Background The Ehlers-Danlos syndromes (EDS) are a paradigm group of rare heritable connective tissue disorders caused by pathogenic defects in genes involved in biosynthesis, fibrillogenesis, and/or supramolecular organization of collagen fibrils in the extracellular matrix (ECM). Joint hypermobility, skin hyperextensibility, abnormal wound healing and easy bruising are among the cardinal clinical features. The classical EDS type, caused by caused by defects in type V or rarely type I collagen, is the most prevalent genetically elucidated EDS type [1].(Chronic) pain is highly prevalent in individuals with EDS and is one of the foremost reasons these individuals seek medical attention. There is a high use of analgesics, surgery, and physical therapy but these treatment modalities often bring only modest relief at best, and some are associated with unwanted side effects. Few studies, almost exclusively conducted in the molecularly unexplained hypermobile EDS type, have brought limited evidence for neuropathic pain and decreased intra-epidermal nerve fiber density. Interestingly, functional and structural abnormalities of the nervous system and associated pain-related behaviors have also been described in mouse models of EDS [2]. Comprehensive human studies on pain prevalence and pain mechanisms in molecularly solved EDS types are however currently not available, thereby representing a major gap in the study of pain in EDS. Objectives The primary aim of this cross-sectional study was to identify the sensory profile of individuals with cEDS. Secondly, we aimed to identify the pain characteristics and the emotional-cognitive burden in cEDS. Methods Nineteen individuals with molecularly confirmed cEDS and 19 healthy matched control were recruited. Sensory profiling included sensitivity to innocuous and noxious stimuli of multiple modalities (electrical, thermal, vibration, touch, pressure) and a parallel and sequential conditioned pain modulation protocol. Moreover, pain characteristics and emotional-cognitive factors that are known to influence pain processing were studied using a set of validated questionnaires (PD-Q, DN4, HADS, HAQ, SF-36, CSI, PVAQ, TAMPA scale). Results: The cEDS cohort showed an altered sensory profile. Higher (p=0.04) detection thresholds for vibration stimuli at the lower limb were found indicating the presence of hypoesthesia. Reduced/altered thermal sensitivity was found with significantly more (p<0.001) paradoxical thermal sensations at the lower limb (usually to heat). Lower pain thresholds were found to mechanical (p<0.001) stimuli at both the upper and lower limbs and to cold (p=0.005) stimulation at the lower limb indicating hyperalgesia.Using a parallel conditioned pain paradigm, significantly (p=0.005 and p=0.046) smaller antinociceptive responses were shown in cEDS suggestive of impaired central pain inhibition. Conclusion This study represents the first systematic investigation of pain in a genetically defined EDS type. With evidence for sensory changes and impaired pain modulation in cEDS, we provide new insights on the possible role of the ECM in the development and persistence of pain. References [1] Malfait et al. Am J Med Genet C Semin Med Genet 2021;187(4):429-445.[2] Malfait et al. Nat. Rev. Dis. Primers 2020;6(1):64. Acknowledgements: NIL. Disclosure of Interests None Declared.Table 1.cEDS cohort compared to control groupPain+Emotional burden(+)Detection thresholdsElectrical=Thermal=Vibration+Touch=Paradoxical thermal sensations+Pain thresholdsElectrical=Cold-Heat=Pressure-Conditioned pain modulation-+/-: statistically significant differences; = non-significant
Pain is one of the most important, yet poorly understood complaints in heritable connective tissue disorders (HCTD) caused by monogenic defects in extracellular matrix molecules. This is particularly the case for Ehlers-Danlos syndromes (EDS), paradigm collagen-related disorders. This study aimed to identify the pain signature and somatosensory characteristics in the rare classical type of EDS (cEDS) caused by defects in type V or rarely type I collagen. We used static and dynamic quantitative sensory testing and validated questionnaires in 19 individuals with cEDS and 19 matched controls. Individuals with cEDS reported clinically relevant pain/discomfort (VAS ≥5/10 in 32% for average pain intensity the past month) and worse health -related quality of life. Altered sensory profile was found in the cEDS group with higher (p=0.04) detection thresholds for vibration stimuli at the lower limb indicating hypoesthesia, reduced thermal sensitivity with more (p<0.001) paradoxical thermal sensations, and hyperalgesia with lower pain thresholds to mechanical (p<0.001) stimuli at both the upper and lower limbs and to cold (p=0.005) stimulation at the lower limb. Using a parallel conditioned pain paradigm, the cEDS group showed significantly smaller antinociceptive responses (p-value between 0.005 and 0.046) suggestive of impaired endogenous central pain modulation. In conclusion, Individuals with cEDS report chronic pain and worse health-related quality of life, and present altered somatosensory perception. This study is the first to systematically investigate pain and somatosensory characteristics in a genetically defined HCTD and provides interesting insights on the possible role of the ECM in the development and persistence of pain.
