Shelter-oriented temperate reef fish species are known to utilize oyster aquaculture cages as habitat. To determine whether differences in the structural design of cages affects fish association with aquaculture gear, underwater video census was used to compare fish abundance, and community composition on two off-bottom cage designs (shelf and bag vs. stacked tray) for aquaculture of eastern oysters (Crassostrea virginica) at farms located in Milford, Norwalk, and Westport, Connecticut (CT) on seven occasions between June and September 2019. Recording on shelf and bag cages was also conducted intermittently at Milford only from 2017 to 2022. Black sea bass, cunner, scup, and tautog were observed throughout all study periods, at all locations, and on both cage designs. During 2019, abundance of black sea bass, tautog, and total fish abundance varied across farms. There were no statistically significant differences in individual species abundance or in overall fish community composition between cage designs. The shelf and bag cages provided a greater volume of accessible interior space to fish with more epifaunal growth on surfaces as compared to stacked tray cages. Seasonally, fish abundance was highest from July to September, declined in November, remained low through winter, and increased in late April. While the maximum abundance of the most common fish varied among years, these species were consistently present during all study years. Our results suggest that shelf and bag and stacked tray cages provided equivalent habitats for temperate reef fish, and that oyster farms in Long Island Sound consistently provided habitat to these species from late spring through fall over 6 years of observations.

Objective Black Sea Bass Centropristis striata are a temperate reef finfish that occupy natural and artificial structured habitats. This study used fish behavior, condition indices, and production estimates to evaluate how oyster aquaculture cages serve as artificial reefs for Black Sea Bass in central Long Island Sound, USA.Methods Underwater video was recorded on oyster farms and a natural rock reef to identify and quantify the behavior of Black Sea Bass that is associated with oyster aquaculture cages and boulders. Juvenile Black Sea Bass were sampled from farms and reefs in Clinton and Milford, Connecticut, to assess individual energy density and relative condition factor as measures of habitat quality. Proximate analysis was conducted to develop a predictive regression for percentage of dry weight and energy density in juvenile Black Sea Bass, which was then applied to estimate energy density in fish that were collected from farms and reefs. The abundance of young-of-the-year Black Sea Bass was used to quantify fish production on the oyster farms.Results Significantly greater shelter and grouping activity were observed on cages than were observed among boulders. Instances of courtship/reproduction in mature fish, escape, foraging, and territorial behavior were statistically similar across the cage and boulder habitats. The condition metrics of energy density and relative condition factor showed no difference in the physiological status of juvenile fish that inhabited farms versus reefs. The enhanced production of Black Sea Bass was estimated to be 4.1 kg/100 cages per year based on higher abundance of young-of-the-year fish on farms relative to the rock reef reference habitat.Conclusions Our results suggest that aquaculture gear provides valuable habitat services that are similar to those obtained via other man-made structures that are considered essential fish habitat for Black Sea Bass throughout their life history. Oyster aquaculture cage farms demonstrably function as artificial reefs and valuable habitat for Black Sea Bass. Information on the quality of habitat services and local population enhancement that are provided to this species by oyster gear can inform resource managers who make decisions about aquaculture permitting and designations of essential fish habitat.

Cultivation of eastern oysters using aquaculture gear increases habitat for temperate reef fish. Cunner (Tautogolabrus adspersus), scup (Stenotomus chrysops) and tautog (Tautoga onitis) inhabit a variety of complex natural and manmade habitats, including oyster aquaculture cage farms. Underwater video was recorded on two cage farms and a rock reef during May-September 2018 to quantify fish behavioural interactions and to assess ecological services provided by aquaculture gear, relative to natural structured seafloor. To collect video, action cameras were mounted on four study cages at a high-density farm of 40-100 commercial cages (dense farm), on four single cages interspersed on low relief seafloor (sparse farm) and adjacent to four boulders on a rock reef (rock reef), within an embayment off Milford, Connecticut in Long Island Sound (NW Atlantic). Video was recorded hourly in 8-min segments from 7 AM to 7 PM. Behaviours associated with habitat provisioning (e.g., courtship/reproduction, escape from predators, foraging, sheltering, schooling/grouping, territoriality) were observed for all three fish species on cages and boulders. Foraging and sheltering activity in cunner was significantly higher on cages than boulders while territorial behaviour occurred more frequently on boulders. Instances of escape from predators, foraging and sheltering behaviours in scup and tautog were significantly higher on cages than on boulders. Courtship/reproduction, grouping and territoriality were also higher on cages than boulders in tautog. Our results suggest that oyster cages confer ecological services that fulfil the basic biological and functional requirements of reef-oriented fish, and provide habitat attributes afforded by natural rock reefs.

