Intertidal organisms are exposed to extreme and variable thermal conditions due to periodic aerial exposure by tides. For sessile species that cannot seek refuge, heat stress is strongly influenced by the timing of low tides, which in semidiurnal tidal systems is governed by the spring-neap tidal cycle. Here, we deployed biomimetic loggers, designed to replicate body temperature of the mussel Mytilus edulis, at two climatologically similar yet tidally distinct sites in Wales, UK, to examine how interactions between climate and tidal phasing regulate intertidal heat stress. Despite comparable weather conditions, South Wales mussels-exposed during midday spring low tides-experienced daily maximum body temperatures over 3 degrees C higher compared to North Wales, where exposure occurred during morning and evening spring low tides. Consequently, South Wales mussels exceed critical temperature thresholds more frequently. Based on the observations, we developed and validated a mussel body temperature model incorporating readily available tidal and climatic data, which accurately reproduced observed logger temperatures and successfully simulated a 2018 mass mortality event in the English Channel. Model experiments showed that tidal phasing can modulate 95th-percentile daily maxima by up to 5.5 degrees C, with midday spring low tides producing the warmest possible conditions. Long-term simulations (1990-2023) further revealed a 2 to 2.5-fold increase in extreme temperature exposure since 2020. These results demonstrate that tidal characteristics in semidiurnal systems can amplify or mitigate intertidal thermal stress as strongly as local climate, and that simple, process-based models can forecast heat exposure and ecological vulnerability under future climate change.
Understanding the effect of marine heatwaves on organisms is central for improving climate change predictions. Even moderate heatwave events are likely to drive performance of organisms especially if they are long relative to the life cycle duration. In ectotherms, such events will affect biological time on a stage-dependent basis; they could alter the timing of life cycle events (e.g. spawning, reproduction) and cause reproductive failure. We use a mathematical framework to explore three different scenarios for the causal relationship between temperature and developmental time and help future experimental research. Here, we highlight the need to experimentally test for (1) stage-dependent responses to temperature and (2) plastic responses to the thermal history. (3) Consider traits linked to developmental time (e.g. body size) and (4) integrate across levels of organization to develop stronger explanatory models. Experiments need to manipulate the timing, duration, and magnitude of warm events.
Marine protected area (MPA) networks are important for supporting biodiversity, enhancing ecosystem resilience, and facilitating species recovery. For the effectiveness of conservation and restoration, functional connectivity plays a vital role. The dispersal, movement, and successful establishment of organisms between suitable habitats and MPAs ensure long-term sustainability of the populations. Despite its importance, functional connectivity is rarely integrated into restoration planning, which limits the effectiveness of species reintroductions, habitat connectivity, and adaptation to environmental changes. In this study, we applied an integrative approach combining molecular detections (environmental DNA [eDNA] and meroplankton metabarcoding) with biophysical modeling to explore the functional connectivity between two Natura 2000 MPAs in the North Sea: Borkum Reef Ground (BRG) and Sylt Outer Reef (SOR). We focused on the European flat oyster (Ostrea edulis), a reef-building species that once provided vast reef habitats but is now functionally extinct in the German Bight and is therefore the subject of recent restoration measures at BRG. Our results showed partial but informative correspondence between molecular detections of oyster genetic traces and the modeled larval pathways during the June-July 2022 sampling period. We further explored larval dispersal across entire spawning seasons in 2022 and 2023. Connectivity between BRG and SOR was highly dependent on larval drift depth. Surface-drifting larvae showed strong interannual variability, with 3% reaching SOR in 2022 when northwesterly winds dominated, increasing to 22% in 2023 under westerly and southwesterly winds. Larvae drifting at depth, however, exhibited near-zero connectivity, leading to high self-recruitment rates, with over 25% settling near the original restoration sites. Our results demonstrate that wind-driven currents are a key driver of interannual variability in larval retention and dispersal. Additionally, they highlight the role of biological traits, such as vertical positioning and pelagic larval duration, in shaping connectivity between MPAs and oyster restoration sites. These findings emphasize the need to integrate connectivity assessments into MPA management and the restoration planning of reef-building benthic species. The interdisciplinary approach presented here provides a quantitative framework for assessing connectivity under species- and site-specific conditions, offering a transferable tool to evaluate the restoration potential of other species and enhance the functional network between MPAs.
