To support ongoing marine spatial planning in New Zealand, a numerical environmental classification using Gradient Forest models was developed using a broad suite of biotic and high-resolution environmental predictor variables. Gradient Forest modeling uses species distribution data to control the selection, weighting and transformation of environmental predictors to maximise their correlation with species compositional turnover. A total of 630,997 records (39,766 unique locations) of 1,716 taxa living on or near the seafloor were used to inform the transformation of 20 gridded environmental variables to represent spatial patterns of compositional turnover in four biotic groups and the overall seafloor community. Compositional turnover of the overall community was classified using a hierarchical procedure to define groups at different levels of classification detail. The 75-group level classification was assessed as representing the highest number of groups that captured the majority of the variation across the New Zealand marine environment. We refer to this classification as the New Zealand “Seafloor Community Classification” (SCC). Associated uncertainty estimates of compositional turnover for each of the biotic groups and overall community were also produced, and an added measure of uncertainty – coverage of the environmental space – was developed to further highlight geographic areas where predictions may be less certain owing to low sampling effort. Environmental differences among the deep-water New Zealand SCC groups were relatively muted, but greater environmental differences were evident among groups at intermediate depths in line with well-defined oceanographic patterns observed in New Zealand’s oceans. Environmental differences became even more pronounced at shallow depths, where variation in more localised environmental conditions such as productivity, seafloor topography, seabed disturbance and tidal currents were important differentiating factors. Environmental similarities in New Zealand SCC groups were mirrored by their biological compositions. The New Zealand SCC is a significant advance on previous numerical classifications and includes a substantially wider range of biological and environmental data than has been attempted previously. The classification is critically appraised and considerations for use in spatial management are discussed.
Several international agreements and conventions require nations to establish Marine Protected Area (MPA) networks as an approach to alleviating biodiversity declines; however, a common problem in planning MPA networks is how to balance conservation objectives against economic objectives. Here, using the distributions of 102 biodiversity features and 7 extractive uses we trial the systematic conservation planning software Zonation as a decision-support tool to facilitate progress towards New Zealand's commitment to establishing a representative network of MPAs while providing for economic development. Our results indicate that: (i) New Zealand's existing MPAs provide on average 70% less representation of the input biodiversity features than would be achieved by an MPA network of equivalent area designed from the outset using Zonation; (ii) small increases in the geographic extent of existing protection results in rapid increases in representation of the selected biodiversity features when systematic conservation planning software is used to inform expansion of existing protection; and (iii) the impacts on existing resource users of an expanded MPA system can be minimized by using Zonation to identify areas that increase biodiversity representation, while avoiding areas where existing uses may be incompatible with marine protection. These results demonstrate the utility of systematic conservation planning software as a decision-support tool within a broader social process for MPA network design and implementation. The iterative application of tools such as Zonation during participatory processes that balance alternative uses could potentially lead to more informed, efficient and socially enduring outcomes that enhance the ability to establish representative MPA networks.
Management decisions aimed at protecting biodiversity ideally should be based on biological information, but for remote and logistically difficult sites, such as are found at high latitudes, these data may be lacking. During March 2009, surveys were completed of the nearshore rocky reef communities around the Bounty and Antipodes Islands, in New Zealand's subantarctic region. Previously considered to support the same habitat types (which used physical variables as surrogates for biological communities), analysis of photoquadrats taken at both island groups showed that the rocky reef communities were significantly different, both in terms of their species composition and in terms of their potential ecological function. While Antipodes Island supported fairly typical subantarctic shallow subtidal marine communities dominated by nongeniculate coralline algae, the rocky reefs at the Bounty Islands were dominated by filter-and suspension-feeding invertebrates, in particular encrusting sponges, barnacles and mussels. The mobile invertebrate fauna associated with these communities were also significantly different between the two island groups. Contrasting geology, oceanographic conditions and nutrient input from seabird and pinniped colonies may all contribute to the observed nearshore community structures at the Bounty and Antipodes Islands. Our research provides a baseline for assessing change in the subantarctic region and highlights the importance of using biological community data where available, to inform conservation management decisions.
This paper is a contribution to the Latitudinal Gradient Project. It describes macro and epifaunal assemblages and habitats at three shallow water locations at the southern end of the western Ross Sea coast, and investigates relationships between faunal composition and environmental characteristics. Many variables (e.g. substrate type, sediment composition, depth, latitude, longitude) contributed to explaining the differences in community composition between locations, with latitude (a likely surrogate for broader scale factors, e.g. ice cover) one of the most important. The percentage explained by environmental characteristics was strongly scale dependent, decreasing with increasing scale of observation. As much as 66% and 75% of the variability in macrofaunal and epifaunal assemblages, respectively, was explained at the smallest scale (i.e. between transects within a location), compared to 9–18% and 11–32%, respectively, at the scale of the entire study. This relationship was also true for species richness and total abundance. This suggests that while small-scale habitat variability will not confound our ability to detect latitudinal gradients in future studies, adequately quantifying the environmental factors important in structuring these communities at larger (latitudinal) spatial scales will be important. Finally, large differences in habitat structure did not translate into large differences in the diversity of fauna, illustrating the difficulty of predicting faunal composition in the Ross Sea based on seafloor topography alone.
At Cape Evans on Ross Island, Antarctica, the rhodophyte Phyllophora antarctica is the dominant primary producer in terms of biomass from 10 to >30 m depth. The vast majority of Phyllophora occurs as accumulations of unattached plants. Whilst decomposition and incorporation of macroalgal drift material into the food web is rapid in temperate ecosystems, we predicted these processes to be slow in Antarctica. We address the functional role of macroalgal detritus in fuelling the biodiversity of benthic communities at Cape Evans during the summers of 2001 and 2002. Specifically we (a) describe the distribution and biomass of attached and drift algae, (b) assess the photosynthetic capacity and degradation of drift accumulations using in situ fluorometry, (c) assess the effect of patches of drift Phyllophora on underlying macrofaunal communities, and, (d) use stable isotopes to investigate the possible uptake of Phyllophora by macrofauna. We found drift Phyllophora accumulations throughout the depth range investigated (3–31 m), with peak biomasses of 140±30 g dwt m−2 in the 15–25 m depth strata. At this depth stratum Phyllophora was a conspicuous habitat element with the % cover on the seafloor averaging 30%. While initially the drift algal accumulations appeared in good health we measured significant declines in photosynthetic capacity between years suggesting ongoing, albeit slow, degradation of the drift algal accumulations. Our results demonstrate that Phyllophora drift accumulations have a structuring role on soft-sediment communities, which increases in strength with the gradual degradation of the algae. The longevity of Phyllophora is enhanced by secondary metabolites, which serve as protection against grazers, and their extreme shade adaptation. However, our carbon and nitrogen stable isotope data of polychaetes and amphipods associated with Phyllophora suggest that macroalgal detritus enters the food web, and although this process is slow, Phyllophora accumulations might serve to dampen the seasonality in food supply providing higher trophic levels with a more constant food source.