Recently, the possibility of LPA-produced muon beams has gained significant interest within the accelerator application community. Directional, multi-GeV muons can be produced via Bethe-Heitler interactions when multi-GeV electrons hit solid targets. They are highly penetrating and, thanks to the compactness of the LPA, offer a path toward a deployable, active muon source. At the BELLA Center of the Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, we previously unambiguously detected muons generated during the interaction of multi-GeV electron beams with a 4 meter-thick electron beam dump. A new campaign has now extended our diagnostic capabilities to single-muon trajectory reconstruction and energy measurements. The setup allowed us to individually reconstruct each muon trajectory, defined by us as a muon passing through three detectors used for the reconstruction. For a subset of events, we extracted the muon energy from the magnetic-field bending angle, demonstrating production of GeV-scale muons. This work provides a key demonstration of track-based active-source muography, which enables non-invasive 3D density mapping of concealed or inaccessible samples, and it will accelerate the development of active LPA-based muon sources where compactness, controlled directionality, low divergence, and deep penetration are required.
Laser-matter interaction at relativistic intensities is central to almost every scientific case for multi-PW laser facilities. In particular, the progress in laser-driven ion acceleration brings this interaction closer to multiple applications, ranging from material science to biomedical research. One of the most important questions regarding ion acceleration is how to obtain high charge ion beams with relativistic energies. Increasing laser energy and intensity usually leads to a number of limitations on maximum achievable ion energies rooted in the fundamental properties of charged particle interaction with strong electromagnetic fields. Following advances in staged laser-plasma electron acceleration, staged ion acceleration could offer a path to relativistic energies. Here, such scheme is explored and the possibility of scaling the acceleration of ion beams to relativistic energies is discussed.
Radiotherapy with Very High Energy Electron (VHEE) beams is being extensively investigated for the treatment of deep-seated tumours, even in view of novel protocols based on the so-called FLASH effect. Laser WakeField Acceleration (LWFA) provides a compact and affordable accelerator technology for VHEE electron beams, featuring ultra-high instantaneous dose rates and holding the promise to provide Ultra-High (average) Dose Rates (UHDRs) needed to activate the FLASH effect, with major efforts ongoing worldwide to fulfill this promise. Therapeutic doses are already at reach, using pencil beams produced via LWFA. These beams typically exhibit significant energy spread, and small transverse size. These features are rather different from those of other beams considered so far in radiotherapy studies. In view of a rapid clinical translation of LWFA-VHEE beams it is therefore of paramount importance to assess the role of these properties in the dose delivery to the patient. Here we present a study carried out via start-to-end (PIC and Monte Carlo) simulations, of the main dosimetric features of a realistic laser-driven VHEE pencil beam targeted on a brain tumor. The entire tumor coverage is achieved by a scanning procedure; the dose pattern resulting from tessellation, i.e. the overlapping of adjacent beamlets, and the role of energy spread are thoroughly discussed. Dose Volume Histograms are presented, and their quality is discussed. The impact of the FLASH effect is also considered, introducing a degree of healthy tissue sparing in the modelling. Finally, the foreseen technological path toward the achievement of FLASH dose rates with LWFA-VHEE beams is briefly outlined.
We present the detection of directional muon beams produced using a PW laser facility at the Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory. The muon source is a multi-GeV electron beam generated in a 30 cm laserplasma accelerator interacting with a high-Z converter target. The GeV photons resulting from the interaction are converted into a high-flux, directional muon beam via pair production. By employing scintillators to capture delayed events, we were able to identify the produced muons and characterize the source. Using theoretical knowledge of the muon production process combined with simulations that are in excellent agreement with the experiments, we demonstrate that laser-plasma accelerators have the capability of generating electron beams with characteristics suitable to produce GeV-scale muons that offer unique advantages with respect to the cosmic background. Laser-plasma-accelerator-based muon sources can therefore enhance muon imaging applications thanks to their compactness, directionality, and high yields, which reduce the exposure time by orders of magnitude compared to cosmic ray muons. Using the Geant4-based simulation code we developed to gain insight into the experimental results, we can design future experiments and applications based on LPA-generated muons.
The potential of the intense secondary muon, neutrino, and (hypothetical) light dark matter beams at the Thomas Jefferson National Accelerator Facility (Jefferson Lab) is explored. These are produced in the high-power dumps with high-current electron beams. Light dark matter searches with the approved Beam Dump eXperiment (BDX) are driving the realization of a new underground vault behind Hall A that could be extended to a Beamdump Facility with little additional installations. High-energy muons created via the Bethe–Heitler process uniquely do not proceed through the more common pion production and decay channels. Several possible muon physics applications are highlighted. Neutrino detector technologies and experiments suitable for a beamdump facility are outlined.