In the context of global change, marine organisms are subjected not only to gradual changes in abiotic parameters, but also to an increasing number of extreme events, such as heatwaves. However, we still know little about the influence of heatwaves on the structure of marine communities, and experimental studies are needed to test the impact of heatwaves alone and in combination with other environmental drivers. Here, we conducted a mesocosm experiment to assess the potential impact of heatwaves on plankton communities, which we did under ambient and future environmental conditions. To simulate future environmental conditions, we simultaneously manipulated temperature and pH based on IPCC predictions for 2100, and dissolved N : P ratios based on the conditions expected in European coastal zones. While we did not observe any effects of simulated heatwaves on phytoplankton abundances, we identified that future environmental conditions may favor smaller phytoplankton species and that additional heatwaves may especially favor small phytoflagellates and coccolithophores. We also observed that future environmental conditions may reduce the abundances and modify the species composition of bacterioplankton, microzooplankton, and mesozooplankton, and that heatwaves may exacerbate these effects. Using a unique approach to examine the potential impacts of heatwaves under current and future environmental conditions on a natural multi‐trophic marine plankton community, we show that the combination of multiple global change drivers has the potential to perturb the entire basis of marine food webs.
In marine ecosystems, crustaceans face an alarming threat from the increasing frequency and intensity of marine heatwaves as their early planktonic stages are particularly temperature sensitive. While the impact of heatwaves on adult crustaceans is well-studied, their effects on larvae remain underexplored. This study focuses on heatwave effects on larvae of the European shore crab, Carcinus maenas. Through a factorial experiment, larvae were exposed to different heatwaves of varying onset timings, durations, and intensities. Survival, development duration, and dry mass decreased under intense heatwaves, with more severe effects observed when heatwaves occurred later in development, highlighting a stage-specific sensitivity to heatwave. We also identified a “region of existence” beyond which larval performance was compromised compared to baseline temperatures. This region defines the heatwave components considered “extreme” for the organism, as well as those inducing neutral or positive effects on performance. Additionally, we distinguished heatwave effects (characterised by their components) from those attributed to the average temperature experienced during the experiments. Our findings demonstrated that larval performance was lower during intense heatwaves compared to the performance expected under a constant average temperature. These findings emphasize the importance of considering heatwave timing relative to the life cycle for predicting marine population responses to climate change.
AimThis study sets out to understand the variability in larval traits of dispersive life stages of a famous invader, the European shore crab Carcinus maenas, in its native distribution range.LocationNorth East Atlantic coast from the Norwegian Arctic to the southern European distribution limit of C. maenas in Southern Spain.TaxonEuropean shore crab Carcinus maenas (Crustacea, Decapoda).MethodsWe quantified latitudinal patterns in larval body mass, elemental composition (C and N content), and thermal tolerance of the first larval stage. We collected crabs from four populations spanning 25 degrees of latitude (Vigo in Northern Spain; Bergen, Trondheim, and Bod & oslash; in Norway) and reanalysed published and unpublished data of body mass and elemental composition of additional populations from Germany, Wales, France, and Southern Spain. Furthermore, we used two laboratory experiments to test the thermal tolerance limits of the first larval stage from Vigo and the Norwegian populations. In the first experiment, we reared larvae from hatching to Zoea II at seven temperatures (9 degrees C-27 degrees C) and from hatching to LT50 at 6 degrees C. In the second experiment, we exposed freshly hatched larvae acutely to increasing or decreasing temperatures (up to 40 degrees C and down to 3 degrees C).ResultsAcross the entire European range, we found a substantial increase in dry mass and carbon and nitrogen content of freshly hatched larvae with latitude. Norwegian populations exhibited higher survival at 9 degrees C than the Vigo population. Furthermore, LT50 at 6 degrees C increased from South to North. All populations showed high survival in the range 12 degrees C-24 degrees C but low survival at 27 degrees C.Main ConclusionsLarval tolerance quantified by using survival to Zoea II is not clearly related to the tolerance quantified with the acute experiments, indicating that each method assesses different aspects of thermal tolerance. Tolerance to low temperature correlated positively to tolerance to high temperature, suggesting that variation among females in larval responses reflects a general physiological quality rather than trade-offs. We provide evidence for potentially adaptive variations in larval body mass and thermal tolerance across a latitudinal gradient for C. maenas.
