In the context of management of the radioactive waste in deep geological formations, the effect of temperature (20-80 degrees C) on U(VI) adsorption by Callovo-Oxfordian claystone (COx) was studied. A step-by-step approach was followed, starting with the single mineral, illite, followed by an increase in the complexity of the system, through the analysis of the clay fraction and the natural samples of the Callovo-Oxfordian formation. Depending on the study conditions, and the speciation of U(VI) in solution (hydrolysed species, carbonate species and presence of ternary U(VI)-Ca(Mg)-carbonate complexes), the temperature effect was either negligible, or positive (where the increase in temperature favours retention). The most important positive effect was observed for the U(VI)/COx system in the presence of ternary complexes. The data were modelled considering an existing sorption model at 20 degrees C and the thermodynamic data available to describe the evolution of the speciation of U(VI) in solution in function of temperature. The enthalpy values associated with the surface complexes were fitted from the experimental data following a stepwise approach based on the van't Hoff equation.
In the context of the radioactive waste management in deep geological formations, U(VI) retention by intact Callovo-Oxfordian claystone (COx) was studied by percolation-type experiments at 20 and 80 degrees C. The experimental results were confronted with modelling prediction based on a published adsorption model developed from dispersed media in the 20-80 degrees C temperature range. For the experiments at 20 degrees C, the adsorption model allowed to explain the results for the intact system; the retention was weak (R-d similar to 10 L.kg(-1)) and the analysis of the COx phases at the end of the experiment confirmed a retention of U by the clay fraction. The adsorption model in temperature also explained the observed trend of increasing retention with increasing temperature. However, it underestimated the temperature effect on the adsorption of U(VI) by the COx clay fraction, and other phases contributed to the retention. Solid-state analysis of the percolation-doped samples indicated a reactivity in the order pyrite>clay>calcite phases. The transposition of the knowledge at 20 degrees C from the dispersed system to the intact medium was therefore not possible at 80 degrees C for the studied U(VI)/COx system.
For the performance assessment of radioactive waste disposal, it is critical to predict the mobility of radionuclides in the geological barrier that hosts it. A key challenge consists of assessing the transferability of current knowledge on the retention properties deduced from model systems to in natura situations. The case of the redox-sensitive element uranium in the Callovo-Oxfordian clay formation (COx) is presented herein. Extensive experimental work was carried out with respect to parameters affecting uranium speciation (pH, PCO2, [Ca] and redox potential) with illite, COx clay fraction and raw COx claystone. The "bottom-up" approach implemented, with illite and montmorillonite as reactive phases, quantitatively explains the adsorption results of U(VI) and U(IV) on COx. While retention is high for U(IV) (Rd∼104 L kg-1), it remains very low for U(VI) (Rd∼4 L kg-1) due to the formation of soluble ternary Ca(Mg)-U(VI)-carbonate complexes. The applicability of the sorption model was then assessed by comparing predictive analyses with data characterizing the behavior of naturally-occurring U (<3 mg kg-1). The COx clay phase is the largest reservoir of naturally-occurring U (∼65%) but only a small fraction appears to be adsorbed (∼1%). Under representative site conditions (especially with respect to reducing conditions), we have concluded that ternary U(VI) complexes control U speciation in solution while U(IV) surface species dominate U adsorption, with Rd values > 70 L kg-1.
Clay-rock formations are under investigation in several countries as a potential host of radioactive waste repositories. In order to assess the long-term safety of these concepts, retention distribution data (Rd) are needed to describe the interaction between radionuclides and natural rock. While Rd values obtained from batch-type experiments with dispersed material are essential for the development of retention models, it is also important to generate retention data under more realistic conditions, in particular with compact samples. Specifically, the literature data on strongly retained radionuclides proves to be very scarce. The present study focuses on the retention of europium (Eu) at trace concentrations on clay samples extracted from the Callovo-Oxfordian (COx) formation in France. Rd values obtained with compact COx samples are assessed by a methodology coupling percolation experiments (in pressurized microcells), performed using submillimeter-sized samples in thickness, and Laser Ablation Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometry measurements. The Rd found at trace concentrations under non-transient conditions are high (Rd > 10(4) mL g(-1)) and in agreement with those recorded under classical batch-type conditions or those deduced from the distribution of naturally-occurring Eu between the pore water and the clay rock. They can be described by modeling with existing sorption databases, considering an adsorption process only on the clay fraction. This was validated by solid state LA-ICP-MS analyses of one of the Eu-spiked COx samples; the added europium was found exclusively in the COx clay fraction.
