ObjectivesMetal-on-metal (MoM) hip resurfacing was introduced into clinical practice because it was perceived to be a better alternative to conventional total hip replacement for young and active patients. However, an increasing number of reports of complications have arisen focusing on design and orientation of the components, the generation of metallic wear particles and serum levels of metallic ions. The procedure introduced a combination of two elements: large-dimension components and hard abrasive particles of metal wear. The objective of our study was to investigate the theory that microseparation of the articular surfaces draws in a high volume of bursal fluid and its contents into the articulation, and at relocation under load would generate high pressures of fluid ejection, resulting in an abrasive water jet.MethodsThis theoretical concept using MoM resurfacing components (head diameter 55 mm) was modelled mathematically and confirmed experimentally using a material-testing machine that pushed the head into the cup at a rate of 1000 mm/min until fully engaged.ResultsThe mathematical model showed the pattern but not the force of fluid ejection, the highest pressures were expected when the separation of the components was only a fraction of one millimetre. The experimental work confirmed the results; with the mean peak ejection pressure of 43 763 N/m(2) equivalent to 306 mmHg or 5 psi.ConclusionsThe mechanical effect of the high-pressure abrasive water jet is the likely cause of the spectrum of complications reported with metal-on-metal resurfacing. Investigating serum levels of metallic elements may not be the best method for assessing the local mechanical effects of the abrasive water jet.

Increasing follow-up identifies the outcome in younger patients who have undergone total hip replacement (THR) and reveals the true potential for survival of the prosthesis. We identified 28 patients (39 THRs) who had undergone cemented Charnley low friction arthroplasty between 1969 and 2001. Their mean age at operation was 17.9 years (12 to 19) and the maximum follow-up was 34 years. Two patients (4 THRs) were lost to follow-up, 13 (16 THRs) were revised at a mean period of 19.1 years (8 to 34) and 13 (19 THRs) continue to attend regular follow-up at a mean of 12.6 years (2.3 to 29). In this surviving group one acetabular component was radiologically loose and all femoral components were secure. In all the patients the diameter of the femoral head was 22.225 mm with Charnley femoral components used in 29 hips and C-stem femoral components in ten. In young patients who require THR the acetabular bone stock is generally a limiting factor for the size of the component. Excellent long-term results can be obtained with a cemented polyethylene acetabular component and a femoral head of small diameter.

The design of the Charnley total hip replacement follows the principle of low frictional torque. It is based on the largest possible difference between the radius of the femoral head and that of the outer aspect of the acetabular component. The aim is to protect the bone-cement interface by movement taking place at the smaller radius, the articulation. This is achieved in clinical practice by a 22.225 mm diameter head articulating with a 40 mm or 43 mm diameter acetabular component of ultra-high molecular weight polyethylene. We compared the incidence of aseptic loosening of acetabular components with an outer diameter of 40 mm and 43 mm at comparable depths of penetration with a mean follow-up of 17 years (1 to 40). In cases with no measurable wear none of the acetabular components were loose. With increasing acetabular penetration there was an increased incidence of aseptic loosening which reflected the difference in the external radii, with 1.5% at 1 mm, 8.8% at 2 mm, 9.7% at 3 mm and 9.6% at 4 mm of penetration in favour of the larger 43 mm acetabular component. Our findings support the Charnley principle of low frictional torque. The level of the benefit is in keeping with the predicted values.

We reviewed 261 patients with 320 Charnley low-friction arthroplasties who had a mean follow-up of 22 years 10 months (20 to 30), Of these, 93.9% considered the operation to be a success; 82.3% were free from pain and 11.6% had occasional discomfort. Satisfactory function was achieved in 59.6% and 62% had an excellent range of movement.The clinical results did not correlate well with the radiological appearance; radiologically loose components did not affect the clinical outcome. The main long-term problem was wear and loosening of the UHMWPE cup. Our findings suggest that the radiological appearance of the arthroplasty is a more reliable indication of the state of the arthroplasty than the clinical results.

The increasing incidence of obesity in the population is a topic of current interest. This trend is reflected in patients undergoing primary Charnley hip replacement. Over a 21 year period from January 1986 to October 2006, during which 6910 primary operations were performed, the body mass of patients increased at a mean rate of 0.48 kg/year. The findings suggest that the test criteria for the endurance of stemmed femoral components be modified. The maximum load should be increased from 2.3 kN to 2.5 kN to reflect patients' increasing weight. The duration of the test should be increased from 5 x 10(6) cycles during which the 'femoral component shall not fracture' to 10 x 10(6) cycles in order to reflect not only the patients' activity level but also the 4-11 year period at risk for stem fracture, and so 'reflect developing clinical experience'.

