Fish stocks face both anthropogenic and environmental pressures, which can drastically reduce population sizes and threaten species' survival. While some species can persist and recover from such disturbances, others require careful management to prevent collapse. We introduce a new, biologically intuitive, measure of persistence, the number of eggs produced by an individual fish over its lifetime (NEL) under a harvest policy. Additionally, we demonstrate the relationship between NEL and other candidate indices such as the inherent net reproductive rate, biomass, number of spawners, and dominant eigenvalue of the Jacobian. We show that, NEL inherits a desirable monotonicity property with respect to harvest survival probabilities. That is, NEL (persistence) is higher when survival is higher. If persistence were measured by the dominant eigenvalue of the Jacobian, we show that this property is violated. Hence, NEL offers a valuable and easily computable index for managers to assess persistence under alternative harvest policies.
Mathematical and statistical models underlie many of the world's most important fisheries management decisions. Since the 19th century, difficulty calibrating and fitting such models has been used to justify the selection of simple, stationary, single-species models to aid tactical fisheries management decisions. Whereas these justifications are reasonable, it is imperative that we quantify the value of different levels of model complexity for supporting fisheries management, especially given a changing climate, where old methodologies may no longer perform as well as in the past. Here we argue that cost-benefit analysis is an ideal lens to assess the value of model complexity in fisheries management. While some studies have reported the benefits of model complexity in fisheries, modeling costs are rarely considered. In the absence of cost data in the literature, we report, as a starting point, relative costs of single-species stock assessment and marine ecosystem models from two Australian organizations. We found that costs varied by two orders of magnitude, and that ecosystem model costs increased with model complexity. Using these costs, we walk through a hypothetical example of cost-benefit analysis. The demonstration is intended to catalyze the reporting of modeling costs and benefits.
In many countries, sustainability targets for managed fisheries are often expressed in terms of a fixed percentage of the carrying capacity. Despite the appeal of such a simple quantitative target, an unintended consequence may be a significant tilting of the proportions of biomass across different ages, from what they would have been under harvest-free conditions. Within the framework of a widely used age-structured model, we propose a novel quantitative definition of "age-balanced harvest" that considers the age-class composition relative to that of the unfished population. We show that achieving a perfectly age-balanced policy is impossible if we harvest any fish whatsoever. However, every non-trivial harvest policy has a special structure that favours the young. To quantify the degree of age-imbalance, we propose a cross-entropy function. We formulate an optimisation problem that aims to attain an "age-balanced steady state", subject to adequate yield. We demonstrate that near balanced harvest policies are achievable by sacrificing a small amount of yield. These findings have important implications for sustainable fisheries management by providing insights into trade-offs and harvest policy recommendations.
Environmental scientists frequently rely on time series of explanatory variables to explain their impact on an important response variable. However, sometimes, researchers are less interested in raw observations of an explanatory variable than in derived indices induced by episodes embedded in its time series. Often these episodes are intermittent, occur within a specific limited memory, persist for varying durations, at varying levels of intensity, and overlap important periods with respect to the response variable. We develop a generic, parametrised, family of weighted indices extracted from an environmental signal called IMPIT indices. To facilitate their construction and calibration, we developed a user friendly app in Shiny R referred to as IMPIT-a. We construct examples of IMPIT indices extracted from the Southern Oscillation Index and sea surface temperature signals. We illustrate their applications to two fished species in Queensland waters (i.e., snapper and saucer scallop) and wheat yield in New South Wales.
Marine phytoplankton can utilize different strategies to cope with ocean warming and freshening from glacial melting in polar regions, which are disproportionally impacted by global warming. In the present study, we investigated the individual and combined effects of a 4 °C increase in seawater temperature (T+) and a 4 psu decrease in salinity (S−) from ambient values on biomass, nutrient use, fatty acid composition and lipid damage biochemistry of natural phytoplankton assemblages from Potter Cove (25 de Mayo/King George Island, Antarctica). Experiments were conducted by exposing the assemblages to four treatments during a 7-day incubation period using microcosm located along shore from January 23 to 31, 2016. The N:P ratio decreased in all treatments from day 4 onwards, but especially under high temperature (T+). Lipid damage was mainly detected under S0T+ and S−T+ conditions, and it decreased when the production of the antioxidant α-tocopherol increased. This antioxidant protection resulted in a build-up of phytoplankton biomass, especially at T+. Under the combined effect of both stressors (S−T+), the concentration of ω3 fatty acids increased, potentially leading to higher-quality FA composition. These results, which were related to the dominance of sub-Antarctic species in phytoplankton assemblages, contribute to the understanding of the potential consequences of ocean warming and increase seawater freshening on the trophic webs of the Southern Ocean.
