Accurate chemical compositions of star-forming regions provide a critical diagnostic tool for characterizing the star formation history and gas flows that regulate galaxy formation. However, the abundance discrepancy factor (ADF) between measurements derived from the "direct" optical electron temperature (Te) method and those from recombination lines (RLs) introduces a similar to 0.2 dex systematic uncertainty in the oxygen abundance. The degree of uncertainty for other elements is unknown. We conduct a comprehensive analysis of O++ and N+ ion abundances using optical and far-infrared (far-IR) spectra of a star-forming region within the nearby dwarf galaxy Haro 3, which exhibits a typical ADF. Assuming homogeneous conditions, the far-IR emission indicates an oxygen abundance higher than that derived using the Te method and consistent with the RL value, as expected from temperature fluctuations, whereas the far-IR nitrogen abundance is too large to be explained by temperature fluctuations. A two-phase analytical model reveals that differential dust obscuration associated with temperature inhomogeneity is likely required to explain all the emission-line ratios, and that the total oxygen metallicity of two phases is consistent with the RL metallicity. Our findings underscore the critical importance of resolving the cause of abundance discrepancies and understanding the biases between different metallicity methods. This work presents a promising methodology, and we identify further approaches to address the dominant sources of uncertainty.
The rest-frame ultraviolet (UV) spectra of star-forming galaxies are increasingly important as they become one of the primary windows to probe the physical properties of cosmic dawn (z > 8) galaxies with the James Webb Space Telescope. However, the systematic discrepancies between UV and optical gas-phase metallicity measurements remain poorly understood in the local universe, partly due to challenges in achieving precise comparisons between UV and optical spectra for the same objects. In this work, we introduce a novel method that leverages the He II lambda 1640 and He II lambda 4686 nebular emission lines to achieve accurate aperture and reddening corrections between UV and optical spectra. Here we apply this method to three nearby Blue Compact Dwarf (BCD) galaxies. Our results demonstrate that this approach enables precise measurements, with electron temperatures (T-e) derived from UV and optical spectra exhibiting closer agreement compared to previous studies, and O/H abundance agreeing within 0.1 dex. However, two BCDs appear to have lower UV-based electron temperatures T-e1666 < T-e4363, in contrast to expectations from the temperature fluctuation model. We consider a variety of possible explanations for these unphysical temperatures - differential dust attenuation, aperture differences, and spatial extent of emission lines - but no suitable cause is identified. These findings suggest a complex gaseous environment associated with star formation, and underscore the need for additional observations to further investigate the nature of He II nebular emission and address the systematic issues between UV and optical nebular properties. Nonetheless, the close empirical agreement of these results indicates that UV- and optical-based nebular temperature and abundance measurements can be reliably compared within 0.1 dex, providing a solid foundation for evolutionary studies from the local Universe to cosmic dawn.
Measurements of the electron density of populations of extragalactic HII regions in nearby galaxies remain limited, despite the relevance of this quantity for characterizing the porosity of the interstellar medium and the escape of the ionizing radiation. We initiated a project aimed at analysing the root-mean-square electron density (n(e))(rms), the in situ density (n(e)) and the volume filling factor (phi) of extragalactic HII regions, investigating the dependence of these attributes on nebular and host galaxy properties. We present an image-segmentation methodology for constructing homogeneous HII region catalogues, and apply it to two pilot galaxies: NGC 2403 and NGC 628. We derive (n(e))(rms) from their H alpha luminosities and equivalent radii (R-eq), and obtain n(e) and phi for spectroscopic subsamples. While ne is below 300 cm(-3) , (n(e))(rms) is typically one to two orders of magnitude lower, implying that 4 is in the range similar to 10(-4) to 10(-1) . The two galaxies exhibit a similar size-density relation, (n(e))(rms) alpha R-eq(-0.3), which breaks for R-eq greater than or similar to 50 pc, show at most a weak dependence of (n(e))(rms) on galactocentric radius for NGC 2403, and no clear dependence of ne or 4 on these parameters. Combining these results with published data, (n(e))rms presents tentative scaling relations with the median HII region size, the fraction of large regions in the parent galaxy, and the star formation rate surface density. These trends, if confirmed, would provide new constraints for massive cluster formation models and important clues for interpreting dependencies observed at high redshift, underscoring the necessity of consistently extending this analysis to larger samples.
