Abstract Tau protein has been implicated as an important mediator of traumatic brain injury (TBI). Adult human brain expresses 6 tau isoforms expressing 3 (3R) or 4 (4R) microtubule binding sites; adult mouse brain expresses only 4R tau. A role for tau isoform expression on TBI disease course is tested using wild-type C57/BL6 mice (WT) and C57/BL6 with a knocked-in human tau coding region (MAPTKI). Uninjured WT and MAPTKI mice have similar brain histology and behavior as they age. At subacute times (14 days post-injury (DPI)), injured MAPTKI mice have less white matter damage with similar neuronal loss as WT. At chronic times (90DPI), MAPTKI mice demyelinate while WT mice remyelinate. At 14DPI, tau phosphorylation differs between WT and MAPTKI mice. At 90DPI, thioflavin-S + protein aggregates in MAPTKI corpus callosum are higher than WT. At 14 or 90DPI, WT and MAPTKI mice acquire Barnes maze, WT retention is impaired at 14DPI and MAPTKI retention impaired at 90DPI. At 14DPI, only MAPTKI mice acquire and retain active place avoidance; at 90DPI, only WT mice acquire active place avoidance. At 14DPI, only injured MAPTKI mice acquire alternating T-maze. These data suggest that WT and MAPTKI differ in both subacute and chronic disease course. At 14DPI, WT mice have greater white matter damage and behavioral impairments than MAPTKI mice. At 90DPI, impairments in WT mice partially recover, yet worsen in MAPTKI mice. This data suggests that 3R tau isoform expression alters the disease course of head injury. Highlights Post-injury disease course of MAPTKI mice expressing 3R and 4R tau differs from wild-type mice expressing only 4R tau. At subacute times post-injury, MAPTKI mice have less white matter, yet similar gray matter, injury than wild-type mice. At chronic times post-injury, white matter damage in MAPTKI worsens. At subacute times post-injury, MAPTKI mice have fewer behavioral deficits than wild type mice. At chronic times post-injury, MAPTKI mice develop behavioral deficits not present at subacute times.
Traumatic brain injury (TBI) can produce chronic limb coordination and gait deficits that are associated with ongoing white matter damage. In rodent TBI models, chronic motor deficits may be obscured by aging or motor compensation. In addition, there are no treatments for TBI. The murine closed head injury (CHI) model produces diffuse, chronic white matter injury that may underlie chronic white matter dysfunction and motor deficits. Evoked compound action potentials (CAP) assess corpus callosum function from 3 to 180-days post injury (DPI). CHI acutely decreases total CAP amplitudes that recover by 90 DPI and increase further at 180 DPI. Total CAP amplitude changes are blocked by dosing of minocycline and N-acetylcysteine beginning 12 h post-injury (MN12). Injured or sham mice have similar times to traverse or number of foot faults on beam walk. DeepLabCut™ markerless limb tracking provides limb positions used to develop novel assays to assess beam walk and simple/complex wheel. Absition analysis integrates the duration and extent of foot faults during beam walk. Injured mice develop absition deficits at 90 DPI that worsen at 180 DPI suggesting a chronic and progressive decline. Chronic absition deficits are blocked by MN12 treatment. Speed typically assesses performance on simple/complex wheel. Novel limb coordination assays show that at 180 DPI, injured mice decrease coordination that significantly correlates with increased total CAP amplitude. MN12 alleviates chronic corpus callosum dysfunction and motor deficits suggesting a strong efficacy to treat TBI. DeepLabCut™ limb tracking reveals chronic deficits and motor compensation not seen with standard outcomes.