El área de “El Rincón” (39° S-41° 30′ S) es un sistema de alta complejidad oceanográfica, de relevancia como área reproductiva y cría de numerosas especies, sujeta a diversas medidas de manejo pesquero. El objetivo del trabajo fue evaluar la evolución temporal del ensamble de peces costeros en el área. Se analizaron 591 lances de pesca y estaciones oceanográficas durante el período 1994-2012 en función de la densidad de peces, la diversidad y la estructura del ensamble, evaluando diferencias interanuales y su relación con variables oceanográficas. Se registraron 70 especies de peces costeros, once de ellas responsables de las diferencias en los ensambles entre años. Los resultados más destacables fueron la tendencia decreciente de la densidad de peces, así como la relación positiva entre la densidad y la temperatura de fondo. El presente trabajo reviste importancia como línea de base de la evolución del ensamble de peces costeros, junto a una exhaustiva caracterización de la dinámica biológica y física de la región en un período de casi dos décadas. Los resultados obtenidos son de importancia para la gestión de recursos costeros, futuros estudios enmarcados en el contexto del cambio climático global y evaluación del impacto antrópico en este ecosistema costero del Atlántico Sudoccidental que brinda numerosos servicios ecosistémicos.
Regime shifts are ecosystem-scale phenomena. In lake studies, most supporting evidence is frequently based on a single state variable. We examined the sediment record of the shallow lake Blanca Chica (Argentina) to explore the response of multiple proxies belonging to different trophic levels (nutrients, chlorophyll and carotenoid pigments, diatoms, Cladocera remains, and Rotifera resting eggs) over the last 250 yr. We explored different ecological indicators to assess changes consistent with regime shifts. To do so, first we identified the timing of transitional periods on multiple-proxies. Then, we explored (1) the nature of the change (linear versus non-linear dynamics), (2) different indicators of a shift across the food web: multimodality and resilience indicators (standard deviation and autocorrelation), and (3) examined the synchronicity of the detected indicators at multiple-trophic levels. Generalized additive models fitted to the ordination scores of the assemblages analyzed revealed two transitions: ca. 1860-1900, and 1915-1990. Ecological indicators of regime shifts revealed that the first transition is consistent with a threshold state response (change in the ecosystem state manifest as a jump when the driver exceeds a state threshold), and the second one with a critical transition (hysteretic transition in which the system change to an alternate stable state). After the first transition lake structure shifted from littoral to pelagic species dominance (evidenced by Cladocera and diatom assemblages), and turbidity increased, in-dicating a rise in lake water level. This transition was non-linear, showed multimodality, and is most likely driven by an increase in precipitation registered in the region since 1870. During the second transition, nutrient levels rose, all indicators showed multimodality, non-linear dynamics and an increase in standard deviation prior to the regime shift. These dynamics are consistent with a critical transition in response to eutrophication, and coincides with a post-1920 change in land use. Our results show that several ecological indicators of regime shifts need to be examined to perform an accurate diagnosis. We highlight the relevance of a multi-proxy ap-proach including multiple-trophic level responses as the appropriate scale of analysis to determine the occur-rence, type and dynamics of regime shifts. We also show that resilience indicators and critical transitions can be detectable in the whole food web and that shallow lakes can undergo different types of regime shifts.
On the southern Patagonian shelf (Argentina, 47 degrees-55 degrees S) phyto- and protozooplankton are key structural and functional components of a complex trophic web that sustains commercially important species. During late summer 2004, spatial structure, assemblage species and their association with environmental characteristics of water masses were studied for the 2-200 mu m phyto- and protozooplankton communities. Ultraplankton 2-5 mu m was the most abundant size-fraction (90%), followed by the lower nanoplankton 5-10 mu m (7.5%), the larger nanoplankton 10-20 mu m (1.5%), and microplankton 20-200 mu m (1%). Several of the 319 morpho-species found are potentially toxic taxa (the dinoflagellates Alexandrium tamarense, Protoceratium reticylatum, Dinophysis acuminata, Prorocentrum cordatum, Karenia and amphidomataceans and the diatom genus Pseudo-nitzschia), and this is important since the area sustains significant fisheries. A ultraphytoeukaryotic coccal cell (probably chlorophyte/prasinophyte) (3 mu m), P. cordatum, and a microplankton naked ciliate were the morpho-species with the highest abundance and occurrence. Abundance and biodiversity patterns indicated that the plankton community structure was heterogeneous vertically, cross-shelf, and along-shelf, suggesting shifts in community structure over the region. Five areas with dissimilar plankton assemblages were defined, each corresponding to different environments. Depth, bathymetry, latitude and temperature were the most explanatory variables for the assemblage distribution patterns observed. This south Patagonian region possesses important fisheries and, considering expected environmental changes, our results help to understand the spatial structure of plankton communities over a broad size spectrum.