Phenotyping mouse model systems of human disease has proven to be a difficult task, with frequent poor inter- and intra-laboratory replicability, particularly in behavioral domains such as social and cognitive function. However, establishing robust animal model systems with strong construct validity is of fundamental importance as they are central tools for understanding disease pathophysiology and developing therapeutics. To complete our studies of mouse model systems relevant to autism spectrum disorder (ASD), we present a replication of the main findings from our two published studies of five genetic mouse model systems of ASD. To assess the intra-laboratory robustness of previous results, we chose the two model systems that showed the greatest phenotypic differences, the Shank3/F and Cntnap2, and repeated assessments of general health, activity and social behavior. We additionally explored all five model systems in the same framework, comparing all results obtained in this three-yearlong effort using informatics techniques to assess commonalities and differences. Our results showed high intra-laboratory replicability of results, even for those with effect sizes that were not particularly large, suggesting that discrepancies in the literature may be dependent on subtle but pivotal differences in testing conditions, housing enrichment, or background strains and less so on the variability of the behavioral phenotypes. The overall informatics analysis suggests that in our behavioral assays we can separate the set of tested mouse model system into two main classes that in some aspects lie on opposite ends of the behavioral spectrum, supporting the view that autism is not a unitary concept.
Behavioral aggression is a common neuropsychiatric symptom that coincides with progressive cognitive decline in adults with Alzheimer's disease (AD). One of the key hallmarks of AD is progressive accumulation of amyloid-beta (Aβ) throughout the brain. The present study was aimed at measuring non-cognitive behaviors such as aggression and relevant pathologies such as plaque load and distribution in mutant mice expressing human APP, namely the APP/PS1 (APPsw/PS1 (m146L)) and TASD41 (hAPP751 with the London V717I9/Swedish double mutation K670M/N671L). In the current study, we were interested in examining progression of behavioral manifestations in male mice of both the APP/PS1 and TASD41 lines. The resident-intruder paradigm was used to assess aggression in AD mice. We also utilized proprietary algorithm-based behavioral platform, the SmartCube® System, to assess whole animal behavior longitudinally. To compliment these behavioral outputs, we additionally performed Serial Two-Photon whole brain imaging and analysis of the distribution, size and density of Aβ-plaques in young and aged AD mice using the TissueCyte® imaging platform. The present findings demonstrate increased aggressive behavior in aged APP/PS1 and TASD41 male mice compared to wild-type littermates. We also demonstrate pharmacological attenuation of aggression in AD mice with acute administration of either antipsychotic (Risperidone) or anxiolytic (Busipirone). Using sophisticated algorithm-based system, SmartCube®, we were able to identify a phenotype effect and distinct behavioral changes in male AD mice as early as 5 months of age that progressed over time. In line with the behavioral data, our whole brain TissueCyte® based analyses suggests that younger mice (∼4-5 months) exhibit very sparse parenchymal plaques while aged mice (>7 months) show a clear progression in the number/size of plaques and display differential increases in regional plaque load number/size. In summary, we demonstrate clear aggressive behavior and pharmacological validation in aged, male mouse models of amyloidosis, with more advanced computer vision systems identifying distinctive behavioral patterns and discriminating the phenotype at early disease stages. Together with the region-specific progression of plaque densities, these models present a valuable tool for early intervention and improved assessment of potential therapeutic approaches for AD and in particular AD-induced aggression.
To expand, analyze and extend published behavioral phenotypes relevant to autism spectrum disorder (ASD), we present a study of three ASD genetic mouse models: Feng’s Shank3 tm2Gfng model, hereafter Shank3/F , Jiang’s Shank3 tm1Yhj model, hereafter Shank3/J , and the Cacna1c deletion model. The Shank3/F and Shank3/J models mimick gene mutations associated with Phelan-Mcdermid syndrome and the Cacna1c model recapitulates the deletion underlying Timothy syndrome. The current study utilizes both standard and novel, computer-vision based behavioral tests, the same methdology used in our previously published companion report on the Cntnap2 null and 16p11.2 deletion models. Overall, some but not all behaviors replicated published findings. Those that replicated, such as social behavior and overgrooming in Shank3 models, also tended to be milder than previous reports. The Shank3/F model, and to a much lesser extent, the Shank3/J and Cacna1c models, showed hypoactivity and a general anxiety-like behavior triggered by external stimuli which pervaded social interactions. We did not detect deficits in a cognitive procedural learning test nor did we observe perseverative behavior in these models. We did, however, find differences in exploratory patterns of Cacna1c mutant mice suggestive of a behavioral effect in a social setting. In addition, Shank3/F but not Shank3/J KO or Cacna1c HET showed differences in sensory-gating. Discrepancies in our current results from previous reports may be dependent on subtle differences in testing conditions, housing enrichment, or background strain. Both positive and negative results from this study will be useful in identifying the most robust and replicable behavioral signatures within and across mouse models of autism. Understanding these phenotypes may shed light of which features to study when screening compounds for potential therapeutic interventions.