This document outlines a community-driven Design Study for a 10 TeV pCM Wakefield Accelerator Collider. The 2020 ESPP Report emphasized the need for Advanced Accelerator R&D, and the 2023 P5 Report calls for the “delivery of an end-to-end design concept, including cost scales, with self-consistent parameters throughout." This Design Study leverages recent experimental and theoretical progress resulting from a global R&D program in order to deliver a unified, 10 TeV Wakefield Collider concept. Wakefield Accelerators provide ultra-high accelerating gradients which enables an upgrade path that will extend the reach of Linear Colliders beyond the electroweak scale. Here, we describe the organization of the Design Study including timeline and deliverables, and we detail the requirements and challenges on the path to a 10 TeV Wakefield Collider.
Future, high-fidelity simulations of multi-GeV-class Laser Wakefield Accelerators (LWFAs) will need to model the propagation of high-intensity laser drivers over meter-scale plasmas with high spatial and temporal resolutions, thus requiring high amounts of computational resources. Various techniques have been devised over the years to reduce the computational cost of such simulations, including the time-averaged ponderomotive approximation, and the use of the Lorentz boosted frame technique. In this paper we discuss the combination of these two computational techniques, highlighting the resulting significant reduction in the computational cost of LWFA simulations and the limitations of this approach. The combination of the two techniques can potentially become essential for the modeling of a multi-TeV, LWFA-based collider.
The workshop focused on the application of ANAs to particle physics keeping in mind the ultimate goal of a collider at the energy frontier (10 TeV, e^+/e^-, e^-/e^-, or γγ). The development of ANAs is conducted at universities and national laboratories worldwide. The community is thematically broad and diverse, in particular since lasers suitable for ANA research (multi-hundred-terawatt peak power, a few tens of femtosecond-long pulses) and acceleration of electrons to hundreds of mega electron volts to multi giga electron volts became commercially available. The community spans several continents (Europe, America, Asia), including more than 62 laboratories in more than 20 countries. It is among the missions of the ICFA-ANA panel to feature the amazing progress made with ANAs, to provide international coordination and to foster international collaborations towards a future HEP collider. The scope of this edition of the workshop was to discuss the recent progress and necessary steps towards realizing a linear collider for particle physics based on novel-accelerator technologies (laser or beam driven in plasma or structures). Updates on the relevant aspects of the European Strategy for Particle Physics (ESPP) Roadmap Process as well as of the P5 (in the US) were presented, and ample time was dedicated to discussions. The major outcome of the workshop is the decision for ALEGRO to coordinate efforts in Europe, in the US, and in Asia towards a pre-CDR for an ANA-based, 10 TeV CM collider. This goal of this coordination is to lead to a funding proposal to be submitted to both EU and EU/US funding agencies. This document presents a summary of the workshop, as seen by the co-chairs, as well as short 'one-pagers' written by the presenters at the workshop.
It is widely accepted that the next lepton collider beyond a Higgs factory would require center-of-mass energy of the order of up to 15 TeV. Since, given reasonable space and cost restrictions, conventional accelerator technology reaches its limits near this energy, high-gradient advanced acceleration concepts are attractive. Advanced and novel accelerators (ANAs) are leading candidates due to their ability to produce acceleration gradients on the order of 1–100 GV/m, leading to compact acceleration facilities. However, intermediate energy facilities (IEF) are required to test the critical technology elements on the way towards multi-TeV-class collliders. Here a science case for a 20–100 GeV center-of-mass energy ANA-based lepton collider that can be a candidate for an intermediate energy facility is presented. The IEF can provide numerous opportunities for high energy physics studies including precision Quantum Chromodynamics and Beyond the Standard Model physics measurements, investigation of charged particle interactions with extreme electromagnetic fields, and exploring muon and proton beam acceleration. Possible applications of this collider include the studies of γγ and electron beam-fixed target/beamdump collider designs. Thus, the goal of the proposed IEF is to both carry out particle physics measurements in the 20-100 GeV ranges as well as to serve as an ANA demonstrator facility.
