Lectins are predominantly oligomeric proteins with several binding sites per molecule. Glycoconjugates are their natural ligands, which often possess multiple binding epitopes. Thus, lectin-glycoconjugate interactions are mostly multivalent in nature. The mechanism of multivalent binding is fundamentally different from those described for monovalent interactions in textbooks and research papers. Over the years, binding studies that make use of different lectins and a variety of multivalent glycoconjugate ligands were conducted in order to understand the underlying principles of multivalency. Starting with seemingly simple synthetic multivalent analogs, systematic studies were carried out using natural glycoconjugate ligands with increasing valency and complexity. Those ligands included multivalent glycoproteins, polyvalent polysaccharides, including glycosaminoglycans, as well as supra-valent mucins and proteoglycans. Models and mechanisms of multivalent binding derived from quantitative data are summarized in the present updated review.
Isothermal titration microcalorimetry (ITC) can directly determine the thermodynamic binding parameters of biological molecules including affinity constant, binding stoichiometry, heat of binding (enthalpy) and indirectly the entropy, and free energy of binding. ITC has been extensively used to study the binding of lectins to mono- and oligosaccharides, but limitedly in applications to lectin-glycoprotein interactions. Inherent experimental challenges to ITC include sample precipitation during the experiment and relative high amount of sample required, but careful design of experiments can minimize these problems and allow valuable information to be obtained. For example, the thermodynamics of binding of lectins to multivalent globular and linear glycoproteins (mucins) have been described. The results are consistent with a dynamic binding mechanism in which lectins bind and jump from carbohydrate to carbohydrate epitope in these molecules leading to increased affinity. Importantly, the mechanism of binding of lectins to mucins appears similar to that for a variety of protein ligands binding to DNA. Recent results also show that high-affinity lectin-mucin cross-linking interactions are driven by favorable entropy of binding that is associated with the bind and jump mechanism. The results suggest that the binding of ligands to biopolymers, in general, may involve a common mechanism that involves enhanced entropic effects that facilitate binding interactions.
Recognition of glycoconjugates by lectins is critical for many biological processes. Lectins interact with glycans through hydrogen bonding, metal ion coordination, hydrophobic association, van der Waals and ionic interactions. Water molecules in the vicinity of the binding sites and glycan conformation also play roles. Furthermore, the valence of the glycan epitopes and the number and geometry of the binding sites of lectins play important roles in their interactions. Natural glycoconjugates are often multivalent and possess multiple copies of the same glycan epitope. Their multivalent interactions with lectins, which are oligomeric proteins, often enhance the weak binding affinities of a single glycan epitope. Multivalent interactions can be either intramolecular or intermolecular. In the latter case, gradients of microaffinity constants are associated with multivalent carbohydrates binding to lectins. When the valence of either the glycoconjugate or lectin exceeds two, intermolecular multivalent binding can result in lectin-glycoconjugate cross-linking interactions that form either organized or disorganized clustered complexes. Such complexes are involved in signal transduction mechanisms on the surface of cells. Scaffolds, the non-glycan parts of glycoconjugates, do not participate in lectin binding yet they modulate lectin binding interactions. In addition, lectins rarely to bind to sulfated glycosaminoglycans (GAGs) and proteoglycans. The human lectin Galectin-3 has the rare ability to do both. The binding affinity of lectins for linear biopolymers, such as mucins and GAGs, is proportional to the length of the polymers. A model termed "bind-and-jump" presented in this chapter explains how lectins interact with mucins and GAGs.
The mucin-type O-glycome in cancer aberrantly expresses the truncated glycans Tn (GalNAcα1-Ser/Thr) and STn (Neu5Acα2,6GalNAcα1-Ser/Thr). However, the role of Tn and STn in cancer and other diseases is not well understood. Our recent discovery of the self-binding properties (carbohydrate-carbohydrate interactions, CCIs) of Tn (Tn-Tn) and STn (STn-STn) provides a model for their possible roles in cellular transformation. We also review evidence that Tn and STn are members of a larger family of glycan tumor antigens that possess CCIs, which may participate in oncogenesis.
