The explosion of sequence information from the various genomic efforts has far outweighed the number of actual protein structures determined by experimental means. Thus it is increasingly important that methodology be developed which can accurately predict the structure of proteins from their sequence. This is often called the "protein folding problem" and this chapter will briefly review the various computational methods available for this. At its highest level, structure prediction is based on the technique of homology modelling but de novo methods such as threading, reduced energy functions and simplistic lattice models have all been used and have proven successful in various cases. It can be concluded that while the protein folding problem is still to be solved, significant advances have been made and the ultimate goal of accurate structure prediction still remains an achievable target
Several new pairs of active and inactive GPCR structures have recently been solved enabling detailed structural insight into the activation process, not only of rhodopsin but now also of the β2 adrenergic, M2 muscarinic and adenosine A2A receptors. Combined with structural analyses they have enabled us to examine the different recent theories proposed for GPCR activation and show that they are all indeed parts of the same process, and are intrinsically related through their effect on the central hydrophobic core of GPCRs. This new unifying general process of activation is consistent with the identification of known constitutively active mutants and an in-depth conservational analysis of significant residues implicated in the process.
The most significant advance in modeling GPCR active states has been the β(2)-adrenergic receptor-Gs complex as this essentially transforms active-state modeling into homology modeling. Various different molecular dynamics-based approaches for modeling active states are presented, and a number of key applications discussed. These simulations have given insights into the activation pathway, conformational changes, dimerization, hydration, the ionic lock, ligand binding, protonation, and sodium binding. Crystallography and simulations have shown that the presence of agonist alone is unlikely to be sufficient to form the active state and that restraints applied to the G protein-binding region are required. The role of various microswitches in activation is discussed, including the controversial rotamer toggle switch. The importance of explicitly simulating experimental molecular probes to understand activation is highlighted, along with the need to ensure that such molecules are well parameterized. Approaches to loop modeling are discussed. We argue that the role of successful virtual screening against active models should not be overestimated as the main conformational changes on activation occur in the intracellular region.
Our previously derived models of the active state of the β2-adrenergic receptor are compared with recently published X-ray crystallographic structures of activated GPCRs (G-protein-coupled receptors). These molecular dynamics-based models using experimental data derived from biophysical experiments on activation were used to restrain the receptor to an active state that gave high enrichment for agonists in virtual screening. The β2-adrenergic receptor active model and X-ray structures are in good agreement over both the transmembrane region and the orthosteric binding site, although in some regions the active model is more similar to the active rhodopsin X-ray structures. The general features of the microswitches were well reproduced, but with minor differences, partly because of the unexpected X-ray results for the rotamer toggle switch. In addition, most of the interacting residues between the receptor and the G-protein were identified. This analysis of the modelling has also given important additional insight into GPCR dimerization: re-analysis of results on photoaffinity analogues of rhodopsin provided additional evidence that TM4 (transmembrane helix 4) resides at the dimer interface and that ligands such as bivalent ligands may pass between the mobile helices. A comparison, and discussion, is also carried out between the use of implicit and explicit solvent for active-state modelling.
The recent publication of several G protein‐coupled receptor (GPCR) structures has increased the information available for homology modeling inactive class A GPCRs. Moreover, the opsin crystal structure shows some active features. We have therefore combined information from these two sources to generate an extensively validated model of the active conformation of the β2‐adrenergic receptor. Experimental information on fully active GPCRs from zinc binding studies, site‐directed spin labeling, and other spectroscopic techniques has been used in molecular dynamics simulations. The observed conformational changes reside mainly in transmembrane helix 6 (TM6), with additional small but significant changes in TM5 and TM7. The active model has been validated by manual docking and is in agreement with a large amount of experimental work, including site‐directed mutagenesis information. Virtual screening experiments show that the models are selective for β‐adrenergic agonists over other GPCR ligands, for (R)‐ over (S)‐β‐hydroxy agonists and for β2‐selective agonists over β1‐selective agonists. The virtual screens reproduce interactions similar to those generated by manual docking. The C‐terminal peptide from a model of the stimulatory G protein, readily docks into the active model in a similar manner to which the C‐terminal peptide from transducin, docks into opsin, as shown in a recent opsin crystal structure. This GPCR‐G protein model has been used to explain site‐directed mutagenesis data on activation. The agreement with experiment suggests a robust model of an active state of the β2‐adrenergic receptor has been produced. The methodology used here should be transferable to modeling the active state of other GPCRs. Proteins 2011. © 2011 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.
