at least one nerve, quantitative analysis of selected brain regions, and sometimes special neurohistological stains. In contrast, the JAS examines multiple systems, so neural tissues undergo conventional tissue processing (eg, immersion fixation, paraffin embedding, H&E staining only). An "expanded neurohistopathology" (or "expanded neuropathology") approach may be performed for JAS if warranted, typically by light microscopic evaluation of more neural tissues (usually additional sections of brain, ganglia, and/or more nerves) or/and special neurohistological stains, to investigate specific questions (eg, a more detailed exploration of a potential neuroactive effect) or to fulfill regulatory requests.
ABSTRACT Mitogen-activated protein 3 kinase 1 (MAP3K1) has a plethora of cell type-specific functions not yet fully understood. Herein, we describe a role for MAP3K1 in female reproductive tract (FRT) development. MAP3K1 kinase domain-deficient female mice exhibited an imperforate vagina, labor failure and infertility. These defects corresponded with shunted Müllerian ducts (MDs), the embryonic precursors of FRT, that manifested as a contorted caudal vagina and abrogated vaginal–urogenital sinus fusion in neonates. The MAP3K1 kinase domain is required for optimal activation of the Jun-N-terminal kinase (JNK) and cell polarity in the MD epithelium, and for upregulation of WNT signaling in the mesenchyme surrounding the caudal MD. The MAP3K1-deficient epithelial cells and MD epithelium had reduced expression of WNT7B ligands. Correspondingly, conditioned media derived from MAP3K1-competent, but not -deficient, epithelial cells activated a TCF/Lef-luciferase reporter in fibroblasts. These observations indicate that MAP3K1 regulates MD caudal elongation and FRT development, in part through the induction of paracrine factors in the epithelium that trans-activate WNT signaling in the mesenchyme.
Direct delivery of therapeutics to the central nervous system (CNS) greatly expands opportunities to treat neurological diseases but is technically challenging. This opinion outlines principal technical aspects of direct CNS delivery via intracerebroventricular (ICV) or intrathecal (IT) injection to common nonclinical test species (rodents, dogs, and nonhuman primates) and describes procedure-related clinical and histopathological effects that confound interpretation of test article-related effects. Direct dosing is by ICV injection in mice due to their small body size, while other species are dosed IT in the lumbar cistern. The most frequent procedure-related functional effects are transient absence of lower spinal reflexes after IT injection or death soon after ICV dosing. Common procedure-related microscopic findings in all species include leukocyte infiltrates in CNS meninges or perivascular (Virchow-Robin) spaces; nerve fiber degeneration in the spinal cord white matter (especially dorsal and lateral tracts compressed by dosing needles or indwelling catheters), spinal nerve roots, and sciatic nerve; meningeal fibrosis at or near IT injection sites; hemorrhage; and gliosis. Findings typically are minimal to occasionally mild. Findings tend to be more severe and/or have a higher incidence in the spinal cord segments and spinal nerve roots at or close to the site of administration.
Adeno-associated virus (AAV) gene therapy vectors are an accepted platform for treating severe neurological diseases. Test article (TA)-related and procedure-related neuropathological effects following administration of AAV-based vectors are observed in the central nervous system (CNS) and peripheral nervous system (PNS). Leukocyte accumulation (mononuclear cell infiltration > inflammation) may occur in brain, spinal cord, spinal nerve roots (SNRs), sensory and autonomic ganglia, and rarely nerves. Leukocyte accumulation may be associated with neuron necrosis (sensory ganglia > CNS) and/or glial changes (microgliosis and/or astrocytosis in the CNS, increased satellite glial cellularity in ganglia and/or Schwann cellularity in nerves). Axonal degeneration secondary to neuronal injury may occur in the SNR (dorsal > ventral), spinal cord (dorsal and occasionally lateral funiculi), and brainstem centrally and in nerves peripherally. Patterns of AAV-associated microscopic findings in the CNS and PNS differ for TAs administered into brain parenchyma (where tissue at the injection site is affected most) versus TAs delivered into cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) or systemically (which primarily impacts sensory ganglion neurons and their processes in SNR and spinal cord). Changes related to the TA and procedure may overlap. While often interpreted as adverse, AAV-associated neuronal necrosis and axonal degeneration of limited severity generally do not preclude clinical testing.
