Increased awareness of pathogens with pandemic potential, especially respiratory viruses, is driving research on next-generation mucosal vaccines. However, clinical translation is still hampered by the lack of relevant experimental systems. Here, we review advances in human mucosal ex vivo cultures and their eligibility for vaccine development as an alternative to animal models. Ranging from organotypic air-liquid interface cultures to lymphoid organoids and microfluidics-based co-cultures, several breakthroughs occurred in recent years in modeling mucosa architecture and physiology, as well as adaptive immune responses. Advancing recent progress for clinical developments may require high-throughput approaches to validate the representativeness of the immune response within models, benchmark best practices for regulatory standardization, and investigate the influence of microbiota on mucosal immune responses.
The adenoviral vector-based AstraZeneca and Janssen COVID-19 vaccines have been associated with rare cases of thrombosis, believed to be triggered, among other factors, by vector binding to the blood protein platelet factor 4 (PF4). To identify vectors with lower thrombosis risk, we screened 50 natural and hexon-modified adenoviruses (Ads). Unlike the applied COVID-19 vaccines and most tested vectors, Ad34 and Ad80, as well as Ad5 vectors with deleted or chemically shielded hexon hyper-variable region 1 (HVR1), did not bind to PF4. Furthermore, interactions with PF4 substantially modified Ad5 infectivity in various immortalized and primary cells, suggesting that PF4 may influence existing vector tropism. Finally, HVR1-deleted Ad5 and Ad34 vectors expressing SARS-CoV-2 spike S1 domain were tested as vaccine candidates in mice and induced robust cellular immune responses. Therefore, the identified PF4 non-binding vectors may represent safe and efficient candidates for clinical applications.
BackgroundThe development of mucosal adenovirus (Ad) vaccine vectors is considered one of the next frontiers to protect vulnerable patients from respiratory and gastrointestinal pathogens. An efficient delivery to or through the oral cavity necessitates a thorough understanding of Ad interactions with saliva for oral, buccal or sublingual vaccine delivery, which could additionally prove instrumental in the containment of natural Ad infections but remains unexplored. Therefore, we investigated the influence of saliva on Ad infectivity, emphasizing its intrinsic antiviral role against particular Ad types in various epithelial cell cultures.MethodsA saliva pool was created from healthy donors (n=16) and incubated with ChAdOx1 or human Ads from 20 different types prior to infection of human immortalized epithelial cells. All human Ads used were replication-competent and expressed a GLN cassette containing a green-fluorescent protein, nano-luciferase, and neomycin resistance. Loss-of-function experiments were conducted by immunoprecipitation or enzymatic digestion of specific saliva components to decipher related mechanisms.ResultsTemporal and inter-individual variability in saliva samples were observed, validating the use of a saliva pool to represent the population. Saliva strongly influenced Ad infectivity, in general through inhibiting species B types and enhancing species D and E Ads, that include the vaccine vector platforms Ad26 and ChAdOx1. Interestingly, Ad20 presented the highest infectivity enhancement, as well as superior to average salivary mucus crossing rates. Furthermore, saliva immunoglobulins and human neutrophil peptides marginally influenced the Ad infectivity, while sialic acid inhibited all tested Ad types.ConclusionSaliva may have a protective role against infection by certain types of Ads. This discovery highlights a potential limitation in the efficacy of next-generation oral Ad vaccine vectors. Consequently, our study underscores the importance of identifying and utilizing saliva-resistant Ad vectors to optimize Ad-based vaccination strategies.
