Horizontal gene transfer introduces foreign DNA that can disrupt cellular processes and is therefore subject to xenogeneic silencing by nucleoid-associated proteins such as H-NS and Hha. In Enterohaemorrhagic Escherichia coli (EHEC), prophages make up a large fraction of the accessory genome and encode many virulence factors, yet their expression must overcome this silencing. We identify a prophage-encoded small RNA (sRNA), HnrS, that functions as an anti-silencing factor by targeting the H-NS paralogue Hha. HnrS is a short (66-nt) sRNA that is enriched in the locus of enterocyte effacement (LEE⁺) E. coli strains and present in up to nine copies in EHEC and Enteropathogenic Escherichia coli (EPEC) genomes. HnrS base-pairs with the hha ribosome-binding site to inhibit translation, thereby modulating Hha-H-NS repression of virulence loci including the LEE type III secretion system. Loss of HnrS alters motility, T3SS expression, and a subset of Hha-regulated genes. These findings reveal an RNA-based counter-silencing strategy encoded by prophage to relieve xenogenic silencing.
The bacterial flagellar filament acts as a propeller to drive most bacterial swimming. The filament is made of flagellin, known as FliC in Escherichia coli. FliC consists of four domains, the highly conserved core D0 and D1 domains and the hypervariable outer D2 and D3 domains. The size and structure of the outer domains vary, being completely absent in some bacterial species. Here, we sought to identify outer domains from various species that are compatible with the ability of E. coli K-12 FliC to form filaments capable of supporting motility. We calculated a phylogeny of 210 representative flagellin amino acid sequences and generated a series of FliC variants, including outer domain-deleted forms and 11 chimeric FliC mutants using domains from E. coli K-12, Salmonella Typhimurium, Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Collimonas fungivorans, Helicobacter mustelae, and Mesorhizobium sp. ORS3359 in various combinations. Notably, two of the chimeric fliC mutants rescued motility in a fliC-disrupted E. coli K-12 strain, both of which contained the S. Typhimurium D2 domain. Overall, we demonstrate that, while most FliC chimeras did not support motility, interchangeability of the outer domains can produce filaments that provide motility, providing insights to guide the design of synthetic flagellins.IMPORTANCEFlagellin is a key protein forming the filament of the bacterial flagellar motor which powers most bacterial swimming. Flagellin can have hypervariable domains which can alter motility in different environments and provide immune evasion. Here we engineered two flagellin chimeras that could drive motility. This indicates that the flagellin outer domains can be exchanged, to some degree, allowing us to refine rational design approaches for engineering of bacterial swimming. Our work shows the challenges to overcome when combining flagellins from different species and provides evidence that domain-switched flagellins can form filaments.
The rotation of the bacterial flagellum is powered by the MotAB stator complex, which converts ion flux into torque. Despite its central role in flagellar function, the evolutionary origin and structural diversity of this system remain poorly understood. Here, we present the first comprehensive phylogenetic and structural characterization of MotAB and its closest non-flagellar homologs. We gathered homologs from 205 genomes across 27 bacterial phyla, estimated phylogenies, inferred ancestral sequences, and predicted structures for both extant and inferred ancestral proteins using AlphaFold. Our analyses characterized two structurally distinct groups: flagellar ion transporters (FIT) and generic ion transporters (GIT). FIT proteins are structurally conserved, including a characteristic square fold domain and a torque-generating interface (TGI). We further delineate FIT proteins into two subgroups, TGI4 and TGI5s, based on the presence of 4 or 5 short helices within the TGI region. TGI5 motors, such as those found in the Escherichia coli K12 system, are primarily restricted to Pseudomonadota, whereas TGI4 motors, such as the Na+-powered polar motors of Vibrio (PomAB), are distributed across a broader range of bacterial lineages. In contrast, GIT proteins exhibit substantial structural and functional heterogeneity and lack features associated with flagellar motility. Nevertheless, a conserved interaction between the A and B subunits is retained across FIT and GIT proteins, with their corresponding genes typically adjacent to operons. Functional assays in E. coli show that FIT-specific structural elements are indispensable for flagellar motility. Our results suggest that the flagellar stator motor complex evolved once from a common ancestral ion transporter, acquiring unique structural traits to support motility. This work provides a robust framework for understanding the evolutionary diversification of stator complexes and their mechanistic specialization.IMPORTANCEFlagellar motility allows bacteria to propel themselves and direct movement according to environmental conditions. It plays a key role in bacterial pathogenicity and survival. We investigated the molecular and structural diversity of the stator motor proteins that provide the ion motive force to power flagellar rotation. This study uses a comparative approach that integrates phylogenetics, 3D protein structure, motility assays, and ancestral state reconstruction (ASR) to provide insights into the structural mechanisms that first powered the flagellar motor. We provide the first phylogenetic and structural characterization and classification of MotAB and relatives.