Plasma based acceleration is considered a promising concept for the next generation of linear electron-positron colliders. Despite the great progress achieved over last twenty years in laser technology, laser and beam driven particle acceleration, and special target availability, positron acceleration remains significantly underdeveloped if compared to electron acceleration. This is due to both the specifics of the plasma-based acceleration, and the lack of adequate positron sources tailored for the subsequent plasma based acceleration. Here a positron source based on the collision of a high energy electron beam with a high intensity laser pulse is proposed. The source relies on the subsequent multi-photon Compton and Breit-Wheeleer processes to generate an electron-positron pair out of a high energy photon emitted by an electron. Due to the strong dependence of the Breit-Wheeler process rate on photon energy and field strength, positrons are created with low divergence in a small volume around the peak of the laser pulse. The resulting low emittance in the submicron range potentially makes such positron source interesting for collider applications.
In this paper we discuss a compact, laser-plasma-based scheme for the generation of positron beams suitable to be implemented in an all-optical setup. A laser-plasma-accelerated electron beam hits a solid target producing electron-positron pairs via bremsstrahlung. The back of the target serves as a plasma mirror to in-couple a laser pulse into a plasma stage located right after the mirror where the laser drives a plasma wave (or wakefield). By properly choosing the delay between the laser and the electron beam the positrons produced in the target can be trapped in the wakefield, where they are focused and accelerated during the transport, resulting in a collimated beam. This approach minimizes the ballistic propagation time and enhances the trapping efficiency. The system can be used as an injector of positron beams and has potential applications in the development of a future, compact, plasma-based electron-positron linear collider.
Laser-plasma accelerators are capable of sustaining accelerating fields of 10–100 GeV/m, 100–1000 times that of conventional technology and the highest fields produced by any of the widely researched advanced accelerator concepts. Laser-plasma accelerators also intrinsically accelerate short particle bunches, several orders of magnitude shorter than that of conventional technology, which leads to reductions in beamstrahlung and, hence, savings in the overall power consumption to reach a desired luminosity. These properties make laser-plasma accelerators a promising accelerator technology for a more compact, less expensive high-energy linear collider providing multi-TeV polarized leptons. In this submission to the Snowmass 2021 Accelerator Frontier, we discuss the motivation for a laser-plasma-accelerator-based linear collider, the status of the field, and potential linear collider concepts up to 15 TeV. We outline the research and development path toward a collider based on laser-plasma accelerator technology, and highlight near-term and mid-term applications of this technology on the collider development path. The required experimental facilities to carry out this research are described. We conclude with community recommendations developed during Snowmass.
Owing to their large accelerating gradients, plasma-based accelerators have attracted considerable interest as potential drivers for future, compact electron–positron colliders. Despite great progress achieved in plasma-based electron acceleration, positron acceleration still remains a challenging task, with an efficient positron source being the prerequisite for such acceleration. Here a concept for a compact, two-stage plasma-based positron source is discussed. In the first stage the positrons are created by a multi GeV electron beam produced by a laser-plasma accelerator interacting with a solid density foil. In the second stage the positrons are captured and accelerated in a plasma wave driven by either an electron beam or a laser pulse. Three potential configurations of such a source are considered: (i) a single electron beam is used for both the creation of positrons in the foil and for driving the wakefield in the second stage; (ii) a train of two electron beams is used: the positrons produced by the trailing beam in the foil are captured and accelerated in the second stage by the plasma wave generated by the leading beam; and (iii) a single electron beam is used to produce positrons in the foil and an independent laser pulse is coupled to the second stage to drive the plasma wave. These three configurations show different degrees of effectiveness with positron capture efficiency, varying from less than a percent to almost half of all produced positrons.
Laser plasma accelerators (LPAs) have promise to be the next generation accelerator for colliders, as well as drive a number of basic science, industry, security and medical applications. Many applications require high brightness electron beams enabled by low emittance. One proposal to achieve ultra-low emittance from an LPA is a two color laser configuration, where a long wavelength laser, with large ponderomotive force, is used to excite a plasma wakefield, while another trailing short wavelength laser is used to ionize inner shell electrons, injecting them in the accelerating phase of the wake [1]. The short wavelength allows for a high electric field for ionization, with low ponderomotive force. Most LPAs use Ti:Sapphire based lasers with central wavelength 0.8 μm. We will present experiments and simulations performed at the BELLA Center on generating the third harmonic of short (45 fs), high fluence (30 mJ/cm2), Ti:Sapphire based laser pulses for the purpose of ionization injection in a quasi-linear wake. Features and challenges unique to short pulse, high fluence harmonic generation and characterization as well as how those challenges were addressed will also be presented.