Abstract Numerous policy and international frameworks consider that “destructive fishing” hampers efforts to reach sustainability goals. Though ubiquitous, “destructive fishing” is undefined and therefore currently immeasurable. Here we propose a definition developed through expert consultation: “Destructive fishing is any fishing practice that causes irrecoverable habitat degradation, or which causes significant adverse environmental impacts, results in long‐term declines in target or nontarget species beyond biologically safe limits and has negative livelihood impacts.” We show strong stakeholder support for a definition, consensus on many biological and ecological dimensions, and no clustering of respondents from different sectors. Our consensus definition is a significant step toward defining sustainable fisheries goals and will help interpret and implement global political commitments which utilize the term “destructive fishing.” Our definition and results will help reinforce the Food and Agricultural Organization's Code of Conduct and meaningfully support member countries to prohibit destructive fishing practices.

Robust impact assessments (IAs) for deep-sea fisheries are essential for safeguarding deep-sea ecosystems against the impacts of bottom fishing. In the high seas, United Nations Resolution commitments require States (independently or through Regional Fisheries Management Organisations (RFMOs)) to conduct IAs to evaluate if fishing is putting vulnerable marine ecosystems (VMEs) at risk. To enhance the efficacy of future IAs, this study evaluated nine IAs against the criteria in the FAO International Guidelines for the Management of Deep-Sea Fisheries in the High Seas. We find that in all IAs, the information required by the FAO Guidelines is either completely lacking or only partially addressed. The main shortcoming of the IAs was inadequate description of the ecosystems potentially affected by fishing. Additional shortcomings include incomplete description of the proposed fishing activities, lack of baseline data and risk assessments, and limited consideration of the indirect impacts of fishing. This study identifies several ways to strengthen the IA process; i) making IAs publicly available; ii) improved collection of baseline data and VME identification; iii) assessment of impacts on broader range of species associated with VMEs or potentially impacted by deep-sea fishing; iv) enhanced cooperation between RFMOs and more streamlined IA processes; v) comprehensive assessment of different types of impacts from fishing and climate change, and vii) improved consideration of uncertainty. Fully compliant IAs are a minimum requirement for the effective function of RFMOs, since they are the primary tool for preventing significant adverse impacts upon vulnerable marine ecosystems and the wider deep-sea environment.

Demersal deep-sea fish assemblages from islands and seamounts are poorly described, even in the Hawaiian archipelago. Knowledge across all depths, in similar settings, is even sparser for other archipelagos in the central and western Pacific. However, recent remotely operated vehicle (ROV) explorations and archived video from human-occupied submersible dives conducted by the Hawai`i Undersea Research Laboratory (HURL) provide an opportunity to explore the structure of these assemblages. Here we describe demersal fish assemblages across the central and western Pacific, including in four Marine National Monuments, and examine the relationship of the assemblages to depth and environmental conditions. We used data collected from 227 underwater vehicle dives resulting in the identification of 24,837 individuals belonging to 89 families and 175 genera. The most frequently occurring genera at depths of 250-500 m were Epigonus, Setarches, Polymixia, and Antigonia, between 500-1000 m were Chlorophthalmus, Aldrovandia, and Neocyttus, and between 1000-3000 m were Synaphobranchus, Kumba, Halosaurus, Ilyophis, and Ipnops. There are strong changes in the fish assemblages with depth and region, and assemblages become more similar between regions with greater depth. Depth and region explained the most variance in assemblage structure followed by seafloor particulate organic carbon flux (a food supply proxy), concentrations of dissolved oxygen, and salinity. The Line Islands and Tokelau Ridge had the highest values of seafloor particulate organic carbon flux for all depth zones investigated (250-3000 m) and the highest abundance of fishes at 250-500 m and 500-1000 m, respectively. Taxon accumulation curves indicated that diversity at the genus level within all regions and depth bins (except 1000-2000 m and 2000-3000 m) had not been reached with the existing sampling effort. However, when combining samples from all regions, diversity generally appeared to decrease with depth. Overall, this study demonstrates that there are significant regional differences in the composition of the deep-sea fish fauna as well as differences across depth. Such distribution patterns suggest that the four Marine National Monuments (Papahānaumokuākea, Marianas Trench, Pacific Remote Islands, and Rose Atoll Marine National Monuments, encompassing an area of 3,063,223 km2) are not replicates of diversity, but complementary components of the regional fauna.

