Like many ecological processes, natural disturbances exhibit scale‐dependent dynamics that are largely a function of the magnitude, frequency and scale at which they are assessed. Ecosystem engineers create patch‐scale disturbances that affect ecological processes, yet we know little about how these effects scale across space or vary through time. Here, we investigate how patch disturbances by beavers Castor canadensis, ecosystem engineers renowned for their pond‐creation behavior, affect ecological processes across space and time. We evaluated how beaver population recovery influenced surface water dynamics in relation to population density over 70 years across multiple spatial scales (pond, watershed and regional) in northern Minnesota. Surface water area was positively related to population density at the watershed scale; however, despite variation in beaver densities (and therefore surface water area) at the watershed scale, regional‐scale surface water area was stable through time. This stability appears to have been driven by asynchronous beaver density fluctuations among watersheds, combined with the increasing importance of abandoned ponds. Beavers initially created and occupied larger ponds with greater surface water area, but through time shifted towards occupying smaller ponds. As ponds accumulated on the landscape proportionally more surface water was stored within abandoned ponds, which offset the smaller size of occupied ponds. Beaver engineering – driven by density‐dependent mechanisms and the legacy effects from abandoned ponds – not only follows general patterns of patch disturbance dynamics by creating a spatial mosaic of patches, but the organism‐created mosaic also appears to generate ecological stability at greater spatial scales. We suggest restoring beavers to landscapes is a viable method for increasing surface water storage and will ultimately help advance numerous conservation and rewilding objectives. Our study demonstrates that ecosystem engineering effects can be scale‐dependent, indicating researchers should evaluate the ecological impact of engineers across diverse spatiotemporal scales to fully understand their functional roles in ecosystems.
Funding provided from the Outdoor Heritage fund as part of the Clean Water, Land and Legacy Amendment
Macroinvertebrate and fish metrics are an essential tool in freshwater biomonitoring. Yet, many well-known stream metrics do not perform well as indicators of anthropogenic stress in lakes and wetlands, and there is a need to better understand the role of potential confounding factors such as latitude or environmental variables acting at regional scales. We attempt to untangle the relationships among metrics and watershed stressors while accounting for potential confounding factors using hierarchical partitioning, and test metric consistency across time, focusing on the Laurentian Great Lakes wetland monitoring programs conducted 10 years apart. Our results show that many frequently used metrics have high temporal variability and are significantly affected by spatial factors, most notably richness-type metrics used in numerous regional monitoring studies. Only a few metrics (invasive fish species richness and relative abundance, mayfly family richness and the relative abundance of Ephemeroptera, Trichoptera, Sphaeriidae and Odonata) had slightly better and more consistent correlations with watershed land use. We suggest that explicit consideration of confounding factors is essential in the context of large-scale monitoring programs, and focus on the less general (such as habitat-specific) metrics may be a more promising approach.
The original version of this report (published April 2020) contained a calculations error; this revised version (published June 2020) has been corrected.
We describe development anthropogenic stress indices for coastal margins of the Laurentian Great Lakes basin. Indices were derived based on the response of species assemblages to watershed-scale stress from agriculture and urbanization. Metrics were calculated for five groups of wetland biota: diatoms, wetland vegetation, aquatic invertebrates, fishes, and birds. Previously published community change points of these assemblages were used to classify each watershed as ‘least-disturbed’, ‘at-risk’, or ‘degraded’ based on community response to these stressors. The end products of this work are an on-line map utility and downloadable data that characterize the degree of agricultural land use and development in all watersheds of the US and Canadian Great Lakes basin. Discrepancies between the observed biological condition and putative anthropogenic stress can be used to determine if a site is more degraded than predicted based on watershed characteristics, or if remediation efforts are having beneficial impacts on site condition. This study provides a landscape-scale evaluation of wetland condition that is a critical first step for multi-scale assessments to help prioritize conservation or restoration efforts.
Minnesota's Lake Superior Coastal Program; This project was funded in part under the Coastal Zone Management Act of 1972, as amended by NOAA's Office of Ocean and Coastal Resource Management, in conjunction with Minnesota's Lake Superior Coastal Progam. Additional 50% matcing support came from the Natural Resources Research Institute at the University of Minnesota Duluth.
