The determinant spreading of T cell autoimmunity plays an important role in the pathogenesis of type 1 diabetes and in the protective mechanism of Ag-based immunotherapy in NOD mice. However, little is known about the role of APCs, particularly B cells, in the spreading of T cell autoimmunity. We studied determinant spreading in NOD/scid or Igμ−/− NOD mice reconstituted with NOD T and/or B cells and found that mice with mature B cells (TB NOD/scid and BMB Igμ−/− NOD), but not mice that lacked mature B cells (T NOD/scid and BM Igμ−/− NOD), spontaneously developed Th1 autoimmunity, which spread sequentially among different β cell Ags. Immunization of T NOD/scid and BM Igμ−/− NOD mice with a β cell Ag could prime Ag-specific Th1 or Th2 responses, but those T cell responses did not spread to other β cell Ags. In contrast, immunization of TB NOD/scid and BMB Igμ−/− NOD mice with a β cell Ag in IFA induced Th2 responses, which spread to other β cell Ags. Furthermore, we found that while macrophages and dendritic cells could evoke memory and effector T cell responses in vitro, B cells significantly enhanced the detection of spontaneously primed and induced Th1 responses to β cell Ags. Our data suggest that B cells, but not other APCs, mediate the spreading of T cell responses during the type 1 diabetes process and following Ag-based immunotherapy. Conceivably, the modulation of the capacity of B cells to present Ag may provide new interventions for enhancing Ag-based immunotherapy and controlling autoimmune diseases.

Reactive oxygen species, such as superoxide, and nitrogen oxides, such as peroxynitrite, are thought to contribute to beta-cell destruction during the disease process that leads to type 1 diabetes. EUK-8 is a member of a new class of synthetic salen-manganese compounds with low toxicity that possess catalytic superoxide dismutase, peroxidase, and catalase activity that can inactivate superoxide and nitrogen oxides (e.g., peroxynitrite and nitrogen dioxide). We observed that EUK-8 administration inhibited the adoptive transfer of type 1 diabetes to NOD mice. In addition, administration of EUK-8 to NOD mice with established autoimmunity completely prevented the development of type 1 diabetes for up to 1 year in age, even though the treatment was discontinued after 35 weeks of age. EUK-8 treatment also prolonged the survival of islet allografts in newly diabetic NOD mice. Thus, reactive oxygen and nitrogen species contribute to the pathoetiology of both spontaneous type 1 diabetes and allograft rejection. In cultures of NIT-1 cells, EUK-8 inhibited cytotoxicity caused by superoxide as well as nitric oxide. Collectively, our findings implicate a greater role for nitrogen oxides (other than peroxynitrite) in beta-cell damage. Antioxidants designed to prevent the formation of both cytotoxic reactive oxygen and nitrogen species may effectively protect beta-cells from spontaneous autoimmunity and alloresponses.

A workshop on autoreactive T-cell responses in NOD mice was held to optimize autoreactive T-cell detection methodologies. Using different proliferation assay protocols, 1 of the 11 participating laboratories detected spontaneous T-cell responses to GAD(524-543) and insulin(9-23) in their NOD mice. Two other laboratories were able to detect autoreactive responses when using enzyme-linked immunospot assay (ELISPOT) and enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) analysis of cytokines in culture supernatants, suggesting that these assays provided greater sensitivity. To address the divergent findings, a follow-up mini-workshop tested NOD mice from four different colonies side-by-side for T-cell proliferative responses to an expanded panel of autoantigens, using the protocol that had enabled detection of responses in the 1st International NOD Mouse T-Cell Workshop. Under these assay conditions, 16 of 16 NOD mice displayed proliferative responses to whole GAD65, 13 of 16 to GAD(524-543), 9 of 16 to GAD(217-236), 7 of 16 to insulin(9-23), and 5 of 16 to HSP277. Thus, spontaneous proliferative T-cell responses can be consistently detected to some beta-cell autoantigens and peptides thereof. Overall, the results suggest that more sensitive assays (e.g., ELISPOT, ELISA analysis of cytokines in supernatants, or tetramer staining) may be preferred for the detection of autoreactive T-cells.

