The 37th British Mass Spectrometry Society (BMSS) annual meeting took place over a brilliantly sunny 3 days by the sea in the historic Eastbourne Winter Gardens on the south coast of England. It was held between 13 and 15 September 2016. Two-hundred attendees enjoyed a conference covering all aspects of MS with speakers drawn from across Europe and North America. The BMSS is particularly proud of the encouragement it offers students and early career scientists, both financially in the form of travel grants and also in terms of opportunities to present at an international level in a supportive atmosphere. Further encouragement to newcomers to the field is offered in the form of the Barber Prize for best oral presentation and the Bordoli Prize for the best poster. This year's winners were Patrick Knight (University of Leeds), the Bordoli Prize for the poster 'Characterising the Interaction of Ataxin-3 and the Poly-Glutamine Aggregation Inhibitor QBP1'; Lisa Deininger (Sheffield Hallam University), the Barber Prize for 'Out Damned Spot! Bottom Up Proteomics for the Analysis of Bloodied Fingermarks'. In addition, the Delegates Choice for best poster went to Hannah Britt (Durham University) for 'Monitoring Reactions of Small Molecules with Cell Membranes by Liquid Chromatography-Mass Spectrometry'. For services to the MS community, Professor Gareth Brenton (Swansea University) was awarded the BMSS Medal; Professor Alison Ashcroft (Leeds University) and Anna Upton (former BMSS administrator) were given lifetime membership of the BMSS.
RATIONALE Intramolecular proton migration has been reported to be required for fragmentation by collision-induced dissociation (CID). If the collision energy is required to provide energy for proton movement to a ‘dissociative’ site, it may be possible to predict the optimal collision energy for fragmentation using quantum computational chemistry software. A greater understanding of the mechanism(s) of proton migration is necessary. METHODS The product ion spectra of seven compounds were obtained at collision energies stepped in the range from 5 to 50 eV, with precursor ions being generated in positive ion mode by both atmospheric pressure chemical ionization (APCI) and electrospray ionisation (ESI) (using an ESCi ionisation source with or without corona discharge, respectively). The products ions observed at each collision energy were assessed in terms of structure to ascertain if they were formed as a result of protonation at the initial ionisation site or if the proton had migrated to a dissociative site. RESULTS Proton migration was shown to be independent of collision energy, stability of the protonated molecule and the distance that the proton moved. Therefore, proton migration is not a barrier to fragmentation as the proton appears to be fully mobile at 5 eV. As proton migration is independent of collision energy for these compounds, whereas fragmentation is energy dependent, protonation at the dissociative site alone is not sufficient to cause bond cleavage. CONCLUSIONS The role of collision energy in bond cleavage may be to increase the vibrational energy of the bond and/or increase the rate of bond cleavage such that it occurs within the residence time of the ion within the collision cell rather than to supply the energy for proton migration. Therefore, quantum chemistry alone cannot predict the collision energies appropriate for fragmentation on the basis of modelling proton movements.
Ion mobility mass spectrometry is used to measure the drift-time of an ion. The drift-time of an ion can be used to calculate the collision cross-section (CCS) in travelling wave ion mobility (e.g. Waters Synapt and Vion instruments) or directly determine the experimental CCS (e.g. Agilent 6560 instrument and many drift-tube instruments). A comparison of the experimental CCS and theoretical CCS values obtained from trajectory method He(g) parameterised MOBCAL and N2(g) parameterised MOBCAL software, for a range of 20 'small molecules' is presented. This study utilises density functional theory B3LYP methods and the 6-31G+(d,p) basis set to calculate theoretical CCS values. This study seeks to assess the accuracy of a common procedure using CCS calibration with poly-(d/l)-alanine derived from drift-cell measurements and the original release of MOBCAL software and compare it with recent improvements with a drug-like molecule calibration set and a revision of MOBCAL parameterised for N2(g) drift gas. This study represents one of the first quantitative evaluations of the agreement between theoretical CCS and experimental CCS values for a range of small pharmaceutically relevant molecules using travelling wave ion mobility mass spectrometry. Accurate theoretical CCS may allow optimisation of ion mobility separations in silico, provide CCS databases that can confirm structures without the need for alternative analytical tools such as nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy (NMR) and assignment of unknowns and positional isomers without requiring reference materials.