Over twenty years ago, Type Ia Supernovae (SNIa) observations revealed an accelerating Universe expansion, suggesting a significant dark energy presence, often modelled as a cosmological constant, \( \Lambda \). Despite its pivotal role in cosmology, the standard $\Lambda$CDM model remains largely underexplored in the redshift range between distant SNIa and the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB). This study harnesses the James Webb Space Telescope's advanced capabilities to extend the Hubble flow mapping across an unprecedented redshift range, from \( z \approx 0 \) to \( z \approx 7.5 \). Using a dataset of 231 HII galaxies and extragalactic HII regions, we employ the \(\text{L}-\sigma\) relation that correlates the luminosity of Balmer lines with their velocity dispersion, to define a competitive technique for measuring cosmic distances. This approach allows the mapping of the Universe expansion history over more than 12 billion years, covering 95\% of its age. Our analysis, using Bayesian inference, constrains the parameter space $\lbrace h, \Omega_m, w_0\rbrace = \lbrace 0.731\pm0.039, 0.302^{+0.12}_{-0.069}, -1.01^{+0.52}_{-0.29}\rbrace $ (statistical) for a flat Universe. Our results provide new insights into cosmic evolution and imply a lack of change in the photo-kinematical properties of the young massive ionizing clusters in HII galaxies across most of the history of the Universe.
We present a quantitative spectroscopic study of 13 blue supergiant stars in the Pinwheel Galaxy M101, based on data obtained with the Low Resolution Imaging Spectrometer available at the Keck I telescope. The average stellar metallicity decreases from ∼1.9 Z _⊙ near the center of the galaxy to ∼0.3 Z _⊙ at the optical outskirts. The galactocentric radial metallicity gradient is statistically consistent with previous studies of the gas-phase oxygen abundance from H ii regions using the direct method. The H ii region-based Cepheid metallicities used by A. G. Riess et al. in their determination of the Hubble constant H _0 are in substantial agreement with our measurements. The direct method gas-phase metallicities of the 18 star-forming galaxies we have analyzed so far, when adjusted upward for a mean ∼0.15 dex oxygen dust depletion factor, are in good agreement with those we infer from the supergiants, over a factor of 50 in metallicity. From the same data, we derive an expression for the metal-dependent depletion of oxygen in photoionized nebulae. Utilizing the flux-weighted gravity–luminosity relationship (FGLR) of blue supergiants, we measure a distance to M101, D = 6.5 ± 0.2 Mpc ( μ = 29.06 ± 0.08), which is within 1 σ from determinations based on the tip of the red giant branch and Cepheids. With M101 as a nearby Type Ia supernova host and using the observed standardized B -band magnitude of the supernova, our FGLR distance yields an independent value of H _0 = 72.5 ± 4.6 km s ^−1 Mpc ^−1 .
Blue supergiant distances of nearby galaxies obtained with the flux-weighted gravity–luminosity relationship are used for a measurement of the zero-points of Tully–Fisher relationships at different photometric passbands. The Cousins I band and the infrared WISE bands W1 and W2 are investigated. The results are compared with previous work using Cepheid and tip of the red giant branch distances. No significant differences were encountered. This supports the large values of the Hubble constant greater than 73 km s ^−1 Mpc ^−1 found with the Tully–Fisher distance ladder work over the last decade. Applying blue supergiant distances on the I -band Tully–Fisher relation observations yields a Hubble constant H _0 = 76.2 ± 6.2 km s ^−1 Mpc ^−1 . The large uncertainty is caused by the still relatively small blue supergiant galaxy sample size but will be reduced in future work.
As part of the SIGNALS survey, which comprises a sample of approximately 40 nearby galaxies observed with the Fourier transform spectrometer SITELLE, we present a study of metal mixing in the spiral galaxy NGC 6946. Taking advantage of the blue sensitivity of our setup, we measure the oxygen and nitrogen abundances of 638 H II regions, and focus our analysis on the abundance fluctuations about the radial gradients. We detect an azimuthal variation of about 0.1 dex in these abundances across the NE spiral arm, with the leading edge being more metal-poor than the trailing edge. This result aligns with galaxy simulations, where radial gas flows along the spiral arms lead to dilution on the leading edge and enrichment on the trailing edge, due to the presence of radial metallicity gradients. Our 2D analysis reveals that oxygen and nitrogen exhibit comparable spatial correlation scales, despite the different injection energies and distinct nucleosynthetic origins – core-collapse supernovae in the case of oxygen and primarily AGB stars for nitrogen. The observed similarity suggests that stellar processes drive these two elements into the ISM over equivalent spatial scales.