Cement-based materials are key components in radioactive waste repository barrier systems. To improve the available knowledge base, the European CEBAMA (Cement-based materials) project aimed to provide insight on general processes and phenomena that can be easily transferred to different applications. A bottom up approach was used to study radionuclide retention by cementitious materials, encompassing both individual cement mineral phases and hardened cement pastes. Solubility experiments were conducted with Be, Mo and Se under high pH conditions to provide realistic solubility limits and radionuclide speciation schemes as a prerequisite for meaningful adsorption studies. A number of retention mechanisms were addressed including adsorption, solid solution formation and precipitation of radionuclides within new solid phases formed during cement hydration and evolution. Sorption/desorption experiments were carried out on several anionic radionuclides and/or toxic elements which have received less attention to date, namely: Be, Mo, Tc, I, Se, Cl, Ra and 14C. Solid solution formation between radionuclides in a range of oxidation states (Se, I and Mo) with the main aqueous components (OH−, SO4−2, Cl−) of cementitious systems on AFm phases were also investigated.
Tree ring proxies are employed in dendroanalysis as a valuable tool for evaluating past anthropogenic contamination. A wide variety of analytical methods are used to quantify tree ring content for a broad spectrum of chemical elements. Laser Ablation Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometry (LA-ICP-MS) is often used to investigate element concentrations in the tree rings. However, several issues regarding the representativeness of laser ablation measurements for trace elements have to be addressed before definitive conclusions can be drawn. In this study, High Resolution (HR)-ICP-MS has been implemented to analyze the trace concentration of uranium (U) in annual growth rings of oak trees (Quercus petraea) using both laser ablation (LA) and solution modes. The three tree samples taken for the present study were located upstream (with respect to the hydrologic system) of a former uranium mine site at Rophin (Puy de Dome, France), where mining operations were performed between 1949 and 1958. According to the LA-HR-ICP-MS technique, two-dimensional quantitative (2D) mapping of uranium has developed to study the spatial distribution of uranium at the tree ring surface. A strong heterogeneity was observed, leading to an average uranium concentration with high uncertainty (50-66%). Pressed pellets of the standard reference material, NIST1570a spinach leaves and uranium doped cellulose powder were adopted as the uranium standards for quantification. No agreement was found between uranium concentrations measured after acid digestion and the values obtained by laser ablation. This comparison highlights the limitations of laser ablation technique; hence the solution mode should be preferred for quantifying uranium trace concentrations in tree rings. However, low uncertainty (< 9%) was found with the HR-ICP-MS solution, this result should be compared with the deviation observed both at the tree scale (approximate to 40%) and across the approximate to 10 m sampling area (approximate to 50%).
Alteration experiments involving intermediate level nuclear waste (ILW) glass in contact with hardened cement paste (HCP) were performed to assess its behavior under simulated repository conditions. Batch experiments were conducted at 20 °C and 50 °C in several artificial cement pore water (ACW) samples (pH from 10 to 13), in the presence of HCP (CEM-I, CEM-V and low pH), with a ratio of glass surface to volume of solution of 8000 m-1 and a ratio of mass of HCP to volume of solution of 10 g L-1. Glass alteration rates increase up to ∼4 × 10-2 g m-2 d-1 with pH in contact with HCP, notably with CEM-I. This value decreases by 2 orders of magnitude in low pH cement solution and also for residual alteration rates. The effect of calcium on glass alteration was observed, mainly in Ca(OH)2 saturated solution, with an incubation effect on the release of Si in solution. Experimental data were successfully modeled with the PhreeqC geochemical code. Glass and HCP samples were characterized via SEM/EDX and micro-Raman studies. This work showed that vitrified glass exhibits good performance in terms of low alteration rates (∼10-4 g m-2 d-1), the absence of secondary phases, and the formation of a gel layer at the surface, when in contact with low pH conditions (in the presence or absence of low pH HCP).