In marine species with complex life cycles, thermal tolerance is usually narrower in larvae than in adults. Hence, range contraction and expansion, as a consequence of climate change, may be enhanced or hampered by among-population variability in the thermal tolerance of larval stages. We quantified the performance (i.e., survival, development, and growth) of larvae of the shore crab Carcinus maenas at different temperatures (range 9°C to 27°C in steps of 3°C) in populations located towards the limits of the European distribution range (South: Vigo, Spain; North: Bergen and Trondheim, Norway). We hypothesised that, given the geographical distance, larvae from northern populations would show increased tolerance to low temperatures while those from southern populations would show increased tolerance to high temperatures. Such patterns would enhance poleward range expansion and counteract contraction as compared with a scenario where thermal tolerance does not change along the latitudinal gradient. Populations from southern Europe (Spain) showed slightly increased survival at higher temperatures compared to those further north and in invasive North American populations. However, there was little variation in larval tolerance between populations of Northern Spain and Norway: survival and growth rates were low at temperatures 9°C and 27°C. Larvae from the northernmost European populations (Norway) showed significantly shorter duration of development at low temperatures, which might have an adaptive value, contingent on the actual pattern of temperatures experienced during the larval phase. Further range expansions (or contractions) are likely to be driven solely by increasing temperatures unless populations located right at the range limit show increased tolerance to low (or high) temperatures.
Rocky shore communities are shaped by complex interactions among environmental drivers and a range of biological processes. Here, we investigated the importance of abiotic and biotic drivers on the population structure of key rocky intertidal species at 62 sites, spanning 50% of the Brazilian rocky shoreline (i.e., 500 km). Large-scale population patterns were generally explained by differences in ocean temperature and wave exposure. For the gastropod species Lottia subrugosa, differences at smaller scales (i.e., 0.1-1 km) were better explained by other abiotic influences such as freshwater discharge and substrate roughness. Based on the general population patterns of intertidal species identified, three main oceanographic groups were observed: a coldoligotrophic grouping at northern sites (Lakes sub-region), a eutrophic group associated with large estuaries and urban zones (Santos and Guanabara bays); and a transitional warm-water group found between the two more productive areas. Larger individuals of Stramonita brasiliensis, L. subrugosa and Echinolittorina lineolata were generally found in the cold-oligotrophic system (i.e., upwelling region), while small suspension feeders dominate the warm-eutrophic systems. Evidence of bottom-up regulation was not observed, and top-down regulation effects were only observed between the whelk S. brasiliensis and its mussel prey Perna perna. Environmental drivers as compared to biotic interactions, therefore, play a key role determining the population structure of multiple intertidal species, across a range of spatial scales along the SW Atlantic shores.
We studied the potential of a recently introduced species, the Asian brush-clawed crab ( Hemigrapsus takanoi ), to expand its distribution range further into the Baltic Sea. H. takanoi has been documented in the southwestern Baltic Sea since 2014. The ability to persist and further expand into the Baltic Proper will depend on their potential to sustain all stages of their complex life cycle, including pelagic larvae, under the Baltic Sea's conditions. Range limits may be established by the tolerance to low salinity, which in addition may be affected by water temperature. A key question is whether local populations at the distribution limit (within the Baltic Sea) show increased tolerance to low salinities and hence promote further expansion. We quantified the combined effects of salinity (10–33 PSU) and temperature (15–24 °C) on larval development in four populations of H. takanoi (two from the Baltic and two from the North Sea). We found substantial differences in larval performance between the populations from the Baltic and North Seas. Larvae from the North Sea populations always showed higher survival and faster development compared with those from the Baltic Sea. Only weak evidence of elevated tolerance towards low salinity was found in the larvae from the Baltic Sea populations. In addition, larvae from the population located near the range limit showed very low survival under all tested salinity-temperature combinations and no evidence of increased tolerance to low salinity. There was no apparent genetic differentiation among the studied populations in the mitochondrial cytochrome c oxidase subunit one gene (COI) implying high connectivity among the populations. In conclusion, the weak evidence of low salinity tolerance in Baltic Sea populations, and poor larval performance for the population located near the range limit, coupled with limited genetic differentiation suggest that subsidies are needed for populations to persist near the range limit. Alternatively, ontogenetic migrations would be required to sustain those populations. Monitoring efforts are needed to elucidate the underlaying mechanisms and document potential future range expansions.
