Stable isotope taggants would constitute unique identifiers for nuclear fuel cycle materials, resulting in expedited timelines and high confidence provenance assessments for nuclear forensics investigations. However, reliably identifying and interpreting stable isotope taggants in nuclear materials recovered from outside of regulatory control will largely be predicated on the assumption that the taggant element intrinsic to the untagged nuclear material exhibits natural isotopic ratios. Here, we present high-precision Ti, Fe, and Ni isotope compositions in 13 commercial low-enriched uranium (LEU) fuel pellets to assess the suitability of these transition metals as stable isotope taggants. Our investigations reveal limited isotope variations among the fuel pellets in all three elements, which are consistent with small mass-dependent isotope fractionations, comparable to variations previously reported for natural samples.In practice, isotopically tagged nuclear materials are expected to fall along isotopic mixing lines, since intrinsic background levels of taggant elements dilute the taggant towards natural isotope compositions. The observation that Ti, Fe, and Ni isotope compositions in a suite of LEU fuel pellets are close to or indistinguishable from estimates for the Bulk Silicate Earth demonstrates that a two end-member mixing assumption would be valid for these transition metals, indicating that all three are promising candidate elements for stable isotope tagging. Finally, we present mass balance calculations to quantify isotopic perturbations expected from admixing isotopically anomalous Ti, Fe, and Ni taggants to assess the interplay between elemental and taggant concentrations and find favorable compromises for facilitating successful taggant identification with current analytical methods.
High-resolution SEM images of uranium-oxide powders encode micro- and nanoscale clues to their synthesis route and calcination temperature. We trained a ResNet-50 model on 11 commercial-scale U3O8 classes, ammonium diuranate (ADU) or uranyl peroxide (H2O2) precursors calcined at temperatures ranging from 400 to 750 degrees C and added a 256-D projection head before the classifier to analyze the learned representation. The best of eight seeds reached 92.4 % accuracy on reserved testing data, but our focus is the structure of the embedding space rather than the accuracy and labels. We quantify class relatedness in the original 256-D space using centroid similarity and distributional distances, and we use Uniform Manifold Approximation Projection (UMAP) for visualization. 'Unknown' images from different preparation methods, SEM operators, and from the literature localized near the expected classes under a nearest-centroid analysis without retraining, as well as clustered in similar UMAP space. This embedding-centered workflow complements black-box classification by providing quantitative, similarity-based comparisons of U3O8 morphologies and reduces storage space by up to 98 % for image data used in millisecond vector search comparisons.
Galaxy Serpent is an ongoing series of virtual, web-based international tabletop exercises designed to advance the application of National Nuclear Forensics Libraries (NNFLs) in investigations involving nuclear and other radioactive material found out of regulatory control. This iteration emphasized interactions between scientific teams and mock investigative entities. Participants utilized their provided NNFLs to assess material consistency with a provided database of holdings, assign confidence levels, and identify key characteristics relevant to investigative queries. The exercise highlighted both challenges encountered and lessons learned, and advanced best practices for integrating a NNFL into nuclear forensics as part of an investigation.
Stable isotope taggants added to nuclear materials could be utilized as diagnostic nuclear forensics signatures; however, intentionally adding taggants is a relatively new and untested concept with respect to the nuclear fuel cycle. In this study, we added trace amounts of stable Mo and W isotope taggants to starting materials used to synthesize UO2 along a wet synthesis pathway. Successful incorporation and recovery of the Mo and W taggants was achieved in the UO2 product and all its precursors. This study demonstrates the efficacy of stable isotope tagging along a wet UO2 production pathway.
Traditional nuclear forensics approaches leverage isotopic measurements for characterizing nuclear forensics signatures in fuel cycle materials. To aid in provenance assessment, isotopically perturbed transition metal taggants can be added to fuel cycle materials. We present a case study for examining natural uranium oxide powder that was tagged with isotopically perturbed Mo before and after irradiation using resonance ionization mass spectrometry. This method accurately and precisely measures taggant and uranium compositions, rapidly enabling the ability to clearly discriminate between tagged particles and other material with application for robust assessment of material provenance.