The molecular mechanism(s) underlying the enhanced self-interactions of mucins possessing the Tn (GalNAcα1-Ser/Thr) or STn (NeuNAcα2-6GalNAcα1-Ser/Thr) cancer markers were investigated using optical tweezers (OT). The mucins examined included modified porcine submaxillary mucin containing the Tn epitope (Tn-PSM), ovine submaxillary mucin with the STn epitope (STn-OSM), and recombinant MUC1 analogs with either the Tn and STn epitope. OT experiments in which the mucins were immobilized onto polystyrene beads revealed identical self-interaction characteristics for all mucins. Identical binding strength and energy landscape characteristics were also observed for synthetic polymers displaying multiple GalNAc decorations. Polystyrene beads without immobilized mucins showed no self-interactions and also no interactions with mucin-decorated polystyrene beads. Taken together, the experimental data suggest that in these molecules, the GalNAc residue mediates interactions independent of the anchoring polymer backbone. Furthermore, GalNAc-GalNAc interactions appear to be responsible for self-interactions of mucins decorated with the STn epitope. Hence, Tn-MUC1 and STn-MUC1 undergo self-interactions mediated by the GalNAc residue in both epitopes, suggesting a possible molecular role in cancer. MUC1 possessing the T (Galβ1-3GalNAcα1-Ser/Thr) or ST antigen (NeuNAcα2-3Galβ1-3GalNAcα1-Ser/Thr) failed to show self-interactions. However, in the case of ST-MUC1, self-interactions were observed after subsequent treatment with neuraminidase and β-galactosidase. This enzymatic treatment is expected to introduce Tn-epitopes and these observations thus further strengthen the conclusion that the observed interactions are mediated by the GalNAc groups.
Isothermal titration microcalorimetry (ITC) can directly determine the thermodynamic binding parameters of biological molecules including affinity constant, binding stoichiometry, and heat of binding (enthalpy) and indirectly the entropy and free energy of binding. ITC has been extensively used to study the binding of lectins to mono-and oligosaccharides, but limited applications to lectin-glycoprotein interactions. Inherent experimental challenges to ITC include sample precipitation during the experiment and relative high amount of sample required, but careful design of experiments can minimize these problems and allow valuable information to be obtained. For example, the thermodynamics of binding of lectins to multivalent globular and linear glycoproteins (mucins) have been described. The results are consistent with a dynamic binding mechanism in which lectins bind and jump from carbohydrate to carbohydrate epitope in these molecules leading to increased affinity. Importantly, the mechanism of binding of lectins to mucins appears similar to that for a variety of protein ligands binding to DNA. Recent results also show that high affinity lectin-mucin cross-linking interactions are driven by favorable entropy of binding that is associated with the bind and jump mechanism. The results suggest that the binding of ligands to biopolymers, in general, may involve a common mechanism that involves enhanced entropic effects that facilitate binding interactions.
Multivalent glycoconjugate-protein interactions are central to many important biological processes. Isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) can potentially reveal the molecular and thermodynamic basis of such interactions. However, calorimetric investigation of multivalency is challenging. Binding of multivalent glycoconjugates to proteins (lectins) often leads to a stoichiometry-dependent precipitation process due to noncovalent cross-linking between the reactants. Precipitation during ITC titration severely affects the quality of the baseline as well as the signals. Hence, the resulting thermodynamic data are not dependable. We have made some modifications to address this problem and successfully studied multivalent glycoconjugate binding to lectins. We have also modified the Hill plot equation to analyze high quality ITC raw data obtained from multivalent binding. As described in this chapter, ITC-driven thermodynamic parameters and Hill plot analysis of ITC raw data can provide valuable information about the molecular mechanism of multivalent lectin-glycoconjugate interactions. The methods described herein revealed (i) the importance of functional valence of multivalent glycoconjugates, (ii) that favorable entropic effects contribute to the enhanced affinities associated with multivalent binding, (iii) that with the progression of lectin binding, the microscopic affinities of the glycan epitopes of a multivalent glycoconjugate decrease (negative cooperativity), (iv) that lectin binding to multivalent glycoconjugates, especially to mucins, involves internal diffusion jumps, (bind and jump) and (v) that scaffolds of glycoconjugates influence their entropy of binding.