We studied survival to 38 years after Charnley low-friction arthroplasty of the hip. We used revision as an end-point, while adopting a policy of regular follow-up and early revision for radiological changes alone if indicated. Between November 1962 and June 2005, 22,066 primary low-friction arthroplasties (17,409 patients) had been performed at Wrightington Hospital by more than 330 surgeons. By June 2006, 1001 (4.5%) hips had been revised and 1490 patients (2662 hips, 12%) had died. At 31 years, where a minimum of 40 hips were still attending follow-up, survival with revision for infection as an endpoint was 95%, for dislocation 98%, for a fractured stem 88.6%, for a loose stem 72.5% and for a loose acetabular component 53.7%. Wear and loosening of the ultra-high-molecular-weight polyethylene acetabular component were the main long-term problems. We conclude that regular follow-up after hip replacement is essential and that all operative findings should be recorded at revision.

We reviewed 1039 revision total hip replacements where an angle-bore acetabular component was used. After a mean follow-up of nine years (0 to 20.6), the incidence of revision for dislocation was 2.1% (22 revisions), a success rate of 97.9%. In 974 revisions, where the indication was other than dislocation, the success rate was 98.5%. Of the 65 revisions for dislocation, 58 (89.2%) were successful after the first revision and a further five after the second revision, an overall success of 96.9%. Two patients elected to have their implants removed. Dislocation after revision of failed total hip replacement is a complex issue. There is often no single cause and no simple solution. The angle-bore acetabular component, in combination with a 22.225-mm diameter femoral head, offers a high level of success.

The Charnley low-frictional torque arthroplasty of the hip with 22.225 mm diameter head and thick ultra high molecular weigh polyethylene cup, both components grouted with cold curing acrylic cement, has reached 43 years of clinical success. Follow-up past 30 years is now available. Over 96% of patients are satisfied with the result. Post operative activity level is a reflection of patient selection. The neuropathic nature of the new joint does not reflect the mechanical state of the arthroplasty: regular follow-up with good quality radiographs is essential. Revisions may have to be undertaken for asymptomatic radiographic changes: a principle that must be understood and accepted before the primary procedure. The long-term problems are wear and cup loosening and strain shielding of the proximal femur. Long-term success will be further extended by understanding and practical application of the principles at the primary procedure and use of low wear materials for the articulation. The operation of total hip arthroplasty marks the beginning and not the end of treatment.

Forty-nine patients (mean age, 37 years; 20-50 years) had had 69 Charnley low-frictional arthroplasties for avascular necrosis of the femoral head. Their mean follow-up was 13.4 years (2-25 years). Five patients (8 hips) had no continuing follow-up, 5 (8 hips) are known to have died, 6 (7 hips) had had a revision at a mean follow-up of 16.4 years (11-25 years): 6 for cup loosening and 1 for a fractured stem and a loose cup. The remaining 33 patients (46 hips) had an excellent clinical result with all stems remaining soundly fixed, but 6 cups were radiologically loose at a mean follow-up of 16 years and 4 months. Wear and cup loosening are the main problems limiting the survival of the arthroplasty.

This article reviews clinical developments in Charnley low frictional torque arthroplasty.

Since wear and loosening of the ultra-high-molecular-weight polyethylene cup are factors which limit the life of an arthroplasty we have attempted to identify factors associated with either low wear (0.02 mm/year or less) or high wear (0.2 mm/year or more). In a series of 1434 Charnley low-friction arthroplasties (1092 patients) 190 (13.2%) showed low wear while 149 (10.4%) showed high wear. We used chi-squared test to assess the significance of various factors. The significant factors of the low-wear group were female gender (p = 0.042), rheumatoid arthritis (p = 0.014), Charnley grade C (p = 0.03) and varus position of the stem (p = 0.003). The use of acetabular cement pressurisation (p = 0.07) and medialisation of the cup (p = 0.07) approached significance. In the high-wear group there was a predominance of men (p = 0.042) with osteoarthritis (p = 0.006) as the underlying hip pathology, and the stem in a valgus position (p = 0.023). Support of the cup by the rim of the acetabulum approached significance (p = 0.07). There was no statistical significance between the two groups for revision for aseptic loosening of the stem or fracture of the stem (p = 0.49). There was a highly significant difference (p < 0.0001) between the two groups for revision for wear and aseptic loosening of the cup, 5.3% compared with 39%. Changes in the cup geometry are probably sufficient to explain the increasing incidence of loosening and revisions with the increasing depth of penetration of the cup. There is much to be gained from the use of a low-wearing ceramic-ultra-high-molecular-weight combination. Tissue reaction to the polyethylene particles cannot be the cause of aseptic loosening of the stem.

We have prospectively studied the wear of enhanced ultra-high molecular-weight polyethylene (Hylamer) in combination with a zirconia femoral head of 22.225 mm diameter on a cemented, triple-tapered, collarless, polished stem, the C Stem. The 71 patients who underwent total hip arthroplasty had a mean follow-up of six years (3 to 8). No patient died or was lost to follow-up. The clinical results were excellent with 96% of patients satisfied. There were no revisions. Two cups were considered to be loose radiologically. One was avulsed from the cement in a skiing accident, with a periprosthetic fracture of the femur, but has remained stable for more than seven years. One femur shows radiological appearances which are compatible with a healing infection. One femoral component is at risk of loosening. The mean rate of penetration of the cup was 0.22 mm/year (0.06 to 0.55). Our results appear to be within the guidelines set by the National Institute of Clinical Excellence. We have discontinued the use of Hylamer despite excellent clinical results and no revisions to date because the high initial rates of penetration did not settle to the expected low levels within the anticipated time.