Many bacteria swim by the rotation of the bacterial flagellar motor (BFM). The BFM is powered by proton translocation across the inner membrane through the heteroheptameric MotA5MotB2 protein complex. Two periplasmic domains of MotB are critical in activating BFM rotation: (1) the peptidoglycan (PG) binding domain that anchors MotB in the PG layer and (2) the plug domain that modulates the proton flow. Existing cytoplasmic fluorescent probes have been shown to negatively affect motor rotation and switching. Here, we inserted a fluorescent probe in the periplasm near the plug of MotB to circumvent issues with cytoplasmic probes and for possible use in observing the mechanism of plug-based regulation of proton flow. We inserted green fluorescent protein and improved light-oxygen-voltage (LOV), a fluorescent version of the LOV domain, in four periplasmic locations in MotB. Insertions near the plug retained motility but showed limited fluorescence for both fluorophores. Additional short, flexible glycine-serine linkers improved motility but did not improve brightness. Further optimization is necessary to improve the fluorescence of these periplasmic probes.
ABSTRACT Powered by ion transport across the cell membrane, conserved ion-powered rotary motors (IRMs) drive bacterial motility by generating torque on the rotor of the bacterial flagellar motor. Homologous heteroheptameric IRMs have been structurally characterized in ion channels such as Tol/Ton/Exb/Gld, and most recently in phage defense systems such as Zor. Functional stator complexes synthesized from chimeras of PomB/MotB (PotB) have been used to study flagellar rotation at low ion-motive force achieved via reduced external sodium concentration. The function of such chimeras is highly sensitive to the location of the fusion site, and these hybrid proteins have thus far been arbitrarily designed. To date, no chimeras have been constructed using interchange of components from Tol/Ton/Exb/Gld and other ion-powered motors with more distant homology. Here, we synthesized chimeras of MotAB, PomAPotB, and ExbBD to assess their capacity for cross-compatibility. We generated motile strains powered by stator complexes with B-subunit chimeras. This motility was further optimized by directed evolution. Whole-genome sequencing of these strains revealed that motility-enhancing residue changes occurred in the A-subunit and at the peptidoglycan binding domain of the B-unit, which could improve motility. Overall, our work highlights the complexity of stator architecture and identifies the challenges associated with the rational design of chimeric IRMs. IMPORTANCE Ion-powered rotary motors (IRMs) underpin the rotation of one of nature’s oldest wheels, the flagellar motor. Recent structures show that this complex appears to be a fundamental molecular module with diverse biological utility where electrical energy is coupled to torque. Here, we attempted to rationally design chimeric IRMs to explore the cross-compatibility of these ancient motors. We succeeded in making one working chimera of a flagellar motor and a non-flagellar transport system protein. This had only a short hybrid stretch in the ion-conducting channel, and function was subsequently improved through additional substitutions at sites distant from this hybrid pore region. Our goal was to test the cross-compatibility of these homologous systems and highlight challenges arising when engineering new rotary motors.