Marine heatwaves (MHWs) are extreme weather events that have major impacts on the structure and functioning of marine ecosystems worldwide. Due to anthropogenic climate change, the occurrence of MHWs is predicted to increase in future. There is already evidence linking MHWs with reductions in biodiversity and incidence of mass mortality events in coastal ecosystems. However, because MHWs are unpredictable, the quantification of their effects on communities is challenging. Here, we use the Helgoland Roads long-term time series (German Bight, North Sea), one of the richest marine time series in the world, and implement a modified before-after control-impact (BACI) design to evaluate MHW effect on mesozooplankton communities. Mesozooplankton play an essential role in connecting primary producers to higher trophic levels, and any changes in their community structure could have far-reaching impacts on the entire ecosystem. The responses of mesozooplankton community to MHWs in terms of community structure and densities occurred mainly in spring and autumn. Abundances of seven taxa, including some of the most abundant groups (e.g. copepods), were affected either positively or negatively in response to MHWs. In contrast, we observed no clear evidence of an impact of summer and winter MHWs; instead, the density of the most common taxa remained unchanged. Our results highlight the seasonally dependent impacts of MHWs on mesozooplankton communities and the challenges in evaluating those impacts. Long-term monitoring is an important contributor to the quantification of effects of MHWs on natural populations.
Leptodius exaratus (H. Milne Edwards, 1834) is an exploited species that has been used as bait for recreational fishing in Kuwait. The biological and ecological aspects of the species required to manage this practice are limited. We investigated the life history and population ecology of L. exaratus in the northwestern Arabian (Persian) Gulf. The spawning season of the crab in Kuwait starts in the late spring and continues through the summer and ends in September. Fecundity is highly correlated to female body size and ranges 2,533–11,991 eggs clutch–1, with a mean number of 7,055 eggs clutch–1. Juveniles are generally recruited between July and September, with lower minor recruitment levels occurring in October and November. Growth is highly seasonal, being slow during the cold season (October-February) and high during the warmer season (March and September), with a higher growth rate in males than in females. The seasonality of growth and reproduction of L. exaratus in the region is strongly related to ambient air and water temperatures. Sexual dimorphism is highly significant between males and females with males, reaching reproductive maturity at 17.43 ± 0.53 mm carapace width (CW) and females at 9.58 ± 1.21 mm CW. The overall sex ratio for the species is 0.8:1 (males:females). Furthermore, the life span of 3–4 yr and an overall mortality slightly higher in males than in females. The results of our study could be used to determine fishery management strategies such as minimum catch sizes and closures periods. The results on life history and dynamics of the complex life cycle of L. exaratus contribute to conservation and sustainable exploitation of the species in Kuwait.
Abstract Leptodius exaratus (H. Milne Edwards, 1834) is an exploited species that has been used as bait for recreational fishing in Kuwait. The biological and ecological aspects of the species required to manage this practice are limited. We investigated the life history and population ecology of L. exaratus in the northwestern Arabian (Persian) Gulf. The spawning season of the crab in Kuwait starts in the late spring and continues through the summer and ends in September. Fecundity is highly correlated to female body size and ranges 2,533–11,991 eggs clutch–1, with a mean number of 7,055 eggs clutch–1. Juveniles are generally recruited between July and September, with lower minor recruitment levels occurring in October and November. Growth is highly seasonal, being slow during the cold season (October-February) and high during the warmer season (March and September), with a higher growth rate in males than in females. The seasonality of growth and reproduction of L. exaratus in the region is strongly related to ambient air and water temperatures. Sexual dimorphism is highly significant between males and females with males, reaching reproductive maturity at 17.43 ± 0.53 mm carapace width (CW) and females at 9.58 ± 1.21 mm CW. The overall sex ratio for the species is 0.8:1 (males:females). Furthermore, the life span of 3–4 yr and an overall mortality slightly higher in males than in females. The results of our study could be used to determine fishery management strategies such as minimum catch sizes and closures periods. The results on life history and dynamics of the complex life cycle of L. exaratus contribute to conservation and sustainable exploitation of the species in Kuwait.
