Relational Web tables have become an important resource for applications such as factual search and entity augmentation. A major challenge for an automatic identification of relevant tables on the Web is the fact that many of these tables have missing or non-informative column labels. Research has focused largely on recovering the meaning of columns by inferring class labels from the instances using external knowledge bases. The table context, which often contains additional information on the table's content, is frequently considered as an indicator for the general content of a table, but not as a source for column-specific details. In this paper, we propose a novel approach to identify and extract column-specific information from the context of Web tables. In our extraction framework, we consider different techniques to extract directly as well as indirectly related phrases. We perform a number of experiments on Web tables extracted from Wikipedia. The results show that column-specific information extracted using our simple heuristic significantly boost precision and recall for table and column search.
In a traditional relational database management system, queries can only be defined over attributes defined in the schema, but are guaranteed to give single, definitive answer structured exactly as specified in the query. In contrast, an information retrieval system allows the user to pose queries without knowledge of a schema, but the result will be a top-k list of possible answers, with no guarantees about the structure or content of the retrieved documents. In this paper, we present DrillBeyond, a novel IR/RDBMS hybrid system, in which the user seamlessly queries a relational database together with a large corpus of tables extracted from a web crawl. The system allows full SQL queries over the relational database, but additionally allows the user to use arbitrary additional attributes in the query that need not to be defined in the schema. The system then processes this semi-specified query by computing a top-k list of possible query evaluations, each based on different candidate web data sources, thus mixing properties of RDBMS and IR systems. We design a novel plan operator that encapsulates a web data retrieval and matching system and allows direct integration of such systems into relational query processing. We then present methods for efficiently processing multiple variants of a query, by producing plans that are optimized for large invariant intermediate results that can be reused between multiple query evaluations. We demonstrate the viability of the operator and our optimization strategies by implementing them in PostgreSQL and evaluating on a standard benchmark by adding arbitrary attributes to its queries.
Entity augmentation is a query type in which, given a set of entities and a large corpus of possible data sources, the values of a missing attribute are to be retrieved. State of the art methods return a single result that, to cover all queried entities, is fused from a potentially large set of data sources. We argue that queries on large corpora of heterogeneous sources using information retrieval and automatic schema matching methods can not easily return a single result that the user can trust, especially if the result is composed from a large number of sources that user has to verify manually. We therefore propose to process these queries in a Top-k fashion, in which the system produces multiple minimal consistent solutions from which the user can choose to resolve the uncertainty of the data sources and methods used. In this paper, we introduce and formalize the problem of consistent, multi-solution set covering, and present algorithms based on a greedy and a genetic optimization approach. We then apply these algorithms to Web table-based entity augmentation. The publication further includes a Web table corpus with 100M tables, and a Web table retrieval and matching system in which these algorithms are implemented. Our experiments show that the consistency and minimality of the augmentation results can be improved using our set covering approach, without loss of precision or coverage and while producing multiple alternative query results.
In recent years, researchers have recognized relational tables on the Web as an important source of information. To assist this research we developed the Dresden Web Tables Corpus (DWTC), a collection of about 125 million data tables extracted from the Common Crawl (CC) which contains 3.6 billion web pages and is 266TB in size. As the vast majority of HTML tables are used for layout purposes and only a small share contains genuine tables with different surface forms, accurate table detection is essential for building a large-scale Web table corpus. Furthermore, correctly recognizing the table structure (e.g. horizontal listings, matrices) is important in order to understand the role of each table cell, distinguishing between label and data cells. In this paper, we present an extensive table layout classification that enables us to identify the main layout categories of Web tables with very high precision. We therefore identify and develop a plethora of table features, different feature selection techniques and several classification algorithms. We evaluate the effectiveness of the selected features and compare the performance of various state-of-the-art classification algorithms. Finally, the winning approach is employed to classify millions of tables resulting in the Dresden Web Table Corpus (DWTC).