Oyster aquaculture gear may augment natural seafloor by providing structured habitat for economically important fish species. Underwater video census was used to assess fish abundance and community composition on eastern oyster (Crassostrea virginica) shelf and bag style aquaculture off-bottom cages and within natural rock reef habitat. During 2018, underwater cameras were mounted on four study cages at a dense shellfish farm of 40-100 commercial cages (dense cage farm), on four single cages interspersed on low relief seafloor (sparse cage farm), and amongst four boulders on a rock reef (rock reef), within an embayment off Milford, Connecticut, which is part of Long Island Sound, in the United States. In 2019, cameras were similarly deployed on two study cages per farm at each of three shellfish farms off Milford, Norwalk and Westport, CT. Video was recorded hourly in eight-minute segments from 7 am to 7 pm. Data loggers monitored seawater temperature, light intensity, and current speed. Fish abundance (MaxN) was calculated for all videos. We compared fish abundance and community composition between May and September, on cage and boulder habitat, on cages at dense and sparse farms and on cages across farm locations. In 2018, abundance of black sea bass (Centropristis striata), scup (Stenotomus chrysops) and tautog (Tautoga onitis) was significantly higher on cages than boulders, regardless of cage number. Cunner (Tautogolabrus adspersus) abundance was significantly higher on boulders than cages when cage sites were grouped. However pairwise comparisons indicated that cunner were significantly higher at the sparse cage farm versus the rock reef but cunner abundance on the dense cage farm and rock reef sites was not significantly different. Abundance of black sea bass, scup, tautog, and cunner were not significantly different across 2019 farm locations. Young-of-the-year fish occurred episodically at all sites during both years, with black sea bass and scup most abundant. Fish abundance corresponded to seasonal changes in seawater temperature and was highest at the warmest temperatures. Light intensity and current speed explained less variation in fish abundance relative to temperature, and relationships were inconsistent across habitats and farm locations Our results suggest that multi-tiered oyster aquaculture cages contribute structure to seafloor environments that provide habitat for temperate reef fish similar to natural rock reefs.

Multi-tiered oyster aquaculture cages may provide habitat for fish assemblages similar to natural structured seafloor. Methods were developed to assess fish assemblages associated with aquaculture gear and boulder habitat using underwater video census combined with environmental DNA (eDNA) metabarcoding. Action cameras were mounted on 3 aquaculture cages at a commercial eastern oyster Crassostrea virginica farm (‘cage’) and among 3 boulders on a natural rock reef (‘boulder’) from June to August 2017 in Long Island Sound, USA. Interval and continuous video recording strategies were tested. During interval recording, cameras collected 8 min video segments hourly from 07:00 to 19:00 h on cages only. Continuous video was also collected for 2-3 h on oyster cages and boulders. Data loggers recorded light intensity and current speed. Seawater was collected for eDNA metabarcoding on the reef and farm. MaxN measurements of fish abundance were calculated in video, and 7 fish species were observed. Black sea bass Centropristis striata , cunner Tautogolabrus adspersus , scup Stenotomus chrysops , and tautog Tautoga onitis were the most abundant species observed in both oyster cage and boulder videos. In continuous video, black sea bass, scup, and tautog were observed more frequently and at higher abundance on the cage farm, while cunner were observed more frequently and at higher abundance on boulders within the rock reef. eDNA metabarcoding detected 42 fish species at the farm and reef. Six species were detected using both methods. Applied in tandem, video recording and eDNA provided a comprehensive approach for describing fish assemblages in difficult to sample structured oyster aquaculture and boulder habitats.