B cells can serve dual roles in modulating T cell immunity through their potent capacity to present Ag and induce regulatory tolerance. Although B cells are necessary components for the initiation of spontaneous T cell autoimmunity to beta cell Ags in nonobese diabetic (NOD) mice, the role of activated B cells in the autoimmune process is poorly understood. In this study, we show that LPS-activated B cells, but not control B cells, express Fas ligand and secrete TGF-beta. Coincubation of diabetogenic T cells with activated B cells in vitro leads to the apoptosis of both T and B lymphocytes. Transfusion of activated B cells, but not control B cells, into prediabetic NOD mice inhibited spontaneous Th1 autoimmunity, but did not promote Th2 responses to beta cell autoantigens. Furthermore, this treatment induced mononuclear cell apoptosis predominantly in the spleen and temporarily impaired the activity of APCs. Cotransfer of activated B cells with diabetogenic splenic T cells prevented the adoptive transfer of type I diabetes mellitus (T1DM) to NOD/scid mice. Importantly, whereas 90% of NOD mice treated with control B cells developed T1DM within 27 wk, <20% of the NOD mice treated with activated B cells became hyperglycemic up to 1 year of age. Our data suggest that activated B cells can down-regulate pathogenic Th1 immunity through triggering the apoptosis of Th1 cells and/or inhibition of APC activity by the secretion of TGF-beta. These findings provide new insights into T-B cell interactions and may aid in the design of new therapies for human T1DM.

B cells can serve dual roles in modulating T cell immunity through their potent capacity to present Ag and induce regulatory tolerance. Although B cells are necessary components for the initiation of spontaneous T cell autoimmunity to β cell Ags in nonobese diabetic (NOD) mice, the role of activated B cells in the autoimmune process is poorly understood. In this study, we show that LPS-activated B cells, but not control B cells, express Fas ligand and secrete TGF-β. Coincubation of diabetogenic T cells with activated B cells in vitro leads to the apoptosis of both T and B lymphocytes. Transfusion of activated B cells, but not control B cells, into prediabetic NOD mice inhibited spontaneous Th1 autoimmunity, but did not promote Th2 responses to β cell autoantigens. Furthermore, this treatment induced mononuclear cell apoptosis predominantly in the spleen and temporarily impaired the activity of APCs. Cotransfer of activated B cells with diabetogenic splenic T cells prevented the adoptive transfer of type I diabetes mellitus (T1DM) to NOD/scid mice. Importantly, whereas 90% of NOD mice treated with control B cells developed T1DM within 27 wk, <20% of the NOD mice treated with activated B cells became hyperglycemic up to 1 year of age. Our data suggest that activated B cells can down-regulate pathogenic Th1 immunity through triggering the apoptosis of Th1 cells and/or inhibition of APC activity by the secretion of TGF-β. These findings provide new insights into T-B cell interactions and may aid in the design of new therapies for human T1DM.

Although glutamic acid decarboxylase (GAD) has been implicated in IDDM, there is no direct evidence showing GAD-reactive T cells are diabetogenic in vivo. To address this issue, 3-wk-old NOD mice received two injections of purified rat brain GAD; one mouse rapidly developed diabetes 3 wk later. Splenocytes from this mouse showed a proliferative response to purified GAD, and were used to generate a CD4+ T cell line, designated 5A, that expresses TCRs encoding Vbeta2 and Vbeta12. 5A T cells exhibit a MHC restricted proliferative response to purified GAD, as well as GAD65 peptide 524-543. After antigen-specific stimulation, 5A T cells secrete IFNgamma and TNFalpha/beta, but not IL-4. They are also cytotoxic against NOD-derived hybridoma cells (expressing I-Ag7) that were transfected with rat GAD65, but not nontransfected hybridoma cells. Adoptive transfer of 5A cells into NOD/SCID mice produced insulitis in all mice. Diabetes occurred in 83% of the mice. We conclude that GAD injection in young NOD mice may, in some cases, provoke diabetes due to the activation of diabetogenic T cells reactive to GAD65 peptides. Our data provide direct evidence that GAD65 autoimmunity may be a critical event in the pathogenesis of IDDM.