ABSTRACTDirected evolution of viral vectors involves the generation of randomized libraries followed by artificial selection of improved variants. Directed evolution only yielded limited results in adenovirus vector (AdV) development until now, mainly due to insufficient complexities of randomized libraries.Clinical applications of AdVs as gene therapy or oncolytic vectors are still hampered by the predetermined tropism of natural types. To overcome this challenge, we hypothesized that the technology of randomized peptide insertions on the capsid surface can be incorporated into the AdV bioengineering toolbox for vector retargeting. Here we developed Adenovirus Directed EVOlution (ADEVO) protocols based on fiber knob peptide display.As a proof-of-concept, HAdV-C5-derived libraries were constructed following three distinct protocols and selected on A549-DCAR cells that lack the HAdV-C5 primary receptor, with the goal of identifying variants able to infect and lyse these tumor cells more efficiently. All protocols enabled the construction of high complexity libraries with up to 9.6x10^5 unique variants, an approximate 100-fold improvement compared to previously published AdV libraries. After selection, the most enriched variants did not display enhanced infectivity but rather more efficient replication and cell lysis. This warrants investigations into potential unsuspected involvement of the fiber protein in adenovirus replication.GRAPHICAL ABSTRACT
Intramuscular vaccines present limitations in eliciting robust mucosal immunity and preventing respiratory pathogens transmission. Sublingual vaccine administration offers promising advantages, including interconnected mucosal protection. Despite these advantages, only a few clinical trials have explored sublingual vaccines, underscoring the necessity of optimizing next-generation vaccine formulas. Critical research priorities include understanding vector behavior in the oral environment, understanding their interactions with mucosal immunity and developing formulations enabling sustained mucosal contact to facilitate efficient transduction. Consequently, tonsil organoids, as representative human mucosal models, could offer critical insights into sublingual immunization. Thus, a multi-disciplinary approach integrating pharmacological, immunological, and manufacturing considerations is pivotal for sublingual vaccines in targeting pathogen-aggravated prevalent respiratory diseases including asthma, COPD and lung cancer, as well as the antimicrobial resistance crisis.
ABSTRACT While recombinant Adenoviruses (rAds) are widely used in both laboratory and medical gene transfer, library-based applications using this vector platform are not readily available. Recently, we developed a new method, the CRISPR/Cas9 mediated in vivo terminal resolution (CTR) aiding high efficiency rescue of rAds from recombinant DNA. Here we report on a genetic workflow that allows construction of BAC-based rAd-libraries employing the efficiency of CTR. We utilized frequent, pre-existing genomic sequences to allow insertion of a selection marker, complementing two selected target sites into novel endonuclease recognition sites. In a second step, this selection marker is replaced with a transgene or mutation of interest via Gibson assembly. Our approach does not cause unwanted genomic off-target mutations while providing substantial flexibility for the site and nature of the genetic modification. This new genetic workflow, which we termed half-site directed fragment replacement (HFR) allows introduction of >10 6 unique modifications into rAd encoding BACs using laboratory scale methodology. To demonstrate the power of HFR, we rescued barcoded viral vector libraries yielding a diversity of ∼2.5×10 4 modified rAd per cm 2 of transfected cell culture. GRAPHICAL ABSTRACT
The adenoviral vector based AstraZeneca and Janssen COVID vaccines have been associated with rare cases of thrombosis, a condition which depends on adenovirus binding to the blood protein Platelet Factor 4 (PF4). In order to identify adenoviruses with low or absent affinity for PF4, we screened dozens of types from various adenovirus species, and Adenovirus type 5 (Ad5) derived vectors carrying genetic or chemical modifications of different hexon hyper-variable regions (HVR). For this purpose, we established an armamentarium of techniques including ELISA-qPCR and Aggregate Pull-Down (APD), which enabled fast and sensitive assessments of virus-protein interactions. Unlike most tested serotypes, Ad34 did not bind to PF4. Likewise, the deletion or shielding of the HVR1 loop of Ad5 seemingly ablated its PF4 binding. Therefore, we showed that PF4 binds to adenovirus hexon through interactions dependent on HVR1, and identified vectors that may avoid or decrease the risk of thrombosis and represent safer candidates for vaccine or gene therapy vector development.