Climate change is impacting the function and distribution of habitats used by marine, coastal, and diadromous species. These impacts often exacerbate the anthropogenic stressors that habitats face, particularly in the coastal environment. We conducted a climate vulnerability assessment of 52 marine, estuarine, and riverine habitats in the Northeast U.S. to develop an ecosystem-scale understanding of the impact of climate change on these habitats. The trait-based assessment considers the overall vulnerability of a habitat to climate change to be a function of two main components, sensitivity and exposure, and relies on a process of expert elicitation. The climate vulnerability ranks ranged from low to very high, with living habitats identified as the most vulnerable. Over half of the habitats examined in this study are expected to be impacted negatively by climate change, while four habitats are expected to have positive effects. Coastal habitats were also identified as highly vulnerable, in part due to the influence of non-climate anthropogenic stressors. The results of this assessment provide regional managers and scientists with a tool to inform habitat conservation, restoration, and research priorities, fisheries and protected species management, and coastal and ocean planning.

Predation is an important process influencing the structure of fish communities. There are multiple approaches used to quantify predatory interactions, and all approaches are beneficial but have their limitations. For example, food habit studies only represent results of successful predation events, direct observations by divers are time limited by both depth and temperature as well as observer effects, acoustic approaches cannot directly identify species, and video has field-of-view constraints when using standard cameras. While no approach is without constraints, the recent availability of small off-the-shelf virtual reality (VR) video cameras that can be used in marine environments offers a more spatially comprehensive field-of-view for conducting studies of community composition and species interactions both on the seafloor and in the overlying water column. Here, we demonstrate an approach for collection and analysis of data from stationary VR video to quantify predator-prey interactions at subtropical reefs in Gray’s Reef National Marine Sanctuary (NW Atlantic). This approach does not substitute for other widely used census and behavioral research approaches but augments those with unique analytical products and interpretation.

The concept of “vulnerable marine ecosystem” (VME) was included in United Nations (UN) General Assembly Resolution 61/105 as part of an international effort to minimize the effects of seafloor fisheries on the high seas. However, defining a VME was left to be developed by technical guidance to the UN Food and Agricultural Organization. In that venue certain categories of organisms were deemed to be indicator species, suggesting that areas with those species would be considered VMEs with subsequent management measures implemented to conserve those ecosystem attributes. We note that on seamounts VME indicator species can be distributed widely, in dense clusters or sparsely. A dense cluster, for example, of scleractinian corals or sponges, is most often referred to as a VME, but we argue that any such dense cluster is not an ecosystem, rather it is a community, likely one of many that make up the ecosystem. Other communities on the seamount that are not part of that dense cluster could include many small species (some yet to be discovered) who are also part of the ecosystem because they are part of the web of interactions and flow of materials/energy on the seamount. We also suggest that a seamount ecosystem might extend over several or many seamounts in a biogeographic area. We conclude that the term “ecosystem” in the VME concept outlined by the United Nations needs to be re-evaluated from a classical ecological perspective leading to spatial management approaches that better address ecologically relevant space and time scales.

One of today's greatest conservation challenges is balancing policies, laws, and management strategies established to achieve economic goals that depend on extracting ocean resources with those established to conserve marine biodiversity. We use the Northeast Canyons and Seamounts Marine National Monument (NCSM) as a case study to explore the consequences of changing from a policy that prevents fishing to a fisheries management policy. We found that opening the NCSM to commercial fishing reduces species protections. Fishing with pelagic and bottom tending fixed gear exposes species inhabiting the sea surface and midwater regions to entanglement and bycatch risk. Fishing with bottom tending fixed gear also exposes deep-sea coral habitat to gear known to have detrimental impacts. The NCSM was designated as a marine national monument due to the area's unique ecological resources that are a subject of scientific interest. Our case study demonstrates that a fisheries management policy is insufficient to protect these ecological resources.