The rotation of the bacterial flagellum is powered by the MotAB stator complex, which converts ion flux into torque. The origin and evolution of this remarkable complex is understudied. Here, we perform the first phylogenetic and structural characterisation and classification of MotAB and nonflagellar relatives. Using 193 genomes sampled across 27 bacterial phyla, we estimated phylogenies and ancestral sequences, and generated AlphaFold predictions for all extant and reconstructed proteins. We then mapped them onto the phylogeny to determine patterns of diversity and distribution of structural innovations. We identify two discrete groups: the Flagellar Ion Transporters (FIT) and the Generic Ion Transporters (GIT). The FIT proteins are structurally conserved and have a square fold domain and a torque-generating interface (TGI). FIT proteins are divided into two clades, termed TGI4 and TGI5, referring to whether there have 4 or 5 short helices in the TGI. TGI5 motors are predominantly found in Proteobacteria and include the well-studied E. coli K12 system, while TGI4 motors are found in diverse phyla and include the Na+-powered polar motors of Vibrio (PomAB). The GIT proteins, on the other hand, are structurally diverse and lack these attributes. The interaction between the A and B subunits is conserved across the FIT and GIT proteins. The two subunits are jointly necessary for function, with the genes typically adjacent within an operon. Motility assays in E. coli show that the structural elements unique to FIT play an important role in flagellar motility. Our results indicate that the stator motor complex has a single origin and shares unique motility-related structural traits. Significance Statement Flagellar motility is a key feature in bacterial pathogenicity and survival. It allows bacteria to propel themselves and direct movement according to environmental conditions. We investigated the molecular and structural diversity of the stator motor proteins that provide the ion motive force to power flagellar rotation. This study integrates phylogenetics, 3D protein structure modeling, motility assays and ancestral state reconstruction (ASR) to provide insights into the structural mechanisms that first powered the flagellar motor. We provide the first phylogenetic and structural characterisation and classification of MotAB and relatives. ### Competing Interest Statement The authors have declared no competing interest.
Many bacteria swim driven by an extracellular filament rotated by the bacterial flagellar motor. This motor is powered by the stator complex, MotA5 MotB2 , an heptameric complex which forms an ion channel which couples energy from the ion motive force to torque generation. Recent structural work revealed that stator complex consists of a ring of five MotA subunits which rotate around a central dimer of MotB subunits. Transmembrane (TM) domains TM3 and TM4 from MotA combine with the single TM domain from MotB to form two separate ion channels within this complex. Much is known about the ion binding site and ion specificity; however, to date, no modeling has been undertaken to explore the MotB-MotB dimer stability and the role of MotB conformational dynamics during rotation. Here, we modeled the central MotB dimer using coiled-coil engineering and modeling principles and calculated free energies to identify stable states in the operating cycle of the stator. We found three stable coiled-coil states with dimer interface angles of 28°, 56°, and 64°. We tested the effect of strategic mutagenesis on the comparative energy of the states and correlated motility with a specific hierarchy of stability between the three states. In general, our results indicate agreement with existing models describing a 36° rotation step of the MotA pentameric ring during the power stroke and provide an energetic basis for the coordinated rotation of the central MotB dimer based on coiled-coil modeling.
The bacterial flagellar motor (BFM) is a rotary nanomachine powered by the translocation of ions across the inner membrane through the stator complex. The stator complex consists of two membrane proteins: MotA and MotB (in H+-powered motors), or PomA and PomB (in Na+-powered motors). In this study, we used ancestral sequence reconstruction (ASR) to probe which residues of MotA correlate with function and may have been conserved to preserve motor function. We reconstructed 10 ancestral sequences of MotA and found four of them were motile in combination with contemporary Escherichia coli MotB and in combination with our previously published functional ancestral MotBs. Sequence comparison between wild-type (WT) E. coli MotA and MotA-ASRs revealed 30 critical residues across multiple domains of MotA that were conserved among all motile stator units. These conserved residues included pore-facing, cytoplasm-facing, and MotA-MotA intermolecular facing sites. Overall, this work demonstrates the role of ASR in assessing conserved variable residues in a subunit of a molecular complex.
Determining which cellular processes facilitate adaptation requires a tractable experimental model where an environmental cue can generate variants that rescue function. The bacterial flagellar motor (BFM) is an excellent candidate-an ancient and highly conserved molecular complex for bacterial propulsion toward favorable environments. Motor rotation is often powered by H+ or Na+ ion transit through the torque-generating stator subunit of the motor complex, and ion selectivity has adapted over evolutionary time scales. Here, we used CRISPR engineering to replace the native Escherichia coli H+-powered stator with Na+-powered stator genes and report the spontaneous reversion of our edit in a low-sodium environment. We followed the evolution of the stators during their reversion to H+-powered motility and used both whole-genome and RNA sequencing to identify genes in-volved in the cell's adaptation. Our transplant of an unfit protein and the cells' rapid response to this edit demonstrate the adaptability of the stator subunit and highlight the hierarchical modularity of the flagellar motor.