Over twenty years ago, Type Ia Supernovae (SNIa) observations revealed an accelerating Universe expansion, suggesting a significant dark energy presence, often modelled as a cosmological constant, Lambda. Despite its pivotal role in cosmology, the standard lambda cold dark matter (Lambda CDM) model remains largely underexplored in the redshift range between distant SNIa and the cosmic microwave background (CMB). This study harnesses the JWST's advanced capabilities to extend the Hubble flow mapping across an unprecedented redshift range, from z approximate to 0 to z approximate to 7.5. Using a data set of 231 H II galaxies and extragalactic H II regions, we employ the L-sigma relation that correlates the luminosity of Balmer lines with their velocity dispersion, to define a competitive technique for measuring cosmic distances. This approach allows the mapping of the Universe expansion history over more than 12 billion years, covering 95 per cent of its age. Our analysis, using Bayesian inference, constrains the parameter space {h,Omega(m),w(0)}={0.731 +/- 0.039,0.302(-0.069)(+0.12),-1.01(-0.29)(+0.52)} (statistical) for a flat universe. Our results provide new insights into cosmic evolution and imply a lack of change in the photokinematical properties of the young massive ionizing clusters in H II galaxies across most of the history of the Universe.
We apply population synthesis techniques to analyze TYPHOON long slit spectra of the starburst barred spiral galaxy M83. The analysis covers a central square of 5 arcmin side length. We determine the spatial distribution of dust through the analysis of reddening and extinction, together with star formation rates, ages, and metallicities of young and old stellar populations. For the first time, a spatial one-to-one comparison of metallicities derived from full-spectral fitting techniques with those obtained from individual young stellar probes has been carried out. The comparison with blue supergiant stars, young massive star clusters, and super star clusters shows a high degree of concordance when wavelength coverage in the B-band is available. The metallicity of the young population is supersolar and does not show a radial metallicity gradient along the investigated part of the disk, in agreement with our chemical evolution model. However, a notable decrease in metallicity is observed in a tightly confined region at the galaxy center, coinciding with circumnuclear orbits. We attribute this to matter infall either from the circumgalactic medium or a dwarf galaxy interloper or, alternatively, to AGN-interrupted chemical evolution. We confirm the presence of a dust cavity with a diameter of 260 pc close to the galaxy center. Dust absorption and molecular CO emission are spatially well correlated. We find an anticorrelation between R_V, the ratio of dust attenuation to reddening, and the emission strength of molecular species present in photo-dissociation regions. We confirm our results by using alternative fitting algorithms and stellar libraries.
The carbon-to-oxygen (C/O) abundance ratio is a valuable tracer of star formation history, as C and O enrichment occurs on different timescales. However, measurements based on ultraviolet (UV) collisionally excited lines and those based on optical recombination lines may be subject to biases from the abundance discrepancy factor (ADF), which is well established for oxygen but uncertain for carbon. We present precise UV-based measurements of gas-phase C ^2+ /O ^2+ ionic abundance in four H ii regions, which have prior optical-based measurements, combined with archival UV data for two additional H ii regions, in order to establish a reliable abundance scale and to investigate biases between the two methods. We find a clear ADF for the C ^2+ ion, which is consistent with that of O ^2+ , assuming a similar temperature structure in the zones of the nebula that these ions occupy. The C/O abundance derived from UV collisional lines and optical recombination lines is therefore also consistent to within <0.1 dex, with an offset of 0.05 ± 0.03 dex in C ^2+ /O ^2+ for the standard T _e method. While the absolute C/H and O/H abundances are subject to large uncertainty from the ADF, our results establish that C/O abundances measured from these different methods can be reliably compared. Thus, we confirm the robustness of gas-phase C/O measurements for studying galaxy evolution and star formation timescales, including from rest-UV observations of high-redshift galaxies with JWST.
Accurate chemical compositions of star-forming regions are a critical diagnostic tool to characterize the star formation history and gas flows which regulate galaxy formation. However, the abundance discrepancy factor (ADF) between measurements from the "direct" optical electron temperature ($T_e$) method and from the recombination lines (RL) represents $\sim0.2$ dex systematic uncertainty in oxygen abundance. The degree of uncertainty for other elements is unknown. We conduct a comprehensive analysis of O$^{++}$ and N$^+$ ion abundances using optical and far-infrared spectra of a star-forming region within the nearby dwarf galaxy Haro 3, which exhibits a typical ADF. Assuming homogeneous conditions, the far-IR emission indicates an O abundance which is higher than the $T_e$ method and consistent with the RL value, as would be expected from temperature fluctuations, whereas the N abundance is too large to be explained by temperature fluctuations. Instead a component of highly obscured gas is likely required to explain the high far-IR to optical flux ratios. Accounting for this obscured component reduces both the IR-based metallicities and the inferred magnitude of temperature fluctuations, such that they cannot fully explain the ADF in Haro 3. Additionally, we find potential issues when predicting the RL fluxes from current atomic data. Our findings underscore the critical importance of resolving the cause of abundance discrepancies and understanding the biases between different metallicity methods. This work represents a promising methodology, and we identify further approaches to address the current dominant uncertainties.
