The greater Paris area has some 12 million inhabitants and 48 heating network production units that exploit the heat capacity of a 1.5 km deep aquifer, the Bathonian limestone. This is one of the most productive aquifers in the world for district heating, with an annual output of about 1.7 TWh of energy. The current challenge for Paris is to triple the number of heating networks using geothermal energy so as to reduce dependence on fossil fuels (40% in 2020 in France). As no detailed geothermal reservoir model is available, drilling involves geological risk. A recent well, drilled at Grigny (20 km south of Paris), turned out to be a failure in transmissibility because the bed of permeable limestones it tapped into was very thin (meter-scale). The main aim of this study is to create a digital database and a 3D geological model of this aquifer to minimize geological risks and optimize the location of future geothermal operations around Paris. By compiling data from 168 wells, a high-resolution 3D geological model of 360 km3 size is constructed (about 40 km x 50 km x 0.2 km), made up of 12.2 million cells and displaying sedimentary facies, sequence stratigraphy, porosity (phi) and permeability (k). About 20% of the oolitic and bioclastic facies are of good reservoir quality (phi > 13% and k > 350 mD), especially in two targeted, highquality reservoir sequences. These facies of interest probably correspond to giant dunes and a shoal/barrier prograding from east to west. In these facies, permeable zones are generally 4 m thick and form patches of 1600 m x 1100 m, on average, elongated perpendicular to the depositional slope. 2D and 3D maps of temperature, salinity, porosity, transmissivity, and permeability allow us to understand the areas of interest for geothermal exploration, as demonstrated around Grigny. This model helps us to apprehend better the heterogeneous character of the reservoir for geothermal prospection and to reduce the risk of future doublets during well implantation. Detailed local models may be extracted to anticipate better the implantation of new doublets in areas with already densely spaced existing wells.
If they are to be economically and technically sustainable, geothermal projects require the production of hot fluid at high flow rates over a 30-year thermal lifetime. The combined use of multiple logging tools in making pet-rophysical assessments of reservoir quality helps to optimize drilling in areas of high geothermal potential. The present paper focuses on four geothermal wells intercepting Middle Jurassic (Dogger) carbonate rocks of the Paris Basin where for the first time Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) log data have been successfully used to investigate reservoir porosity-permeability heterogeneities. A total of ten facies have been identified from recovered cuttings and cores and grouped into four facies associations along a schematic carbonate ramp profile. From the wells studied, four reservoir units exhibiting porosities exceeding 15% and permeabilities of up to 1 Darcy (D) were traced in the Calcaires de Comblanchien, the Oolithe Blanche and the Calcaires marneux a` Phola-domyes formations. The well's sub-horizontal trajectory and well-logs correlations between two wells, made it possible a priori to identify porous and permeable layers extending over at least 500 m and up to 2000 m within the Bathonian reservoir, providing useful pointers for further 3D reservoir geomodeling. Permeabilities derived from well testing proved to be overestimated when compared with NMR-derived permeabilities, illustrating the upscaling problem that is invariably a challenge in carbonate systems. NMR can be combined with production logging tool (PLT), that provides data on the distribution and thickness of productive layers, to give indications for example about continuous permeability record along the geothermal wells or about the proportion of micro and macroporosities in rocks. Based on the geological classification derived from examination of cores and cuttings, four rock-types (including mean T2 pore-size distributions) have been identified and attributed to a given sedimentary facies and depositional environment by extending a clustering method to NMR log distributions from wells.
Chlorite is recognized worldwide as a key mineral that inhibits the development of quartz cement in deeply buried sandstone reservoirs. Iron-rich chlorite is mainly formed by the transformation of a precursor clay mineral; however, few studies have focused on the early stages before the crystallization of chlorite. This study analyzed shallowly buried (400-1000 m) coastal sandstones from within the Wealden Group of the Paris Basin. Berthierine, a 7 A trioctahedral clay mineral belonging to the serpentine group, approximatively with same chemistry as chlorite but a different crystal structure, has been identified in a 900-m deep well but not in a 400-600-m-deep well. Berthierine has mainly been observed as clay coatings around detrital grains with a typical honeycomb texture. Nanopetrographic observations suggest that the honeycomb textural organization of the clay particles found in deeper buried sandstone reservoirs (>1500 m) is acquired from a berthierine precursor at shallow depths. However, small amounts of quartz overgrowths are observed on the surface of detrital grains at shallow depths and low temperature (below 40 degrees C), and it is believed that precursor berthierine coatings are primarily responsible for the inhibition of quartz overgrowths before Fe-rich chlorite is formed. This suggests that the key mineral primarily controlling the reservoir quality of deeply buried sandstone reservoirs is berthierine rather than iron-rich chlorite, which challenges the commonly accepted assertion that chlorite coating is the main process that inhibits quartz overgrowths. The source-to-sink context of the Paris Basin during the Early Cretaceous was decisive with respect to the supply of sands and berthierine clay precursors (in particular kaolinite and iron-rich, hydroxy-interlayered clay minerals) to the center of the basin.