Huntington’s Disease (HD) is a progressive neurodegenerative disorder that causes motor, cognitive, and psychiatric symptoms. In these experiments, we tested if operant training at an early age affected adult cognitive deficits in the zQ175 KI Het (zQ175) mouse model of HD. In Experiment 1 we trained zQ175 mice in a fixed-ratio/progressive ratio (FR/PR) task to assay learning and motivational deficits. We found pronounced deficits in response rates and task engagement in naïve adult zQ175 mice (32-33 weeks age), while deficits in zQ175 mice trained from 6-7 weeks age were either absent or less severe. When those mice were re-tested as adults, FR/PR performance deficits were absent or otherwise less severe than deficits observed in naïve adult zQ175 relative to wild type (WT) mice. In Experiment 2, we used a Go/No-go operant task to assess the effects of early cognitive testing on response inhibition deficits in zQ175 mice. We found that zQ175 mice that began testing at 7-8 weeks did not exhibit deficits in Go/No-go testing, but when re-tested at 28-29 weeks age exhibited an initial impairment that diminished with training. These transient deficits were nonetheless mild relative to deficits observed among adult zQ175 mice without prior testing experience. In Experiment 3 we trained mice in a two-choice visual discrimination test to evaluate cognitive flexibility. As in prior experiments, we found performance deficits were mild or absent in mice that started training at 6-9 weeks of age, while deficits in naive mice exposed to training at 28-29 weeks were severe. Re-testing mice at 28-29 weeks age, were previously trained starting at 6-9 weeks, revealed that deficits in learning and cognitive flexibility were absent or reduced relative to effects observed in naive adults. In Experiment 4, we tested working memory deficits with a delayed non-match to position (DNMTP) test. Mice with prior experience exhibited mild working memory deficits, with males zQ175 exhibiting no deficits, and females performing significantly worse than WT mice at a single delay interval, whereas naive zQ175 exhibited severe delay-dependent deficits at all intervals exceeding 1 s. In sum, these experiments indicate that CAG-dependent impairments in motivation, motor control,
Patricia Kabitzke, Daniela Brunner, Dansha He, Pamela A. Fazio, Kimberly Cox, Jane Sutphen, Lucinda Thiede, Emily Sabath, Taleen Hanania, Vadim Alexandrov, Randall Rasmusson, Will Spooren, Anirvan Ghosh, Pamela Feliciano, Barbara Biemans, Marta Benedetti, and Alice Luo Clayton. PsychoGenics, Inc., Tarrytown, NY, USA Department of Psychiatry, Columbia University, New York, NY, USA Department of Physiology and Biophysics, SUNY Buffalo School of Medicine and Biomedical Sciences, Buffalo, NY, USA Roche Pharma Research and Early Development, NORD, Roche Innovation Center, Basel, Switzerland Simons Foundation Autism Research Initiative, New York, NY, USA
Autism spectrum disorder comprises several neurodevelopmental conditions presenting symptoms in social communication and restricted, repetitive behaviors. A major roadblock for drug development for autism is the lack of robust behavioral signatures predictive of clinical efficacy. To address this issue, we further characterized, in a uniform and rigorous way, mouse models of autism that are of interest because of their construct validity and wide availability to the scientific community. We implemented a broad behavioral battery that included but was not restricted to core autism domains, with the goal of identifying robust, reliable phenotypes amenable for further testing. Here we describe comprehensive findings from two known mouse models of autism, obtained at different developmental stages, using a systematic behavioral test battery combining standard tests as well as novel, quantitative, computer-vision based systems. The first mouse model recapitulates a deletion in human chromosome 16p11.2, found in 1% of individuals with autism. The second mouse model harbors homozygous null mutations in Cntnap2, associated with autism and Pitt-Hopkins-like syndrome. Consistent with previous results, 16p11.2 heterozygous null mice, also known as Del(7Slx1b-Sept1)4Aam weighed less than wild type littermates displayed hyperactivity and no social deficits. Cntnap2 homozygous null mice were also hyperactive, froze less during testing, showed a mild gait phenotype and deficits in the three-chamber social preference test, although less robust than previously published. In the open field test with exposure to urine of an estrous female, however, the Cntnap2 null mice showed reduced vocalizations. In addition, Cntnap2 null mice performed slightly better in a cognitive procedural learning test. Although finding and replicating robust behavioral phenotypes in animal models is a challenging task, such functional readouts remain important in the development of therapeutics and we anticipate both our positive and negative findings will be utilized as a resource for the broader scientific community.
