Grey mullets (family Mugilidae) are widespread across coastal, brackish, and freshwater habitats, and have supported fisheries for millennia. Despite their global distribution and commercial value, little is known about their movement ecology and its role in the co-existence of sympatric mullet species. Gaps in knowledge about migratory behaviour, seasonal occurrence, and movement scales have also impeded effective management, highlighting the need for further research. This study aimed to identify key habitats and timing of grey mullet presence across the Dutch Wadden Sea, North Sea, and freshwater areas, and to explore potential behavioral differences between two grey mullet species: thicklip mullet (Chelon labrosus) and thinlip mullet (Chelon ramada). Using acoustic telemetry, we tracked 86 tagged grey mullet over three years (thicklip mullet, N = 74; thinlip mullet, N = 12), combining data from 100 local acoustic receivers and the European Tracking Network. Both species were detected in the Wadden Sea from April to November, however, thinlip mullet arrived in the Wadden Sea earlier than thicklip mullet (median date = May 16 vs. June 7). Individual residency in the Wadden Sea lasted a median 97 days for thicklip mullet and 94 days for thinlip mullet. Thinlip mullet were also detected by more receivers and over a larger area than thicklip mullet, indicating differences in movement behaviour. Both species showed an affinity for receivers near major harbours, with thinlip mullet more often detected near fresh water outflows. Seasonal migrations between coastal and offshore waters were also observed, with one thinlip mullet returning to freshwater across consecutive years. North Sea detections spanned ten months, with a gap during the presumed spawning period (Jan–Feb). Our data suggest that thinlip mullet show a preference for deeper gullies while thicklip mullet may spend more time in shallow areas and flooded tidal flats. These findings highlight the importance of the Wadden Sea as a seasonal foraging ground and provide insights into the migratory patterns of grey mullets.
The movement ecology of European seabass, Dicentrarchus labrax, remains poorly understood, especially in the northern ranges of its distribution. To investigate migration patterns of seabass from the southern North Sea, we combined data from different projects from four countries using various tagging techniques. This resulted in 146 recaptures (out of 5598 externally marked seabass), 138 detected animals (out of 162 seabass fitted with an acoustic transmitter) and 76 archived depth and temperature series (out of 323 seabass with an archival tag). Using geolocation modelling, we distinguished different migration strategies, whereby individual fish migrated to the eastern English Channel (15.1%), the western English Channel (28.3%), the Celtic Sea and the norther part of the Bay of Biscay (17.0%), or stayed in the North Sea (39.6%). A high number of seabass exhibited fidelity to the North Sea (90.5% of recaptures, 55.3% for acoustic transmitters and 44.7% of archival tags). Although seabass are generally considered to migrate southwards in winter, a large number of individuals (n = 62) were observed in the southern North Sea, where spawning might potentially occur in a particular deep location along the coast of Norfolk in the UK. Our results highlight the need to consider fine-scaled population structuring in fisheries assessment, and indicate that current seasonal fisheries closures are not aligned with the ecology of seabass in the North Sea.
Range tests play a critical role in designing acoustic telemetry studies, guiding equipment configuration, deployment techniques, and the analysis of animal movement data. These studies often strive to capture the effects of environmental variation on detection efficiency over time but are frequently limited in spatial and temporal scale. This could lead to disparities between test results and the circumstances encountered during animal tracking studies. In this study, we evaluated detection range and efficiency at two distinct spatial and temporal scales in a dynamic intertidal ecosystem. Two range tests were conducted, the first being a small-scale study using 6 receivers deployed over 1 month. Using modern acoustic receivers with built-in transmitters and environmental sensors, we then conducted a large-scale range test with 22 receiver stations over a full year to approximate the area and duration of a typical animal movement study. Differences in detection range between the two studies occurred as a result of environmental variation and tag power output, with midpoint ranges estimated as 123 m (small scale, low power), 149 m (small scale, high power) and 311 m (large scale, very high power). At both scales, wind speed emerged as the most influential factor explaining temporal variation in predicted detection efficiency. However, this effect was modulated by wind direction which varied as a result of land sheltering and fetch between the two study scales. At the small scale, detection efficiency decreased with winds from the south and east, while at the large scale, northern and westerly winds were most detrimental. Water temperature had a positive effect on predicted detection efficiency at both scales, while relative water level was positive at the small scale and negative at the large scale. Additional factors, including precipitation and Topographic Position Index, were found to influence detection efficiency at a large scale. Moreover, sensors associated with receivers in the larger array revealed the significant influences of receiver tilt and ambient noise. These discrepancies in the outcomes of the two studies underscore the critical role of scale in range test design and emphasize the need for long-term, in situ range testing at relevant spatial scales.