The discovery of new highly potent and selective dopamine (DA) D(3) receptor antagonists has recently allowed the characterization of the DA D(3) receptor in a range of preclinical animal models of drug addiction. A novel series of 1,2,4-triazol-3-yl-azabicyclo[3.1.0]hexanes, members of which showed a high affinity and selectivity for the DA D(3) receptor and excellent pharmacokinetic profiles, is reported here. Members of a group of derivatives from this series showed good oral bioavailability and brain penetration and very high in vitro affinity and selectivity for the DA D(3) receptor, as well as high in vitro potency for antagonism at this receptor. Several members of this series also significantly attenuate the expression of conditioned place preference (CPP) to nicotine and cocaine.
The aim of this work is to study the role of pore residues on drug binding in the NaV1.8 channel. Alanine mutations were made in the S6 segments, chosen on the basis of their roles in other NaV subtypes; whole cell patch clamp recordings were made from mammalian ND7/23 cells. Mutations of some residues caused shifts in voltage dependence of activation and inactivation, and gave faster time course of inactivation, indicating that the residues mutated play important roles in both activation and inactivation in the NaV1.8 channel. The resting and inactivated state affinities of tetracaine for the channel were reduced by mutations I381A, F1710A, and Y1717A (for the latter only inactivated state affinity was measured), and by mutation F1710A for the NaV1.8-selective compound A-803467, showing the involvement of these residues for each compound, respectively. For both compounds, mutation L1410A caused the unexpected appearance of a complete resting block even at extremely low concentrations. Resting block of native channels by compound A-803467 could be partially removed (“disinhibition”) by repetitive stimulation or by a test pulse after recovery from inactivation; the magnitude of the latter effect was increased for all the mutants studied. Tetracaine did not show this effect for native channels, but disinhibition was seen particularly for mutants L1410A and F1710A. The data suggest differing, but partially overlapping, areas of binding of A-803467 and tetracaine. Docking of the ligands into a three-dimensional model of the NaV1.8 channel gave interesting insight as to how the ligands may interact with pore residues.
A novel 4-hydroxyl(diphenyl)methyl substituted quinuclidine series was discovered as a very promising class of muscarinic antagonists. The structure-activity relationships of the connectivity of the diphenyl moiety to the quinuclidine core and around the ring nitrogen side chain are described. Computational docking studies using an homology model of the M-3 receptor readily explained the observed structure-activity relationship of the various compounds. Compound 14o was identified as a very potent, slowly reversible M-3 antagonist with a very long in vivo duration of bronchoprotection.
Recent advances in structural biology for G-protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) have provided new opportunities to improve the definition of the transmembrane binding pocket. Here a reference set of 44 residue positions accessible for ligand binding was defined through detailed analysis of all currently available crystal structures. This was used to characterize pharmacological relationships of Family A/Rhodopsin family GPCRs, minimizing evolutionary influence from parts of the receptor that do not generally affect ligand binding. The resultant dendogram tended to group receptors according to endogenous ligand types, although it revealed subdivision of certain classes, notably peptide and lipid receptors. The transmembrane binding site reference set, particularly when coupled with a means of identifying the subset of ligand binding residues, provides a general paradigm for understanding the pharmacology/selectivity profile of ligands at Family A GPCRs. This has wide applicability to GPCR drug design problems across many disease areas.