Motility provides a selective advantage to many bacterial species and is often achieved by rotation of flagella that propel the cell towards more favourable conditions. In most species, the rotation of the flagellum, driven by the Bacterial Flagellar Motor (BFM), is powered by H+ or Na+ ion transit through the torque-generating stator subunits of the motor complex. The ionic requirements for motility appear to have adapted to environmental changes throughout history but the molecular basis of this adaptation, and the constraints which govern the evolution of the stator proteins are unknown. Here we use CRISPR-mediated genome engineering to replace the native H+-powered stator genes of Escherichia coli with a compatible sodium-powered stator set from Vibrio alginolyticus and subsequently direct the evolution of the stators to revert to H+-powered motility. Evidence from whole genome sequencing indicates both flagellar- and non-flagellar-associated genes that are involved in longer-term adaptation to new power sources. Overall, transplanted Na+-powered stator genes can spontaneously incorporate novel mutations that allow H+-motility when environmental Na+ is lacking.
ABSTRACTLiposomes are widely used as synthetic analogues of cell membranes and for drug delivery. Lipid-binding DNA nanostructures can modify the shape, porosity and reactivity of liposomes, mediated by cholesterol-modifications. DNA nanostructures can also be designed to switch conformations by DNA strand displacement. However, the optimal conditions to facilitate stable, high-yield DNA-lipid binding while allowing controlled switching by strand-displacement are not known. Here we characterised the effect of cholesterol arrangement, DNA structure, buffer and lipid composition on DNA-lipid binding and strand displacement. We observed that binding was inhibited below pH 4, and above 200 mM NaCl or 40 mM MgCl2, was independent of lipid type, and increased with membrane cholesterol content. For simple motifs, binding yield was slightly higher for double-stranded DNA than single-stranded. For larger DNA origami tiles, 4 – 8 cholesterol modifications were optimal, while edge positions and longer spacers increased yield of lipid-binding. Strand displacement achieved controlled removal of DNA tiles from membranes, but was inhibited by overhang domains, which are used to prevent cholesterol aggregation. These findings provide design guidelines for integrating strand-displacement switching with lipid-binding DNA nanostructures. This paves the way for achieving dynamic control of membrane morphology, enabling broader applications in nanomedicine and biophysics.
Liposomes, aqueous vesicles enclosed by lipid bilayers, are widely used in research as simple, synthetic analogues of cell membranes. Membrane-binding DNA nanostructures have been developd whichh can modify the shape, porosity and reactivity of liposomes. Lipid-DNA binding is moderated using strands with hydrophobic or amphipathic chemical groups such as cholesterol. However, the factors that affect the binding interactions of cholesterol-modified DNA and membrane bilayers have not been systematically investigated. Here we characterise the effect of buffer and lipid composition and DNA structure near the cholesterol motif on the strength of DNA-lipid binding. We observed that DNA-membrane binding is inhibited at increasing ionic concentrations and that binding is severely reduced in strongly acidic conditions. Background membrane cholesterol content demonstrated a more varied effect, dependent on lipid composition. The composition of the DNA, whether simplex or duplex, showed little effect on binding, as did the presence or absence of a single-stranded ‘overhang’ to protect the cholesterol and prevent DNA strand aggregation. Our results inform the design and modelling of the membrane binding of cholesterolated DNA nanostructures.
The bacterial flagellar motor is driven by an ion flux that is converted to torque by motor-attendant complexes known as stators. The dynamics of stator assembly around the motor in response to external stimuli have been the subject of much recent research, but less is known about the evolutionary origins of stator complexes and how they select for specific ions. Here, we review the latest structural and biochemical data for the stator complexes and compare these with other ion transporters and microbial motors to examine possible evolutionary origins of the stator complex.