The St. Louis River drains an area of 9412km2 into the western arm of Lake Superior. The river's lower section, including a 48.5km2 estuary, was designated as a Great Lakes Area of Concern due to degradation from industrial activities. Part of the estuary is occupied by the largest port in the Great Lakes. A GIS-based stressor index was previously developed to characterize anthropogenic stress within the watershed. The components of the stressor index were road density, point-source pollution permit density, population density, and percent agricultural and developed land. Water quality sampling was conducted at 27 sites in the estuary in tributaries and associated nearshore areas during multiple flow regimes in 2010–2011. Additional data were analyzed from 34 upper watershed sites sampled in 2009–2010. Stressor scores were significantly (p<0.1) and positively correlated with TSS, turbidity, TP, NO2−/NO3−-N, dissolved oxygen saturation, pH, specific electrical conductivity, chloride, sulfate, and E. coli in the upper watershed. In the estuary, the index was significantly and positively correlated with NO2−/NO3−-N, NH4+-N, and chloride at multiple flow regime and location combinations. Soil K factor (an erosivity index from recent NRCS SSURGO soil surveys) was found to have stronger relationships with sediment related parameters than the stressor gradient. Although originally designed to help stratify sampling across a gradient of landscape stress and identify reference areas for restoration projects, the stressor index was shown to have substantial predictive power for multiple water quality parameters.
Stressor gradients and spatial narratives of the St. Louis River Estuary, a joint Minnesota and Wisconsin Sea Grant study, connected aquatic science research with spatially-explicit stories of local resource issues and place-based geo-quests to enhance spatial awareness and stewardship of the estuary. The goal of this paper is to report and reflect on an integrated study that combined environmental humanities and technology with aquatic science in a spatial context. Our study was organized into three objectives around research, outreach, and evaluation. First, we summarized anthropogenic stressors within high resolution watersheds and linked the watershed stress estimates to aquatic habitats within the estuary. Second, we designed tools to deliver place-based environmental science and technology to targeted users to increase awareness, learning, and the potential for long-term stewardship. And third, we evaluated the responses of targeted end users to their interaction with the project's integrated science and innovative delivery methods. Finally, central to all three objectives, we created a dynamic website to facilitate regional to national coastal outreach and education goals. We found significant correlations between the stressor index and the water quality and biotic data, along with variability attributed to landscape elements. Connecting this science with the place-based experiences we collected is expected to expand the scope and reach of state, bi-national and non-governmental outreach programs. The project also has direct applications to classroom science education. Developing this integrated project contributed to our shared knowledge of environmental and cultural aspects of the estuary for place-based education, and offers several lessons for future work of this nature.
Context Green infrastructure may improve water quality and mitigate flooding in forest-urban watersheds, but reliably quantifying all benefits is challenging because most land cover maps depend on moderate- to low-resolution data. Complex and spatially heterogeneous landscapes that typify forest-urban watersheds are not fully represented with these types of data. Hence important questions concerning how green infrastructure influences water quality and quantity at different spatial scales remain unanswered. Objectives Demonstrate the feasibility of creating novel high-resolution land cover maps across entire watersheds and highlight deficiencies of standard land cover products. Methods We used object-based image analysis (OBIA) to create high-resolution (0.5 m) land cover maps and detect tree canopy overlapping impervious surfaces for a representative forest-urban watershed in Duluth, MN, USA. Unbiased estimates of accuracy and area were calculated and compared with similar metrics for the 30-m National Land Cover Database (NLCD). Results Mapping accuracies for the high-resolution land cover and canopy overlap maps were ~90 %. Error-adjusted estimates of area indicated that impervious surfaces comprised ~21 % of the watershed, tree canopy overlapped ~10 % of impervious surfaces, and that three high-resolution land cover classes differed significantly from similar NLCD classes. Conclusions OBIA can efficiently generate high-resolution land cover products of entire watersheds that are appropriate for research and inclusion in the decision-making process of managers. Metrics derived from these products will likely differ from standard land cover maps and may produce new insights, especially when considering the unprecedented opportunity to evaluate fine-scale spatial heterogeneity across watersheds.
Total suspended solids (TSS) and total phosphorus (TP) have been shown to be strongly correlated with turbidity in watersheds. High-frequency in situ turbidity can provide estimates of these potential pollutants over a wide range of hydrologic conditions. Concentrations and loads were estimated in four western Lake Superior trout streams from 2005 to 2010 using regression models relating continuous turbidity data to grab sample measures of TSS and TP during differing flow regimes. TSS loads estimated using the turbidity surrogate were compared with those made using FLUX software, a standard assessment technique based on discharge and grab sampling for TSS. More traditional rating curve methodology was not suitable because of the high variability in the particulates vs. discharge relationship. Stream-specific turbidity and TSS data were strongly correlated (r(2) = 0.5 to 0.8; p < 0.05) and less so for TP (r(2) = 0.3 to 0.7; p < 0.05). Near-continuous turbidity monitoring (every 15 min) provided a good method for estimating both TSS and TP concentration, providing information when manual sample collection was unlikely, and allowing for detailed analyses of short-term responses of flashy Lake Superior tributaries to highly variable weather and hydrologic conditions while the FLUX model typically resulted in load estimates greater than those determined using the turbidity surrogate, with 17/23 stream years having greater FLUX estimates for TSS and 18/23 for TP.