The use of intra-cytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) has increased significantly worldwide, often chosen instead of in vitro fertilization (IVF), yet long-term health outcomes are unknown and health differences between ICSI and IVF conceptions have not been comprehensively assessed. A systematic review of health outcomes of ICSI-conceived offspring beyond the neonatal period compared to IVF-conceived offspring was carried out. PubMed, OVID Medline/Embase, Informit, Web of Science and Proquest databases were searched on 9 November 2016 for studies reporting on health outcomes in ICSI-conceived offspring beyond 28 days after birth. Physical and psychosocial health were the main outcome measures. The search strategy yielded 2781 articles; 2539 were not relevant or did not meet inclusion criteria and 137 were duplicates. One hundred and five full-text papers were evaluated further and 34 satisfied the inclusion criteria. Studies comparing ICSI- and IVF-conceived children suggest their neurodevelopment is comparable. Growth and aspects of physical health are also similar; however, studies are few and limited to childhood. ICSI-conceived children may be at increased risk of autism and intellectual impairment. No difference in risk of childhood cancer was reported in one study. Whilst the neurodevelopment of ICSI-conceived children appears comparable to those of IVF conception, data relating to neurodevelopmental disorders, growth, physical health and childhood cancer are inconclusive. Further research into health outcomes in adolescence and adulthood is required before conclusions can be drawn about the long-term safety of ICSI compared to IVF. Until then, ICSI might be better reserved for its original intended use, male-factor infertility.
Chromosomal microarray (CMA) testing is now performed frequently in paediatric care. Although CMAs improve diagnostic yields, they increase detection of variants of unknown and uncertain clinical significance (VUS). Understanding parents', paediatricians' and genetic health professionals' (GHPs) views regarding variant disclosure may reduce the potential for communication of unwanted information. A questionnaire was designed to compare disclosure preferences of these three groups in Australia. One hundred and forty-seven parents, 159 paediatricians and 69 GHPs hold similar views with at least 89% of respondents certainly or probably favouring disclosure of all categories of variants. However, some differences were observed between health care providers (HCPs: paediatricians and GHPs) and parents, who were less sure of their disclosure preferences. There was consensus among respondent groups that knowledge of a variant of certain clinical significance would provide more practical and emotional utility compared to VUS. Compared to HCPs, parents placed more emphasis on using knowledge of a VUS when considering future pregnancies (p < 0.001). This study may help HCPs anticipate parents' preferences for genomic testing. As whole exome/genome sequencing is integrated into clinical practice, the potential for differing views of parents and HCPs should be considered when developing guidelines for result disclosure.
BACKGROUND The use of assisted reproductive technology (ART) is now well established in many countries and the first generations of offspring are reaching maturity. We reviewed the published literature to describe the available evidence about health outcomes in ART-conceived young people who were of an adolescent age or older. METHODS The EMBASE, Medline and PsychINFO databases were searched from January 1998 to October 2010. Key inclusion criteria were that the study sample have a mean age of ≥ 12 years or a mean follow-up period of ≥ 12 years and were conceived by ART. RESULTS Seven publications reported physical health outcomes and 10 reported psychosocial health outcomes in ART offspring. Compared with control groups, some differences in physiological outcomes in relation to growth and development, chronic illness and risk of cancer have been reported. Overall, psychosocial studies of ART-conceived young people indicate that their cognitive function and psychological and social adjustment are similar to that of comparison groups. CONCLUSIONS Overall, nine ART-conceived populations of this age group have been studied. Most samples included < 300 participants and methodologies varied between studies. Health information on this age group is therefore limited and the clinical significance of the findings remains unclear. Further research focusing on ART-conceived young adults is needed, particularly in relation to neurological health outcomes where no studies have been reported to date.