Cognitive deficits frequently arise after traumatic brain injury. The murine closed head injury (CHI) models these deficits since injured mice cannot acquire Barnes maze. Dosing of minocycline plus N-acetylcysteine beginning 12 hours post-CHI (MN12) restores Barnes maze acquisition by an unknown mechanism. Increased hippocampal synaptic efficacy is needed to acquire Barnes maze, synaptic long-term potentiation (LTP) models this increased synaptic efficacy in vitro . LTP has an early phase (E-LTP) lasting up to one hour that is mediated by second messengers that is followed by a late phase (L-LTP) that needs new synthesis of protein kinase M zeta (PKMζ). PKMζ has constitutive kinase activity because it lacks the autoinhibitory regulatory domain found in other PKCs. Due to its constitutive activity, the amount of PKMζ kinase activity is determined by PKMζ protein levels. We report that CHI bilaterally decreases PKMζ levels in the CA3 and CA1 hippocampus. MN12 increases CA1 PKMζ expression. CHI inhibits E-LTP in slices from the ipsilesional hippocampus and inhibits L-LTP in slices from both hippocamppi. MN12 treatment reestablishes both E-LTP and L-LTP in slices from the injured MN12-treated hippocampus. The restoration of L-LTP from injured MN12-treated hippocampus is mediated by PKMζ because L-LTP is blocked by the specific PKMζ inhibitor, ζ-stat. Hippocampal ζ-stat infusions also prevents Barnes maze acquisition in injured, MN12-treated mice. These data suggest that post-injury minocycline plus N-acetylcysteine targets PKMζ to improve synaptic plasticity and cognition in mice with closed-head injury.
How can short-lived molecules selectively maintain the potentiation of activated synapses to sustain long-term memory? Here, we find kidney and brain expressed adaptor protein (KIBRA), a postsynaptic scaffolding protein genetically linked to human memory performance, complexes with protein kinase Mzeta (PKMζ), anchoring the kinase’s potentiating action to maintain late-phase long-term potentiation (late-LTP) at activated synapses. Two structurally distinct antagonists of KIBRA-PKMζ dimerization disrupt established late-LTP and long-term spatial memory, yet neither measurably affects basal synaptic transmission. Neither antagonist affects PKMζ-independent LTP or memory that are maintained by compensating PKCs in ζ-knockout mice; thus, both agents require PKMζ for their effect. KIBRA-PKMζ complexes maintain 1-month-old memory despite PKMζ turnover. Therefore, it is not PKMζ alone, nor KIBRA alone, but the continual interaction between the two that maintains late-LTP and long-term memory.
Background Acute injury following brain trauma may evolve into a chronic and progressive disorder. Chronic consequences of TBI have been understudied, in part, due to the lack of robust behavioral changes that are delayed in onset as well as chronic and progressive. Assessment of the chronic consequences of TBI also must distinguish behavioral changes that arises due to age vs those that develop and evolve over time due to injury. Methods C57BL/6 mice receive single closed head injury (CHI) and are analyzed at 7DPI, 14DPI or 180DPI on neurological severity score, open field, rotarod, beam walk, and simple-complex wheel. Results In the center of open field, injured mice have a turn bias at 180 days post-injury (DPI) not present at 7DPI. On rotarod, injured mice have shorter latencies at 7DPI, but not at 180DPI due to a large age effect in sham-injured mice. On beam walk at 180DPI, both sham and injured groups more slowly traverse a 2cm and 1cm beam than at 7DPI. Foot-faults show no significant effects of age or injury. On simple wheel injury affects speed at 14DPI with no effect on distance travelled. The lack of injury-dependent effects on beam walk or simple-complex wheel despite visible impairment was the impetus to assess limb position using Deeplabcut™ markerless tracking. Custom Python scripts were then developed to compute beam walk absition or foot fault severity (integral of limb displacement over time), and step frequency and quadrupedal limb coordination in simple-complex wheel. On the 2cm beam, age increased absition in all limbs of uninjured mice and both forelimbs of injured mice. On the 1cm beam both forelimbs and the left hindlimb of injured mice at 180DPI have larger absition than uninjured mice at 180DPI or injured mice at 7DPI. On a simple wheel injury affected speed only at 14 DPI with no effect on distance travelled. In contrast, injured mice at 180DPI developed a compensatory running strategy by increasing step frequency variability. This allowed injured mice at 180 DPI to reach sham-level quadrupedal limb coordination and improve running speed as compared to 14 DPI assessment. On complex wheel, injured mice at 180DPI do not express this compensatory running strategy resulting in impaired quadrupedal limb coordination. These data suggest chronic and progressive motor deficits of injured mice at 180DPI. Conclusions A single impact produces chronic and progressive motor deficits. Quantitative motor analysis using DeepLabCut™ tracking reveals deficits not seen using standard outcomes.
