Functionally graded materials (FGMs) fabricated via additive manufacturing of blended powders offer the potential to spatially tailor properties for new technologies, such as fusion first-wall systems, turbine blades, and spacecraft. However, processing these materials is difficult due to the multiplicity of processing parameters to optimize, all of which must be changed as substrate material, powder feedstock compositions, and melt pool dynamics evolve. This work systematically evaluates the qualitative and quantitative effects of these variables on the melt pool size, shape, composition, and particle distribution in an exemplar Ti-Ta system, and connects the experimental results to Marangoni flow behavior and phenomena observed in other systems. Increasing laser power linearly increases melt pool size and layer thickness, driving engineering considerations such as part/geometrical tolerances. Decreasing laser velocity changes the melt pool shape from lenticular to convex and reduces chemical homogeneity due to extreme thermal and compositional gradients between the melt pool center and boundaries. Thermophysical property differences between the powder feedstock and substrate material, as well as the directionality of the gradient, affect dilution and melt pool dynamics, which in turn affect the melt pool boundary characteristics, shape, and uniformity. Mixed powder feedstocks of intermediate compositions do not behave according to linear interpolations between single-material endpoints, instead building taller and wider melt pools. As such, it is recommended to quantify process maps for at least one intermediate composition in the FGM or multi-material system of interest to ensure optimized processing parameters, predictable melt pool sizes and shapes, and compositional and spatial precision.
Functionally graded materials (FGMs) are of increasing interest due to their ability to join dissimilar alloys with spatially tailored properties. However, joining incompatible materials such as steels and refractory alloys poses difficulties in processing, particularly regarding the formation of brittle intermetallic phases (e.g. σ) and cracks. The precipitation and growth of these phases are dependent on composition, which can be mitigated by Calphad-based path planning approaches, and kinetics, which are in turn dependent on the thermal history throughout the part. In this work, we propose guidelines for path planning using an effective temperature range that can capture relevant formation of deleterious phases, demonstrated on a gradient system between SS316 and titanium-zirconium-molybdenum (TZM). Computational path planning between SS316-Cr-TZM was used to predict σ phase formation from SS316 to Cr using “effective lower temperatures” (defined as the temperature above which phase transformation kinetics are assumed to become relevant) between 500 and 1000 °C, which were then validated with FGM builds produced by directed energy deposition (DED). Compositions and phase fractions were measured experimentally for direct comparison to Scheil and equilibrium predictions. Several phase transformations mechanisms are discussed to give insights into next-generation path planning accounting for microstructural evolution. Paths both avoiding and containing σ phase are fabricated and compared to investigate sources of cracking; in all cases, solidification and ductile-to-brittle transition (DBTT) cracking were identified as the main crack formation mechanisms and a new path from Cr to TZM was proposed, incorporating Nb and V to reduce crack susceptibility.
Materials with smooth compositional gradients or functionally grade materials (FGMs) produced via additive manufacturing (AM), enables joining dissimilar materials and optimizing multiple properties in advanced engineering applications. However, as-printed AM microstructures exhibit micro-segregation and solidification defects which, when combined with controlling macroscale gradient properties, complicates necessary post-processing. Here, we use CALPHAD-informed diffusion modelling to design post-processing heat treatments for lightweight to refractory FGMs. Ti-Ta (0 to 85 at. % Ta) FGMs were fabricated using laser-based directed energy deposition AM. Post-processing heat treatments at 1000 degrees C and 1500 degrees C were designed to promote homogenization across specific length scales and experimentally validated. Investigation of chemical segregation and microstructures demonstrated that the length scale of homogenization is controlled as a function of time, temperature, and local composition. Ta-rich regions exhibited incomplete homogenization compared to Ti-rich layers. Unmelted Ta particles were found to completely dissolve at 1500 degrees C. By controlling cooling rate (200 degrees C/min), martensitic structures were produced between 14-36 at. % Ta, consistent with martensitestart temperatures calculations, while furnace cooling (2 degrees C/min) produced alpha+beta morphologies. This work establishes a validated predictive framework for designing post-processing to tailor microstructure and chemical architecture in AM FGMs, facilitating their deployment in demanding environments.
This work presents a physics-informed framework for predicting solidification morphology and defect susceptibility in additively manufactured Ti–22Al–25Nb across a broad processing space. The framework integrates solidification microstructure selection (SMS) analysis with a single-track defect-based printability map to establish a unified methodology linking processing parameters to both interfacial morphology and manufacturability. Thermal gradients G and solidification rates R are first computed using the Thermo-Calc Additive Manufacturing (TC-AM) module, a finite-interface-dissipation (FID) phase-field (PF) model coupled with CALPHAD method is then employed to systematically distinguish planar and dendritic regimes as functions of G and R. By superimposing the printability map onto the morphology projections, a comprehensive process–structure framework is obtained. Across most processing conditions, the predicted microstructure is predominantly dendritic, while planar growth emerges only under selected laser power P and scan speed v combinations. In addition to morphology classification, the framework quantifies the dendritic area fraction and introduces a width-based morphology descriptor to characterize the spatial extent of planar/dendritic regions within the melt pool. It provides mechanistic insight into the interplay between solidification physics and defect formation, offering practical guidance for parameter selection and microstructural control in Ti–22Al–25Nb additive manufacturing (AM).