RATIONALEFifteen molecules were modelled using quantum chemistry, prior to interpreting their collision-induced dissociation (CID) product ion spectra, in a 'blind trial' to establish if calculated protonation-induced bond elongation could be used to predict which bonds cleaved during CID. Bond elongation has the potential to be used as a descriptor predicting bond cleavage.METHODSThe 15 molecules were modelled with respect to protonation-induced bond length changes using Density Functional Theory (DFT). Significant bond elongations were highlighted to flag potential bond cleavages. CID product ion spectra, obtained using positive ion electrospray ionisation (Waters Synapt G1), were interpreted to establish if observed bond cleavages correlated with calculated bond elongations. Calculations were also undertaken using AM1 (Austin Model 1) to see if this rapid approach gave similar results to the computationally demanding DFT.RESULTSThe AM1-calculated bond elongations were found to be similar to those generated by DFT. All the polarised bonds observed to cleave (n = 82) had been calculated to elongate significantly. Protonation, possibly via proton migration, on the most electronegative atom in the bond appeared to initiate cleavage, leading to a 100% success rate in predicting the bonds that broke as a result of protonation on a heteroatom. Cleavage of carbon-carbon bonds was not predicted.CONCLUSIONSCleavage of the polarised bonds appears to result from protonation on the more electronegative atom of the bond, inducing conformational changes leading to bond weakening. AM1-calculated bond length changes act as a descriptor for predicting bond cleavage. However, the impetus for cleavage of the unpolarised bonds may be product ion stability rather than bond weakening.
Fragmentation of molecules under collision-induced dissociation (CID) conditions is not well-understood. This may make interpretation of MSMS spectra difficult and limit the effectiveness of software tools intended to aid mass spectral interpretation. Density Functional Theory (DFT) has been successfully applied to explain the thermodynamics of fragmentation in the gas phase by the modelling the effect that protonation has on the bond lengths (and hence bond strengths). In this study, dofetilide and four methylated analogues were used to investigate further the potential for using DFT to understand and predict the CID fragmentation routes. The products ions present in the CID spectra of all five compounds were consistent with charge-directed fragmentation, with protonation adjacent to the cleavage site being required to initiate fragmentation. Protonation at the dissociative site may have occurred either directly or via proton migration. A correlation was observed between protonation-induced bond lengthening and the bonds which were observed to break in the CID spectra. This correlation was quantitative in that the bonds calculated to elongate to the greatest extent gave rise to the most abundant of the major product ions. Thus such quantum calculations may offer the potential for contributing to a predictive tool for aiding the accuracy and speed mass spectral interpretation by generating numerical data in the form of bond length increases to act as descriptors flagging potential bond cleavages.
A high-performance liquid chromatography-electrospray ionization-tandem mass spectrometry (HPLC-ESI-MS/MS) approach to the characterization of dialkyl tertiary amine-N-oxides is presented. The methodology is based upon forming reconstructed ion current chromatograms (RICCs) of m/z values of product ions known to form through diagnostic losses from dialkyl tertiary amine-N-oxides. The diagnostic losses of N,N-dimethylhydroxylamine and N,N-diethylhydroxylamine were identified through the analysis of a structurally diverse library of compounds by ESI-low-energy collision-induced dissociation (CID)-MS/MS using quadrupole ion trap-mass spectrometry (QIT-MS) and quadrupole time-of-flight-mass spectrometry (QqTOF-MS). The library consisted of dialkyl tertiary amine-containing commercially available pharmaceuticals, along with a number of model, synthetic N-oxides. The loss of the nitrogen-containing group was observed in 89% of the low-energy CID product ion spectra acquired using various collision energies. Further, the resultant product ions, formed through the loss of the nitrogen-containing group, were shown to be unstable because of the observation of second-generation dissociation. These observations regarding gas-phase ion chemistry could be useful to developers of in silico programs for fragmentation prediction by allowing the creation of improved algorithms and models for predicting dissociation. Using the information derived from the library analysis, the characterization methodology was developed and demonstrated using tetracaine. The approach is rapid, MS/MS platform independent, utilizes existing technology, and could be automated. Further, it is definitive and overcomes the limitations of other tools for N-oxide identification by localizing the site of oxidation. Thus, it provides a useful addition to the existing approaches for metabolite identification.
The experimental investigation of site-specific intra-ionic hydrogen/deuterium (H/D) exchange in the low-energy collision-induced dissociation (CID) product ion spectra of protonated small molecules generated by electrospray ionisation (ESI) is presented. The observation of intra-ionic H/D exchange in such ions under low-energy CID conditions has hitherto been rarely reported. The data suggest that the intra-ionic H/D exchange takes place in a site-specific manner between the ionising deuteron, localised at either a tertiary amine or a tertiary amine-N-oxide, and a gamma-hydrogen relative to the nitrogen atom. Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy measurements showed that no H/D exchange takes place in solution, indicating that the reaction occurs in the gas phase. The compounds analysed in this study suggested that electron-withdrawing groups bonded to the carbon atom bearing the gamma-hydrogen can preclude exchange. The effect of the electron-withdrawing group appears dependent upon its electronegativity, with lower chi value groups still allowing exchange to take place. However, the limited dataset available in this study prevented robust conclusions being drawn regarding the effect of the electron-withdrawing group. The observation of site-specific intra-ionic H/D exchange has application in the area of structural elucidation, where it could be used to introduce an isotopic label into the carbon skeleton of a molecule containing specific structural features. This could increase the throughput, and minimise the cost, of such studies due to the obviation of the need to produce a deuterium-labelled analogue by synthetic means.
Tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) is widely used for the identification of metabolites at all stages of the pharmaceutical discovery and development process. The assignment of ions in the product ion spectra can be time-consuming and hence delay feedback of results that may influence the direction of a project. A deeper understanding of the processes involved in generation of the product ions formed via collision-induced dissociation may allow development of chemically intelligent software to aid spectral interpretation. Current commercially available spectral interpretation software takes a mainly arithmetical approach resulting in extensive lists of numerically plausible ions, many of which may not be chemically feasible. In this study, high-resolution MS/MS spectra were obtained for maraviroc and two of its synthetic metabolites, and structures for the product ions proposed. Density functional theory (DFT) based on in silico modelling was undertaken to investigate whether the fragmentation observed was potentially a result of bond lengthening (and hence weakening) as a consequence of protonation of the molecule at the most thermodynamically stable site(s). It was determined that for all three compounds, where the product ions resulted from simple bond cleavages (not rearrangements), the bonds that cleaved had been calculated to elongate after protonation. It was also noted that the protonated molecule may represent a mixture of singly charged protonated species and that the most basic sites in the molecule may not necessarily be the most thermodynamically stable for protonation.
S-oxidation is a common metabolic route for sulfur-containing compounds. Whilst investigating the dissociation of a series of chemically synthesised model S-oxide metabolites, two unexpected losses of 62 m/z units were observed in the collision-induced dissociation (CID) product ion spectrum of protonated 3-dimethylaminomethyl-4-(4-methanesulfinyl-3-methylphenoxy)benzenesulfonamide. A single loss was initially assigned using the low-resolution product ion spectrum, acquired by electrospray ionisation quadrupole ion trap mass spectrometry (ESI-QIT-MS), as methanethial, S-oxide via a charge-remote, four-centred rearrangement. This assignment was consistent with well-documented hydrogen rearrangements in the literature. Further, the loss was not observed for the parent compound. Thus, it was inferred that the site of metabolism was involved in the dissociation and the attractive nature of the four-centred rearrangement meant that the loss of methanethial, S-oxide was a logical assignment. However, deuterium-labelling experiments and accurate mass measurements, performed using electrospray ionisation Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry (ESI-FT-ICR-MS), showed that the nominal loss of 62 m/z units occurs via two distinct dissociation pathways. Neither of these losses was of methanethial, S-oxide as initially hypothesised from the low-resolution product ion spectrum of the protonated molecule. Mechanisms consistent with the experimental findings are postulated. An MS(3) spectrum of the fully exchanged, deuterated species supported the proposed mechanisms by suggesting that 3-dimethylaminomethyl-4-(4-methanesulfinyl-3-methylphenoxy)benzenesulfonamide has multiple sites of protonation in the gas phase. The planar structures of the posited product ions are likely to provide the driving force for the rearrangements. The relevance of the observations with regards to pharmaceutical drug metabolite identification is discussed.
Prediction of tandem mass spectrometric (MS/MS) fragmentation for non-peptidic molecules based on structure is of immense interest to the mass spectrometrist. If a reliable approach to MS/MS prediction could be achieved its impact within the pharmaceutical industry could be immense. Many publications have stressed that the fragmentation of a molecular ion or protonated molecule is a complex process that depends on many parameters, making prediction difficult. Commercial prediction software relies on a collection of general heuristic rules of fragmentation, which involve cleaving every bond in the structure to produce a list of 'expected' masses which can be compared with the experimental data. These approaches do not take into account the thermodynamic or molecular orbital effects that impact on the molecule at the point of protonation which could influence the potential sites of bond cleavage based on the structural motif. A series of compounds have been studied by examining the experimentally derived high-resolution MS/MS data and comparing it with the in silico modelling of the neutral and protonated structures. The effect that protonation at specific sites can have on the bond lengths has also been determined. We have calculated the thermodynamically most stable protonated species and have observed how that information can help predict the cleavage site for that ion. The data have shown that this use of in silico techniques could be a possible way to predict MS/MS spectra.