Marine species with a pelagic larval phase have the potential to disperse hundreds of kilometres via ocean currents, thus connecting geographically distinct populations. Connectivity between populations therefore plays a central role in population dynamics, genetic diversity and resilience to exploitation or decline and can be an important vector in the management of fisheries. The scallop, Pecten maximus, is a valuable benthic bivalve with a variety of management measures at both regional and national scales. A bio-physical numerical model was developed to simulate and characterise the larval transport and population connectivity of scallops across commercial fishing grounds within the Irish and Celtic Seas. The model incorporated realistic oceanographic currents and known behavioural traits of P. maximus larvae including spawning times, pelagic larval duration, and vertical migration during the various developmental stages i.e., passive, active swimming, vertical migrations, since growth rates change with temperature, which varies spatially and temporally, it was used in the model to determine when an individual larva changed its behaviour. Simulations showed a high degree of connectivity between most populations, with multiple connections allowing for substantial exchanges of larvae. The exception was a population off North Cornwall that was entirely reliant on self-recruitment. A sensitivity analysis of the biological parameters suggested that ocean current patterns primarily controlled the connectivity network, but the strength of the connections was sensitive to spawning date and the specific features of diel vertical migrations. The model identified weakly connected populations that could be vulnerable to overfishing, and populations that are ‘strong connectors’ and a vital source of larvae to maintain the metapopulation. Our approach highlights the benefits of characterising population connectivity as part of an effective management strategy for sustainable fisheries.
We examined the taxonomical and functional traits of free-living nematodes, focusing on their density by genus, maturity index (MI), and trophic diversity index (ITD) to determine whether these indices are sensitive to changes in the organic content of the sediment. Samples were collected in autumn and spring from 12 subtidal sampling stations in Rocha Lagoon, distributed between the outer (near the mouth) and the inner sector. We identified 26 genera, with higher abundance in the inner sector, likely due to increased organic matter and biopolymers. In spring, both sectors had sediments rich in fresh organic matter, dominated by deposit-feeding nematodes and showing low trophic diversity (high ITD values). In autumn, the inner sector maintained similar characteristics to spring sampling, while the outer one was dominated by older organic matter, predatory nematodes and higher trophic diversity. The MI showed low variation between sectors, suggesting a disturbed environment. Our findings support the use of ITD to assess other aspects of communities such as the response of trophic groups to the freshness of organic matter, while the MI seems less effective for assessing the ecological status of Rocha Lagoon. Understanding nematode biodiversity and functional traits is crucial for effective ecological quality assessments.
Geometric morphometrics offer various methods that are often used in the analysis of fossil specimens, due to the specimen's morphological nature. One of these methods, outline analysis, can be applied to compare the shape of specimens in various contexts. Here, we use outline analysis to investigate the developmental stages of fossil specimens. We use the extant European shore crab to test a pipeline where elliptic Fourier analysis and discriminant function analysis are used to provide an objective interpretation of a specimens' developmental stage. We then test the pipeline, using a case of a recently redescribed juvenile fossil crab (Liocarcinus oligocenicus). We find, that in data sets without phylogenetic variation, this pipeline works well in identifying developmental stages. However, it is less efficient when data sets increase in noise. Furthermore, Carcinus maenas expresses a clear morphological separation between juveniles and adults.
Leptodius exaratus (H. Milne Edwards, 1834) is an exploited species that has been used as bait for recreational fishing in Kuwait. The biological and ecological aspects of the species required to manage this practice are limited. We investigated the life history and population ecology of L. exaratus in the northwestern Arabian (Persian) Gulf. The spawning season of the crab in Kuwait starts in the late spring and continues through the summer and ends in September. Fecundity is highly correlated to female body size and ranges 2,533-11,991 eggs clutch-1, with a mean number of 7,055 eggs clutch-1. Juveniles are generally recruited between July and September, with lower minor recruitment levels occurring in October and November. Growth is highly seasonal, being slow during the cold season (October-February) and high during the warmer season (March and September), with a higher growth rate in males than in females. The seasonality of growth and reproduction of L. exaratus in the region is strongly related to ambient air and water temperatures. Sexual dimorphism is highly significant between males and females with males, reaching reproductive maturity at 17.43 +/- 0.53 mm carapace width (CW) and females at 9.58 +/- 1.21 mm CW. The overall sex ratio for the species is 0.8:1 (males:females). Furthermore, the life span of 3-4 yr and an overall mortality slightly higher in males than in females. The results of our study could be used to determine fishery management strategies such as minimum catch sizes and closures periods. The results on life history and dynamics of the complex life cycle of L. exaratus contribute to conservation and sustainable exploitation of the species in Kuwait.
