Haptic actuators employing speed reductions display desirable increased force capability but have difficulty producing feelings of free space motion due to friction and inertia magnification implicit to actuator dynamics. This work describes a control topology that enables geared haptic actuators to produce highly transparent free space motion when combined with backlash nonlinearities. While the presence of backlash enables the proposed free space motion control, it is also a source of instability, limit cycles, and to some extent rendering distortion. We introduce a smoothed gain scheduling function to mitigate limit cycling and expand the range of stable impedances that can be rendered. The introduction of a design metric called the free space envelope provides a framework to evaluate the effectiveness of the free space controller. Together these two control approaches enable transparent free space, high-force, and stable haptic interactions in systems with backlash, a characteristic common in many speed reducers.

This paper describes a frequency partitioned admittance actuation approach which has the potential to expand the rendering capability of admittance based haptic devices by extending the admittance control's position control bandwidth. The actuation approach combines a high bandwidth, low amplitude actuator in series with a low bandwidth, large amplitude actuator. Summing the actuator velocities of these two leads to an actuator with both a large amplitude displacement and a high position control bandwidth. We describe the actuation and control approach and experimentally validate the approach with a one degree of freedom testbed. We experimentally demonstrate improvements in rendering through a measurable reduction in the minimum stable rendered inertia, the primary metric by which admittance-based systems are assessed, and an increase in the frequency range over which force rendering is accurate, known as the rendering bandwidth, as compared to a baseline admittance-based actuated system. Finally, we investigate the consequences of potential position saturation of the high frequency actuation during operation, on both rendering stability and rendering output impedance.

This work investigates the stability and rendering limitations of admittance-type haptic devices. We investigated a wider range of impedances than had previously been considered, including stiffness, damping, mass, and combinations thereof. The coupled human driving impedance, actuator position control bandwidth, and loop delay are identified as major factors affecting the range of stable impedances. Finally, the theoretical results are experimentally verified using a custom one degree of freedom admittance type haptic device.

Impedance based kinesthetic haptic devices have been a focus of study for many years. Factors such as delay and the dynamics of the device itself affect the stable rendering range of traditional active kinesthetic devices. A parallel hybrid actuation approach, which combines active energy supplying actuators and passive energy absorbing actuators into a single actuator, has recently been experimentally shown to increase the range of stable virtual stiffness a haptic device can achieve when compared to the active component of the actuator alone. This work presents both a stability and rendering range analysis that aims to identify the mechanisms and limitations by which parallel hybrid actuation increases the stable rendering range of virtual stiffness. Increases in actuator stability are analytically and experimentally shown to be linked to the stiffness of the passive actuator.

Cooperative robots or “cobots” promise to allow humans and robots to work together more closely while maintaining safety. However, to date the capabilities of cobots are greatly diminished compared to industrial robots in terms of the force and power they are able to safely produce. This is in part due to the actuation choices of cobots. Low impedance robotic actuators aim to solve this problem by attempting to provide an actuator with a combination of low output impedance and a large bandwidth of force control. In short the ideal actuator has a large dynamic range. Existing actuators success and performance has been limited. We propose a high force and high power balanced hybrid active-passive actuator which aims to increase the actuation capability of low impedance actuators and to safely enable high performance larger force and workspace robots. Our balanced hybrid actuator does so, by combining and controlling a series elastic actuator, a small DC motor, and a particle brake in parallel. The actuator provides low and high frequency power producing active torques, along with power absorbing passive torques. Control challenges and advantages of hybrid actuators are discussed and overcome through the use of trajectory optimization, and the safety of the new actuator is evaluated.

This work investigates the stability of admittance type haptic devices in the context of a wider range of impedances than previously considered. More specifically, we consider the stable range of mass and damping. The coupled human driving impedance, actuator position control bandwidth, and loop delay are identified as major factors affecting the range of stable impedances. Finally, theoretical results are experimentally verified using a custom one degree of freedom admittance type haptic device.

Handheld haptic devices are often limited in rendering capability, as compared to traditional grounded devices. Strenuous design criteria on weight, size, power consumption, and the ungrounded nature of handheld devices, can drive designers to prioritize actuator force or torque production over other components of dynamic range like bandwidth, transparency, and the range of stable impedances. Hybrid actuation, the use of passive and active actuators together, has the potential to increase the dynamic range of handheld haptic devices due to the large passive torque capability, the stabilizing effects of passive actuators, the high bandwidth of conventional DC servomotors, and the synergy between actuators. However, to date the use of hybrid actuation has been limited due to the highly nonlinear torque characteristics of available passive actuators that result in poor rendering accuracy. This paper describes a hybrid actuation approach and novel control topology which aims to solve actuation challenges associated with nonlinear passive actuators in hybrid and handheld haptic devices. The performance of the device is assessed experimentally, and the approach is compared to existing handheld devices.

Hybrid actuation approaches for haptic interfaces generally suffer from asymmetry in active and passive torque capabilities. This paper describes the design of a high-performance balanced hybrid haptic device, which addresses the asymmetry by combining a high-power, low-impedance active compliant actuation (series-elastic actuator) with energy absorbing high-force passive actuation in parallel with a fast, low-power secondary active actuation. We describe the actuation, design and control approaches and experimentally validate the approach with a one degree-of-freedom testbed. The performance is compared with active only approach and results show significant improvements in stability and rendering range of the device.