Previous work on additively-manufactured oxide dispersion strengthened alloys focused on experimental approaches, resulting in larger dispersoid sizes and lower number densities than can be achieved with conventional powder metallurgy. To improve the as-fabricated microstructure, this work integrates experiments with a thermodynamic and kinetic modeling framework to probe the limits of the dispersoid sizes and number densities that can be achieved with powder bed fusion-laser beam. Bulk samples of a Ni–20Cr + 1 wt% Y2O3 alloy are fabricated using a range of laser power and scanning velocity combinations. Scanning transmission electron microscopy characterization is performed to quantify the dispersoid size distributions across the processing space. The smallest mean dispersoid diameter (29 nm) is observed at 300 W and 1200 mm/s, with a number density of 1.0 × 1020 m−3. The largest mean diameter (72 nm) is observed at 200 W and 200 mm/s, with a number density of 1.5 × 1019 m−3. Scanning electron microscopy suggests that a considerable fraction of the oxide added to the feedstock is lost during processing, due to oxide agglomeration and the ejection of oxide-rich spatter from the melt pool. After accounting for these losses, the model predictions for the dispersoid diameter and number density align with the experimental trends. The results suggest that the mechanism that limits the final number density is collision coarsening of dispersoids in the melt pool. The modeling framework is leveraged to propose processing strategies to limit dispersoid size and increase number density.
Additive manufacturing ( AM) has revolutionized component design for liquid rocket engines by offering rapid manufacturing capabilities. This has led to significant opportunities for development and flight programs in the propulsion industry, resulting in cost and schedule savings, as well as performance improvements through new designs and alloy development. A noteworthy example is the GRX-810 oxide dispersion strengthened (ODS) alloy, which was specifically developed for extreme temperatures. This Ni-Co-Cr based alloy was created using integrated computational materials engineering (ICME) techniques to focus on a new class of materials with exceptional temperature and oxidation-resistant properties. The GRX-810 alloy utilizes AM processes to incorporate nano-scale yttria particles throughout its microstructure, resulting in remarkable enhancements. Compared to traditional Nickel-based superalloys, the GRX-810 alloy offers a twofold increase in tensile strength, 1,000-fold better creep properties, and two-fold improvement in oxidation resistance. NASA successfully demonstrated the development and manufacturing of components using the GRX-810 alloy through laser powder bed fusion (L-PBF) and laser powder directed energy deposition (LP-DED) processes. Extensive efforts were made to model, evaluate metallurgical properties, develop heat treatment processes, characterize the microstructure, and determine mechanical properties. The GRX-810 alloy was specifically designed for aerospace applications, including liquid rocket engine injectors, preburners, turbines, and hot-section components, capable of withstanding temperatures up to 1,100 degrees C. The objective of this alloy development is to bridge the temperature gap between traditional Nickel-based superalloys and refractory alloys. This paper provides a comprehensive comparison of the GRX-810 alloy with other aerospace alloys, discussing its microstructure, mechanical properties, processing advancements, component development, and hot-fire testing results. The ultimate goal of this development was to elevate the Technology Readiness Level (TRL) of the GRX-810 alloy, enabling its integration into NASA and commercial aerospace applications.
A follow-on study was performed on NASA’s recently developed nickel-based P/M TSNA-1 diskDisk alloy to evaluate the influence of processingProcessing on the alloy’s mechanical propertiesMechanical properties. The composition of the alloy was tailored to improve the high-temperatureHigh temperature creepCreep strength through transformation strengthening of precipitatePrecipitates phases. Initial alloy developmentAlloy development was done utilizing HIP processingProcessing. The follow-on study evaluated the properties of the forged version of the alloy which provided for a more realistic processingProcessing history similar to that utilized in the engine industry. The creepCreep performance of the forged material significantly exceeded the original HIPHot Isostatic Pressing (HIP) material and outperformed alloys like LSHR and ME3 by an order of magnitude. The TSNA-1 alloy’s cyclic and dwell FCG behavior was also characterized. While the HIP condition of the alloy exhibited very poor dwell FCG resistance in comparison to the LSHR P/M diskDisk alloy, the forgingForging processed TSNA-1 drastically improved the crack growth behavior. In the forged condition, both cyclic and dwell FCG behavior of the alloy were equivalent to a current LSHR P/M alloy.
