Atomically precise subnanometer catalysts are of significant interest because of their remarkable efficiency in a variety of catalytic reactions. However, the dynamic changes of active sites under reaction conditions, in particular, the transition of cluster-oxide interface structure have not yet been well-elucidated, lacking in situ measurements. By using multiple state-of-the-art in situ characterizations, here we show a dynamic interplay between copper tetramers and iron oxides in a single-size Cu-4/Fe2O3 catalyst, yielding an enrichment of surface Cu-4-Fe2+ species under reaction conditions that boosts CO2 hydrogenation at near-atmospheric pressures. During reaction, Cu-4 clusters facilitate the reduction of Fe2O3 producing surface-rich Fe2+ species in the proximate sites. The as-formed Fe2+ species in return promotes CO2 activation and transformation over Cu4 cluster, resulting in strikingly high methanol synthesis at low temperatures and C-1/C-3 hydrocarbon production in a high-temperature regime. The discovery of highly active Cu-4-Fe2+ sites thus provides new insights for the atomic-level design of copper catalyst toward high-efficiency CO2 conversion under mild conditions.
We have used ab initio density functional theory together with ab initio atomistic thermodynamics, and in situ x-ray absorption near edge spectroscopy (XANES) experiments, to study the oxidation of sub-nanometer clusters of CunOx supported on a hydroxylated amorphous alumina substrate in an O2-rich environment. We obtain (p , T) phase diagrams: these differ notably for the nanoclusters compared to the bulk. Both the theory and experiment suggest that in the presence of oxygen, the cluster will oxidize from its elemental state to the oxidized state as the temperature decreases. We obtain a clear trend for the transition of Cun → CunOn/2: we see that the smaller the cluster, the greater is the tendency toward oxidation. However, we do not see a monotonic size-dependent trend for the transition of CunOn/2 → CunOn. We suggest that theoretically computed Bader charges constitute a simple yet quantitative way to align experimental measures of XANES edges with theoretical calculations, so as to yield oxidation states for nanoclusters. Our results have important implications for the use of small clusters in fields such as nanocatalysis and nanomedicine.
Having the ability to tune the oxidation state of Cu nanoparticles is essential for their utility as catalysts. The degree of oxidation that maximizes product yield and selectivity is known to vary, depending on the particular reaction. Using first principles calculations and XANES measurements, we show that for subnanometer sizes in the gas phase, smaller Cu clusters are more resistant to oxidation. However, this trend is reversed upon deposition on an alumina support. We are able to explain this result in terms of strong cluster-support interactions, which differ significantly for the oxidized and elemental clusters. The stable cluster phases also feature novel oxygen stoichiometries. Our results suggest that one can tune the degree of oxidation of Cu catalysts by optimizing not just their size, but also the support they are deposited on.
The Cover Feature shows the size-dependent reduction temperature of oxidized subnanometer copper clusters supported on hydroxylated alumina. The reduction temperature decreases with cluster size for the supported clusters, in stark contrast with the opposite trend found for free gas-phase clusters from first principles calculations. These findings underline the importance of cluster–support interactions and show ways of tuning, by size and support effects, the oxidation state of clusters, which can provide a handle to control their catalytic properties. More information can be found in the Communication by S. Vajda, S. Narasimhan et al.
Size-selected Cu, catalysts (n = 3, 4, 20) were synthesized on Al2O3 thin films using mass-selected cluster deposition. A systematic study of size and support effects was carried out for CO, hydrogenation at atmospheric pressure using a combination of in situ grazing incidence X-ray absorption spectroscopy, catalytic activity measurement, and first principles calculations. The catalytic activity for methanol synthesis is found to strongly vary as a function of the cluster size; the Cu-4/Al2O3 catalyst shows the highest turnover rate for CH3OH production. With only one atom less than Cu-4, Cu-3 showed less than 50% activity. Density functional theory calculations predict that the activities of the gas-phase Cu clusters increase as the cluster size decreases; however, the stronger charge transfer interaction with Al2O3 support for Cu-3 than for Cu-4 leads to remarkably reduced binding strength between the adsorbed intermediates less favorable energetic pathway to transform carbon dioxide to methanol and supported Cu-3, which subsequently results in a less favorable energtic pathway to transform carbon dioxi de to methanol.
We report a nanoparticulate iron oxide based catalyst for CO2 conversion with high efficiency at low pressures and on the effect of the presence of copper on the catalyst's restructuring and its catalytic performance. In situ X-ray scattering reveals the restructuring of the catalyst at the nanometer scale. In situ X-ray absorption near edge structure (XANES) shows the evolution of the composition and oxidation state of the iron and copper components under reaction conditions along with the promotional effect of copper on the chemical transformation of the iron component. X-ray diffraction (XRD), XANES and Raman spectroscopy proved that the starting nano catalyst is composed of iron oxides differing in chemical nature (alpha-Fe2O3, Fe3O4, FeO(OH)) and dimensionality, while the catalyst after CO2 conversion was identified as a mixture of alpha-Fe, Fe3C, and traces of Fe5C2. The significant increase of the rate CO2 is turned over in the presence of copper nanoparticles indicates that Cu nanoparticles activate hydrogen, which after spilling over to the neighbouring iron sites, facilitate a more efficient conversion of carbon dioxide.