Aspartame, an artificial sweetener commonly used as a sugar substitute, is currently authorized for use in more than 100 countries. Hundreds of studies, conducted in various countries dating back to the 1970s, have shown that aspartame is safe at real-world exposure levels. Furthermore, multiple human epidemiology studies have provided no indication that consumption of aspartame induces cancer. Given the continued controversy surrounding the Ramazzini Institute's (RI) studies suggesting that aspartame is a carcinogenic hazard in rodents and evaluation by the International Agency for Research on Cancer, this report aims to provide the perspective of experienced pathologists on publicly available pathology data regarding purported proliferative lesions in liver, lung, lymphoid organs, and mammary gland as well as their implications for human risk assessment as reported for three lifetime rodent carcinogenicity bioassays of aspartame conducted at the RI. In the authors' view, flaws in the design, methodology and reporting of the RI aspartame studies limit the utility of the data sets as evidence that this agent represents a carcinogenic hazard. Therefore, all three RI studies, and particularly the accuracy of their pathology diagnoses and interpretations, should be rigorously reviewed by qualified and experienced veterinary toxicologic pathologists in assessing aspartame's carcinogenic risk.
Veterinary pathology credentials serve as a concise means attesting to educational attainments and experiences indicating a readiness for professional practice. Given the cost, time, and stress associated with obtaining different qualifications, pathologists must consider what credentials enhance their readiness. In this commentary, the authors describe how their various degrees and certifications have facilitated their individual and organizational success. The minimum credentials for proficient veterinary pathology practice are a veterinary medical degree (DVM or equivalent) and advanced pathology training (residency and/or on-the-job "apprenticeship") ideally culminating in board certification in pathology (American College of Veterinary Pathologists [ACVP] diplomate status or equivalent). Graduate degrees (MS, PhD, MPH, etc) and/or other qualifications in allied biomedical fields (eg, board certification in internal medicine, laboratory animal medicine, poultry medicine, preventive medicine, or toxicology) may improve employability by affirming specialty knowledge in another complementary discipline. The authors note that pathology positions may be obtained without a long list of degrees or certifications, and that more credentials may provide occupational flexibility for some employers. However, a good work ethic, experience in the field, ability to adapt to changes, job satisfaction, good attitude, and demonstrated productivity are also important, and indeed, they are often the paramount criteria for career success as a veterinary pathologist.
Respiratory diseases are one of the leading causes of death and disability around the world. Mice are commonly used as models of human respiratory disease. Phenotypic analysis of mice with spontaneous, congenital, inherited, or treatment-related respiratory tract abnormalities requires investigators to discriminate normal anatomic features of the respiratory system from those that have been altered by disease. Many publications describe individual aspects of normal respiratory tract development, primarily focusing on morphogenesis of the trachea and lung. However, a single reference providing detailed low- and high-magnification, high-resolution images of routine hematoxylin and eosin (H&E)-stained sections depicting all major structures of the entire developing murine respiratory system does not exist. The purpose of this atlas is to correct this deficiency by establishing one concise reference of high-resolution color photomicrographs from whole-slide scans of H&E-stained tissue sections. The atlas has detailed descriptions and well-annotated images of the developing mouse upper and lower respiratory tracts emphasizing embryonic days (E) 9.0 to 18.5 and major early postnatal events. The selected images illustrate the main structures and events at key developmental stages and thus should help investigators both confirm the chronological age of mouse embryos and distinguish normal morphology as well as structural (cellular and organ) abnormalities.
Adeno-associated virus (AAV)-based vectors are the most frequently used platform for retinal gene therapy. Initially explored for the treatment of loss-of-function mutations underpinning many inherited retinal diseases, AAV-based ocular gene therapies are increasingly used to transduce endogenous cells to produce therapeutic proteins, thus producing site-specific biofactories. Relatively invasive ocular routes of administration (ROA) mean prominent procedure-related in-life, and histopathological findings may be observed with some regularity. Test article-related findings may vary with the ROA and cell populations transduced, with retinal pigmented epithelium (RPE) changes prominent (ranging from pigment alteration through degeneration, with or without associated degeneration of the overlying retina) with subretinal ROA, and more anterior changes (iris, ciliary body) generally observed with the intravitreal ROA. Ocular inflammation is the most frequent finding that occurs nonclinically and in patients, and is particularly pronounced with intravitreal administration. Extraocular findings may be observed in extraocular muscles, regional ganglia, or central visual pathways with multiple ocular ROA. Work is still needed to understand the mechanisms underpinning many of these ocular and extraocular findings. Emerging patient data is helping to clarify both the potential for translating nonclinical findings to predict possible human responses and the applicability of nonclinical biomonitoring methods to the clinical setting.