Oncolytic viruses are a promising technology to attack cancer cells and to recruit immune cells to the tumor site. Since the Lipocalin-2 receptor (LCN2R) is expressed on most cancer cells, we used its ligand LCN2 to target oncolytic adenoviruses (Ads) to cancer cells. Therefore, we fused a Designed Ankyrin Repeat Protein (DARPin) adapter binding the knob of Ad type 5 (knob5) to LCN2 to retarget the virus toward LCN2R with the aim of analyzing the basic characteristics of this novel targeting approach. The adapter was tested in vitro with Chinese Hamster Ovary (CHO) cells stably expressing the LCN2R and on 20 cancer cell lines (CCLs) using an Ad5 vector encoding luciferase and green fluorescent protein. Luciferase assays with the LCN2 adapter (LA) showed 10-fold higher infection compared with blocking adapter (BA) in CHO cells expressing LCN2R and in cells not expressing the LCN2R. Most CCLs showed an increased viral uptake of LA-bound virus compared with BA-bound virus and for five CCLs viral uptake was comparable to unmodified Ad5. Flow cytometry and hexon immunostainings also revealed increased uptake of LA-bound Ads compared with BA-bound Ads in most tested CCLs. Virus spread was studied in 3D cell culture models and nine CCLs showed increased and earlier fluorescence signals for LA-bound virus compared with BA-bound virus. Mechanistically, we show that the LA increases viral uptake only in the absence of its ligand Enterobactin (Ent) and independently of iron. Altogether, we characterized a novel DARPin-based system resulting in enhanced uptake demonstrating potential for future oncolytic virotherapy.
As the MHC-I-pathway is key to antigen presentation to cytotoxic T-cells and, therefore, recognition by the host adaptive immune system, we hypothesized that SARS-CoV-2 including its Variants of Concern (VOCs), influences MHC-I expression on epithelial cell surfaces as an immune evasion strategy. We conducted an in vitro time course experiment with the human airway epithelial cell line Calu-3 and the human colorectal adenocarcinoma cell line Caco-2. Cells were infected with SARS-CoV-2 strains non-VOC/B.1.1, Alpha/B.1.1.7, Beta/B.1.351, Gamma/P.1, and Delta/B.1.617.2. At 2, 24, 48 and 72 h post-infection we performed RT-qPCR to track viral replication. Simultaneously, we performed intracellular staining with a serum of a double-vaccinated healthy adult containing a high amount of spike protein antibody. In flow cytometry experiments, we differentiated between infected (spike protein positive) and bystander (spike protein negative) cells. To compare their HLA expression levels, cells were stained extracellularly with anti-HLA-A-IgG and anti-HLA-B,C-IgG. While HLA-A expression was stable on infected Calu-3 cells for all variants, it increased to different degrees on bystander cells in samples infected with VOCs Beta, Gamma, Delta, or non-VOC over the time course analyzed. In contrast, HLA-A levels were stable in bystander Calu-3 cells in samples infected with the Alpha variant. The upregulation of MHC-I on spike protein negative bystander cells in Calu-3 cell cultures infected with Beta, Gamma, Delta, and partly non-VOC might suggest that infected cells are still capable of secreting inflammatory cytokines like type-I interferons stimulating the MHC-I expression on bystander cells. In comparison, there was no distinct effect on HLA expression level on Caco-2 cells of any of the VOCs or non-VOC. Further investigations of the full range of immune evasion strategies of SARS-CoV-2 variants are warranted.
Supplementary Table from Novel Group C Oncolytic Adenoviruses Carrying a miRNA Inhibitor Demonstrate Enhanced Oncolytic Activity In Vitro and In Vivo
The adenovirus vector platform remains one of the most efficient toolboxes for generation of transfer vehicles used in gene therapy and virotherapy to treat tumors, as well as vaccines to protect from infectious diseases. The adenovirus genome and capsids can be modified using highly efficient techniques, and vectors can be produced at high titers, which facilitates their rapid adaptation to current needs and disease applications. Over recent years, the adenovirus vector platform has been in the center of attention for vaccine development against the ongoing coronavirus SARS-CoV-2/COVID-19 pandemic. The worldwide deployment of these vaccines has greatly deepened the knowledge on virus-host interactions and highlighted the need to further improve the effectiveness and safety not only of adenovirus-based vaccines but also of gene therapy and oncolytic virotherapy vectors. Based on the current evidence, we discuss here how adenoviral vectors can be further improved by intelligent molecular design. This review covers the full spectrum of state-of-the-art strategies to avoid vector-induced side effects ranging from the vectorization of non-canonical adenovirus types to novel genome engineering techniques.