A quantitative spectroscopic study of blue supergiant stars in the Hubble constant anchor galaxy NGC 4258 is presented. The non-LTE analysis of Keck I telescope LRIS spectra yields a central logarithmic metallicity (in units of the solar value) of [Z] = -0.05 +/- 0.05 and a very shallow gradient of -(0.09 +/- 0.11) r/r 25 with respect to galactocentric distance in units of the isophotal radius. Good agreement with the mass-metallicity relationship of star-forming galaxies based on stellar absorption line studies is found. A comparison with H ii region oxygen abundances obtained from the analysis of strong emission lines shows reasonable agreement when the M. Pettini & B. E. J. Pagel calibration is used, while the D. Zaritsky et al. calibration yields values that are 0.2-0.3 dex larger. These results allow us to put the metallicity calibration of the Cepheid period-luminosity relation in this anchor galaxy on a purely stellar basis. Interstellar reddening and extinction are determined using Hubble Space Telescope and JWST photometry. Based on extinction-corrected magnitudes, combined with the stellar effective temperatures and gravities we determine, we use the flux-weighted gravity-luminosity relationship to estimate an independent spectroscopic distance. We obtain a distance modulus m - M = 29.38 +/- 0.12 mag, in agreement with the geometrical distance derived from the analysis of the water maser orbits in the galaxy's central circumnuclear disk.
We have obtained high-quality spectra of blue supergiant candidates in the dwarf irregular galaxy Leo A with the Low Resolution Imaging Spectrometer at the Keck I telescope. From the quantitative analysis of seven B8–A0 stars, we derive a mean metallicity [ Z ] = −1.35 ± 0.08, in excellent agreement with the gas-phase chemical abundance. From the stellar parameters and the flux-weighted gravity–luminosity relation (FGLR), we derive a spectroscopic distance modulus m − M = 24.77 ± 0.11 mag, significantly larger (∼0.4 mag) than the value indicated by RR Lyrae and other stellar indicators. We explain the bulk of this discrepancy with blue loop stellar evolution at very low metallicity and show that the combination of metallicity effects and blue loop evolution amounts, in the case of Leo A, to an ∼0.35 mag offset of the FGLR to fainter bolometric luminosities. We identify one outlier of low bolometric magnitude as a post-AGB star. Its metallicity is consistent with that of the young population, confirming the slow chemical enrichment of Leo A.
The book consists of a number of short articles that present achievements of the Araucaria members, collaborators, and friends, in various aspects of distance determinations and related topics. It celebrates the 20-year anniversary of the Araucaria Project, acknowledges the people who worked for its success, and popularises our methods and results among broader readership. This book is a part of a project that has received funding from the European Union's Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 695099.
ABSTRACT We present a spatially resolved spectroscopic study for the metal poor H ii galaxy J084220+115000 using MEGARA Integral Field Unit observations at the Gran Telescopio Canarias. We estimated the gas metallicity using the direct method for oxygen, nitrogen, and helium and found a mean value of 12 + log (O/H) = 8.03 ± 0.06, and integrated electron density and temperature of ∼161 cm−3 and ∼15400 K, respectively. The metallicity distribution shows a large range of Δ(O/H) = 0.72 dex between the minimum and maximum (7.69 ± 0.06 and 8.42 ± 0.05) values, unusual in a dwarf star-forming galaxy. We derived an integrated log (N/O) ratio of −1.51 ± 0.05 and found that both N/O and O/H correspond to a primary production of metals. Spatially resolved maps indicate that the gas appears to be photoionized by massive stars according to the diagnostic line ratios. Between the possible mechanisms to explain the starburst activity and the large variation of oxygen abundance in this galaxy, our data support a possible scenario where we are witnessing an ongoing interaction triggering multiple star-forming regions localized in two dominant clumps.
We present the first quantitative spectral analysis of blue supergiant stars in the nearby galaxy NGC 2403. Out of a sample of 47 targets observed with the LRIS spectrograph at the Keck I telescope we have extracted 16 B- and A-type supergiants for which we have data of sufficient quality to carry out a comparison with model spectra of evolved massive stars and infer the stellar parameters. The radial metallicity gradient of NGC 2403 that we derive has a slope of -0.14 (+/- 0.05) dex/r_e, and is in accordance with the analysis of H II region oxygen abundances. We present evidence that the stellar metallicities that we obtain in extragalactic systems in general agree with the nebular abundances based on the analysis of the auroral lines, over more than one order of magnitude in metallicity. Adopting the known relation between stellar parameters and intrinsic luminosity we find a distance modulus m-M = 27.38 +/- 0.08 mag. While this can be brought into agreement with Cepheid-based determinations, it is 0.14 mag short of the value measured from the tip of the red giant branch. We update the mass-metallicity relation secured from chemical abundance studies of stars in resolved star-forming galaxies.