Mucins are linear, heavily O-glycosylated proteins with physiological roles that include cell signaling, cell adhesion, inflammation, immune response and tumorgenesis. Cancer-associated mucins often differ from normal mucins by presenting truncated carbohydrate chains. Characterization of the binding properties of mucins with truncated carbohydrate side chains could thus prove relevant for understanding their role in cancer mechanisms such as metastasis and recognition by the immune system. In this work, heterotypic interactions of model mucins that possess the Tn (GalNAcαThr/Ser) and T (Galβ1-3GalNAcαThr/Ser) cancer antigens derived from porcine submaxillary mucin (PSM) were studied using atomic force microscopy. PSM possessing only the Tn antigen (Tn-PSM) was found to bind to PSM analogs possessing a combination of T, Tn and STn antigens as well as biosynthetic analogs of the core 1 blood group A tetrasaccharide (GalNAcα1-3[Fucα1-2] Galβ1-3GalNAcαSer/Thr). The rupture forces for the heterotypic interactions ranged from 18- to 31 pN at a force-loading rate of ∼0.5 nN/s. The thermally averaged distance from the bound complex to the transition state (xβ) was estimated to be in the range 0.37-0.87 nm for the first barrier of the Bell Evans analysis and within 0.34-0.64 nm based on a lifetime analysis. These findings reveal that the binding strength and energy landscape for heterotypic interactions of Tn-PSM with the above mucins, resemble homotypic interactions of Tn-PSM. This suggests common carbohydrate epitope interactions for the Tn cancer antigen with the above mucin analogs, a finding that may be important to the role of the Tn antigen in cancer cells.
Mice with null mutations in specific Golgi glycosyltransferases show evidence of glycan compensation where missing carbohydrate epitopes are found on biosynthetically related structures. Repetitive saccharide sequences within the larger glycan structures are functional epitopes recognized by animal lectins. These studies provide the first in vivo support for the existence of a feedback system that maintains and regulates glycan epitope density in cells. Receptor regulation by lectin-glycan interactions and the Golgi provides a mechanism for the adaptation of cell surface receptors and solute transporters in response to environmental cues and intracellular signaling. We suggest that other posttranslational modification systems might have similar conditional features regulated by density-dependent ligand-epitope interactions.
Mucins are linear O-glycosylated glycoproteins involved in inflammation, cell adhesion, and tumorigenesis. Cancer-associated mucins often possess increased expression of the T (Galβ1,3GalNAcαThr/Ser) and Tn (GalNAcαThr/Ser) cancer antigens, which are diagnostic markers for several cancers, including colon cancer. We have used AFM based single-molecule forced unbinding under near physiological conditions to investigate the self-interactions between porcine submaxillary mucin (PSM) as well as between PSM analogs possessing various carbohydrates including the T- and Tn-antigen. Distributions of unbinding forces and corresponding force loading rates were determined for force loading rates from 0.18 nN/s to 39 nN/s, and processed to yield most probable unbinding forces f* and lifetimes of the interactions. Parameter f* varied in the range 27 to 50 pN at force loading rates of about 2 nN/s among the various mucins. All mucin samples investigated showed self-interaction, but the tendency was greatest for PSM displaying only the Tn-antigen (Tn-PSM) or a mixture of Tn-, T-antigen, and the trisaccharide Fucα1,2Galβ1,3GalNAc (Tri-PSM). Weaker self-interactions were observed for native PSM (Fd-PSM), which consists of a nearly equal mixture of the longer core 1 blood group A tetrasaccharide (GalNAcα1,3(Fucα1,2)Galβ1,3GalNAcαSer/Thr) and Tn-antigen. The data are consistent with the truncated Tn and T glycans enhancing self-interaction of the mucins. These carbohydrate cancer antigens may, thus, play an active role in the disease by constitutively activating mucin and mucin-type receptors by self-association on cells.
It has been recently proposed that lectins such as galectins, C-type lectins and siglecs in innate immunity bind to foreign pathogens by density-dependent recognition of surface glycans (Dam and Brewer 2010). In many cases, foreign pathogens including viruses and bacteria possess glycan epitopes such as Man and LacNAc residues that are also found on host cells (Vasta 2009). Host lectins appear to bind to the pathogens due to their high density and number of glycan epitopes relative to those on host cells (Dam and Brewer 2010). Unique “weak” glycan epitopes on foreign pathogens appear to be strong epitopes when presented in high-density presentations such as polysaccharides and lipopolysaccharides (Dam and Brewer 2010). Thus, the concept of lectins as pattern recognition receptors in innate immunity (Medzhitov and Janeway 2000; Vasta 2009) has been replaced