Huntington's disease (HD) is an autosomal dominant, progressive neurodegenerative disorder caused by expansion of CAG repeats in the huntingtin gene. Tissue transglutaminase 2 (TG2), a multi-functional enzyme, was found to be increased both in HD patients and in mouse models of the disease. Furthermore, beneficial effects have been reported from the genetic ablation of TG2 in R6/2 and R6/1 mouse lines. To further evaluate the validity of this target for the treatment of HD, we examined the effects of TG2 deletion in two genetic mouse models of HD: R6/2 CAG 240 and zQ175 knock in (KI). Contrary to previous reports, under rigorous experimental conditions we found that TG2 ablation had no effect on either motor or cognitive deficits, or on the weight loss. In addition, under optimal husbandry conditions, TG2 ablation did not extend R6/2 lifespan. Moreover, TG2 deletion did not change the huntingtin aggregate load in cortex or striatum and did not decrease the brain atrophy observed in either mouse line. Finally, no amelioration of the dysregulation of striatal and cortical gene markers was detected. We conclude that TG2 is not a valid therapeutic target for the treatment of HD.
BACKGROUND:Huntington's disease (HD) is characterized not only by severe motor deficits but also by early cognitive dysfunction that significantly increases the burden of the disease for patients and caregivers. Considerable efforts have concentrated, therefore, on the assessment of cognitive deficits in some HD mouse models. However, many of these models that exhibit cognitive deficits also have contemporaneous serious motor deficits, confounding interpretation of cognitive decline.OBJECTIVE:The BACHD and zQ175 mouse models present a more slowly progressing disease phenotype in both motor and cognitive domains, and might therefore offer a better opportunity to measure cognitive decline over a longer timeframe; such models could be useful in screening therapeutic compounds. In order to better define the cognitive impairments evident in BACHD and zQ175 HD mice, both were tested in an instrumental touchscreen visual discrimination assay designed to assess discrimination learning and cognitive flexibility.METHODS:BACHD and zQ175 mice, as well as their WT controls were tested for their ability to discriminate two complex visual stimuli. Following this discrimination phase, the reinforcement contingencies were reversed and the previously incorrect stimulus became the correct stimulus. In a final, third phase of testing, two novel stimuli were introduced and mice were required to undergo a second round of discrimination testing with these stimuli.RESULTS:Our results show that learning during the discrimination phase was similar between the WT and BACHD mice. In contrast, the zQ175 at 26 weeks of age showed decreased accuracy over the last 10 days of discrimination, compared to WT controls. During subsequent reversal and novel stimuli phases, both BACHD and zQ175 mice exhibited significant deficits compared to WT controls.CONCLUSIONS:Our results suggest that the BACHD, and for the first time, zQ175 HD models exhibit cognitive inflexibility and psychomotor slowing, a phenotype that is consistent with cognitive symptoms described in HD patients.
The neurodegenerative disorder Huntington’s disease (HD) is characterized by motor dysfunction, cognitive impairment and psychiatric symptoms. The R6/2 (120 CAG repeats) mouse model of HD recapitulates many of the symptoms of the disease, including marked impairments in cognition and severe motor deficits. As cholinergic function has been reported to be affected in both HD patients and this mouse model, we tested whether treatment with the cholinesterase inhibitor donepezil could improve the R6/2 mice performance in the two-choice swim tank visual discrimination and reversal task. In this test mice are trained to swim towards a light cued platform located on one side of a water-filled tank. Once mice reach an acquisition criterion a reversal ensues. Wild-type and R6/2 mice were dosed with donepezil (0.6 mg/kg/day) or vehicle starting at 8 weeks of age and tested starting at 9 weeks of age. In experiment 1, vehicle-treated R6/2 mice showed a significant deficit during acquisition and reversal as compared to vehicle-treated WT mice. Donepezil improved reversal in the R6/2 group. In experiment 2, we confirmed the beneficial effect of donepezil on reversal in similar conditions. Donepezil had no effect on activity as measured in the open field test or through the latency to reach the platform during the swim test. We suggest that the donepezil-induced improvements in cognitive function observed in the R6/2 transgenic model of HD may reflect amelioration of deficits in cholinergic function that have been reported previously in this model. Further work is required to confirm the findings of these interesting although preliminary studies.