Glacier Bay National Park and Preserve (GBNPP) in Southeast Alaska is a system of glaciated fjords with a unique and recent history of deglaciation. As such, it can serve as a natural laboratory for studying patterns of distribution in marine communities with proximity to glacial influence. In order to examine the changes in fjord-based coral communities, underwater photo-quadrats were collected during multipurpose dives with a remotely operated vehicle (ROV) in March of 2016. Ten sites were chosen to represent the geochronological and oceanographic gradients present in GBNPP. Each site was surveyed vertically between 100 and 420 meters depth and photo-quadrats were extracted from the video strip transects for analysis. The ROV was equipped with onboard CTD which recorded environmental data (temperature and salinity), in order to confirm the uniformity of these characteristics at depth across the fjords. The percent cover and diversity of species were lowest near the glaciated heads of the fjords and highest in the Central Channel and at the mouths of the fjords. Diversity is highest where characteristics such as low sedimentation and increased tidal currents are predominant. The diverse communities at the mouths of the fjords and in the Central Channel were dominated by large colonies of the Red Tree Coral, Primnoa pacifica, as well as sponges, brachiopods, multiple species of cnidarians, echinoderms, molluscs and arthropods. The communities at the heads of the fjords were heavily dominated by pioneering species such as brachiopoda, hydrozoan turf, the encrusting stoloniferan coral Sarcodyction incrustans, and smaller colonies of P. pacifica. This research documents a gradient of species dominance from the Central Channel to the heads of the glaciated fjords, which is hypothesized to be driven by a combination of physical and biological factors such as glacial sedimentation, nutrient availability, larval dispersal, and competition.

The American sand lance (Ammodytes americanus, Ammodytidae) and the Northern sand lance (A. dubius, Ammodytidae) are small forage fishes that play an important functional role in the Northwest Atlantic Ocean (NWA). The NWA is a highly dynamic ecosystem currently facing increased risks from climate change, fishing and energy development. We need a better understanding of the biology, population dynamics and ecosystem role of Ammodytes to inform relevant management, climate adaptation and conservation efforts. To meet this need, we synthesized available data on the (a) life history, behaviour and distribution; (b) trophic ecology; (c) threats and vulnerabilities; and (d) ecosystem services role of Ammodytes in the NWA. Overall, 72 regional predators including 45 species of fishes, two squids, 16 seabirds and nine marine mammals were found to consume Ammodytes. Priority research needs identified during this effort include basic information on the patterns and drivers in abundance and distribution of Ammodytes, improved assessments of reproductive biology schedules and investigations of regional sensitivity and resilience to climate change, fishing and habitat disturbance. Food web studies are also needed to evaluate trophic linkages and to assess the consequences of inconsistent zooplankton prey and predator fields on energy flow within the NWA ecosystem. Synthesis results represent the first comprehensive assessment of Ammodytes in the NWA and are intended to inform new research and support regional ecosystem-based management approaches.

Long Island Sound (LIS) is a large estuary on the Atlantic coast of the highly developed northeast United States. However, limited spatially comprehensive habitat information has been available at sufficient resolution to inform planning and management of conflicting uses. A pilot project was conducted at a site with diverse topography and sediment characteristics in central LIS. The aim of the study was to develop methodologies to characterize the variety of benthic habitats and infaunal and epifaunal communities. This information was then used to produce habitat maps to inform stakeholders and decision-makers. Backscatter was processed using supervised segmentation with final acoustic "habitat" patches defined by sediment grain size, bathymetry, slope, and a topographic roughness index. Ecological attributes were determined using diversity indices and multivariate and image analyses of species composition data collected seasonally via grab samples, photography, and video. Some community dominants exhibited stability across seasons while others were seasonal in occurrence. Linkages between species and community distributions to seafloor characteristics occurred across multiple spatial scales. An integrated habitat map synthesized the general characteristics of seafloor habitats and associated species to provide a first order visualization of this complex subtidal landscape.