AbstractMost ecological studies attempting to understand causes of population dynamics and community structure disregard intraspecific trait variation. We quantified the importance of natural intra‐cohort variation in body size and density of juveniles for recruitment of a sessile marine organism, the barnacle Semibalanus balanoides. Barnacles are representative of species organised in metapopulations, that is, as open local populations connected by larval dispersal. We tracked the individual growth and survival of a cohort of juvenile barnacles from two shores of North Wales. Barnacles settled as larvae in spring of 2002 on previously cleared rock. The density of these new recruits was experimentally manipulated in June and randomly selected individuals were monitored from June to October to evaluate the role of barnacle size and density in predicting survival. In doing so we characterised density at three spatial scales (quadrat: 25 cm2, cells within quadrats: 25 mm2 and neighbourhood: number of neighbours in physical contact with the target barnacle). At all scales, variations in juvenile body size exacerbated the effect of density‐dependent mortality on population size. While density‐dependent mortality was very intense in the small‐sized individuals, large‐sized individuals experienced very weak density‐dependent mortality and showed high survival rates. Using the concept of ‘Jensen inequality’, we show that important biases in estimations of survival, based on population size only, occur at high barnacle densities, where survival is low. Our study highlights the role of body size variation in understanding dynamics of open populations.
Biological monitoring of planktonic animals is greatly dependent on the deployment of traps.A variety of specialized traps have been designed for surface plankton and vertebrates. However, certain groups, such as planktonic larvae of benthic marine invertebrates remain underrepresented in sampling efforts. Catching them has proven to be more challenging because of their size, swimming ability, location, and abundance. In the present study a successful light trap for sampling American lobster larvae in New Brunswick, Canada, is evaluated on the island of Helgoland (German Bight, North Sea). Our results showed the traps were successful in catching larvae in laboratory experiments but were unable to catch European lobster larvae in the field. Traps deployed in the field were successful in capturing other benthic and pelagic zooplankton predominantly consisting of crustaceans from the orders: Cumacea, Amphipoda, Mysida and Isopoda. The low density of lobster larvae, the island's topography, and their unique photactic response possibly limited the success rate of the light traps. Future research is needed to construct a specialized trap to sample Helgoland's lobster larvae and provide information on the current larval fitness and population numbers.
Marine heatwaves and other extreme temperature events can drive biological responses, including mass mortality. However, their effects depend on how they are experienced by biological systems (including human societies). We applied two different baselines (fixed and shifting) to a time series of North Sea water temperature to explore how slowly vs. quickly adapting systems would experience extreme temperatures. We tested if the properties of marine heatwaves and the association with atmospheric heatwaves were robust to a change in baseline. A fixed baseline produced an increase in the frequency and duration of marine heatwaves, which would be experienced as the new normal by slowly adapting systems; 7 of the 10 most severe heatwaves occurred between 1990 and 2018. The shifting baseline removed the trend in the frequency but not duration of heatwaves; the 1990s appeared as a period of change in the frequency of strong and severe heatwaves as compared to the 1980s. There were also common patterns among baselines: marine heatwaves were more frequent in late summer when temperatures peak; temperature variability was characterized by low frequency, large amplitude fluctuations (i.e., as red noise), known to drive extinction events. In addition, marine heatwaves occurred during or just after atmospheric heatwaves. Our work highlights the importance of identifying properties of marine heatwaves that are robust or contingent on a change in baseline.
The Asian shore crab Hemigrapsus sanguineus has become invasive in North Europe and it co-occurs and competes with the native European shore crab Carcinus maenas . Both species develop through a feeding and dispersive larval phase characterised by several zoeal and a settling megalopa stage. Larvae of marine crabs are vulnerable to food limitation and warming has the potential to exacerbate the negative effects of food limitation on survival and growth. We quantified the combined effects of temperature and food limitation on larval performance (survival and growth) of H. sanguineus and we compared our results with those reported on performance of C. maenas larvae, under the same experimental design and methodology. Larvae from four females of H. sanguineus collected on Helgoland (North Sea) were experimentally reared from hatching to megalopa, at four temperatures (range 15–24 °C) and two food conditions (permanent vs. daily limited access to food). Larval survival of H. sanguineus was low at 15 °C and increased with temperature, in contrast to the high survival reported for C. maenas larvae in the range 15–24 °C. Food limitation reduced survival and body mass of H. sanguineus larvae at all temperatures, but without evidence of the exacerbating effect caused by high temperatures and reported for C. maenas . By contrast, high temperature (24 °C) mitigated the negative effect of food limitation on body mass on H. sanguineus larvae. Advantages of H. sanguineus over C. maenas appear especially under the increased temperatures expected from climate change.