Data completeness is one of the most important data quality dimensions and an essential premise in data analytics. With new emerging Big Data trends such as the data lake concept, which provides a low cost data preparation repository instead of moving curated data into a data warehouse, the problem of data completeness is additionally reinforced. While traditionally the process of filling in missing values is addressed by the data imputation community using statistical techniques, we complement these approaches by using external data sources from the data lake or even the Web to lookup missing values. In this paper we propose a novel hybrid data imputation strategy that, takes into account the characteristics of an incomplete dataset and based on that chooses the best imputation approach, i.e. either a statistical approach such as regression analysis or a Web-based lookup or a combination of both. We formalize and implement both imputation approaches, including a Web table retrieval and matching system and evaluate them extensively using a corpus with 125M Web tables. We show that applying statistical techniques in conjunction with external data sources will lead to a imputation system which is robust, accurate, and has high coverage at the same time.
Of the structured data published on the web, for instance as datasets on Open Data Platforms such as data.gov, but also in the form of HTML tables on the general web, only a small part is in a relational form. Instead the data is intermingled with formatting, layout and textual metadata, i.e., it is contained in partially structured documents. This makes transformation into a true relational form necessary, which is a precondition for most forms of data analysis and data integration. Studying data.gov as an example source for partially structured documents, we present a classification of typical normalization problems. We then present the DeExcelerator, which is a framework for extracting relations from partially structured documents such as spreadsheets and HTML tables.
Named entity extraction is an established research area in the field of information extraction. When tailored to a specific domain and with sufficient pre-labeled training data, state-of-the-art extraction algorithms have achieved near human performance. However, when presented with semi-structured data, informal text or unknown domains where training data is not available, extraction results can deteriorate significantly. Recent research has focused on crowdsourcing as an alternative to automatic named entity extraction or as a tool to generate the required training data. While humans easily adapt to semi-structured data and informal style, a crowd-based approach also introduces new issues due to monetary costs or spamming. We address these issues by combining automatic named entity extraction algorithms with crowdsourcing into a hybrid approach. We have conducted a wide range of experiments on real world data to identify a set of subtasks or operators, that can be performed either by the crowd or automatically. Results show that a meaningful combination of these operators into complex processing pipelines can significantly enhance the quality of named entity extraction in challenging scenarios, while at the same time reducing the monetary costs of crowdsourcing and the risk of misuse.
Platforms for publication and collaborative management of data, such as Data.gov or Google Fusion Tables, are a new trend on the web. They manage very large corpora of datasets, but often lack an integrated schema, ontology, or even just common publication standards. This results in inconsistent names for attributes of the same meaning, which constrains the discovery of relationships between datasets as well as their reusability. Existing data integration techniques focus on reuse-time, i.e., they are applied when a user wants to combine a specific set of datasets or integrate them with an existing database. In contrast, this paper investigates a novel method of data integration at publish-time, where the publisher is provided with suggestions on how to integrate the new dataset with the corpus as a whole, without resorting to a manually created mediated schema or ontology for the platform. We propose data-driven algorithms that propose alternative attribute names for a newly published dataset based on attribute- and instance statistics maintained on the corpus. We evaluate the proposed algorithms using real-world corpora based on the Open Data Platform opendata.socrata.com and relational data extracted from Wikipedia. We report on the system's response time, and on the results of an extensive crowdsourcing-based evaluation of the quality of the generated attribute names alternatives.
There is an ever-increasing amount and variety of open web data available that is insufficiently examined or not considered at all in decision making processes. This is because of the lack of end-user friendly tools that help to reuse this public data and to create knowledge out of it. Therefore, we propose a schema-optional data repository that provides the flexibility necessary to store and gradually integrate heterogeneous web data. Based on this repository, we propose a semi-automatic schema enrichment approach that efficiently augments the data in a "pay-as-you-go" fashion. Due to the inherently appearing ambiguities we further propose a crowd-based verification component that is able to resolve such conflicts in a scalable manner.