Long-term storage of high-level nuclear waste glass in France is expected to occur in an engineered barrier system (EBS) located in a subsurface Callovo-Oxfordian (COx) clay rock formation in the Paris Basin in northeastern France. Understanding the behavior of glass dissolution in the complex system is critical to be able to reliably model the performance of the glass in this complex environment. To simulate this multi-barrier repository scenario in the laboratory, several tests have been performed to measure glass dissolution rates of the simulated high-level nuclear waste glass, SON68, in the presence of COx claystone at 90°C. Experiments utilized a High-Performance Liquid Chromatography (HPLC) pump to pass simulated Bure site COx pore water through a reaction cell containing SON68 placed between two COx claystone cores for durations up to 200days. Silicon concentrations at the outlet were similar in all experiments, even the blank experiment with only the COx claystone (∼4mg/L at 25°C and ∼15mg/L at 90°C). The steady-state pH of the effluent, measured at room temperature, was roughly 7.1 for the blank and 7.3–7.6 for the glass-containing experiments demonstrating the pH buffering capacity of the COx claystone. Dissolution rates for SON68 in the presence of the claystone were elevated compared to those obtained from flow-through experiments conducted with SON68 without claystone in silica-saturated solutions at the same temperature and similar pH values. Additionally, through surface examination of the monoliths, the side of the monolith in direct contact with the claystone was seen to have a corrosion thickness 2.5× greater than the side in contact with the bulk glass powder. Results from one experiment containing 32Si-doped SON68 also suggest that the movement of Si through the claystone is controlled by a chemically coupled transport with a Si retention factor, Kd, of 900mL/g.
Understanding the behavior of 137Cs and 135Cs in soils and geological formations is of considerable interest in the context of nuclear accidents and nuclear waste repositories. Although the clay fraction is known to be responsible for sorption, there are still unanswered questions raised by the literature data concerning (i) the reversibility of the sorption process(es), (ii) the validity of the additivity rule (the overall distribution coefficient (Kd) for a radionuclide on a mixture of minerals is predicted from the distribution coefficients measured on individual minerals) and (iii) the validity of model transposition from dispersed systems to consolidated/intact systems. Because of these uncertainties, the validity of sorption models at equilibrium under in-situ conditions and for very long-term interaction is still pending. These different issues are studied in the present work for the Callovo–Oxfordian (COx) clay-rich rock Formation, which is under investigation in France as a geological barrier for a long-term nuclear waste repository. The work is based on sorption data measured on thirteen samples of different mineralogy taken from five different boreholes at several depths within the COx sedimentary layer. To our knowledge, it is the most extended Cs sorption dataset that has been published for a single clay formation in term of (i) sample locations (and thus natural variability), (ii) sorption conditions (powder dispersed in suspension, compacted powders and intact samples) and (iii) equilibration time (from one week to five years). Moreover, for the first time ever, radioactive Cs sorption results were compared to the natural distribution of non-radioactive Cs isotopes between pore water and the solid phase. The experimental system appeared to be in chemical equilibrium as much as can be expected for an ion-exchange reaction. More particularly, no kinetically-controlled process leading to partial Cs irreversibility was observed, in contrary to what was found in the literature for soils. This difference in behavior may be related to the difference in the illite studied, i.e. a soil-type illite which would be more altered than a sedimentary formation-type illite. No decrease in site capacity was observed between dispersed and intact/compacted states. A model based on exchange reactions with cations interacting with illite (frayed edge, type-II and planar sites) and mixed layer illite–smectite (I/S) (planar sites) using parameters published in the literature enabled the Kd variation to be described as a function of Cs concentration, the mineralogy of the samples, the change in water composition and the temperature (22–80°C). Our study clearly demonstrates that no frayed edge sites should be considered on the illite fraction of I/S, thus emphasizing the difference of sorption properties between an I/S mixed layer mineral and a corresponding mechanical mix of illite and smectite minerals. The robustness of the model was confirmed by data analysis describing the behavior of naturally-occurring Cs in the formation thereby demonstrating the effectiveness of the Cs sorption processes in a very long-time period prospective. Lastly, the model was used to predict the sorption of trace concentrations of Cs in the COx Formation on the time-scale relevant for nuclear waste disposal performance assessment. As expected, the retention was significant with Kd values ranging from 100 to 2000L/kg whatever the conditions that were probed and a simulation covering a period of over 105years could show that the COx Formation is an efficient barrier to prevent Cs transport from the storage facility to the surrounding environment.