The walking activity of normal subjects and total hip arthroplasty (THA) patients from the Wrightington Hospital for Joint Disease and The General Infirmary at Leeds was assessed by means of electronic pedometers. The principal objectives were to establish the extent to which joint arthroplasty patients recover their activity relative to normal subjects and to establish the number of loading cycles to which prostheses should be subjected in joint simulator studies of implant performance. A further objective was to establish an experimental procedure for the assessment of the role of activity in contributing to the well-known scatter in the measurements of femoral head penetration into acetabular cups in in vivo studies of implant performance. The last-mentioned issue is addressed in another article ([1]). The walking activity of 2 normal subjects of disparate ages was assessed during 1 full year. It was concluded that fair estimates of activity could be achieved by recording pedometer readings during successive 2- to 4-week periods. This approach was adopted in the full assessment of the walking activity of cohorts of normal subjects and THA patients. Linear regression expressions relating the number of steps taken daily and the annual number of loading cycles on each leg to age are presented for normal subjects and THA patients. In all cases, activity declines with age, but it is shown that total joint arthroplasty is not at all restrictive on walking activity-a remarkable testimony to the efficacy of total joint arthroplasty. Attention is drawn, however, to different levels of activity of THA patients recorded in the present United Kingdom study and a similar survey conducted in California.

Aretrospective review of socket fixation in 34 hips of 28 patients with an average follow-up of 9 years 3 months has been reported. Thirty out of 34 sockets remain well fixed with excellent clinical outcome in 17, satisfactory in 7 patients. The cement pressuriser does not seem to alter the outcome of socket fixation. We conclude that revised surgical techniques and flanged socket design will improve socket survival in long term.

In a prospective study of 75 consecutive primary Charnley low friction arthroplasties carried out for osteoarthritis, loose bodies were found in nine hip joints; an incidence of 12%. Whether their presence is the cause or the effect of the condition remains unclear. Their discoid or spherical shape suggests that they were free and had been subjected to sliding or rolling motion. Those of irregular shape may have remained partly attached within the capsule, or become confined to a space.

Successful long-term clinical results with the Charnley low-friction torque arthroplasty have identified proximal femoral strain shielding as a long-term problem to be addressed. The problem has arisen because of the load transfer by a distally supported stem that is no longer subject to fracture. To overcome this problem and improve proximal load transfer to the femur, a continuous triple-tapered stem--the C stem--was designed. This article describes the first 500 primary hip arthroplasties at a mean follow-up of 3 years, 5 months (range, 1-7 years). There have been no revisions for aseptic stem loosening, and no stem is considered to be at risk for loosening. In 20% of cases, there was subjective radiologic improvement of the bone-cement interface.

Survivorship of total hip arthroplasties (THAs) has been linked to penetration of the femoral head into the polyethylene acetabular cup and to polyethylene wear. The activity level of patients with THAs is considered to be an important factor affecting wear, and the purpose of this study was to explore the relationship between activity as recorded by pedometers and cup penetration. The measurement of daily activity levels of normal subjects and THA patients of various ages are discussed in another article ([1]). Subjects were monitored continuously during 2- to 4-week periods using simple pedometer devices. Patients (n = 54; mean age, 58 years) from the Centre for Hip Surgery at Wrightington Hospital for whom the penetration data also were available were included in the study. The average activity level for the patient group was 1.426 million loading cycles on each hip joint per year. Radiographic penetration measurements were compared for 81 hips in 54 patients with a mean follow-up of 13.1 years (range, 1.3-26.4 years). The overall correlation of penetration with implantation period is known to be poor, however, and did not improve significantly when the penetration was plotted against a new parameter that took account of not only implant life, but also the level of activity and patient weight. The considerable scatter of penetration levels was noted to increase with increasing implantation period, which indicates that in the multifactorial problem of polyethylene wear, other factors, particularly femoral head surface finish or polyethylene deterioration, may predominate.

Between 1983 and 1988 we carried out 45 Charnley low-friction arthroplasties with autografts from the femoral head in 41 patients for developmental dysplasia of the hip. The preoperative radiographs were assessed for the severity of DDH according to the classifications of Crowe et al, Hartofilakidis et al and Sharp. The postoperative and follow-up radiographs were analysed for coverage of the socket by the graft, for loosening and for the outcome of the fixation of the bone graft. Two patients died (two hips) at four and seven years after THR from causes unrelated to the surgery and were excluded from the final radiological analysis. The mean age of the patients at the time of operation was 46 years 3 months. The autograft of the femoral head covered a mean 26% (16 to 35) of the acetabular component. All the grafts united. Some degree of resorption of the bone graft occurred in 27 patients, and always involved the lateral part of the graft, which was beyond the margin of the socket. After a mean follow-up of 11 years there had been no revisions and 38 patients had no pain or only slight discomfort. One socket migrated and four others were fully demarcated. Our findings indicate that the Charnley LFA with an autograft of the femoral head for DDH remains successful at a follow-up of 15 years.