D.J. Amor1,2,3,4,8, J.X. Xu1,2, J.L. Halliday1,2, I. Francis3, D.L. Healy5,6, S. Breheny5,6, H.W.G. Baker4,7, and A.M. Jaques1 Murdoch Childrens Research Institute, Royal Children’s Hospital, Parkville, Victoria, Australia Department of Paediatrics, University of Melbourne, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia Victorian Clinical Genetics Services, Royal Children’s Hospital, Parkville, Victoria, Australia Melbourne IVF, East Melbourne, Victoria, Australia Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, Monash University, Clayton, Victoria, Australia Monash IVF, Richmond, Victoria, Australia Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, University of Melbourne, Royal Women’s Hospital, Parkville, Victoria, Australia
BACKGROUND First trimester screening (FTS) for Down syndrome combines measurement of nuchal translucency, free beta-human chorionic gonadotrophin and pregnancy-associated plasma protein-A (PAPP-A). The aim of this study was to undertake a detailed analysis of FTS results in singleton pregnancies conceived using assisted reproductive technologies (ART) and non-ART pregnancies. METHODS A record linkage study compared outcomes in 1739 ART-conceived and 50 253 naturally conceived pregnancies. RESULTS Overall, significantly lower PAPP-A levels were detected in ART pregnancies (0.83 multiples of median, MoM) than in controls (1.00 MoM) (t-test P < 0.001). This difference remained after excluding complicated pregnancies. Analysis of factors affecting PAPP-A levels suggested fresh compared with frozen embryo transfers and use of artificial cycles compared with natural cycles for frozen transfers were associated with lower values. The adjusted odds ratio (AdjOR) for receiving a false-positive result was 1.71 (95% CI 1.44-2.04; P < 0.001) for ART pregnancies compared with non-ART pregnancies, and this leads to a higher AdjOR (1.24, 95% CI 1.03-1.49; P = 0.02) for having a chorionic villous sampling (CVS) or amniocentesis. CONCLUSIONS ART pregnancies have reduced FTS PAPP-A levels leading to an increased likelihood of receiving a false-positive result and having a CVS/amniocentesis. Lower PAPP-A may reflect impairment of early implantation with some forms of ART.
OBJECTIVE:The objective of this study was to follow up and evaluate the statewide first-trimester combined screening programme for Down syndrome and trisomy 18 at Genetic Health Services Victoria, Australia. DESIGN:Retrospective population cohort. SETTING:Maternal Serum Screening Laboratory records. SAMPLE:All women screened between February 2000 and June 2002 (16,153 pregnancies). METHODS:Screening results were matched to Victorian perinatal and birth defect data via record linkage, with an ascertainment of 96.8% of pregnancy outcomes. Manual follow up with health professionals increased ascertainment to more than 99%. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES:Fetal Down syndrome or trisomy 18, and combined screen results, to calculate test characteristics. RESULTS:Using a risk threshold of 1 in 300 at time of ultrasound, the sensitivities for standard first-trimester combined screening and augmented 13-week combined screening for Down syndrome were 87.3 and 90.5% and the false-positive rates (FPR) were 4.1 and 3.9%, respectively. The sensitivity for trisomy 18 was 66.7% (10/15, 95% CI 42.8-90.5%) with a 0.4% FPR and 15.2% positive predictive value (1 in 250 risk threshold). CONCLUSIONS:The combined use of record linkage and manual follow-up techniques was effective in ascertaining more than 99% of pregnancy outcomes for calculations of accurate test characteristics of the combined screen. The sensitivity for Down syndrome at Genetic Health is comparable to similar populations. However, the sensitivity for trisomy 18 is lower than that elsewhere, which may reflect the overall low birth prevalence of trisomy 18 and associated small numbers in this particular cohort.
This study was undertaken to document the phenotype of Kabuki (Niikawa-Kuroki) syndrome in patients from Australia and New Zealand, with particular emphasis on growth patterns, behavior, and relationship between head circumference and intellectual level. Data on 27 children and adults with Kabuki (Niikawa-Kuroki) syndrome from Australia and New Zealand were collected by questionnaire and clinical assessment. The patients ranged in age from 7 months to 36 years with a mean age of 7 years and 2 months. The mean age at diagnosis was 3(5/6) years, but in most cases, the facial phenotype was evident from infancy. The minimum birth prevalence was calculated at 1 in 86,000. Three of our patients died. Parents reported a behavior phenotype characterized by an excellent long-term memory and avoidance of eye contact. No correlation was found between head circumference and severity of intellectual disability. Eight of 14 patients over the age of 5 years were overweight or obese. Six of these eight patients had failure to thrive in infancy. One patient developed insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus in adolescence. Some individuals with Kabuki (Niikawa-Kuroki) syndrome show a characteristic growth profile with failure to thrive in infancy progressing to obesity or overweight in middle childhood or adolescence. A behavior phenotype was noted which requires further investigation. Head size is not a predictor of degree of intellectual disability.