To identify new CRF1 receptor antagonists, an attempt to modify the bis-hetherocycle moiety present in the top region of the dihydropirrole[2,3]pyridine template was made following new pharmacophoric hypothesis on the CRF1 receptor antagonists binding pocket. In particular, the 2-thiazole ring, present in the previous series of compounds, was replaced by more hydrophilic non aromatic hetherocycles able to make appropriate H-bond interactions with amino acid residues Thr192 and Tyr195. This exploration, followed by an accurate analysis of the substitution of the pendant aryl ring, enabled to identify in vitro potent compounds showing excellent pharmacokinetics and outstanding in vivo activity in animal models of anxiety, both in rodents and primates.
Novel 2-methyl-5-quinolinyl-1-piperazinylalkyl-3,4-dihydro-2H-1,4-benzoxazin-3-ones showing high affinities for the 5-HT(1A/1B/1D) receptors coupled with potent 5-HT reuptake inhibitory activity have been discovered. This is the first report describing docking of the lead compound 6-{2-[4-(2-methyl-5-quinolinyl)-1-piperazinyl]ethyl}-2H-1,4-benzoxazin-3(4H)-one 1, into a model of the 5-HT transporter and the 5-HT(1A) receptor model.
In an effort to discover novel CRF-1 receptor antagonists exhibiting improved physicochemical properties, a dihydropirrole[2,3]pyridine scaffold was designed and explored in terms of the SAR of the substitution at the pendent phenyl ring and the nature of the heterocyclic moieties present in the upper region of the molecule. Selective and potent compounds have been discovered endowed with reduced ClogP with respect to compounds known in the literature. Of particular relevance was the finding that the in vitro affinity of the series was maintained by reducing the overall lipophilicity. The results achieved by this exploration enabled the formulation of a novel hypothesis on the nature of the receptor binding pocket of this class of CRF-1 receptor antagonists, making use of in silico docking studies of the putative nonpeptidic antagonist binding site set up in house by homology modeling techniques.
This chapter describes modeling techniques that have been reported for the design of G protein-complex receptor (GPCR) ligands, summarizing the success of key methodologies and the targets to which they have been applied. The discussion focuses mainly on the building of GPCR models and their use in structure-based ligand design, although a summary of key ligand-based methods is also included. The first section describes the model building process. The history of receptor modeling and the data on which it is based are reported, explaining how modeling techniques and the resulting models have evolved as the quality and quantity of underlying experimental studies have increased. Both homology modeling and de novo model-building methods are covered. Current challenges and aims for the future are also discussed with particular focus on modeling of activated receptor states and Family B and C GPCRs. The focus of the chapter then moves to the utilization of these models for drug design. Firstly design techniques based on the docking of small numbers of ligands into receptor models are discussed. Then the challenging topic of combining high-throughput docking techniques with receptor models is tackled. Finally, an attempt is made to summarize the wealth of small-molecule modeling methods that have been reported in the literature. Particular attention is paid to methods for selecting compound sets enriched in GPCR ligands which encompass library design. Due to the immensity of that task and the fact that ligand-based methods are discussed in detail elsewhere in this book, the emphasis in this chapter is on those methods that either have special relevance to GPCR ligands, or those that have been shown to be particularly successful when applied to the area.
Human big conductance Ca2+- and voltage-gated K+ channels (hBK) are putative drug targets for cardiovascular, respiratory and urological diseases. Here we have used molecular simulation and bioinformatics approaches to construct models of two domains important for Ca2+ binding and channel gating, namely the regulator of conductance for K+ (RCK1) domain and the so-called calcium bowl (CB). As templates for RCK1 were used the corresponding domains from a K+ channel from E. coli and the K+ channel from Methanobacterium thermoautothropicum (MthK). CB was modeled upon the structure of the human thrombospondin-1 C-terminal fragment and allowing the domain to relax in a simulated aqueous environment for 10-ns molecular dynamics simulations. The relevance of these models for interpreting the available molecular biology data is then discussed.