The National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) has been involved in the development and maturation of metal additive manufacturing (AM) for space applications since the late 2000's. Several efforts have focused on the understanding of AM processes through material characterization and testing, standards development, component fabrication, and infusion into propulsion development and flight applications. NASA matured commonly used aerospace alloys from various alloy families (Nickel, Copper, Stainless and Steel, Aluminum, and Titanium-based) through detailed AM process and heat treatment characterization, in addition to mechanical and thermophysical testing. While these alloys are actively used in many propulsion applications, there is a need for ongoing AM optimized alloys using integrated computational materials engineering (ICME) and process development for high performance applications. The applications targeted are liquid rocket engines; advanced propulsion systems; and in-space propulsion with high heat fluxes, high pressure, and/or that use propellants that can degrade alloys (e.g., hydrogen). This paper highlights the characterization and physical properties of the more common AM alloys using laser powder bed fusion (L-PBF) and laser powder directed energy deposition (LP-DED) processes. Additionally, this paper discusses some of the ongoing novel alloy development and maturation using AM for use in these harsh environments, such as GRCop-42, GRCop-84, NASA HR-1, GRX-810, and C-103. The results from these processes demonstrated that AM could enable rapid development, and that optimized alloys could be developed using ICME, yielding higher performances. These alloys have undergone modeling, fundamental metallurgical evaluations, heat treatment studies, detailed microstructure characterization, and mechanical testing campaigns. This, combined with direct application-specific component fabrication and hot-fire testing, enabled the increase of the Technology Readiness Level (TRL) through high duty-cycle testing. A background and overview of these novel AM-enabled alloys and AM processing developments including metallurgical and mechanical property studies is presented here. The latest advancement in the parallel component development and hot-fire testing and future developments for these alloys is also discussed.
In this paper, we make use of composite voxels in elasto-viscoplastic formulations based on fast Fourier transforms (EVPFFT) to calculate the stress field around an elliptical crack. The predicted stress field at the vicinity of the crack is verified against recently developed analytical solutions. The representation of an elliptical crack in the image-based method is stair-stepped, resulting in oscillations that are mitigated by the use of partially-filled, i.e. composite voxels. Dependencies of the oscillations in the predicted stress fields based on minor changes in the crack size crack size and aspect ratio are discussed and quantified. New understanding is gained of the factors that affect the oscillations, such as the aspect ratio of the ellipse, and the effect of minor changes in the crack interface location. The results show that the use of composite voxels significantly reduces the spurious oscillations in predicted stress fields, and consequently improves the agreement between the EVPFFT simulations and analytical solutions.
Multiprincipal-element alloys are an enabling class of materials owing to their impressive mechanical and oxidation-resistant properties, especially in extreme environments 1 , 2 . Here we develop a new oxide-dispersion-strengthened NiCoCr-based alloy using a model-driven alloy design approach and laser-based additive manufacturing. This oxide-dispersion-strengthened alloy, called GRX-810, uses laser powder bed fusion to disperse nanoscale Y 2 O 3 particles throughout the microstructure without the use of resource-intensive processing steps such as mechanical or in situ alloying 3 , 4 . We show the successful incorporation and dispersion of nanoscale oxides throughout the GRX-810 build volume via high-resolution characterization of its microstructure. The mechanical results of GRX-810 show a twofold improvement in strength, over 1,000-fold better creep performance and twofold improvement in oxidation resistance compared with the traditional polycrystalline wrought Ni-based alloys used extensively in additive manufacturing at 1,093 °C 5 , 6 . The success of this alloy highlights how model-driven alloy designs can provide superior compositions using far fewer resources compared with the ‘trial-and-error’ methods of the past. These results showcase how future alloy development that leverages dispersion strengthening combined with additive manufacturing processing can accelerate the discovery of revolutionary materials.