The composition Al-16Ce-1Mg has been developed as a dedicated alloy for processing by laser powder bed fusion (LPBF). Guided by thermodynamic considerations and exploiting the unique conditions during LPBF, the strongly hypereutectic alloy features nm-scale aluminum dendrites reinforced by a continuous intermetallic network. The unique temperature stability of Al-Ce alloys as well as the microstructure topology and scale grant the alloy high strength in as-printed state with excellent thermal stability. The superior mechanical properties of the continuously reinforced nanocomposite were established by comparison with the spheroidized, microstructure of similar scale.
We present anab initiofree energy model derived from a fully relativistic density functional theory (DFT) electronic structure with dynamic magnetism forδ-plutonium (face-centered cubic, fcc). The DFT model is extended with orbital-orbital interaction in a parameter free orbital polarization (OP) mechanism consistent with previous modeling of plutonium. Gibbs free energy is built from components associated with the temperature dependence of the electronic structure and the corresponding electronic entropy, lattice vibrations within an anharmonic lattice dynamics model, and dynamical fluctuations of the magnetization density, i.e. magnetic fluctuations. The fluctuation model consists of transverse and longitudinal modes driven by temperature induced excitations of the DFT + OP electronic structure. Theab initiomodel thus incorporates fluctuating states beyond the electronic ground state. Thanks to the dynamic magnetism, the theory predicts excellent thermodynamic properties and a Gibbs free energy in accord with CALPHAD and semi-empirical modeling developed from the thermodynamic observables. The magnetic fluctuations further explain anomalous behaviors of the thermal expansion in plutonium. Specifically, a thermal expansion for theδ-plutonium system turning from positive to negative at temperatures above room temperature, a tendency for gallium to reduce and remove the negative thermal expansion depending on composition, and a positive thermal expansion for the high temperatureϵphase.
High entropy alloys (HEAs) correspond to a new and emerging class of materials that allows us to explore a large composition space to tune mechanical strength and thermal stability. Therefore, to design better alloys, it is important to scan the high-dimensional space of chemistry, composition and temperature. To facilitate this search, we present a method to screen intrinsically ductile body centered cubic (BCC) refractory alloys from electronic structure calculations by using the density of states (DOS) at the Fermi level, g (mu F). This correlation between intrinsic ductility and g (mu F) is tested by analyzing group V (V, Nb, Ta) and VI (Mo, W) refractory metals, binary alloys, such as W-Nb, W-V, Mo-Nb and Mo-V, and refractory alloys for which experimental stress-strain measurements are available. In addition, we perform a high-throughput exploration of the entire composition space of a recently proposed alloy system, CrMoNbV, and identify compositions that exhibit high intrinsic ductility.
High-entropy alloys (HEAs) are promising candidates for advanced structural applications due to their excellent mechanical properties. Additive manufacturing (AM), with its rapid solidification conditions, enables the creation of unique nonequilibrium microstructures. To fully leverage the synergy between AM and HEAs, understanding how processing affects structure and properties is essential. Here, how solidification rate influences microstructure evolution and phase transformation pathway in laser additively manufactured AlCrFe2Ni2 eutectic HEAs is investigated. By increasing the laser scan speed and hence the solidification rate, distinct solidification modes evolving from coupled eutectic to anomalous eutectic and eventually to single-phase solidification are revealed. These transitions result in distinct microstructures and a wide range of mechanical properties. Thermodynamic modeling and molecular dynamics simulations reveal that low cooling rates allow for sufficient atomic diffusion and phase separation, facilitating coupled eutectic growth. In contrast, rapid cooling suppresses diffusion and destabilizes the solid-liquid interface, promoting anomalous or single-phase solidification. This integrated experimental and computational approach provides a multiscale understanding of solidification mechanisms in HEAs and underscores how kinetic effects can over-ride thermodynamic predictions under nonequilibrium conditions. These results demonstrate that AM can serve as a powerful tool to design HEAs with tailored microstructures and properties.