The Callovo-Oxfordian (COx) clayed formation is chosen in France as the possible site for an underground nuclear waste disposal. The question raised in this paper concerns the ability of the COx to sorb iodine. Experimental set-ups working in both batch and dynamic systems have been designed for the accurate determination of weak retention factors (i.e. <0.1L/kg) under conditions relevant to the geological formation. Adsorption data measurements were combined with speciation studies performed by anion exchange chromatography. Iodide was shown to be the only form of iodine present in the system regarding both the natural pristine iodine content of the samples and iodine added to the samples. A weak but significant adsorption was observed at 20°C (Kd<0.31L/kg). The adsorption process is reversible when working under fixed PCO2 (1% CO2) with the necessity to consider a kinetic-controlled process under dynamic conditions. When the partial CO2 pressure was not controlled, a part of iodine was shown to be irreversibly bound, probably in a newly precipitated carbonate phase. A Kd value in the range of 0.01–0.14L/kg can be given under controlled PCO2 to describe the adsorption of trace concentrations of iodine by the COx formation.
In France, within the framework of investigations of the feasibility of deep geological disposal of high-level radioactive waste, studies on corrosion products of steel over packs are ongoing. Such studies concern silica and radionuclide retention. The objective of the present work is to study sorption of silicic acid on compacted magnetite in percolation cells to attempt to simulate confined site conditions. Potentiometric titration of commercial magnetite was carried out with both dispersed and compacted magnetite. The titration of the magnetite suspension has been made with two different methods: a batch method (several suspensions) and a direct fast method (one suspension). The Gran’s function gave 1.7 (±0.4) and 2.4 (±0.5) sorption sites nm−2 with these respective methods but site densities as high as 20/nm2 could be obtained by modelling. The titration of magnetite compacted at 120 bars showed that the evolution of charge density on magnetite surfaces is similar for compacted and dispersed magnetite. Silicic acid sorption onto dispersed and compacted magnetite was similar with sorption site densities ranging between 2.2 and 4.4/nm2.
This paper contributes to the comprehension of kinetic and equilibrium phenomena governing metal ion sorption on organic-matter-coated mineral particles. Sorption and desorption experiments were carried out with Eu ion and polyacrylic acid (PAA)-coated alumina colloids at pH 5 in 0.1 M NaClO4 as a function of the metal ion loading. Under these conditions, M interaction with the solid is governed by sorbed PAA (PAAads). The results were compared with spectroscopic data obtained by time-resolved laser-induced fluorescence spectroscopy (TRLFS) with Cm and Gd. The interaction between M and PAAads was characterized by a kinetically controlled process: after rapid metal adsorption within less than 1 min, the speciation of complexed M changed at the particle surface till an equilibrium was reached after about 4 days. At equilibrium, one part of complexed M was shown to be not exchangeable. This process was strongly dependent on the ligand-to-metal ratio. Two models were tested to explain the data. In model 1, the kinetically controlled process was described through successive kinetically controlled reactions that follow the rapid metal ion adsorption. In model 2, the organic layer was considered as a porous medium: the kinetic process was explained by the diffusion of M from the surface into the organic layer. Model 1 allowed a very good description of equilibrium and kinetic experimental data. Model 2 could describe the data at equilibrium but could not explain the kinetic data accurately. In spite of this disagreement, model 2 appeared more realistic considering the results of the TRLFS measurements.