Traumatic brain injury (TBI) results in both rapid and delayed brain damage. The speed, complexity, and persistence of TBI present large obstacles to drug development. Preclinical studies from multiple laboratories have tested the FDA-approved anti-microbial drug minocycline (MINO) to treat traumatic brain injury. At concentrations greater than needed for anti-microbial action, MINO readily inhibits microglial activation. MINO has additional pleotropic effects including anti-inflammatory, anti-oxidant, and anti-apoptotic activities. MINO inhibits multiple proteins that promote brain injury including metalloproteases, caspases, calpain, and polyADP-ribose-polymerase-1. At these elevated doses, MINO is well tolerated and enters the brain even when the blood–brain barrier is intact. Most preclinical studies with a first dose of MINO at less than 1 h after injury have shown improved multiple outcomes after TBI. Fewer studies with more delayed dosing have yielded similar results. A small number of clinical trials for TBI have established the safety of MINO and suggested some drug efficacy. Studies are also ongoing that either improve MINO pharmacology or combine MINO with other drugs to increase its therapeutic efficacy against TBI. This review builds upon a previous, recent review by some of the authors (Lawless and Bergold, Neural Regen Res 17:2589–92, 2022). The present review includes the additional preclinical studies examining the efficacy of minocycline in preclinical TBI models. This review also includes recommendations for a clinical trial to test MINO to treat TBI.
Traumatic brain injury (TBI) acutely damages the brain; this injury can evolve into chronic neurodegeneration. While much is known about the chronic effects arising from multiple mild TBIs, far less is known about the long-term effects of a single moderate to severe TBI. We found that a single moderate closed head injury to mice induces diffuse axonal injury within 1-day post-injury (DPI). At 14 DPI, injured animals have atrophy of ipsilesional cortex, thalamus, and corpus callosum, with bilateral atrophy of the dorsal fornix. Atrophy of the ipsilesional corpus callosum is accompanied by decreased fractional anisotropy and increased mean and radial diffusivity that remains unchanged between 14 and 180 DPI. Injured animals show an increased density of phospho-tau immunoreactive (pTau+) cells in the ipsilesional cortex and thalamus, and bilaterally in corpus callosum. Between 14 and 180 DPI, atrophy occurs in the ipsilesional ventral fornix, contralesional corpus callosum, and bilateral internal capsule. Diffusion tensor MRI parameters remain unchanged in white matter regions with delayed atrophy. Between 14 and 180 DPI, pTau+ cell density increases bilaterally in corpus callosum, but decreases in cortex and thalamus. The location of pTau+ cells within the ipsilesional corpus callosum changes between 14 and 180 DPI; density of all cells increases including pTau+ or pTau- cells. >90% of the pTau+ cells are in the oligodendrocyte lineage in both gray and white matter. Density of thioflavin-S+ cells in thalamus increases by 180 DPI. These data suggest a single closed head impact produces multiple forms of chronic neurodegeneration. Gray and white matter regions proximal to the impact site undergo early atrophy. More distal white matter regions undergo chronic, progressive white matter atrophy with an increasing density of oligodendrocytes containing pTau. These data suggest a complex chronic neurodegenerative process arising from a single moderate closed head injury.