Uranium carbides with refractory metal additions are considered for Gen IV nuclear reactors and nuclear thermal propulsion as fuels for their high-temperature and corrosion resistant properties. Understanding kinetic effects that dictate microstructural evolution during fabrication and operating conditions is essential to advance technological development of these fuels. This work presents the development of an atomic mobility database for CNb-U systems based off available experimental data supported with ab-initio methods. The mobility assessments and uncertainty quantification (using Markov chain Monte Carlo) were conducted in the Kawin software. Carbon diffusion is considered dominant, as metal diffusion is much slower, with niobium diffusion being even slower and rate limiting than uranium metal. We provide a comprehensive and self-consistent thermo-kinetic database that is validated by diffusion couple simulations through Kawin. This enables prediction of microstructural and phase evolution critical for the development and lifetime assessment of next generation nuclear fuels.
Property models are becoming more widely adopted by commercial Calphad databases, but they are not nearly as common in non-commercial or traditional academic Calphad databases. A primary driver is that user-friendly Calphad modeling tools that support property models are not widely available. Here we present new property modeling capabilities that have been implemented in ESPEI (the Extensible, Self-optimizing Phase Equilibrium Infrastructure). These capabilities include both generating property model parameters from data and improvements to the algorithmic selection of the most appropriate model from a series of candidates. Two illustrative examples are given that use ESPEI to fit different property models. First, we generate molar volume model parameters for Group IV, V, and VI refractory BCC alloys based on the model by Lu et al. (2005). Second, we demonstrate the extensibility of ESPEI’s property modeling capabilities by implementing a custom PyCalphad model for BCC elastic stiffness parameters to generate and compare parameters to the ones assessed by Marker et al. (2018) using the same data. Property models generated by ESPEI can be used in PyCalphad or further optimized with uncertainty quantification using ESPEI.
Functionally graded materials have the potential to improve upon monolithic parts by locally tailoring compositions to surrounding environmental conditions. Difficulties arise when designing composition gradients as incompatible materials can result in detrimental phase formation and failure of the gradient joint. As many alloys are multi-component, designing a composition gradient free of detrimental phases is difficult due to the large composition space available to explore. A framework was developed that improves the path planning algorithm and surrogate models with adaptive sampling schemes specific to their problem definition. A cost function was created to minimize a property (such as cracking susceptibility) along a path. This framework was applied to the Mo-Nb-Ta-Ti system as a case study to showcase the efficiency in building the surrogate models and in iterating different optimal compositionally graded paths.
Predicting phase stability in high entropy alloys (HEAs), such as phase fractions as functions of composition and temperature, is essential for understanding alloy properties and screening desirable materials. Traditional methods like CALPHAD are computationally intensive for exploring high-dimensional compositional spaces. To address such a challenge, this study explored and compared the effectiveness of random forests (RF) and deep neural networks (DNN) for accelerating materials discovery by building surrogate models of phase stability prediction. For interpolation scenarios (testing on the same order of system as trained), RF models generally produce smaller errors than DNN models. However, for extrapolation scenarios (training on lower-order systems and testing on higher order systems), DNNs generalize more effectively than traditional ML models. DNN demonstrate the potential to predict topologically relevant phase composition when data were missing, making it a powerful predictive tool in materials discovery frameworks. The study uses a CALPHAD dataset of 480 million data points generated from a custom database, available for further model development and benchmarking. Experiments show that DNN models are data-efficient, achieving similar performance with a fraction of the dataset. This work highlights the potential of DNNs in materials discovery, providing a powerful tool for predicting phase stability in HEAs, particularly within the Cr-Hf-Mo-Nb-Ta-Ti-V-W-Zr composition space.
Ti5553 (Ti-5Al-5Mo-5V-3Cr wt.%) is a titanium alloy widely used for its high strength-to-weight ratio and good formability at elevated temperatures. Unlike Ti-6Al-4V, Ti5553 does not undergo martensitic transformation, preventing cracking of brittle martensite upon rapid cooling. This makes it a strong candidate for additive manufacturing (AM), particularly laser powder bed fusion (L-PBF). L-PBF offers the unique opportunity to make fine lattice structures to reduce component weight. Despite the growing field of AM, there have been limited studies on L-PBF Ti5553 lattices and how their properties differ from the bulk. The present work addresses this knowledge gap by investigating microstructures and properties of L-PBF bulk and lattice parts and the effect of post L-PBF heat treatments. Electron microscopy and mechanical testing show that the high dislocation density formed during L-PBF increases bulk part’s yield strength by approximately 100MPa compared to the conventional alloy. Digital image correlation during compression testing of octet truss lattices reveals a layer-by-layer failure mode. Compared to the bulk, the lattice contains copious ω nanoprecipitation and weaker <001> texture, smaller average grain sizes, and larger content of high-angle grain boundaries. These features elicit differences in Taylor factor distributions for the lattice depending on load direction, underlining challenges in predicting lattice mechanical response based on bulk properties. By examining the processing-structure-property relationships in the bulk and lattice, the present results delineate their microstructural and mechanical differences and establish a benchmark for the future design applications of L-PBF Ti5553.