We place novel constraints on the cosmokinetic parameters by using a joint analysis of the newest VLT-KMOS HII galaxies (HIIG) with the Supernovae Type Ia (SNIa) Pantheon sample. We combine the latter datasets in order to reconstruct, in a model-independent way, the Hubble diagram to as high redshifts as possible. Using a Gaussian process we derive the basic cosmokinetic parameters and compare them with those of ΛCDM. In the case of SNIa, we find that the extracted values of the cosmokinetic parameters are in agreement with the predictions of ΛCDM model. Combining SNIa with high redshift tracers of the Hubble relation, namely HIIG data, we obtain consistent results with those based on ΛCDM as far as the present values of the cosmokinetic parameters are concerned, but find significant deviations in the evolution of the cosmokinetic parameters with respect to the expectations of the concordance ΛCDM model.
We present novel cosmological constraints based on a joint analysis of our H ii galaxies (HIIG) Hubble relation with the full Planck cosmic microwave background (CMB) anisotropy spectrum and the baryon acoustic oscillations (BAO) probes. The HIIG span a large redshift range (0.088 ≤ z ≤ 2.5), reaching significantly higher redshifts than available Type Ia supernovae (SNeIa) and hence they probe the cosmic expansion at earlier times. Our independent constraints compare well with those based on the ‘Pantheon’ compilation of SNeIa data, which we also analyse. We find our results to be in agreement with the conformal Λ cold dark matter (ΛCDM) model within 1σ. We also use our HIIG data to examine the behaviour of the dark energy equation-of-state parameter under the Chevallier–Polarski–Linder (CPL) parametrization, w = w0 + waz/(1 + z), and find consistent results with those based on SNeIa, although the degeneracy in the parameter space and the individual parameter uncertainties, when marginalizing one over the other, are quite large.
We present independent determinations of cosmological parameters using the distance estimator based on the established correlation between the Balmer line luminosity, L(H beta), and the velocity dispersion (sigma) for H II galaxies (HIIG). These results are based on new VLT-KMOS high spectral resolution observations of 41 high-z (1.3 <= z <= 2.6) HIIG combined with published data for 45 high-z and 107 z <= 0.15 HIIG, while the cosmological analysis is based on the MultiNest Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) procedure not considering systematic uncertainties. Using only HIIG to constrain the matter density parameter (Omega(m)), we find Omega(m) = 0.244(-0.049)(+0.040) (stat), an improvement over our best previous cosmological parameter constraints, as indicated by a 37 percent increase of the figure of merit. The marginalized best-fitting parameter values for the plane {Omega(m); w(0)} = (stat) show an improvement of the cosmological parameters constraints by 40 percent. Combining the HIIG Hubble diagram, the cosmic microwave background (CMB) and the baryon acoustic oscillation (BAO) probes yields Omega(m) = 0.298 +/- 0.012 and w(0) = -1.005 +/- 0.051, which are certainly compatible - although less constraining - than the solution based on the joint analysis of Ia supernovae (SNIa), CMB and BAO measurements. An attempt to constrain the evolution of the dark energy with time (CPL model), using a joint analysis of the HIIG, CMB, and BAO measurements, shows a degenerate 1 sigma contour of the parameters in the {w(0), w(a)} plane.
Our work presents an independent calibration of the J-region Asymptotic Giant Branch (JAGB) method using Infrared Survey Facility (IRSF) photometric data and a custom luminosity function profile to determine JAGB mean magnitudes for nine galaxies. We determine a mean absolute magnitude of carbon stars of $M_{LMC}=-6.212 \pm 0.010$ (stat.) $\pm 0.030$ (syst.) mag. We then use near-infrared photometry of a number of nearby galaxies, originally obtained by our group to determine their distances from Cepheids using the Leavitt law, in order to independently determine their distances with the JAGB method. We compare the JAGB distances obtained in this work with the Cepheid distances resulting from the same photometry and find very good agreement between the results from the two methods. The mean difference is 0.01 mag with an rms scatter of 0.06 mag after taking into account seven out of the eight analyzed galaxies that had their distances determined using Cepheids. The very accurate distance to the Small Magellanic Cloud (SMC) based on detached eclipsing binaries (Graczyk et al. 2020) is also in very good agreement with the distance obtained from carbon stars.