The development and deployment of a new generation of nuclear reactors necessitates a thorough evaluation of techniques used to characterize nuclear materials for nuclear forensic applications. Advanced fuels proposed for use in these reactors present both challenges and opportunities for the nuclear forensic field. Many efforts in pre-detonation nuclear forensics are currently focused on the analysis of uranium oxides, uranium ore concentrates, and fuel pellets since these materials have historically been found outside of regulatory control. The increasing use of TRISO particles, metal fuels, molten fuel salts, and novel ceramic fuels will require an expansion of the current nuclear forensic suite of signatures to accommodate the different physical dimensions, chemical compositions, and material properties of these advanced fuel forms. In this work, a semi-quantitative priority scoring system is introduced to identify the order in which the nuclear forensics community should pursue research and development on material signatures for advanced reactor designs. This scoring system was applied to propose the following priority ranking of six major advanced reactor categories: (1) molten salt reactor (MSR), (2) liquid metal-cooled reactor (LMR), (3) very-high-temperature reactor (VHTR), (4) fluoride-salt-cooled high-temperature reactor (FHR), (5) gas-cooled fast reactor (GFR), and (6) supercritical water-cooled reactor (SWCR).
Image analysis techniques have been applied and shown to be a valuable tool in nuclear forensics analysis. The interlaboratory exercise reported here has tested quantitative and qualitative approaches for characterizing nuclear materials. Particle size, surface features and morphology descriptions were compared by four laboratories on a common image set generated by Scanning Electron Microscopy and Digital Light Microscopy. Quantitative analysis of the image sets through the Morphological Analysis for MAterials software highlighted the strength of image analysis, but also that the application of the software alone can introduce significant bias in the analysis. Qualitative morphology descriptions following the process outlined by Tamasi et al. (J Radioanal Nuclear Chem 307:1611–1619, 2015) were compared with a discussion on the robustness and reproducibility of the results. Future work should continue to focus on proficiency and standardization of image analysis through continued exercises within the extended nuclear forensics community.
The addition of isotopically enriched taggants to material at the front end of the nuclear fuel cycle could be a powerful tool used to assist law enforcement authorities should material outside of regulatory control be found. Two potential candidates for this purpose are molybdenum (Mo) and tungsten (W) as both elements have five or more stable isotopes and are trace elements contained within nuclear fuel. However, there is a concern that Mo and W could undergo isotope fractionation during processes like uranium enrichment and to date, it is unknown if nuclear fuels have natural Mo and W isotope compositions. If Mo and W isotopic variability is present in nuclear fuels, this would hinder the use of these elements as isotopic taggants because it would be difficult to discern the original taggant isotope composition with high confidence. Therefore, a set of 16 low enriched uranium (LEU) fuel pellets from US commercial producers was analyzed using multi collector-inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (MC-ICPMS) to determine Mo and W isotope compositions (i.e., 94Mo/92Mo, 95Mo/92Mo, 96Mo/92Mo, 97Mo/92Mo, 98Mo/92Mo, 183W/182W, 184W/182W, and 186W/182W). Relative to terrestrial standards, LEU fuel pellets have variable Mo and W isotope compositions, thereby complicating the use of these elements as isotopically enriched taggants. As such, this work demonstrates that the isotope composition of any potential taggant must be well characterized in the base nuclear fuel prior to any taggant addition. Furthermore, these results suggest that Mo and W are not ideal candidates for isotopically enriched taggants.
Novel analytical approaches to determining the trapped 38Ar/36Ar ratio of gases contained within Martian meteorites are presented and applied to the Martian regolith breccia Northwest Africa (NWA) 7034 and paired stone NWA 11220. The resulting data indicate that extensive mass-dependent fractionation of atmospheric Ar may have occurred within 150 million years of planetary formation, ostensibly as a result of diffusion-limited hydrodynamic escape. The inferred fractional loss of Ar and lighter atmospheric constituents exceeds 50%. These data suggest that volatiles derived from planetary outgassing and/or impactors may dominate the present abundance of atmospheric Ar.