The human mechanosensitive ion channel PIEZO1 is gated by membrane tension and regulates essential biological processes such as vascular development and erythrocyte volume homeostasis. Currently, little is known about PIEZO1 plasma membrane localization and organization. Using a PIEZO1-GFP fusion protein, we investigated whether cholesterol enrichment or depletion by methyl-β-cyclodextrin (MBCD) and disruption of membrane cholesterol organization by dynasore affects PIEZO1-GFP’s response to mechanical force. Electrophysiological recordings in the cell-attached configuration revealed that MBCD caused a rightward shift in the PIEZO1-GFP pressure–response curve, increased channel latency in response to mechanical stimuli, and markedly slowed channel inactivation. The same effects were seen in native PIEZO1 in N2A cells. STORM superresolution imaging revealed that, at the nanoscale, PIEZO1-GFP channels in the membrane associate as clusters sensitive to membrane manipulation. Both cluster distribution and diffusion rates were affected by treatment with MBCD (5 mM). Supplementation of polyunsaturated fatty acids appeared to sensitize the PIEZO1-GFP response to applied pressure. Together, our results indicate that PIEZO1 function is directly dependent on the membrane composition and lateral organization of membrane cholesterol domains, which coordinate the activity of clustered PIEZO1 channels.
TRP channels of the transient receptor potential ion channel superfamily are involved in a wide variety of mechanosensory processes, including touch sensation, pain, blood pressure regulation, bone loading and detection of cerebrospinal fluid flow. However, in many instances it is unclear whether TRP channels are the primary transducers of mechanical force in these processes. In this study, we tested stretch activation of eleven TRP channels from six mammalian subfamilies. We found that these TRP channels were insensitive to short membrane stretches in cellular systems. Furthermore, we purified TRPC6 and demonstrated its insensitivity to stretch in liposomes, an artificial bilayer system free from cellular components. Additionally, we demonstrated that, when expressed in C. elegans neurons, mouse TRPC6 restores the mechanoresponse of a touch insensitive mutant but requires diacylglycerol for activation. These results strongly suggest that the mammalian members of the TRP ion channel family are insensitive to tension induced by cell membrane stretching and, thus, are more likely to be activated by cytoplasmic tethers or downstream components and to act as amplifiers of cellular mechanosensory signaling cascades.
Mechanosensitive ion channels are membrane gated pores which are activated by mechanical stimuli. The focus of this study is on Piezo1, a newly discovered, large, mammalian, mechanosensitive ion channel, which has been linked to diseases such as dehydrated hereditary stomatocytosis (Xerocytosis) and lymphatic dysplasia. Here we utilize an established in-vitro artificial bilayer system to interrogate single Piezo1 channel activity. The droplet-hydrogel bilayer (DHB) system uniquely allows the simultaneous recording of electrical activity and fluorescence imaging of labelled protein. We successfully reconstituted fluorescently labelled Piezo1 ion channels in DHBs and verified activity using electrophysiology in the same system. We demonstrate successful insertion and activation of hPiezo1-GFP in bilayers of varying composition. Furthermore, we compare the Piezo1 bilayer reconstitution with measurements of insertion and activation of KcsA channels to reproduce the channel conductances reported in the literature. Together, our results showcase the use of DHBs for future experiments allowing simultaneous measurements of ion channel gating while visualising the channel proteins using fluorescence.
Mechanosensitive (MS) ion channels are integral membrane proteins which play a crucial role in fast signaling during mechanosensory transduction processes in living cells. They are ubiquitous and old in the evolutionary sense, given their presence in cells from all three kingdoms of life found on Earth, including bacterial, archaeal, and eukaryotic organisms. As molecular transducers of mechanical force, MS channels are activated by mechanical stimuli exerted on cellular membranes, upon which they rapidly and efficiently convert these stimuli into electrical, osmotic, and/or chemical intracellular signals. Most of what we know about the gating mechanisms of MS channels comes from the work carried out on bacterial channels. However, recent progress resulting from identification and structural information of eukaryotic K2P-type TREK and TRAAK as well as Piezo1 and Piezo2 MS channels has greatly contributed to our understanding of the common biophysical principles underlying the gating mechanism and evolutionary origins of these fascinating membrane proteins. Using Piezo1 channels as an example, we briefly describe in this review what we have learned about their biophysics, physiological functions, and potential roles in “mechanopathologies.”