Traumatic brain injury has a complex pathophysiology that produces both rapid and delayed brain damage. Rapid damage initiates immediately after injury. Treatment of traumatic brain injury is typically delayed many hours, thus only delayed damage can be targeted with drugs. Delayed traumatic brain injury includes neuroinflammation, oxidative damage, apoptosis, and glutamate toxicity. Both the speed and complexity of traumatic brain injury pathophysiology present large obstacles to drug development. Repurposing of Food and Drug Administration-approved drugs may be a highly efficient approach to get therapeutics to the clinic. This review examines the preclinical outcomes of minocycline and N-acetylcysteine as individual drugs and compares them to the minocycline plus N-acetylcysteine combination. Both minocycline and N-acetylcysteine are Food and Drug Administration-approved drugs with pleiotropic therapeutic effects. As individual drugs, minocycline and N-acetylcysteine are well tolerated, with known pharmacokinetics, and enter the brain through an intact blood-brain barrier. At concentrations greater than needed for anti-microbial action, minocycline is a potent anti-inflammatory minocycline, also acts as an antioxidant and inhibits multiple enzymes that promote brain injury including metalloproteases, caspases, and polyADP-ribose-polymerase-1. N-acetylcysteine alone is also an antioxidant. It increases brain glutathione, prevents lipid oxidation, and protects mitochondria. N-acetylcysteine also acts as an anti-inflammatory as well as increases extracellular glutamate by activating the Xc cystine-glutamate anti-transporter. These multiple actions of minocycline and N-acetylcysteine have made them attractive candidates to treat traumatic brain injury. When first dosed within the one hour after injury, either minocycline or N-acetylcysteine improves a diverse set of therapeutic outcome measures in multiple traumatic brain injury animal models. A small number of clinical trials for traumatic brain injury have established the safety of minocycline or N-acetylcysteine and suggested that either drug has some efficacy. Preclinical studies have shown that minocycline plus N-acetylcysteine have positive synergy resulting in therapeutic effects and a more prolonged therapeutic time window not seen with the individual drugs. This review compares the actions of minocycline and N-acetylcysteine, individually and in combination. Evidence supports that the combination has greater utility to treat traumatic brain injury than the individual drugs.
Authors: Changchi Hsieh,1,* Panayiotis Tsokas,1,2,* Alejandro Grau-Perales,3 Edith Lesburguères,3,§ Joseph Bukai,4 Kunal Khanna,4 Joelle Chorny,4 Ain Chung,3,# Claudia Jou,5 Nesha S. Burghardt,5 Christine A. Denny,6 Rafael E. Flores-Obando,1 Benjamin Rush Hartley,1,& Laura Melissa Rodríguez Valencia,2 A. Iván Hernández,4 Peter J. Bergold,1,7 James E. Cottrell,2 Juan Marcos Alarcon,4 André Antonio Fenton,1,3 Todd Charlton Sacktor 1,2,7
Multiple drugs to treat traumatic brain injury (TBI) have failed clinical trials. Most drugs lose efficacy as the time interval increases between injury and treatment onset. Insufficient therapeutic time window is a major reason underlying failure in clinical trials. Few drugs have been developed with therapeutic time windows sufficiently long enough to treat TBI because little is known about which brain functions can be targeted if therapy is delayed hours to days after injury. We identified multiple injury parameters that are improved by first initiating treatment with the drug combination minocycline (MINO) plus N-acetylcysteine (NAC) at 72 h after injury (MN72) in a mouse closed head injury (CHI) experimental TBI model. CHI produces spatial memory deficits resulting in impaired performance on Barnes maze, hippocampal neuronal loss, and bilateral damage to hippocampal neurons, dendrites, spines and synapses. MN72 treatment restores Barnes maze acquisition and retention, protects against hippocampal neuronal loss, limits damage to dendrites, spines and synapses, and accelerates recovery of microtubule associated protein 2 (MAP2) expression, a key protein in maintaining proper dendritic architecture and synapse density. These data show that in addition to the structural integrity of the dendritic arbor, spine and synapse density can be successfully targeted with drugs first dosed days after injury. Retention of substantial drug efficacy even when first dosed 72 h after injury makes MINO plus NAC a promising candidate to treat clinical TBI.
PKMζ is an autonomously active PKC isoform crucial for the maintenance of synaptic long-term potentiation (LTP) and long-term memory. Unlike other protein kinases that are transiently stimulated by second messengers, PKMζ is persistently activated through sustained increases in kinase protein expression. Therefore, visualizing increases in PKMζ expression during long-term memory storage might reveal the sites of its persistent action and thus the location of memory-associated LTP maintenance in the brain. Using quantitative immunohistochemistry validated by the lack of staining in PKMζ-null mice, we examined the amount and distribution of PKMζ in subregions of the hippocampal formation of wild-type mice during LTP maintenance and spatial long-term memory storage. During LTP maintenance in hippocampal slices, PKMζ increases in the pyramidal cell body and stimulated dendritic layers of CA1 for at least 2 h. During spatial memory storage, PKMζ increases in CA1 pyramidal cells for at least 1 month, paralleling the persistence of the memory. The subset of CA1 pyramidal cells that are tagged by immediate early gene Arc-driven transcription of fluorescent proteins, whose expression increases during initial memory formation, also expresses the persistent increase of PKMζ during memory storage. In the memory-tagged cells, the increased PKMζ expression persists in dendritic compartments within stratum radiatum for 1 month, indicating the long-term storage of information in the CA3-to-CA1 pathway during remote spatial memory. We conclude that persistent increases in PKMζ trace the molecular mechanism of LTP maintenance and thus the sites of information storage within brain circuitry during long-term memory.