Following the Open Data trend, governments and public agencies have started making their data available to the public using web portals, web services or REST interfaces. Ideally, making this data available on the web would lead to more transparency, participation and innovation throughout society. However, just publishing the data on the web is not enough. To truly advance the open society, the publication platforms need to fulfill certain legal, administrative as well as technical requirements. In this paper we present a survey of existing Open Government Data platforms, focusing on the technical aspects. We studied over fifty Open Data repositories operated by national, regional and communal governments, as well as international organizations. Features such as standardization, discoverability and machine-readability of data were taken into account. Furthermore, a subset of five repositories was examined in more detail, additionally analyzing data and metadata quality. We introduce a number of aspects of openness in order to classify the surveyed repositories and asses the state of Open Data on the web. We point out shortcomings of the existing portals regarding reusability and sketch our vision of an improved Open Data repository. For detailed information about our Open Data survey please also visit the following
Following the Open Data trend, governments and public agencies have started making their data available on the Web and established platforms such as data.gov or data.un.org. These Open Data platforms provide a huge amount of data for various topics such as demographics, transport, finance or health in various data formats. One typical usage scenario for this kind of data is their integration into a database or data warehouse in order to apply data analytics. However, in today's business intelligence tools there is an evident lack of support for so-called situational or ad-hoc data integration. In this demonstration we will therefore present DrillBeyond, a novel database and information retrieval engine which allows users to query a local database as well as the Web of Open Data in a seamless and integrated way with standard SQL. The audience will be able to pose queries to our DrillBeyond system which will be answered partly from local data in the database and partly from datasets that originate from the Web of Data. We will show how such queries are divided into known and unknown parts and how missing attributes are mapped to open datasets. We will demonstrate the integration of the open datasets back into the DBMS in order to apply its analytical features.
Open data platforms such as data.gov or opendata.socrata. com provide a huge amount of valuable information. Their free-for-all nature, the lack of publishing standards and the multitude of domains and authors represented on these platforms lead to new integration and standardization problems. At the same time, crowd-based data integration techniques are emerging as new way of dealing with these problems. However, these methods still require input in form of specific questions or tasks that can be passed to the crowd. This paper discusses integration problems on Open Data Platforms, and proposes a method for identifying and ranking integration hypotheses in this context. We will evaluate our findings by conducting a comprehensive evaluation using on one of the largest Open Data platforms.
The increasing amount and variety of data available in the web leads to new possibilities in end-user focused data analysis. While the classic data base technologies for data integration and analysis (ETL and BI) are too complex for the needs of end users, newer technologies like web mashups are not optimal for data analysis. To make productive use of the data available on the web, end users need easy ways to find, join and visualize it. We propose a domain specific language (DSL) for querying a repository of heterogeneous web data. In contrast to query languages such as SQL, this DSL describes the visualization of the queried data in addition to the selection, filtering and aggregation of the data. The resulting data mashup can be made interactive by leaving parts of the query variable. We also describe an abstraction layer above this DSL that uses a recommendation-driven natural language interface to reduce the difficulty of creating queries in this DSL.
Government initiatives for more transparency and participation have lead to an increasing amount of structured data on the web in recent years. Many of these datasets have great potential. For example, a situational analysis and meaningful visualization of the data can assist in pointing out social or economic issues and raising people’s awareness. Unfortunately, the ad-hoc analysis of this so-called Open Data can prove very complex and time-consuming, partly due to a lack of efficient system support. On the one hand, search functionality is required to identify relevant datasets. Common document retrieval techniques used in web search, however, are not optimized for Open Data and do not address the semantic ambiguity inherent in it. On the other hand, semantic integration is necessary to perform analysis tasks across multiple datasets. To do so in an ad-hoc fashion, however, requires more flexibility and easier integration than most data integration systems provide. It is apparent that an optimal management system for Open Data must combine aspects from both classic approaches. In this article, we propose OPEN , a novel concept for the management and situational analysis of Open Data within a single system. In our approach, we extend a classic database management system, adding support for the identification and dynamic integration of public datasets. As most web users lack the experience and training required to formulate structured queries in a DBMS, we add support for non-expert users to our system, for example though keyword queries. Furthermore, we address the challenge of indexing Open Data.
Mapping complex metadata structures is crucial in a number of domains such as data integration, ontology alignment or model management. To speed up the generation of such mappings, automatic matching systems were developed to compute mapping suggestions that can be corrected by a user. However, constructing and tuning match strategies still requires a high manual effort by matching experts as well as correct mappings to evaluate generated mappings. We therefore propose a self-configuring schema matching system that is able to automatically adapt to the given mapping problem at hand. Our approach is based on analyzing the input schemas as well as intermediate matching results. A variety of matching rules use the analysis results to automatically construct and adapt an underlying matching process for a given match task. We comprehensively evaluate our approach on different mapping problems from the schema, ontology and model management domains. The evaluation shows that our system is able to robustly return good quality mappings across different mapping problems and domains.