BackgroundAdenoviral vectors are among the most frequently used vectors for gene therapy and cancer treatment. Most vectors are derived from human adenovirus (Ad) serotype 5 despite limited applicability caused by pre-existing immunity and unfavorable liver tropism, whereas the other more than 100 known human serotypes remain largely unused. Here, we screened a library of human Ad types and identified Ad4 as a promising candidate vector. MethodsReporter-gene-expressing viruses representative of the natural human Ad diversity were used to transduce an array of muscle cell lines and two- or three-dimensional tumor cultures. The time-course of transgene expression was monitored by fluorescence or luminescence measurements. To generate replication-deficient Ad4 vector genomes, successive homologous recombination was applied. ResultsAd4, 17 and 50 transduced human cardiomyocytes more efficiently than Ad5, whereas Ad37 was found to be superior in rhabdomyocytes. Despite its moderate transduction efficiency, Ad4 showed efficient and long-lasting gene expression in papillomavirus (HPV) positive tumor organoids. Therefore, we aimed to harness the potential of Ad4 for improved muscle transduction or oncolytic virotherapy of HPV-positive tumors. We deleted the E1 and E3 transcription units to produce first generation Ad vectors for gene therapy. The E1- and E1/E3-deleted vectors were replication-competent in HEK293 cells stably expressing E1 but not in the other cell lines tested. Furthermore, we show that the Ad5 E1 transcription unit can complement the replication of E1-deleted Ad4 vectors. ConclusionsOur Ad4-based gene therapy vector platform contributes to the development of improved Ad vectors based on non-canonical serotypes for a broad range of applications.
Oncolytic viruses are a promising technology to attack cancer cells and to recruit immune cells to the tumor site. Since the Lipocalin-2 receptor (LCN2R) is expressed on most cancer cells, we used its ligand LCN2 to target oncolytic adenoviruses (Ads) to cancer cells. Therefore, we fused a DARPin adapter binding the knob of Ad type 5 (knob5) to LCN2 to retarget the virus towards LCN2R with the aim of analyzing the basic characteristics of this novel targeting approach. The adapter was tested in vitro with Chinese Hamster Ovary (CHO) cells stably expressing the LCN2R and on 20 cancer cell lines (CCLs) using an Ad5 vector encoding luciferase and green fluorescent protein (GFP). Luciferase assays with the LCN2 adapter (LA) showed 10-fold higher infection compared to blocking adapter (BA) in CHO cells expressing LCN2R and in cells not expressing the LCN2R. Most CCLs showed an increased viral uptake of LA-bound virus compared to BA-bound virus and for five CCLs viral uptake was comparable to unmodified Ad5. Flow cytometry and hexon immunostainings also revealed increased uptake of LA-bound Ads compared with BA-bound Ads in most tested CCLs. Virus spread was studied in 3D cell culture models and nine CCLs showed increased and earlier fluorescence signals for LA-bound virus compared to BA-bound virus. Mechanistically we show that the LCN2 adapter increases viral uptake only in the absence of its ligand Enterobactin (Ent) and independently of iron. Together, we characterized a novel DARPin-based system resulting in enhanced uptake demonstrating potential for future oncolytic virotherapy.
Respiratory viruses play an important role in asthma exacerbation, and early exposure can be involved in recurrent bronchitis and the development of asthma. The exact mechanism is not fully clarified, and pathogen-to-host interaction studies are warranted to identify biomarkers of exacerbation in the early phase. Only a limited number of international exacerbation cohorts were studied. Here, we have established a local pediatric exacerbation study in Germany consisting of children with asthma or chronic, recurrent bronchitis and analyzed the viriome within the nasopharyngeal swab specimens derived from the entire cohort (n = 141). Interestingly, 41% of exacerbated children had a positive test result for human rhinovirus (HRV)/human enterovirus (HEV), and 14% were positive for respiratory syncytial virus (RSV). HRV was particularly prevalent in asthmatics (56%), wheezers (50%), and atopic (66%) patients. Lymphocytes were decreased in asthmatics and in HRV-infected subjects, and patients allergic to house dust mites were more susceptible to HRV infection. Our study thus confirms HRV infection as a strong 'biomarker' of exacerbated asthma. Further longitudinal studies will show the clinical progress of those children with a history of an RSV or HRV infection. Vaccination strategies and novel treatment guidelines against HRV are urgently needed to protect those high-risk children from a serious course of disease.