The chemical and isotopic compositions of fallout melt glasses from nuclear tests contain a range of information constraining the physical conditions within the fireball and the mechanisms of fallout formation but historic studies tended to exclude the behavior of stable major and trace elements. Here, we present a large study specifically focused on major and trace element relationships within a population of macroscale fallout samples from a single event. We interpret these data to better constrain how fallout melt glass formation in near surface environments is influenced by that environment and demonstrate how major and trace element abundances can provide useful insights into chemical processes within the fireball. Data confirm that the uranium in the fallout glass population derives from two isotopically distinct endmembers: isotopically enriched uranium (presumably from the weapon), and natural composition uranium that may be a combination of anthropogenic and environmental materials from within the blast zone. The similarity between major and trace element concentrations in fallout and corresponding local soils from the event site confirm the local soils as the most probable source of entrained material into the fireball and the source of carrier material into which the bomb vapor was incorporated. The lack of correlation between major and trace element abundances with size indicates that volatility driven processes, such as condensation from the fireball, do not control the composition of macroscale fallout melt glass. Although the fallout has major and trace element chemical characteristics broadly similar to those of the local, associated soils, some systematic differences are observed between the two populations. Fallout melt glass is depleted in volatile elements such as K, Na, Tl and Pb, consistent with heating to temperatures above similar to 1000 degrees C for 3-10 s. This is supported by the results of laser heating experiments performed on rhyolitic soil at temperatures (1600-2200 degrees C) and timescales (1-120 s) that are broadly relevant to fallout formation conditions. Relative enrichments of metals such as Cu and Co do not correlate with the abundance of uranium, suggesting that fallout also records input of near field anthropogenic materials. Our observations suggest that major chemical features can be related to processing in the fireball and used to inform the thermal-chemical evolution of the system. Ultimately, these data are consistent with a fallout formation mechanism that involves rapid melting of surface materials to form carrier material melts with minor incorporation of bomb vapor and a degree of volumetric volatile loss due to heating.
Several studies have evaluated the morphology of uranium compounds produced under controlled conditions at the laboratory scale, but it is unclear whether the morphological characteristics of these materials persist in commercially produced uranium ore concentrates (UOCs). To assess the morphology in “real-world” UOCs, we qualitatively evaluated the morphological profile of secondary electron images from over 100 commercial UOCs using a previously published lexicon. We observe differences between samples with differing chemical composition and samples with similar chemical composition and differing provenance. This work contextualizes morphology for commercially produced UOCs and will provide a basis for future machine learning efforts.
This interlaboratory study measured thorium concentrations and isotope compositions in uranium ore concentrates from different geographical locations to examine whether thorium impurities may be useful forensic signatures for uranium ore concentrates found out of regulatory control. Measured 230Th/232Th in fifteen uranium ore concentrates record over three orders of magnitude of compositional variation. Results demonstrate that 230Th/232Th used in combination with U/Th ratios resulted in a unique signature for individual uranium ore concentrates from different processing locations. Data presented here suggest potential for 230Th/232Th and U/Th to be used as comparative signatures to investigate the provenance of seized uranium ore concentrates.
A multiproxy record from a fast‐growing stalagmite reveals variable hydroclimate on the California coast across the 8.2 kyr event and a precursor event likely caused by initial drainage of proglacial Lake Agassiz. Using speleothem δ 44 Ca, we develop the first semiquantitative estimates of paleorainfall variability for California through calibration with measurements of the modern climate and cave environment. We find that the magnitude of rainfall variability during the 8.2 kyr event approached the multiyear variability observable in the recent past (1950–2019) and the magnitude of variability during the precursor event likely exceeded this range. Additionally, we observe other instances of multidecadal variability comparable in magnitude to the precursor event during the record. Our work suggests that speleothem calcium isotope ratios are a powerful semiquantitative means to reconstruct paleorainfall, although numerous factors must be assessed in each cave system before applying this approach.