COPD is a major cause of mortality in the western world. A(2A) agonists are postulated to reduce the lung inflammation that causes COPD. The cardiovascular effects of A(2A) agonists dictate that a compound needs to be delivered by inhalation to be therapeutically useful. The pharmacological and pharmacokinetic SAR of a series of inhaled A(2A) agonists is described leading through to human pharmacokinetic data for a clinical candidate.
A 50 m/z unit loss from protonated 4-benzenesulfinyl-3-methylphenylamine has been observed and investigated using electrospray ionisation quadrupole ion trap mass spectrometry (ESI-QIT-MS). It was hypothesised that the specific fragmentation was affected by the presence of an ortho methyl group in relation to the sulfoxide functionality, i.e. an ortho effect influences the preferred dissociation pathway. This was because the des-methyl homologue did not display a 50 m/z unit loss. This fragmentation was shown to be a two-step process with sequential losses of a hydroxyl radical and a thiol radical. Molecular modelling calculations showed that the most favourable site of protonation for 4-benzenesulfinyl-3-methylphenylamine was the sulfoxide oxygen, which would facilitate the loss of a hydroxyl radical. Subsequent deuterium-exchange experiments confirmed that the loss was a hydroxyl radical and afforded definitive assignment of the site of protonation. Furthermore, the involvement of a single exchangeable hydrogen atom in the overall 50 m/z unit loss was demonstrated. Thus, supportive evidence was provided for the involvement of the ortho methyl group in the second stage of the fragmentation, leading to the loss of the thiol radical. Accurate mass measurements, performed using electrospray ionisation Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry (ESI-FTICR-MS), verified the elemental formulae of the individual losses. The ion structure following the 50 m/z unit loss was proposed to be a protonated aminofluorene and was supported by comparing the product ion spectrum of commercially available protonated 2-aminofluorene with the MS4 data of protonated 4-benzenesulfinyl-3-methylphenylamine. Fragmentation mechanisms are proposed. The relevance of the loss with regards to pharmaceutical drug metabolite identification is discussed.
Increased demand for assays for compounds at the early stages of drug discovery within the pharmaceutical industry has led to the need for open-access mass spectrometry systems for performing quantitative analysis in a variety of biological matrices. The open-access mass spectrometers described here are LC/MS/MS systems operated in 'multiple reaction monitoring' (MRM) mode to obtain the sensitivity and specificity required to quantitate low levels of pharmaceutical compounds in an excess of biological matrix. Instigation of these open-access systems has resulted in mass spectrometers becoming the detectors of choice for non-expert users, drastically reducing analytical method development time and allowing drug discovery scientists to concentrate on their core expertise of pharmacokinetics and drug metabolism. Setting up an open-access facility that effectively allows a user with minimal mass spectral knowledge to exploit the MS/MS capability of triple quadrupole mass spectrometers presents a significantly different challenge from setting up qualitative single stage mass spectrometry systems. Evolution of quantitative open access mass spectrometry within a pharmaceutical drug metabolism and pharmacokinetics group, from its beginnings as a single generic system to a series of specialist fully integrated walk-up facilities, is described.
An observation that a series of proprietary compounds containing a methyl thiophenyl group all underwent metabolic S-oxidation, and that the product ion spectra of the resulting S-oxides showed methyl radical loss under low-energy atmospheric pressure ionisation tandem mass spectrometry (API-MS/MS) conditions, has led to an investigation of the fragmentation of commercially available sulphoxides. The phenyl methyl sulphoxides studied do lose methyl radicals under MS/MS conditions on triple quadrupole mass spectrometers. In addition, the phenyl sulphoxides, with simple substituents other than a methyl group, also showed a tendency to lose the substituent as a radical. It was concluded that radical loss from these simple sulphoxides was characteristic of S-oxidation of these molecules. Radical losses, such as those reported here, are used in-house to distinguish S-oxidation from N- and C-oxidation in metabolism studies.
Turbulent flow chromatography coupled to tandem mass spectrometry (TFC-MS-MS) has recently emerged as a potentially fast, sensitive and specific technique for the direct analysis of pharmaceutical compounds from crude plasma. TFC-MS-MS removes the need for time-consuming sample preparation procedures such as solid-phase extraction (SPE) or liquid-liquid extraction (LLE). A relatively high flow rate combined with the use, of an HPLC column with large porous particles allows the on-line clean up and quantification of compounds in plasma samples. Until, now, the amount of plasma directly injected into TFC systems has rarely exceeded 30 μL in order to prevent rapid column degradation. Increasing the injection volume also induces high carry-over levels, particularly for drugs with basic and/or lipophilic properties.