This questionnaire-based study in Victoria, Australia, examined the responses of pregnant women, aged 37 years and over, to a question about what they expected prenatal testing (screening and/or diagnosis) for birth defects to tell them about their pregnancy. Content analysis showed that, of the 432 tested women, 61.3% mentioned Down syndrome, chromosomal abnormalities or trisomies. Women undergoing both screening and diagnosis were more likely than those having one or other test to mention Down syndrome (adjusted OR = 1.6, P = 0.06), having adjusted for age, marital status, education, residence and parity. Similarly, those from an English-speaking background were more likely to mention Down syndrome, etc. compared to women from a non-English-speaking background (adjusted OR = 3.5, P < 0.001). Down syndrome, a fundamental piece of information about prenatal tests, was not mentioned in nearly 40% of women's responses. This suggests that pregnant women need clearer information about prenatal testing, including the conditions that might be detected.
Clinical, demographic and laboratory data from infants with congenital hypothyroidism (CH) born in the Australian state of Victoria from the commencement of neonatal screening in mid-1977 until December 1988 are reported. These provide a baseline for a 12-year prospective longitudinal study on physical and neuro-psychological outcome until mid-1997, the subject of a second paper. Infants with CH were detected using a primary TT4 screening test. Demographic data were collected prospectively using a clinical assessment protocol. Nearly all affected infants underwent 99mTc pertechnetate scanning at the initial assessment to determine the underlying aetiology of their hypothyroidism. 704,723 infants were screened and 199 with permanent primary hypothyroidism (one in 3,541) were identified. The most common aetiologies were thyroid ectopia (46%), thyroid aplasia (33%), and 'dyshormonogenesis' (11%). The clinical abnormalities classically described in CH were more evident in infants with aplasia, and the striking female preponderance in infants with thyroid dysplasia (syn. dysgenesis) was confirmed. Other features included increased frequencies of 'dyshormonogenesis' in infants of parents of Middle-Eastern origin and of labour induction in infants with dysplasia. A closed posterior fontanelle was not found in any infant with thyroid aplasia.
Objective: To provide an overview of the characteristics of Victorian infants born between 1983 and 1995 who are affected by one or more of 27 sentinel birth defects.Methodology: Using data on congenital malformations supplied to the Victorian Perinatal Data Collection Unit from multiple sources between 1983 and 1995, information was summarised for 25 231 infants (born at 20 weeks or more) and 1566 terminations of pregnancy before 20 weeks' gestation.Results: During the 13-year study period in Victoria, 3.2% of babies had at least one malformation. Congenital dislocation of the hip was the most common defect with a prevalence of 28.9 per 10 000 pregnancies or 1/346. Increase in birth prevalence between 1983 and 1995 is greatest in obstructive defects of the renal pelvis, hypospadias and the trisomies 21,13 and 18. Nearly 50% of pregnancies affected by anencephaly were terminated before 20 weeks compared to 26% affected by spina bifida, The perinatal mortality of infants born at 20 weeks or more with congenital malformations is more than 10 times greater than that of infants without any malformations. Males are more at risk of being born with a malformation than females. Congenital malformations are more common in infants of multiple pregnancies and those of low birthweight.Conclusion: This large data collection is a valuable source of information for perinatal epidemiologists, for providers of prenatal diagnostic services and for the care of the disabled. In addition, the continued reporting and monitoring of birth defects will allow for targeted research that may lead to a better understanding of their aetiology.
We have studied a large population-based cohort of women who had amniocentesis at 14 weeks' gestation (early amniocentesis) in Victoria, a state of Australia, to determine fetal loss rates and maternal morbidity. This was done by linking two registers--one containing information on all prenatal diagnostic tests in the state, and the other a register of all births at or after 20 weeks' gestation. Almost complete follow-up was achieved. The spontaneous fetal loss rate was significantly higher for women of age 37 years and over having early amniocentesis (2.5 per cent), as compared with the fetal loss rate found previously on the same geographically defined population who had amniocentesis at about 16 weeks' gestational age (1.1 per cent). Three classes of maternal morbidity reported to the birth register (post 20 weeks' gestation) were also analysed. The most significant finding was a reduced rate of premature rupture of membranes with early amniocentesis when compared with a group having later amniocentesis, or the background population not having any amniocentesis. There was no significant increase in the occurrence of antepartum bleeding or genito-urinary tract infection for women having early amniocentesis. These data agree with other studies in showing that early amniocentesis is associated with a significant increased risk of fetal loss, as compared with later amniocentesis. In addition we have shown no significant increase in the occurrence of three indicators of maternal morbidity, reported at or after 20 weeks' gestation.