As part of the Snowmass'21 community planning excercise, the Advanced Accelerator Concepts (AAC) community proposed future linear colliders with center-of-mass energies up to 15 TeV and luminosities up to 50 × 10 34 cm -2 s -1 in a compact footprint. In addition to being compact, these machines must also be energy efficient. We identify two challenges that must be addressed in the design of these machines. First, the Beam Delivery System (BDS) must not add significant length to the accelerator complex. Second, beam parameters must be chosen to mitigate beamstrahlung effects and maximize the luminosity-per-power of the machine. In this paper, we review advances in plasma lens technology that will help to reduce the length of the BDS system and we detail new Particle-in-Cell simulation studies that will provide insight into beamstrahlung mitigation techniques. We apply our analysis to both e + e - and γγ colliders. The challenges and solutions described in this paper are considered independently. A unified, self-consistent concept for a BDS system for a 15 TeV linear collider will be the subject of future work.
The Beam Delivery System (BDS) is a critical component of a high-energy linear collider. It transports the beam from the accelerator and brings it to a focus at the Interaction Point. The BDS system includes diagnostic sections for measuring the beam energy, emittance, and polarization, as well as collimators for machine protection. The length of the BDS increases with collision energy. Higher collision energies also require higher luminosities, and this is a significant constraint on the design for energy-frontier machines. Here, we review BDS designs based on traditional quadrupole magnets and examine the challenges involved in extending these to the Multi-TeV regime consistent with requirements for advanced accelerator concepts.
Laser-driven plasma-based accelerators are a compact method to accelerate electron beams, and accelerating gradients of 1–100 GV/m, several orders of magnitude larger than conventional accelerators, have been experimentally demonstrated. These high accelerating gradients combined with space charge shielding provided by the background plasma ions allow for the generation of high brightness electron beams. Plasma-based accelerators also naturally produce ultra-short beams, a fraction of the plasma wavelength. Controlled injection techniques, such as density gradient injection and laser-triggered injection, enable control over the electron beam production and phase space distribution. Two-color ionization injection, where one long-wavelength laser pulse generates a plasma wave for acceleration, and a second short-wavelength laser pulse is used to ionize and trap electrons, is capable of generating multi-kA electron beams with sub 100 nm normalized emittances. These laser-plasma-based methods of ultra-bright electron beam generation will be discussed, and progress toward experimental demonstration of two-color ionization injection will be reported.
It is widely accepted that the next lepton collider beyond a Higgs factory would require center-of-mass energy of the order of up to 15 TeV. Since, given reasonable space and cost restrictions, conventional accelerator technology reaches its limits near this energy, high-gradient advanced acceleration concepts are attractive. Advanced and novel accelerators (ANAs) are leading candidates due to their ability to produce acceleration gradients on the order of 1--100~GV/m, leading to compact acceleration structures. Over the last 10-15 years significant progress has been achieved in accelerating electron beams by ANAs. For example, the demonstration of several-GeV electron beams from laser-powered capillary discharge waveguides, as well as the proof-of-principle coupling of two accelerating structures powered by different laser pulses, has increased interest in ANAs as a viable technology to be considered for a compact, TeV-class, lepton linear collider. However, intermediate facilities are required to test the technology and demonstrate key subsystems. A 20-100 GeV center-of-mass energy ANA-based lepton collider can be a possible candidate for an intermediate facility. Apart from being a test beam facility for accelerator and detector studies, this collider will provide opportunities to study muon and proton beam acceleration, investigate charged particle interactions with extreme electromagnetic fields (relevant for beam delivery system designs and to study the physics at the interaction point), as well as precision Quantum Chromodynamics and Beyond the Standard Model physics measurements. Possible applications of this collider include the studies of $\gamma\gamma$ and $e$-ion collider designs.
White paper to the Proceedings of the U.S. Particle Physics Community Planning Exercise (Snowmass 2021): Linear colliders based on laser-plasma accelerators
In this paper we discuss design considerations and beam dynamics challenges associated with laser-driven plasma-based accelerators as applied to multi-TeV-scale linear colliders. Plasma accelerators provide ultra-high gradients and ultra-short bunches, offering the potential for compact linacs and reduced power requirements. We show that stable, efficient acceleration with beam quality preservation is possible in the nonlinear bubble regime of laser-plasma accelerators using beam shaping. Ion motion, naturally occuring for dense beams (i.e., low emittance and high energy) severely damps transverse beam instabilities. Coulomb scattering by the background ions is considered and it is shown that the strong focusing in the plasma strongly suppresses scattering-induced emittance growth. Betatron radiation emission from the transverse motion of the beam in the plasma will result in beam power loss and energy spread growth; however for sub-100 nm emittances, the beam power loss and energy spread growth will be sub-percent for multi-TeV-class plasma linacs.