The human mechanosensitive ion channel PIEZO1 is gated by membrane tension and regulates essential biological processes such as vascular development and erythrocyte volume homeostasis [1,2,3]. Currently, little is known about PIEZO1 plasma membrane localization and organization. Using a PIEZO1-GFP fusion protein, we investigated whether cholesterol enrichment, depletion (methyl-β-Cyclodextrin; MBCD) and the disruption of membrane cholesterol organization (Dynasore) affects PIEZO1's response to mechanical force. STORM super-resolution imaging revealed that, at the nano-scale, PIEZO1 channels in the membrane associate as clusters which increase in number upon cholesterol addition. Both cluster size and diffusion rates were profoundly affected by treatment with MBCD (5 mM). In addition, electrophysiological recordings in the cell-attached configuration revealed that MBCD caused a rightward shift in the PIEZO1 pressure-response curve and increased channel latency in response to mechanical stimuli. Our results indicate that PIEZO1 function is directly dependent on the amount and lateral organization of membrane cholesterol which is crucial for the concerted inactivation of PIEZO1 clusters. 1 Cahalan SM, et al. Piezo1 links mechanical forces to red blood cell volume. eLife. 2015;4. 2 Rode B, et al. Piezo1 channels sense whole body physical activity to reset cardiovascular homeostasis and enhance performance. Nat Commun. 2017;8. 3 Li J, et al. Piezo1 integration of vascular architecture with physiological force. Nature, 2014. Supported by the Australian Research Council and the National Health and Medical Research Council of Australia.
The level of fatty acid saturation in phospholipids is a crucial determinant of the biophysical properties of the lipid bilayer. Integral membrane proteins are sensitive to changes of their bilayer environment such that their activities and localization can be profoundly affected. When incorporated into phospholipids of mammalian cells, poly-unsaturated fatty acids (PUFAs) determine the mechanical properties of the bilayer thereby affecting several membrane-associated functions such as endo- and exo-cytosis and ion channel/membrane receptor signalling cascades. In order to understand how membrane tension is propagated through poly-unsaturated bilayers, we characterized the effect of lipid saturation on liposome reconstituted MscS and MscL, the two bacterial mechanosensitive ion channels that have for many years served as models of ion- channel-mediated mechanotransduction. The combination of NMR and patch clamp experiments in this study demonstrate that bilayer thinning is the main responsible factor for the modulation of the MscL threshold of activation while a change in transbilayer pressure profile is indicated as the main factor behind the observed modulation of the MscS kinetics. Together, our data offer a novel insight into how the structural shape differences between the two types of mechanosensitive channels determine their differential modulation by poly-unsaturated phospholipids and thus lay the foundation for future functional studies of eukaryotic ion channels involved in the physiology of mechanosensory transduction processes in mammalian cells. Sumnway: Mechanosensitive channels MscL and MscS are differentially modulated by poly-unsaturated fatty acids in lipid bilayers. MscL becomes sensitized because of increased hydrophobic mismatch while MscS open state is stabilized due to changes in the bilayer lateral pressure profile determined by NMR.
Mechanical stimuli acting on the cellular membrane are linked to intracellular signaling events and downstream effectors via different mechanoreceptors. Mechanosensitive (MS) ion channels are the fastest known primary mechano-electrical transducers, which convert mechanical stimuli into meaningful intracellular signals on a submillisecond time scale. Much of our understanding of the biophysical principles that underlie and regulate conversion of mechanical force into conformational changes in MS channels comes from studies based on MS channel reconstitution into lipid bilayers. The bilayer reconstitution methods have enabled researchers to investigate the structure-function relationship in MS channels and probe their specific interactions with their membrane lipid environment. This brief review focuses on close interactions between MS channels and the lipid bilayer and emphasizes the central role that the transbilayer pressure profile plays in mechanosensitivity and gating of these fascinating membrane proteins.