Ten patients with maxillonasal hypoplasia (Binder "syndrome"), who were prenatally exposed to phenytoin (usually in combination with other anticonvulsants), were identified retrospectively. In addition to their facial anomalies, 6 of the patients were radiographed neonatally and showed punctate calcification, characteristic of chondrodysplasia punctata. Evidence is presented that the facial abnormalities seen in these children are due to anticonvulsant-induced vitamin K deficiency, causing abnormal development of the cartilaginous nasal septum. We propose that early vitamin K supplementation of at-risk pregnancies may prevent the development of maxillonasal hypoplasia, which in some patients is severely disfiguring and causes great emotional distress. Correction of this facial defect requires surgical and dental treatment over a long period of time.
Even in areas where prenatal diagnostic testing is offered at no cost to women over a certain age, uptake of testing is not complete. We have studied the factors that affect uptake in Victoria, Australia. In 1988-92, 43% of 37-39-year-old women and 29% of those 40 years and over had no diagnostic testing despite their eligibility for a free test. We compared the characteristics of untested women (n = 3074) with those of tested women (2462 amniocentesis, 1575 chorionic villus sampling) by use of record-linkage between the Victorian birth register and fetal diagnosis data collection. The indication for testing was maternal age alone. Women who had had 3 or more previous births were less likely than those of lower parity to undergo testing (odds ratio 0.54 [95% CI 0.46-0.63], p < 0.001), whereas those who had had a previous termination of pregnancy were more likely to be tested than those who had not (1.52 [1.26-1.83], p < 0.001). Women born in non-English-speaking countries and women who lived in rural areas were less likely to be tested. Women who gave birth in private hospitals were more likely to be tested than those who gave birth in any public hospital or at home. These data help to distinguish between issues of choice and access to diagnostic testing. Factors that hinder testing of rural women and of those from non-English-speaking backgrounds should be addressed.
Current measures of livebirth prevalence of Down syndrome are derived from data obtained up to 20 years ago, before the introduction of the prenatal diagnostic tests amniocentesis and chorionic villus sampling (CVS). For women aged 36–52 years, but who were not tested prenatally, we proposed to make a direct estimate of current livebirth prevalence of Down syndrome. We could also determine prevalence at the time of CVS and amniocentesis in women of the same age undergoing prenatal testing. Differences in these prevalences allow an estimation of the relative loss of Down syndrome during pregnancy. In Victoria, Australia, we identified 3041 women having CVS, 7504 having amniocentesis, and 13 139 having no test. Smoothed regression estimates of age‐specific livebirth prevalence were found to be higher than in the early studies. The estimate of spontaneous loss was 17 per cent between the time of CVS and amniocentesis, and 18 per cent after the time of amniocentesis. The latter figure is lower than previous estimates and may be explained by a greater likelihood of a Down syndrome fetus surviving to be liveborn, given the modern approach to early obstetric intervention. These current risk estimates of livebirth may be useful updates for genetic counselling, but perhaps more importantly, may be used as precise maternal age‐related risk figures, necessary in the design and implementation of prenatal screening programmes for Down syndrome.
Record linkage between a prenatal diagnosis register and a congenital malformation register in the state of Victoria, Australia, has enabled further evaluation of the suggested association between limb deficiencies and early chorion villus sampling (CVS). We found 3 anomalies in this category after later CVS (i.e., 9 weeks and beyond), but our data suggest that advanced maternal age may be a risk factor for both terminal and all limb deficiencies. The data from Victoria are tabulated with data obtained from other registers. Different birth prevalence figures are obtained by different registers, therefore limiting comparisons between registers.
Women who are the most difficult to trace after amniocentesis or chorion villus sampling are often those who have had an adverse pregnancy outcome. To calculate total fetal loss figures for use in prenatal counselling we have followed in a multicentre study 100% of women who had undergone these procedures.Early spontaneous loss (within three weeks of the procedure) and total spontaneous loss were much lower after amniocentesis (0.2% and 1.3%, respectively) than after chorion villus sampling (1.2% and 2.9%). Four spontaneous fetal losses among the 20 pregnancies that were the most difficult to follow-up increased the loss rate by 0.5% for chorion villus sampling. Risk of early fetal loss after chorion villus sampling was related to experience of the operator (relative risk [RR] 4.3, p = 0.003), and total fetal loss was lower in pregnancies tested at 10 weeks' or more gestational age compared with those tested before 10 weeks' (RR 0.4, p = 0.01). A table showing the frequency of each of the seven possible outcomes after amniocentesis and chorion villus sampling is useful in counselling those considering one or other test.