The vast majority of reported (likely) pathogenic missense variants in the genes coding for the fibrillar collagens leads to the substitution of one of the obligatory glycine residues in the Gly-Xaa-Yaa repeat sequence of the triple helical domain. Their phenotypic consequences and deleterious effects have been well-documented. However, with increasing access to molecular diagnostic testing based on next-generation sequencing techniques, such as sequencing of multi-gene panels and whole-exome sequencing, non-glycine substitutions are more frequently identified in individuals suspected to have a heritable collagen disorder, but their pathogenic effect is often difficult to predict.Some specific non-glycine substitutions in the proα1(I)- (p.(Arg312Cys)) and proα1(III)- (glutamic acid to lysine at different positions) collagen chain have been identified in a number of individuals presenting a phenotype showing features of both classical and vascular Ehlers-Danlos syndrome. The number of reported individuals with these defects is currently very low, and several of these non-glycine substitutions had initially been categorised as variants of unknown significance (VUS), complicating early diagnosis, accurate counselling, management guidelines, and correct classification. This collaborative study reports on the phenotype of 22 and 7 individuals harbouring these rare variants in COL1A1 and COL3A1, respectively, expanding our knowledge on clinical presentation, phenotypic variability, and natural history, and informing on the risk for potentially life-threatening events, such as vascular, gastro-intestinal, and pregnancy-related complications.
The Ehlers-Danlos syndromes (EDS) are a heterogeneous group of heritable connective tissue diseases. The autosomal recessive kyphoscoliotic EDS results from deficiency of either lysyl hydroxylase 1 (encoded by PLOD1), crucial for collagen cross-linking; or the peptidyl-prolyl cis-trans isomerase family FK506-binding protein 22 kDa (FKBP22 encoded by FKBP14), a molecular chaperone of types III, IV, VI, and X collagen. This study reports the clinical manifestations of three probands with homozygous pathogenic FKBP14 variants, including the previously reported c.362dupC; p.(Glu122Argfs*7) variant, a novel missense variant (c.587A>G; p.(Asp196Gly)) and a start codon variant (c.2T>G; p.?). Consistent clinical features in the hitherto reported individuals (n = 40) are kyphoscoliosis, generalized joint hypermobility and congenital muscle hypotonia. Severe vascular complications have been observed in 12.5%. A previously unreported feature is microcornea observed in two probands reported here. Both the c.587A>G and the c.362dupC variant cause complete loss of FKBP22. With immunocytochemistry on dermal fibroblasts, we provide the first evidence for intracellular retention of types III and VI collagen in EDS-FKBP14. Scratch wound assays were largely normal. Western blot of proteins involved in the unfolded protein response and autophagy did not reveal significant upregulation in dermal fibroblasts.