with lectins as density-dependent glycan binding receptors. However, in order for host lectins to bind to density-dependent expression of glycans on foreign pathogens, the glycan density of host cells must be established and controlled. Evidence that metazoans do regulate their surface glycan density comes from a new study on the effects of mutations in the pathway for the formation of a specific branch chain in Nlinked glycoproteins in mouse cells that results in apparent global compensation of glycan epitope number (density) in the remaining branch chains of the mutant’s N-linked carbohydrates (Takamatsu et al. 2010). N-acetylglucosaminyltransferase-IV (GnT-IV) exists as two isoenzymes, a and b, that initiate the synthesis of the GlcNAcβ1-4 branch on the core Manα1-3 arm of N-glycans. One effect of the GlcNAcβ1-4 branch chain is to increase the glycan epitope density per N-linked carbohydrate chain. Takamatsu et al. (2010) engineered and characterized GnT-IVb-deficient mice and double-IVa/IVbdeficient mice. Wild-type mice have GnT-IVa expression restricted to gastrointestinal tissue, while GnT-IVb is broadly expressed among organs. GnT-IVb-deficient mice show aberrant GnT-IVa expression corresponding to the GnT-IVb distribution pattern, and hence, the GnT-IVb-deficient mice show mild phenotypic alterations in hematopoietic cells and hemostasis. Importantly, GnT-IVa/IVb double-deficient mice have completely abolished GnT-IV activity, and thus there is a complete disappearance of the GlcNAcβ1-4 branch on the Manα1-3 arm of the N-linked glycans that was confirmed by matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry (MS) and gas chromatography-MS analyses. The absence of the GlcNAcβ1-4 branch, however, was shown by MS analyses as additional glycan epitope extensions on the remaining branches in the tissues of the N-linked glycans of the GnT-IVa/IVb double-deficient mice. For example, the Le epitope is found in greater number in the N-linked glycans from mouse kidney cells, and biosynthetic compensation is observed in biand triantennary N-glycans of the double mutant relative to the tetra-antennary N-glycans of the wild-type cells (Figure 1) (Takamatsu et al. 2010). Similar biosynthetic compensation was observed for other glycan epitopes such as polylactosamine in the pancreas. Analysis shows that these additional glycan epitopes in the GnT-IVa/IVb double-deficient mice are due to elevated expression of glycosyltransferases that are normally involved in their biosynthesis. Remarkably, the phenotype of the GnT-IVa/IVb double-deficient mice was similar to that of the GnT-IVa single-deficient mice, which is relatively mild compared to the wild-type mice. The ability of the GnT-IVa/IVb double-deficient mice to effectively restore glycan epitope density in the remaining N-linked glycans of the different organs of the mice suggests that maintenance of this density is critical to the homeostatic function of the cells and organs of the mouse. The authors describe these findings as the first example of induced glycomic compensation of glycosyltranserase activities of cells from different organs of the mice (Takamatsu et al. 2010). They also suggest that maintenance of the overall expression of glycan ligands for endogenous lectins in the double-mutant mice appears to prevent cellular dysfunctions, but no mechanism was suggested for these effects. We suggest that a possible mechanism for regulating cell surface glycan density in both the wild-type and GnT-IVa/
The legume species of Cymbosema roseum of Diocleinae subtribe produce at least two different seed lectins. The present study demonstrates that C. roseum lectin I (CRL I) binds with high affinity to the "core" trimannoside of N-linked oligosaccharides. Cymbosema roseum lectin II (CRL II), on the other hand, binds with high affinity to the blood group H trisaccharide (Fucα1,2Galα1-4GlcNAc-). Thermodynamic and hemagglutination inhibition studies reveal the fine binding specificities of the two lectins. Data obtained with a complete set of monodeoxy analogs of the core trimannoside indicate that CRL I recognizes the 3-, 4- and 6-hydroxyl groups of the α(1,6) Man residue, the 3- and 4-hydroxyl group of the α(1,3) Man residue and the 2- and 4-hydroxyl groups of the central Man residue of the trimannoside. CRL I possesses enhanced affinities for the Man5 oligomannose glycan and a biantennary complex glycan as well as glycoproteins containing high-mannose glycans. On the other hand, CRL II distinguishes the blood group H type II epitope from the Lewis(x), Lewis(y), Lewis(a) and Lewis(b) epitopes. CRL II also distinguishes between blood group H type II and type I trisaccharides. CRL I and CRL II, respectively, possess differences in fine specificities when compared with other reported mannose and fucose recognizing lectins. This is the first report of a mannose-specific lectin (CRL I) and a blood group H type II-specific lectin (CRL II) from seeds of a member of the Diocleinae subtribe.