Solidification or hot cracks are commonly observed defects in a number of metal alloys and may lead to deterioration of additively manufactured parts quality. In this study, ultra-high-speed x-ray radiography experiments enable the observation and characterization of bundles of hot-cracks that form in monobloc AA6061 substrate. The crack bundles are related to meltpool characteristics and pore formation. Crack propagation rate is also presented for the case of a crack that initiates from a pore. Two types of relevant pore formation are also described, namely keyhole porosity and crack-remelting porosity. The results of this study are expected to facilitate the validation of theoretical and numerical models of solidification cracking.
Crack initiation, crack coalescence and small crack growth behavior were monitored for over 400 seeded in-clusions during interrupted low cycle fatigue testing conducted on the P/M Udimet 720 nickel disk alloy at 650 degrees C. Two types of seeded alumina inclusions with average sizes of 54 mu m and 122 mu m were used in the study performed at varying loading conditions resulting in LCF lives ranging from 2,000 cycles to over 1,000,000 cycles. The fatigue behavior was sub-categorized into four groups. Visual maps detailing inclusion size/cycle history were developed. The effect of surface residual stresses on the fatigue life was also investigated.
Additive manufacturing (AM) represents an exciting new approach towards producing metallic aerospace components. The ability to make complex geometries that were impossible to create using conventional manufacturing methods has sparked interest from the aerospace community, including NASA. The use of AM components for crucial and human rated space missions necessitates a full characterization of the differences between AM and more conventional wrought and cast processes. For this study, sixteen different commercially available superalloy 718 powder feedstocks were obtained, built using laser powder bed fusion ( L -PBF), and microstructurally and mechanically analyzed. These measurements revealed a wide range of build qualities and microstructures despite all powder lots falling within the 718 chemical specification and being processed using the same prescribed build and heat treatment parameters. Statistical analysis found a strong correlation of the amount of carbon in the powder with the final grain size and strength of the heat-treated 718 part. Ultimately, this study highlights the need of a refined superalloy 718 chemical specification for powder lots to be used in AM.
Additive manufacturing currently facilitates new avenues for materials discovery that have not been fully explored. In this study we reveal how additive manufacturing can be leveraged to produce dispersion strengthened (DS), multi-principal element alloys (MPEA) without the use of traditional mechanical alloying or chemical reactions. This new processing technique employed resonant acoustic mixing to coat an equiatomic NiCoCr powder with nano-scale yttrium oxides. Then, through laser powder bed fusion (L-PBF), the coated powder was successfully consolidated into 99.9% dense parts. Microstructural analysis confirmed the successful incorporation and dispersion of nano-scale oxides throughout the build volume. Furthermore, high temperature mechanical testing of the DS alloys showed significant improvements in strength and ductility over the baseline NiCoCr. As a result, this recently discovered processing route opens a new alloy design and production path that is synergistic between additive manufacturing and dispersion strengthening, possibly enabling a new generation of high-performance alloys.
The effects of post-build heat-treatments on the microstructure, phase formation, recrystallization behavior, and mechanical properties of laser powder bed additively manufactured Inconel 718 superalloy were investigated. Several heat-treatment schedules were used, including simulated hot isostatic pressing (HIP), and variations of the standard double aging treatment with various soaking times and quench procedures. Their effects on the precipitation, grain morphology, grain size, texture sharpness and mechanical properties were all documented. For the as-built coupons, columnar grains with inter-dendritic micro-segregation were formed along the build direction (xz-plane) with equiaxed grains forming on perpendicular sections to the build direction (xy-plane). After prolonged soaking times during the simulated HIP process, the microstructure transitioned from heterogeneous columnar grains to homogenous recrystallized grains with MC-type carbide precipitates. This leads to changes of microhardness (281 HV2.0 to 171 HV2.0), Young's modulus (209 GPa-229 GPa) and texture intensity. However, aging treatments increased both hardness and Young's modulus possibly because of formation of gamma '' and gamma' precipitates in the Ni-matrix and the small effective grain size. Phase analysis using XRD confirmed the evolution of the precipitate formation. The combination of additive manufacturing and post-build heat-treatments can result in optimized microstructures and mechanical properties for specific applications depending on part requirements and operating conditions.