The discovery of new highly potent and selective dopamine D3 receptor antagonists has recently permitted characterization of the role of the dopamine D3 receptor in a wide range of preclinical animal models. A novel series of 1,2,4-triazol-3-yl-thiopropyl-tetrahydrobenzazepines demonstrating a high level of D3 affinity and selectivity with an excellent pharmacokinetic profile is reported here. In particular, the pyrazolyl derivative 35 showed good oral bioavailability and brain penetration associated with high potency and selectivity in vitro. In vivo characterization of 35 confirmed that this compound blocks the expression of nicotine- and cocaine-conditioned place preference in the rat, prevents nicotine-triggered reinstatement of nicotine-seeking behavior in the rat, reduces oral operant alcohol self-administration in the mouse, increases extracellular levels of acetylcholine in the rat medial prefrontal cortex, and potentiates the amplitude of the relative cerebral blood volume response to d-amphetamine in a regionally specific manner in the rat brain.
Long and short QT syndromes associated with loss and gain of human ether-a-go-go-related gene (hERG) channel activity, respectively, can cause life-threatening arrhythmias. As such, modulation of hERG channel activity is an important consideration in the development of all new therapeutic agents. In the present study, we investigated the mechanisms of action of 2-[2-(3,4-dichloro-phenyl)-2,3-dihydro-1H-isoindol-5-ylamino]-nicotinic acid (PD-307243), a known hERG channel activator, on hERG channels stably expressed in Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells using the patch-clamp technique. In the whole-cell recordings, the extracellular application of PD-307243 concentration-dependently increased the hERG current and markedly slowed hERG channel deactivation and inactivation. PD-307243 had no effect on the selectivity filter of hERG channels. The activity of PD-307243 was use-dependent. PD-307243 (3 and 10 μM) induced instantaneous hERG current with little decay at membrane potentials from -120 to -40 mV. At more positive voltages, PD-307243 induced an Ito-like upstroke of hERG current. The actions of PD-307243 on the rapid component of delayed rectifier K+ current (IKr) in rabbit ventricular myocytes were similar to those observed in hERG channel-transfected CHO cells. Inside-out patch experiments revealed that PD-307243 increased hERG tail currents by 2.1 ± 0.6 (n = 7) and 3.4 ± 0.3-fold (n = 4) at 3 and 10 μM, respectively, by slowing the channel deactivation but had no effect on channel activation. During a voltage-clamp protocol using a prerecorded cardiac action potential, 3 μM PD-307243 increased the total potassium ions passed through hERG channels by 8.8 ± 1.0-fold (n = 5). Docking studies suggest that PD-307243 interacts with residues in the S5-P region of the channel.
Investigation of halogen substitution in lead compound 1 has led to the identification of analogues which combine high affinity for 5-HT1A receptors and potent serotonin reuptake inhibitory activity. Several compounds show an improved selectivity over 5-HT1B and 5-HT1D receptors and a superior pharmacokinetic profile in the rat.
In this work molecular modeling was applied to generate homology models of the pore region of the Na v 1.2 and Na v 1.8 isoforms of human voltage-gated sodium channels. The models represent the channels in the resting, open, and fast-inactivated states. The transmembrane portions of the channels were based on the equivalent domains of the closed and open conformation potassium channels KcsA and MthK, respectively. The critical selectivity loops were modeled using a structural template identified by a novel 3D-search technique and subsequently merged with the transmembrane portions. The resulting draft models were used to study the differences of tetrodotoxin binding to the tetrodotoxin-sensitive Na v 1.2 (EC50: 0.012 μM) and -insensitive Na v 1.8 (EC50: 60 μM) isoforms, respectively. Furthermore, we investigated binding of the local anesthetic tetracaine to Na v 1.8 (EC50: 12.5 μM) in resting, conducting, and fast-inactivated state. In accordance with experimental mutagenesis studies, computational docking of tetrodotoxin and tetracaine provided (1) a description of site 1 toxin and local anesthetic binding sites in voltage-gated sodium channels. (2) A rationale for site 1 toxin-sensitivity versus -insensitivity in atomic detail involving interactions of the Na v 1.2 residues F385-I and W943-II. (3) A working hypothesis of interactions between Na v 1.8 in different conformational states and the local anesthetic tetracaine.