Comorbid post-traumatic stress disorder with traumatic brain injury (TBI) produce more severe affective and cognitive deficits than PTSD or TBI alone. Both PTSD and TBI produce long-lasting neuroinflammation, which may be a key underlying mechanism of the deficits observed in co-morbid TBI/PTSD. We developed a model of co-morbid TBI/PTSD by combining the closed head (CHI) model of TBI with the chronic variable stress (CVS) model of PTSD and examined multiple behavioral and neuroinflammatory outcomes. Male C57/Bl6 mice received sham treatment, CHI, CVS, CHI then CVS (CHI → CVS) or CVS then CHI (CVS → CHI). The CVS → CHI group had deficits in Barnes maze or active place avoidance not seen in the other groups. The CVS → CHI, CVS and CHI → CVS groups displayed increased basal anxiety level, based on performance on elevated plus maze. The CVS → CHI had impaired performance on Barnes Maze, and Active Place Avoidance. These performance deficits were strongly correlated with increased hippocampal Iba-1 level an indication of activated MP/MG. These data suggest that greater cognitive deficits in the CVS → CHI group were due to increased inflammation. The increased deficits and neuroinflammation in the CVS → CHI group suggest that the order by which a subject experiences TBI and PTSD is a major determinant of the outcome of brain injury in co-morbid TBI/PTSD.
Traumatic brain injury (TBI) is a major cause of death and disability. Despite its importance in public health, there are presently no drugs to treat TBI. Many reasons underlie why drugs have failed clinical trials, one reason is that most drugs to treat TBI lose much of their efficacy before patients are first treated. This review discusses the importance of therapeutic time window; the time interval between TBI onset and the initiation of treatment. Therapeutic time window is complex, as brain injury is both acute and chronic, resulting in multiple drug targets that appear and disappear with differing kinetics. The speed and increasing complexity of TBI pathophysiology is a major reason why drugs lose efficacy as time to first dose increases. Recent Phase III clinical trials treated moderate to severe TBI patients within 4-8 h after injury, yet they turned away many potential patients who could not be treated within these time windows. Additionally, most head trauma is mild TBI. Unlike moderate to severe TBI, patients with mild TBI often delay treatment until their symptoms do not abate. Thus, drugs to treat moderate to severe TBI likely will need to retain high efficacy for up to 12 h after injury; drugs for mild TBI, however, will likely need even longer windows. Early pathological events following TBI progress with similar kinetics in humans and animal TBI models suggesting that preclinical testing of time windows assists the design of clinical trials. We reviewed preclinical studies of drugs first dosed later than 4 h after injury. This review showed that therapeutic time window can differ depending upon the animal TBI model and the outcome measure. We identify the few drugs (methamphetamine, melanocortin, minocycline plus N-acetylcysteine, and cycloserine) that demonstrated good therapeutic windows with multiple outcome measures. On the basis of their therapeutic window, these drugs appear to be excellent candidates for clinical trials. In addition to further testing of these drugs, we recommend that the assessment of therapeutic time window with multiple outcome measures becomes a standard component of preclinical drug testing.
May 9, 2019April 9, 2019Free AccessRestoration of Barnes maze, Protein Kinase Mζ and MAP2 by Minocycline plus NAcetylcysteine when first dosed 72 hours after experimental traumatic brain injury (P5.6-014)Syed Rahman, Elena Nikulina, Michael Vaysblat, Kristen Whitney, and Peter BergoldAuthors Info & AffiliationsApril 9, 2019 issue92 (15_supplement) Letters to the Editor