We present the application of a Convolutional Neural Network (CNN) to relate stress concentrations to surface roughness. Stress concentrations at the low points of rough surfaces are one of the primary causes of fatigue crack initiation but there is no generally accepted method for analyzing rough surfaces to predict crack initiation. Synthetically generated rough surfaces, instantiated in a mechanical model allow for the simulation of stress concentrations, creating a database of surface images and corresponding mechanical data. In this work, the CNN is designed and trained to interpret a height map of a surface and, from that data, to predict the stress concentrations created by the surface. Using a simple architecture, the CNN achieved R-2 = 0.75 in prediction for test images, i.e., those not used in training. This CNN can be adapted for experimental surfaces thus creating a new and straightforward tool for prediction of crack initiation. Considerable care was taken to minimize the complexity of the CNN architecture and to make it interpretable via viewports.
In additive manufacturing (AM) processes, materials are selectively added in layer-wise fashion to build three-dimensional objects. This approach provides several advantages over conventional manuf...
We used ultrahigh-speed synchrotron x-ray imaging to quantify the phenomenon of vapor depressions (also known as keyholes) during laser melting of metals as practiced in additive manufacturing. Although expected from welding and inferred from postmortem cross sections of fusion zones, the direct visualization of the keyhole morphology and dynamics with high-energy x-rays shows that (i) keyholes are present across the range of power and scanning velocity used in laser powder bed fusion; (ii) there is a well-defined threshold from conduction mode to keyhole based on laser power density; and (iii) the transition follows the sequence of vaporization, depression of the liquid surface, instability, and then deep keyhole formation. These and other aspects provide a physical basis for three-dimensional printing in laser powder bed machines.
Characterizing complex surface topologies is necessary to understand stress concentrations created by rough surfaces, particularly those made via laser power-bed additive manufacturing (AM). Synchrotron-based X-ray microtomography (\(\upmu \hbox {XCT}\)) of AM surfaces was shown to provide high resolution detail of surface features and near-surface porosity. Using the CT reconstructions to instantiate a micromechanical model indicated that surface notches and near-surface porosity both act as stress concentrators, while adhered powder carried little to no load. Differences in powder size distribution had no direct effect on the relevant surface features, nor on stress concentrations. Conventional measurements of surface roughness, which are highly influenced by adhered powder, are therefore unlikely to contain the information relevant to damage accumulation and crack initiation.
A unique approach to correlating an evolving 3D microstructure in an Al-Cu alloy and its micro-scale mechanical properties has been introduced. Using these nanoscale three-dimensional microstructures derived from Transmission X-ray Microscopy (TXM), individual contributions from different strengthening mechanisms were quantified. The spatial distribution and morphology of the individual θ′ and θ phases were seen to play an important role in influencing dislocation storage. Uniaxial micro-compression experiments were used to quantify the stress-strain response of the alloy at different aging times. Transmission electron microscopy (TEM) aided in discerning dislocation activity at these precipitates. A model is proposed to accurately predict the variation in yield stress by using appropriate morphological parameters from the 3D microstructure and its validity has been corroborated using experimental measurements. Distributions of 2D and 3D inter-precipitate spacing were seen to provide crucial insights on influencing deformation in such precipitation-strengthened alloys. Finally, the transition in deformation behavior and origin of numerous strain bursts were investigated using in situ micropillar compression testing.