The hypermobile type of Ehlers-Danlos syndrome (hEDS) is a heritable connective tissue disorder, associated with joint hypermobility and prominent chronic pain. Because experimental pain testing in hEDS is scarce, the underlying mechanisms are still poorly understood.The present study assesses endogenous pain facilitation and pain inhibition in hEDS, using a protocol for temporal summation of pain (TSP), conditioned pain modulation (CPM) and exercise-induced hypoalgesia (EIH).Twenty women with hEDS and 20 age-matched healthy controls participated. After evaluating thermal and mechanical pain thresholds (PPT), TSP was assessed using 10 repetitive painful pressure stimuli. CPM was provoked using pressure as the test stimulus and hand immersion in hot water (46°) as the conditioning stimulus. EIH was assessed after a submaximal cycling protocol.The hEDS group demonstrated reduced PPTs and showed significantly more TSP after repeated painful stimuli than the control group. In comparison to the healthy control group, the hEDS group demonstrated significantly less EIH at the quadriceps test location. At the trapezius, EIH did not significantly differ between groups. No significant differences were found between the hEDS group and control group in the CPM response.The results demonstrate increased TSP in hEDS, suggesting increased central pain facilitation. EIH should be studied more extensively but may be disturbed when evaluated in the muscles that are activated during exercise. The CPM results are inconclusive and require more research.Studies regarding the mechanisms that underlie pain in hEDS are scarce, although it is the most prevalent and disabling symptom in this patient population. This study demonstrates increased temporal summation in hEDS and suggests that exercise-induced hypoalgesia may be reduced. Because exercise is a cornerstone in the multidisciplinary treatment of heritable connective tissue disorders, gaining knowledge in this field is important. Pressure stimuli were used to facilitate the international usability of the protocols, allowing for future data acquisition in large cohorts.
The Ehlers–Danlos syndromes are a group of multisystemic heritable connective tissue disorders with clinical presentations that range from multiple congenital malformations, over adolescent-onset debilitating or even life-threatening complications of connective tissue fragility, to mild conditions that remain undiagnosed in adulthood. To date, thirteen different EDS types have been recognized, stemming from genetic defects in 20 different genes. While initial biochemical and molecular analyses mainly discovered defects in genes coding for the fibrillar collagens type I, III and V or their modifying enzymes, recent discoveries have linked EDS to defects in non-collagenous matrix glycoproteins, in proteoglycan biosynthesis and in the complement pathway. This genetic heterogeneity explains the important clinical heterogeneity among and within the different EDS types. Generalized joint hypermobility and skin hyperextensibility with cutaneous fragility, atrophic scarring and easy bruising are defining manifestations of EDS; however, other signs and symptoms of connective tissue fragility, such as complications of vascular and internal organ fragility, orocraniofacial abnormalities, neuromuscular involvement and ophthalmological complications are variably present in the different types of EDS. These features may help to differentiate between the different EDS types but also evoke a wide differential diagnosis, including different inborn errors of metabolism. In this narrative review, we will discuss the clinical presentation of EDS within the context of inborn errors of metabolism, give a brief overview of their underlying genetic defects and pathophysiological mechanisms and provide a guide for the diagnostic approach.
The Ehlers–Danlos Syndromes (EDS) comprise a clinically and genetically heterogeneous group of complex hereditary disorders of connective tissue, with common features including joint hypermobility, soft and hyperextensible skin, abnormal wound healing, easy bruising, and signs of generalized connective tissue friability. Initial ultrastructural studies suggested that the abnormalities underlying EDS affected the collagen “wickerwork” of the connective tissue, and early biochemical and genetic studies identified defects in fibrillar types I, III, and V collagen, and in enzymes involved in their posttranslational modification, lysyl hydroxylase 1 and the procollagen amino-proteinase ADAMTS2. More recent discoveries have implicated a range of other, diverse extracellular matrix (ECM) molecules in the physiopathology of EDS, including the glycoprotein tenascin X, the FACIT type XII collagen, the intracellular chaperone and peptidylprolyl isomerase FKBP22, enzymes involved in glycosaminoglycan biosynthesis (D4ST1, DS-epi1, galactosyltransferase I and II), an intracellular zinc transporter ZIP13, (putative) transcription factors ZNF469 and PRDM5, factors involved in the classical complement pathway (C1r and C1s), and most recently, the ECM molecule AEBP1 that is involved in collagen polymerization. In this chapter, we give an overview of the different types of EDS and describe how the identification of their molecular underpinnings, and the study of pathophysiologic consequences of these defects in humans and in cellular and mouse models have provided key insights into the complex pathways of collagen fibrillogenesis and supramolecular organization of the collagen fibrils in the ECM.