Coastal habitats serve essential roles in the life cycles of migratory fishes, impacting both local and regional population stability. Conservation efforts for coastal fish often rely on spatial approaches within designated boundaries to mitigate threats and enhance production. However, in open coastal environments, migratory behaviours can extend beyond these protected areas, exposing individuals to potential threats or population bottlenecks elsewhere in their range. To improve conservation outcomes, a comprehensive understanding of movements across the entire migratory range is essential. Aquatic telemetry is a valuable tool for studying these behaviours, but must be adapted to address questions at multiple spatial and temporal scales. In this study we demonstrate how a combination of telemetry techniques can capture both local and regional fish behaviours. We begin by introducing the implications of migratory behaviours for fish conservation in open coastal environments, using the Wadden Sea as an example where additional research and management are needed to address fish declines. We then present a case study which uses the Dutch Wadden Sea to illustrate how a multi-scale telemetry approach can enhance both fundamental knowledge and conservation strategies for migratory fish. Within this case study, we present the general movement strategies exhibited by coastal migrants, alongside an overview of telemetry techniques applicable for open coastal systems. We then apply a size-based assessment using a reference tag to estimate the suitability of common Wadden Sea species for long-term tracking. Drawing from these results, we select four example species to showcase how species-specific understanding of fish life history and abundance can guide tracking studies, accompanied by illustrative examples using telemetry data. Expanding from this case study, we transition to a broader discussion were we provide overarching perspectives on tracking in open coastal ecosystems and offer recommendations to enhance future tracking studies in the Wadden Sea. The integration of telemetry methodologies aligns research and management with fish movement over multiple scales, improving our understanding of fish behaviors and contributing to more effective conservation strategies.
Acoustic telemetry (AT) has emerged as a valuable tool for monitoring aquatic animals in both European inland and marine waters over the past two decades. The European Tracking Network (ETN) initiative has played a pivotal role in promoting collaboration among AT researchers in Europe and has led to a significant increase in the number of tagged and observed aquatic animals in transboundary European waters. While AT benefits decision-making and delivers essential data to management bodies, its potential for management decision-making mechanisms has yet to be fully harnessed. We reviewed existing research, studies, and organisational initiatives related to aquatic animal tracking and their utility in fisheries management in European waters. We found that AT has already contributed to many aspects of fisheries management, such as improved understanding of stock dynamics, identification of critical habitats, assessment of migration routes, and evaluation of the effectiveness of conservation measures. However, broader utilisation of tracking technologies is needed. By leveraging the full potential of AT, managers can make more informed decisions to protect, restore, and sustainably manage European waters and creatures that live therein.
As Arctic ecosystems become increasingly vulnerable to climate- and human-induced stressors, effective marine management will rely on the characterization of fish movements. Over a six-year study period, the movements of 65 Greenland sharks (Somniosus microcephalus) (41 males, 24 females; mean LT = 2.48 ± 0.50 m) were monitored using static acoustic telemetry. Shark presence in a typical deep-water fjord was restricted to the summer open-water period. Residency duration varied based on age class (juvenile, n = 17; subadult, n = 48); however, activity space size and extent were comparable. A quarter of tagged sharks (n = 16) returned to the system in subsequent years after tagging, with individuals redetected for a maximum of 4 years. Movements between coastal and offshore waters occurred primarily via a deep-water channel with sharks detected along the channel banks. These multiyear data depict how a potentially vulnerable Arctic predator utilizes a deep-water fjord in the context of the regional development of community inshore and offshore commercial fisheries.