Using a combination of data obtained from high-definition still images, video, and specimens collected during human-occupied submersible and remotely-operated vehicle dives spanning the period 2003 to 2014, we provide the first detailed characterization of the megabenthic assemblages in the lower bathyal on the New England and Corner Rise Seamounts in the Northwest Atlantic. Over all, the New England Seamounts east from Retriever to Nashville have a more diverse megabenthic fauna than Corner Rise, but the lowest diversity was observed on the three seamounts located closest to the continental margin. The megabenthic assemblage structure varies both within and across seamounts, and hierarchical cluster analysis revealed groups dependent on location (as measured by longitude) and depth, with substrate composition an additional but less significant factor at the regional scale. We conclude that the megabenthos assemblages in the bathyal Northwest Atlantic are determined, at the regional scale, by the water masses in which they reside.

The Northeast Canyons and Seamounts Marine National Monument (NECSMNM) was designated by President Barack Obama in 2016, using his authority under the Antiquities Act of 1906. The Act allows a President to proclaim as national monuments “historic landmarks, historic and prehistoric structures, and other objects of historic or scientific interest” that are “upon the lands owned or controlled” by the United States but to reserve each designation to “the smallest area compatible with the proper care and management of the objects to be protected.” Protection in general excludes commercial scale extraction and is in perpetuity. Here we present analyses of physiographic and ecological datasets that facilitated assessment of the conservation benefits of protections for a new monument. We also review and synthesize the ecological literature to describe processes that operate in continental margin and deep-sea settings, in order to demonstrate the monument area is bounded for proper management and is an object of scientific interest. Results indicate that the current monument designation is an area of high diversity and ecological connectivity across depths and along the continental margin. The monument boundaries contain hot spots (areas of high abundance and species richness) for seafloor communities (inclusive of benthic invertebrate and demersal fish) as well as marine mammals in the epipelagic. Many species are sensitive to disturbance and vulnerable to human activities (e.g., deep-sea corals and sponges) with very long recovery times and extremely low resilience. The monument contains at least nine exemplars of offshore northwest Atlantic marine wildlife communities and habitats (e.g., deep shelf invertebrates, shelf fish, deep sea corals and sponges in canyons and on seamounts, deep sea fish, chemosynthetic communities, deep sea soft sediment, shelf edge cetaceans, and seabirds). The region is relatively undisturbed and can serve as a reference site to focus future research on ecological processes in an increasingly industrialized ocean and one subject to the synergies of regional climate effects. These results suggest that there is great potential for discovery and novel research in this first Atlantic Ocean Marine National Monument.

We observed sea turtles with time-lapse video cameras (deployed for studies of fish behavior during June 2017) at "live-bottom" reefs in depths of 18-20 m within Gray's Reef National Marine Sanctuary off the coast of Georgia, USA (NW Atlantic). These reefs, sandstone ledges emerging from surrounding sand seafloor, were deeply undercut and apparently served as resting habitat for turtles to wedge themselves between sand seafloor and hard rock overhead. We observed 22 distinct individuals over 27 occurrences including 10 Caretta caretta (L.) (Loggerhead), 3 Chelonia mydas (L.) (Green Sea Turtle), and 9 unidentified to species based on individual markings. We documented resting periods up to 144 minutes (mean = 37.2 min, SD = 39.1). Notable was that most observations (67%) occurred during twilight and night periods. To put these video observations in perspective, we analyzed diver observations of 34 turtles encountered at the surface prior to and during visual fish census surveys (2010-2017) at 18 ledges. Those ledges had significantly taller and deeper undercuts than 18 other ledges with no turtles (ANOSIM P = 0.043 and SIMPER comparisons). These limited observations indicate time-lapse video of seafloor habitats along with diver surveys may yield new insights into sea turtles' habitat requirements, patterns of site fidelity, and ecological role as ecosystem engineers, as well as effects on sea turtles of coincident human uses such as fishing, vessel use, and recreational diving.