Chronic pain is one of the most common, yet poorly studied, complaints in people suffering from Ehlers-Danlos syndromes (EDS). This heterogeneous group of heritable connective tissue disorders is typically characterized by skin hyperextensibility, joint hypermobility, and generalized connective tissue fragility. Most EDS types are caused by genetic defects that affect connective tissue biosynthesis, thereby compromising collagen biosynthesis or fibrillogenesis and resulting in a disorganized extracellular matrix. Even though chronic pain is a major source of disability, functional impairment, and psychosocial suffering in EDS, currently used analgesics and other treatment strategies provide inadequate pain relief and thus represents an important unmet medical need. An important contributor to this is the lack of knowledge about the underlying mechanisms. In this narrative review, we summarize the current understanding of pain and the associated mechanisms in EDS based on clinical studies focusing on questionnaires and experimental pain testing as well as studies in animal models of EDS. In addition, we highlight the challenges, gaps, and opportunities in EDS-pain research.
Classical Ehlers-Danlos syndrome (cEDS) is a heritable connective tissue disorder mainly caused by pathogenic variants in COL5A1 or COL5A2, encoding type V collagen. Its diagnosis, based on clinical criteria and molecular confirmation, can be challenging. We report the molecular and clinical characteristics of 168 probands (72 clinically evaluated at our center) and 65 relatives with a clinical presentation of cEDS. Type V collagen defects were found in 145 probands, 121 (83.5%) were located in COL5A1 and 24 (16.5%) in COL5A2. Although 85.6% of molecularly confirmed patients presented the two major clinical criteria (generalized joint hypermobility, hyperextensible skin with atrophic scarring), significant inter- and intrafamilial phenotypic variability was noted. COL5A2 variants often caused a more severe phenotype. Vascular complications were rare in individuals with type V collagen defects (1.4%). Among the 72 probands clinically evaluated in our center, the mutation detection rate was 82.0%. The majority (68.1%) harbored COL5A1/COL5A2 defects. Yet, 13.9% harbored a defect in another gene (COL1A1, PLOD1, TNXB, AEBP1) highlighting important clinical overlap and the need for molecular confirmation of the diagnosis as this has implications regarding follow-up and genetic counseling. Eighteen percent of the 72 probands remained molecularly unexplained and a COL5A1 variant of unknown significance was identified in 6.9%.
BackgroundProteoglycans are large and structurally complex macromolecules which can be found in abundancy in the extracellular matrix and on the surface of all animal cells. Mutations in the genes encoding the enzymes responsible for the formation of the tetrasaccharide linker region between the proteoglycan core protein and the glycosaminoglycan side chains lead to a spectrum of severe and overlapping autosomal recessive connective tissue disorders, collectively coined the glycosaminoglycan linkeropathies'.ResultsWe report the clinical findings of two novel patients with a complex linkeropathy due to biallelic mutations in B3GAT3, the gene that encodes glucuronosyltransferase I, which catalyzes the addition of the ultimate saccharide to the linker region. We identified a previously reported c.667G>A missense mutation and an unreported homozygous c.416C>T missense mutation. We also performed a genotype and phenotype-oriented literature overview of all hitherto reported patients harbouring B3GAT3 mutations. A total of 23 patients from 10 families harbouring bi-allelic mutations and one patient with a heterozygeous splice-site mutation in B3GAT3 have been reported. They all display a complex phenotype characterized by consistent presence of skeletal dysplasia (including short stature, kyphosis, scoliosis and deformity of the long bones), facial dysmorphology, and spatulate distal phalanges. More variably present are cardiac defects, joint hypermobility, joint dislocations/contractures and fractures. Seven different B3GAT3 mutations have been reported, and although the number of patients is still limited, some phenotype-genotype correlations start to emerge. The more severe phenotypes seem to have mutations located in the substrate acceptor subdomain of the catalytic domain of the glucuronosyltransferase I protein while more mildly affected phenotypes seem to have mutations in the NTP-sugar donor substrate binding subdomain.ConclusionsLoss-of-function mutations in B3GAT3 are associated with a complex connective tissue phenotype characterized by disproportionate short stature, skeletal dysplasia, facial dysmorphism, spatulate distal phalanges and -to a lesser extent- joint contractures, joint hypermobility with dislocations, cardiac defects and bone fragility. Based on the limited number of reported patients, some genotype-phenotype correlations start to emerge.