Bridging the support gap in heterogeneous ultrananocatalysis.
Size-selected Ag-4 and Ag-16 clusters on a titania surface have been studied for their potential in CO oxidation using theoretical calculations and X-ray absorption near edge spectroscopy. The first peak at the measured Ag Kedge of Ag-16@TiO2 is more prominent in air than in carbon monoxide environment, but no variation was found between the spectra of Ag-4@TiO2 in air and in carbon monoxide environments. Density functional theory calculations show a preference for molecular oxygen adsorption for Ag-4@TiO2 and that for a dissociative one on Ag-16@TiO2, while carbon monoxide reactions with adsorbed oxygen reduced the Ag-16@TiO2 cluster. The dissociated oxygen atoms increased the oxidation state of Ag-16 cluster and resulted in the prominent first peak in Ag K-edge spectrum in quasi-particle theory calculations, with the subsequent carbon monoxide oxidation reversing the character of Ag Kedge spectrum associated with the reduction of the cluster. The results provide insight into the size selectivity of supported subnanometer silver clusters in their interactions with oxygen and carbon monoxide, with implications on the cluster catalytic properties in oxidative reactions.
A combined experimental and theoretical investigation of Ag-Pt sub-nanometer clusters as heterogeneous catalysts in the CO→CO2 reaction (COox) is presented. Ag9 Pt2 and Ag9 Pt3 clusters are size-selected in the gas phase, deposited on an ultrathin amorphous alumina support, and tested as catalysts experimentally under realistic conditions and by first-principles simulations at realistic coverage. In situ GISAXS/TPRx demonstrates that the clusters do not sinter or deactivate even after prolonged exposure to reactants at high temperature, and present comparable, extremely high COox catalytic efficiency. Such high activity and stability are ascribed to a synergic role of Ag and Pt in ultranano-aggregates, in which Pt anchors the clusters to the support and binds and activates two CO molecules, while Ag binds and activates O2 , and Ag/Pt surface proximity disfavors poisoning by CO or oxidized species.
Recent studies of single-atom catalysts open up the prospect of designing exceptionally active and environmentally efficient chemical processes. The stability and durability of such catalysts is governed by the strength with which the atoms are bound to their support and their diffusive behaviour. Here we use aberration-corrected STEM to image the diffusion of single copper adatoms on graphene oxide. We discover that individual atoms exhibit anomalous diffusion as a result of spatial and energetic disorder inherent in the support, and interpret the origins of this behaviour to develop a physical picture for the surface diffusion of single metal atoms.
Co1-xPtx clusters of 2.9-nm size with a range of atomically precise Pt/Co atomic ratios (x = 0, 0.25, 0.5, 0.75, 1) were synthesized using the mass-selected low-energy cluster beam deposition (LECBD) technique and soft-landed onto an amorphous alumina thin film prepared by atomic layer deposition (ALD). Utilizing ex situ X-ray photoemission spectroscopy (XPS), the oxidation state of the as-made clusters supported on Al2O3 was determined after both a 1-h-long exposure to air and aging for several weeks while exposed to air. Next, the aged duster samples were characterized by grazing-incidence X-ray absorption spectroscopy (GIXAS) and then pretreated with diluted hydrogen and further exposed to the mixture of diluted CO and H-2 up to 225 degrees C at atmospheric pressure, and the temperature-dependent evolutions of the particle size/shape and the oxidation states of the individual metal components within the dusters were monitored using in situ grazing-incidence small-angle X-ray scattering and X-ray absorption spectroscopy (GISAXS/GIXAS). The changes in the oxidation states of Co and Pt exhibited a nonlinear dependence on the Pt/Co atomic ratio of the dusters. For example, a low Pt/Co ratio (x <= 0.5) facilitates the formation of Co(OH)(2), whereas a high Pt/Co ratio (x = 0.75) stabilizes the Co3O4 composition instead through the formation of a Co-Pt core-shell structure where the platinum shell inhibits the reduction of cobalt in the core of the Co1-xPtx alloy dusters. The obtained results indicate methods for optimizing the composition and structure of binary alloy clusters for catalysis.
APXPS was used to investigate the effect of oxygen adsorption on the band bending and electron affinity of ALD Al2O3, ZnO and TiO2 ultrathin films.