In the non-obese diabetic (NOD) mouse, a Th1-biased autoimmune response arises spontaneously against glutamic acid decarboxylase, concurrent with the onset of insulitis. Subsequently, Th1-type autoreactivity spreads intra- and intermolecularly to other beta-cell autoantigens (beta CAAs), suggesting that a spontaneous Th1 cascade underlies disease progression. Induction of Th2 immunity to a single beta CAA results in the spreading of Th2-type T-cell and humoral responses to other beta CAAs in an infectious manner. Thus, both Th1 and Th2 autoimmunity can evolve in amplificatory cascades defined by site-specific, but not antigen-specific, positive feedback circuits. Despite the continued presence of Th1 autoimmunity, the induction of Th2 spreading is associated with active tolerance to beta CAAs and reduced disease incidence. With disease progression there is an attenuation of beta CAA-inducible Th2 spreading, presumably because of a reduced availability of uncommitted beta CAA-reactive precursor T cells. We discuss the implications of these findings for the rational design of antigen-based immunotherapeutics.

Autoantigen-based immunotherapeutics have been shown to activate regulatory responses capable of inhibiting T cell-mediated autoimmune disease in animal models. However, their efficacy generally declines, as treatment occurs later in the disease process, and their mechanism of action is a matter of intense debate. Here, we report that the early administration of beta cell autoantigens (betaCAAs) to nonobese diabetic (NOD) mice broadly diverts the natural development of potentially pathogenic Thl-biased autoimmune responses toward the Th2 phenotype through Th2 spreading. With disease progression, there was a steady decline in the ability of betaCAA treatment to promote Th2-type cellular and humoral autoimmunity. Late in the disease process, some betaCAAs were still able to induce Th2 responses and Th2 spreading (although to a much lesser extent), while other autoantigens were not. This attenuation of inducible Th2 immunity with disease progression is likely to reflect a reduction in the availability of uncommitted autoantigen-reactive precursor T cells. These findings suggest that there are inherent differences in the frequency of betaCAA-reactive T cells and that, in advanced stages of autoimmune disease, regulatory responses may be best elicited with target tissue Ags against which large uncommitted T cell pools are still available. Since individuals presenting the first signs of autoimmune disease are likely to already have an advanced disease process, these findings may be useful for the rational design of Ag-based immunotherapeutics.

A cloned Thl cell line was isolated from pancreatic lymph nodes of NOD mice that carries a T-cell receptor encoding Vβ14 and proliferates in response to NOD islets, islet supernatant, and crystalline bovine and rat insulin, specifically to a B-chain peptide bound to IAg7. The response to islet supernatant was reduced by 75% by anti-insulin antibody treatment. The insulin-reactive clone reduced insulitis and totally blocked the development of spontaneous diabetes in NOD mice (n = 8) as well as the adoptive transfer of diabetes into irradiated NOD mice following the injection of splenocytes from diabetic mice (n = 13). Trafficking of the adoptively transferred cells was assessed by labeling the clone or diabetic splenocytes with a fluorescent marker (Dil). The labeled clone was detected in the islet periphery, whereas labeled splenocytes alone invaded the islets by 3 days. In contrast, the protective clone dramatically delayed and reduced the number of labeled diabetic splenocytes infiltrating the islet, although their appearance in the spleen was unaffected. In vitro, the clone as well as supernatant derived from the clone blocked the proliferation of diabetic NOD splenocytes to islets. This inhibitory effect was diminished by anti–transforming growth factor-β. In conclusion, an insulin-specific Thl cell was isolated from NOD mice that traffics to the islet and prevents the spontaneous development and the adoptive transfer of diabetes. It appears to act locally by releasing transforming growth factor-β and/or other factors that inhibit homing to and/or proliferation of diabetic splenocytes within the islet. These findings may provide insights into and suggest mechanisms for the protective effects of insulin therapy against diabetes.