Synthetic introduction of aglyconic substitutions into carbohydrate ligands is an approach toward identifying potent inhibitors of medically relevant lectins. We tested a panel of 27 galactoside/lactoside derivatives harboring varying aglycone moieties together with some O-3/O-3' functionality toward a biohazardous plant toxin and four human adhesion/growth-regulatory galectins. Differential sensitivity profiles of lectin binding with cases showing activity increase relative to galactose/lactose were revealed by systematic assessments using a solid-phase assay. Quantitative differences between the homologous human proteins could even be detected. Binding of substituted lactosides to galectins-1 and -3 was shown to be enthalpically driven. To determine the potential of substituted glycosides to protect cells from harmful lectin association, binding assays with human tumor cells were performed. Invariably, compounds were identified with increased potency relative to the unsubstituted parent sugars. However, aglyconic substitutions were shown to be able to convey cytotoxicity. This report directs further attention to examining additional 2'- and 3'-substitutions of the galactose core and the potential of ligand presentation in glycoclusters to enhance avidity and selectivity, continuing to use the herein applied strategic combination of a convenient biochemical test system with bioassays.
The biological signaling properties of lectins, which are carbohydrate-binding proteins, are due to their ability to bind and cross-link multivalent glycoprotein receptors on the surface of normal and transformed cells. While the cross-linking properties of lectins with multivalent carbohydrates and glycoproteins are relatively well understood, the mechanisms of binding of lectins to multivalent glycoconjugates are less well understood. Recently, the thermodynamics of binding of lectins to synthetic clustered glycosides, a multivalent globular glycoprotein, and to linear glycoproteins (mucins) have been described. The results are consistent with a dynamic binding mechanism in which lectins bind and jump from carbohydrate to carbohydrate epitope in these molecules. Importantly, the mechanism of binding of lectins to mucins is similar to that for a variety of protein ligands binding to DNA. Recent analysis also shows that high-affinity lectin-mucin cross-linking interactions are driven by favorable entropy of binding that is associated with the bind and jump mechanism. The results suggest that the binding of ligands to biopolymers, in general, may involve a common mechanism that involves enhanced entropic effects which facilitate binding and subsequent complex formation including enzymology.
Mucins form a group of heavily O‐glycosylated biologically important glycoproteins that are involved in a variety of biological functions, including modulating immune response, inflammation, and adhesion. Mucins are also involved in cancer and metastasis and often express diagnostic cancer antigens. Recently, a modified porcine submaxillary mucin (Tn‐PSM) containing GalNAcα1‐O‐Ser/Thr residues was shown to bind to soybean agglutinin (SBA) with ∼106‐fold enhanced affinity relative to GalNAcα1‐O‐Ser, the pancarcinoma carbohydrate antigen. In this study, dynamic force spectroscopy is used to investigate molecular pairs of SBA and Tn‐PSM. A number of force jumps that demonstrate unbinding or rebinding events were observed up to a distance equal to 2.0 μm, consistent with the length of the mucin chain. The unbinding force increased from 103 to 402 pN with increasing force loading rate. The position of the activation barrier in the energy landscape of the interaction was 0.1 nm. The lifetime of the SBA–TnPSM complex in the absence of applied force was determined to be in the range 1.3–1.9 s. Kinetic parameters describing the rate of dissociation of other sugar lectin interactions are in the range 3.3 × 10−3–2.5 × 10−3 s. The long lifetime of the SBA‐TnPSM complex is compatible with a binding model in which lectin molecules “bind and jump” from α‐GalNAc residue to α‐GalNAc residue along the polypeptide chain of Tn‐PSM before dissociating. These findings have important implications for the molecular recognition properties of mucins. © 2009 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Biopolymers 91: 719–728, 2009.
The innate immune response of multicellular organisms is initiated by the binding of soluble and membrane-bound host molecules including lectins to the surface of pathogenic organisms. Until recently, it was believed that the epitopes recognized by host molecules were uniquely associated with the pathogenic organisms. Hence, the term pattern recognition receptors (PRRs) was used to describe their binding specificities. However, with an expanding number of lectin classes including C-type lectins, siglecs, and galectins recognized as PRRs, it is apparent that many of the glycan epitopes recognized on foreign pathogens are present in the host and involved in cellular functions. Hence, the molecular basis for pattern recognition by lectins of carbohydrate epitopes on pathogens is in question. A number of studies indicate that the density and number of glycan epitopes in multivalent carbohydrates and glycoprotein receptors determine the affinity of lectins and their effector functions. This paper reviews lectins that are involved in innate immunity, mechanisms of enhanced affinity and cross-linking of lectins with density-dependent glycan epitopes, density-dependent recognition of glycan receptors by lectins in host systems and lectin-glycan interactions in foreign pathogens. Evidence indicates that lectin pattern recognition in innate immunity is part of a general mechanism of density-dependent glycan recognition. This leads to a new definition of lectin receptor in biological systems, which considers the density and number of glycan epitopes on the surface of cells and not just the affinity of single epitopes.