The study of the electrochemical behavior (in the presence of N-2 or CO2) of size-controlled naked Cu-5 and Cu-20 nanoclusters, prepared using a combination of gas-phase cluster ion sources, mass spectrometry, and soft-landing techniques, evidences some relevant results regarding the redox behavior of these sub-nanometre sized copper particles and the effect of CO2 on them. Cu-20 nanoclusters show anodic redox processes occurring at much lower potential with respect to Cu-5 nanoclusters, which behave relatively similar to much larger Cu particles. However, Cu-5 nanoclusters coordinate effectively CO2 (hydrogen carbonate) in solution, different from Cu-20 nanoclusters and larger Cu particles. This effect, rather than the redox behavior, is apparently connected to the ability of Cu-5 nanoclusters to reduce CO2 under cathodic conditions at low overpotential. Although preliminary, these results provide rather exciting indications on the possibility of realizing low overpotential electrocatalytic conversion of CO2.
Co1–xPtx clusters of 2.9-nm size with a range of atomically precise Pt/Co atomic ratios (x = 0, 0.25, 0.5, 0.75, 1) were synthesized using the mass-selected low-energy cluster beam deposition (LECBD) technique and soft-landed onto an amorphous alumina thin film prepared by atomic layer deposition (ALD). Utilizing ex situ X-ray photoemission spectroscopy (XPS), the oxidation state of the as-made clusters supported on Al2O3 was determined after both a 1-h-long exposure to air and aging for several weeks while exposed to air. Next, the aged cluster samples were characterized by grazing-incidence X-ray absorption spectroscopy (GIXAS) and then pretreated with diluted hydrogen and further exposed to the mixture of diluted CO and H2 up to 225 °C at atmospheric pressure, and the temperature-dependent evolutions of the particle size/shape and the oxidation states of the individual metal components within the clusters were monitored using in situ grazing-incidence small-angle X-ray scattering and X-ray absorption spectroscopy (GISAXS/GIXAS). The changes in the oxidation states of Co and Pt exhibited a nonlinear dependence on the Pt/Co atomic ratio of the clusters. For example, a low Pt/Co ratio (x ≤ 0.5) facilitates the formation of Co(OH)2, whereas a high Pt/Co ratio (x = 0.75) stabilizes the Co3O4 composition instead through the formation of a Co–Pt core–shell structure where the platinum shell inhibits the reduction of cobalt in the core of the Co1–xPtx alloy clusters. The obtained results indicate methods for optimizing the composition and structure of binary alloy clusters for catalysis.
Single atoms and small atomic clusters offer a range of novel, tunable properties for a number of applications such as selective catalysis [1]. Achieving precise control of the desired properties of these systems first requires an understanding of the interaction between the cluster and its support. Advances in aberration‐corrected scanning transmission electron microscopy (STEM) mean that atomic resolution imaging and characterisation is now achievable for many materials. Observing individual atoms and small clusters remains difficult, however, due to low signal‐to‐noise ratio and beam‐induced motions causing blurring during image acquisition. One route around these problems is to acquire rapid image sequences in an effort to reduce the electron dose and also to capture any dynamic behaviour of the atoms. Making use of the spatial and temporal correlations between frames, and using a novel processing method based on singular value thresholding [2], we have developed robust approaches to recover individual atomic positions, including STEM acquisition rates of 10 frames per second or better [3]. We have applied the approach to the study of catalytically‐important copper atoms on few‐layer graphene oxide (GO), where the presence of functional groups on GO may aid the control of deposited clusters by acting as preferential pinning sites. Processing and analysis of an annular dark‐field STEM image sequence reveals a range of behaviours, with some strongly‐pinned atoms and other more mobile atoms undertaking random walks on the surface (Figure 1b). Further investigation of the jump distances (Figure 1c) and mean‐squared displacements (Figure 1d) reveals that the diffusion of adatoms on GO is anomalous. We combine this information with ab‐initio DFT calculations to provide new insight into the formation and behaviour of small atom clusters under an electron beam, and the interactions between few‐atom catalysts and high surface area supports.
The complexity of the water oxidation reaction makes understanding the role of individual catalytic sites critical to improving the process. Here, size-selected 27-atom cobalt clusters (Co27 ) deposited on hematite (Fe2 O3 ) anodes were tested for water oxidation activity. The uniformity of these anodes allows measurement of the activity of catalytic sites of well-defined nuclearity and known density. Grazing incidence X-ray absorption near-edge spectroscopy (GIXANES) characterization of the anodes before and after electrochemical cycling demonstrates that these Co27 clusters are stable to dissolution even in the harsh water oxidation electrochemical environment. They are also stable under illumination at the equivalent of 0.4 suns irradiation. The clusters show turnover rates for water oxidation that are comparable or higher than those reported for Pd- and Co-based materials or for hematite. The support for the Co27 clusters is Fe2 O3 grown by atomic layer deposition on a Si chip. We have chosen to deposit a Fe2 O3 layer that is only a few unit cells thick (2 nm), to remove complications related to exciton diffusion. We find that the electrocatalytic and the photoelectrocatalytic activity of the Co27 /Fe2 O3 material is significantly improved when the samples are annealed (with the clusters already deposited). Given that the support is thin and that the cluster deposition density is equivalent to approximately 5 % of an atomic monolayer, we suggest that annealing may significantly improve the exciton diffusion from the support to the catalytic moiety.