Recent developments of carbon capture and storage and geothermal subsurface prospects in the Middle Jurassic limestone of the central part of the Paris Basin have rejuvenated interest in the world class outcrops of the Bathonian Oolithe Blanche Formation on the southeastern edge of the Basin. Here, ooid-bioclast grainstones occur as large-scale (10–15 m high) clinoforms in the upper part of the Oolithe Blanche, which remain enigmatic and variously interpreted. High-resolution sequence stratigraphic correlations, constrained by biostratigraphic markers and integrated with regional palaeogeography, indicate that the clinoforms are giant dunes developed during the early part of the regressive phase of a third-order transgressive–regressive sequence (Bt3), in the northern part of the Burgundy Bathonian carbonate ramp. Carbonate sand bodies up to 15 m high with intervening troughs, formed subaqueous giant dune field(s) with calculated wavelengths of about 500–800 m. Using dune height as a proxy for calculating the palaeobathymetry of deposition, it is concluded that the dunes formed under a minimum water depth of about 60 m. A detailed facies analysis of the sediments underlying the dunes, which include beds rich in brachiopods in living position corresponding to the MFS of the third-order transgressive–regressive sequence (Bt3), supports such a water depth. The constitutive facies of the dunes themselves also reflect a significant water depth, despite the presence of ooids that are definitely transported away from their main production zone. This new interpretation of the large-scale clinoforms in the upper Oolithe Blanche and the associated revised palaeobathymetry have implications for the interpretations of Bathonian carbonates across the Paris Basin, which are relevant to ongoing projects of reservoir characterization of subsurface prospects.
This study showcases the value of drone photogrammetry in creating a meter-scale geological model of complex carbonate geobodies. Although drone photogrammetry is now commonly used for modeling the sedimentary facies and architecture of sandstone outcrops, its use is not widespread in creating geomodels of carbonate geobodies. Drone photogrammetry can generate accurate line-drawing correlation and detailed architecture analysis along inaccessible vertical faces of outcrops and permits observations of unreachable places. This work models the Bathonian limestones of Massangis quarry (Burgundy) as an example. The quarry covers an area of 0.4 km(2) and is considered as an analogue for the Oolithe Blanche geothermal reservoir in the center of the Paris Basin. The Massangis quarry model represents a good analogue for reservoir microporosity and secondary porosity associated with dedolomitization. Ten facies are described and grouped into three facies associations (1) clinoforms, (2) tidal to subtidal facies, and (3) lagoonal facies. The clinoforms are sets of very large marine dunes 15-20 m high that prograded N70? across the platform as part of a regressive systems tract. Moldic rhombohedral pore spaces associated with dedolomitization are well-expressed within clinoforms and in the bioturbated levels of lagoonal facies. Drone photogrammetry combined with the "Truncated Gaussian with Trends" algorithm implemented in Petrel (R) software is used to create a geological model that faithfully reproduces the facies architecture observed in the quarry cliffs. Drone photogrammetry can be combined with field work to describe and locate facies and so constrain the spatial distribution of petrophysical properties. It also helps constraining the shapes of geobodies in the model grid for more realistic geological static models and helps providing 3D petrophysical models from an outcropping analogue for geothermal and petroleum reservoirs.y
With around 50 heating networks today operating, the aera around Paris is the European region which concentrates the most heating network production units in terms of deep geothermal energy. In France, the energy-climate strategy plans to produce 6.4TWh in 2023, compared to 1.5TWh produced in 2016. Despite an exceptional geothermal potential, the current average development rate of 70MWh/year will not allow this objective to be achieved, it would be necessary to reach a rate of 6 to 10 times higher. The optimization of the use of deep geothermal energy is a major challenge for France, and in Ile-de-France, which has a population of nearly 12 million inhabitants. This project aims to reconstruct and simulate heat flows in the Paris Basin using an innovative methodology (1) to characterize, predict and model the properties of reservoirs (facies, porosity, permeability) and (2) simulate future circulations and predict the performance at a given location (sedimentary basin) on its geothermal potential. This study focuses on a high density area of well infrastructures around Cachan, (8 doublets, 1 triplet in 56 km2). A new sub-horizontal doublet concept has been recently (2017) drilled at Cachan to enhance heat exchange in medium to low permeability formations. Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR T2) logs have been recorded in the sub-horizontal well (GCAH2) providing information on pore size distribution and permeability. We integrated all logging data (gamma ray, density, resistivity, sonic, NRM T2) of the 19 wells in the area and 120 thin section observations from cuttings to derive a combined electrofacies-sedimentary facies description. A total of 10 facies is grouped into 5 facies associations coded in all the 19 wells according to depths and 10 3rd order stratigraphic sequences are recognized. The cell size of the 3D grid was set to 50 m x 50 m for the XY dimensions. The Z-size depends on the thickness of the sub-zones, averaging 5 m. The resulting 3D grid is composed of a total of nearly 8.105cells. After upscaled, facies and stratigraphic surfaces are used to create a reliable model using the “Truncated Gaussian With Trends” algorithm. The petrophysical distribution “Gaussian Random Function Simulation” is used to populate the entire grid with properties, included 2000 NMR data, considering each facies independently. The best reservoir is mainly located in the shoal deposits oolitic grainstones with average porosity of 12.5% and permeability of 100 mD. Finally, hydrodynamic and thermal simulations have been performed using Pumaflow to give information on the potential risk of interference between the doublets in the area and advices are given in the well trajectory to optimize the connectivity and the lifetime of the system. NMR data, especially permeability, allow to greater improve the simulations, defining time probabilities of thermal breakthrough in an area of high density wells.
In France, heating networks are largely dependent on fossil fuels (42%), and deep geothermal energy represents less than 5% of the energy mix of heating networks. Deployment of geothermal energy in large cities is limited by a geological risk, difficult to predict. This risk constitutes an obstacle to the future development of geothermal energy in the Ile-de-France region. The aim of this work is to develop a predictive 3D reservoir model in terms of stratigraphic geometries, facies, porosity, permeability and temperature at a given location in Ile-de-France. We focus on the main geothermal reservoirs in the area: the Middle Jurassic limestones. In order to create this 3D model, 80 wells (630 logs), drilled over the last 60 years, were studied over an area of 800 km2. The first phase of this study consisted in digitizing the old well data, particularly log data on 80 wells (GR, Sonic, resistivity) and adding all recent wells (with neutron porosity and NMR logs). We also compiled from the drilling reports 694 porosity (phi) – permeability (k) values previously measured on cores from plugs, and we imported them into the geomodeller Petrel®. Two reference wells with cores of the reservoir were studied in detail from a sedimentological and stratigraphic point of view in order to link sedimentary facies, logs and phi-k in a well-defined sedimentological framework. We also digitized temperature in 40 wells. The sequence stratigraphy framework allows to define 11 3rd order stratigraphic sequences from the Bajocian (jason Zone) to the Middle Callovian (zigzag Zone). Twelve surfaces from Bj5 to Ca3 corresponding to 3rd order Maximum Regressive Surfaces (MRS) allow to correlate all wells and to define stratigraphic geometries. A total of 10 facies are grouped into 4 facies associations (1) marls of lower offshore (facies association FA1), (2) marl-limestone alternations of upper offshore (FA2), (3) oolitic grainstones of the shoreface (FA3) and (4) lagoon micritic limestones (FA4). These facies associations were coded in all wells according to the log depths. The best reservoir is mainly located in the oolitic and bioclastic grainstones (FA3) with average porosity of 12% and permeability of 130 mD. The lagoon micritic facies also presents interesting properties with average porosity of 8.2% and permeability of 46 mD. The model has been meshed into 6.5 million of cells split on 64 vertical cell layers of 150 m x150 m x about 5 m (length ×width ×height) each bearing specific property information (facies, porosity, permeability). The final model shows a high variability of the facies distribution over the 11 depositional sequences. The maximum thickness of the oolitic reservoir is about 50 m in the western part of the study area between surface Bt2 and Bt4. By combining the isopach map of oolitic facies between surface Bt2 and Bt4 with porosity above 10%, permeability of more than 100 mD and temperature larger than 60°C, we locate areas of interest for geothermal development in the Paris Basin.