Variable movement strategies can complicate the conservation and management of mobile species. Given its extreme life history traits as a long-lived, deep-water species, the Greenland shark ( Somniosus microcephalus ) is vulnerable to fisheries bycatch, but little is known over its long-term movements across a spatially and seasonally variable Arctic environment. To address this knowledge gap, the movements of Greenland sharks in coastal fjords and offshore waters of Baffin Bay were examined using seven years of acoustic telemetry data. Seasonal patterns in broad-scale movements and inshore-offshore connectivity were compared among 155 sharks (101 males, 54 females [mean LT = 2.65 ± 0.48 m, range 0.93-3.5 m]) tagged in 6 discrete coastal locations spanning from Grise Fiord to Cumberland Sound (Nunavut). Sharks exhibited transient movements throughout coastal and offshore regions with some evidence of seasonally recurring hotspots revealed by repeat detections of individuals at sites over multiple years. Shark presence in coastal fjords occurred exclusively during the coastal ice-free period (July to November), regardless of the location of tagging or detection, while presence in the offshore was recorded during the period of ice re-formation and cover (November to July). Through multi-year telemetry, it was possible to reveal repetitive patterns in broad-scale habitat use for a complex marine predator with direct relevance for understanding the seasonal distribution of mobile Arctic consumers and informing regional fisheries management.
Long-lived species share life history traits such as slow growth, late maturity, and low fecundity, which lead to slow recovery rates and increase a population’s vulnerability to disturbance. The Greenland shark (Somniosus microcephalus) has recently been recognized as the world’s longest-lived vertebrate, but many questions regarding its biology, physiology, and ecology remain unanswered. Here we review how current and future research will fill knowledge gaps about the Greenland shark and provide an overall framework to guide research and management priorities for this species. Key advances include the potential for specialised ageing techniques and demographic studies to shed light on the distribution and age-class structure of Greenland shark populations. Advances in population genetics and genomics will reveal key factors contributing to the Greenland shark’s extreme longevity, range and population size, and susceptibility to environmental change. New tagging technologies and improvements in experimental and analytical design will allow detailed monitoring of movement behaviours and interactions among Greenland sharks and other marine species, while shedding light on habitat use and susceptibility to fisheries interactions. Interdisciplinary approaches, such as the combined use of stable isotope analysis and high-tech data-logging devices (i.e. accelerometers and acoustic hydrophones) have the potential to improve knowledge of feeding strategies, predatory capabilities, and the trophic role of Greenland sharks. Measures of physiology, including estimation of metabolic rate, as well as heart rate and function, will advance our understanding of the causes and consequences of long lifespans. Determining the extent and effects of current threats (as well as potential mitigation measures) will assist the development of policies, recommendations, and actions relevant for the management of this potentially vulnerable species. Through an interdisciplinary lens, we propose innovative approaches to direct the future study of Greenland sharks and promote the consideration of longevity as an important factor in research on aquatic and terrestrial predators.
Advances in biotelemetry have revealed the movement behaviours of many terrestrial and shallow-water organisms, contributing critical insight for their conservation and management. However, persistent technological and logistical challenges have thus far impeded the implementation of biotelemetry in the deep sea. Despite these limitations, innovations in telemetry technology, experimental design, and animal handling have allowed the study of 13 families of deep-water fishes to date, providing movement records spanning from surface waters down to 5900 m depth and across nearly all of the worlds oceans. Telemetry devices employed in deep-sea tracking studies have included both commercially available and custom-built transmitters belonging to multiple tag categories: acoustic transponders/code-activated acoustic transponders, acoustic transmitters (coded and continuous, e.g., 'pingers'), pop-up satellite archival tags, and archival tags (data loggers). Specially adapted tagging approaches, including in situ methods such as dart tagging via manned submersible, underwater surgical implantation, and the ingestion of baited transmitters have facilitated the monitoring of species that can not survive being brought to the surface, while modified capture, tag, and release approaches have been used for species that can withstand depressurization. These tracking data have revealed patterns in the vertical and horizontal movement behaviours and population connectivity of a number of data deficient species, as well as contributing to management by allowing the effectiveness of reserves, fisheries management boundaries, and fishery closures to be evaluated. With the rapid expansion of fisheries and natural resource exploration to depths beyond the continental shelf, further monitoring of deep-sea habitats and species is essential. By examining these substantial breakthroughs in biotelemetry application, in addition to the range of cutting-edge technologies that could be adapted for use in deep water, we strive to promote the timely advancement of this research in the deep sea. Further diversification of these tools and techniques will be necessary to expand the accessibility of this field to the broader scientific community.