Alloys that are Ni-doped, such as the (Sm1−yZry)(Fe1−xCox)12 and (Ce0.5Sm0.5)Fe10Co2 systems, are studied because of their magnetic properties. The (Sm1−yZry)(Fe1−xCox)11−zTiz and (Ce.1−xSmx)Fe9Co2Ti alloys are considered contenders for vastly effective permanent magnets because of their anisotropy field and Curie temperature. Ti can act as a stabilizer for the SmFe12 compound but substantially suppresses saturation magnetization. To maintain the saturation magnetization in the scope of 1.3–1.5 T, we propose substituting a particular quantity of Fe and Co in the (Sm1−yZry)(Fe1−xCox)12 and (Ce0.5Sm0.5)Fe10Co2 alloys with Ni. By performing ab initio calculations, we show that Ni incorporation results in increased thermodynamic stability and, in contrast to Ti, has a parallel spin moment aligned to the moment of the SmFe12 compound and improves its saturation magnetization without affecting the anisotropy field or Curie temperature.
Here the discovery of refractory multi-principal element alloys (MPEAs) with high-temperature strength and stability is pursued within a constrained and application-relevant design space. A comprehensive approach is developed and applied to explore all 165 ternary systems in the Al-Ce-Fe-Hf-Mo-Nb-Ta-Ti-V-W-Zr family. A subset of ternary systems that contain large areas in composition–temperature space with high strength and robust BCC phase stability is found. Twelve sets of high-performing alloys are identified, each set optimized for one combination of phase constraint, optimization target, and temperature range. Preliminary mechanical tests support the viability of the method. This work highlights the importance of considering phase stability, exploring non-equiatomic regions of composition space, and applying application-relevant constraints. Parts I and II provide three down-selection techniques for identifying high-performing BCC refractory MPEAs, design guidelines, and many candidates predicted to have BCC phase stability and strengths 2–3 times higher than any reported to date.
Metal additive manufacturing technologies keep receiving a great deal of interest as well as strong requests to develop methods to link the process science to printed parts performance and understand how to overcome inherent limitations. A high-fidelity model based on the multiphysics ALE3D code was developed to reproduce the directed energy deposition process down to the powder scale. This includes resolving the laser-powder-melt pool interactions (powder impingement and incorporation into melt pool, hydrodynamics flow condition and laser absorption inefficiencies) as well as the resulting solidification microstructure. This micrometer scale digital twin captured the effect of powder incorporation process and powder flow rate on porosity. Furthermore, it was used to explore how a ring laser beam profile instead of the standard Gaussian laser profile could decrease the thermal gradient along the solidification front in the melt pool, which in turn can increase propensity for more desirable equiaxed grains.
Al-Ce-based alloys are promising candidates for additive manufacturing (AM) due to their hot cracking resistance and because they do not require heat treatment to obtain precipitation strengthening. The rapid solidification characteristic of AM can lead to enhanced mechanical properties; however, the strengthening mechanisms over large composition ranges are unclear. Here, combinatorial synthesis by directed-energy deposition (DED) and hardness measurements were used to rapidly map the composition-dependent strength of the ternary Al-Ce-Mg system. Tensile testing and microstructure characterization of selected compositions were performed to elucidate the compositional dependence of the strengthening mechanisms. Al11Ce3 precipitates were present in all cases, and the maximum hardness (1.25 GPa) was measured for the Al-8Ce-10Mg composition. A combination of (i) Hall-Petch strengthening, based on the FCC matrix phase cell size; (ii) precipitation strengthening, based on Al11Ce3 volume fraction and size; and (iii) solid solution strengthening, based on Mg composition of the matrix phase, were used to account for the measured strengths. Hardness is shown to correlate well with ultimate tensile strength in alloys with substantial work-hardening, highlighting the value of surface-based techniques for rapid screening.
Refractory metal-based multi-principal element alloys (MPEAs) are compelling materials for high-temperature (1000–2000 K) structural applications. However, only a minuscule fraction of their vast and heterogeneous compositional design space has been explored, leaving many potentially interesting alloys undiscovered. In this two-part work, a large region of the 11-element Al-Cr-Fe-Hf-Mo-Nb-Ta-Ti-V-W-Zr design space is computationally explored to identify refractory MPEAs with simultaneously high yield strength or specific yield strength and body-centered cubic (BCC) solid solution stability. In Part I , two case studies illuminate key factors and considerations in the yield strength versus phase stability tradeoff, provide guidelines for narrowing the expansive design space, and identify many candidates predicted to be stronger than refractory MPEAs reported to date, with BCC phase stability. Our findings indicate that medium entropy ternary alloys can outperform alloys with more elements and highlight the importance of exploring regions away from the equiatomic center of composition space.