The mitigation of plasma disruptions in tokamaks has become a very important topic in magnetic fusion research, motived by the potential challenges that may occur in ITER disruptions due to the high magnetic field and high plasma current. Such disruptions can have a deleterious effect on the internal components due to the fast dissipation of the plasma thermal energy and the magnetic stored energy leading to large forces, as well as the possible formation of several megaamperes of energetic runaway electrons during the current quench. Oak Ridge National Laboratory has been developing and deploying technology to inject material into the plasma to rapidly radiate the thermal energy and start a fast plasma current ramp down to dissipate the magnetic stored energy. The choice of materials to inject and the injection technology have evolved over the past decades to arrive at the present systems planned for ITER based on cryogenic pellets of hydrogen-neon mixtures for thermal mitigation and hydrogen pellets for runaway electron mitigation. This scheme injects shattered cryogenic material into the plasma from pellets formed in situ in a pipe gun and fired onto angled metal surfaces at the end of the injection line just before entering the plasma.In this paper, we describe the evolution of schemes and technologies that have been employed for disruption mitigation and runaway electron prevention and dissipation, discuss how they have performed in present-day experiments, and give the outlook for the use of this technology in a burning plasma and how it may continue to evolve in the future.
Efficient plasma core fuelling is a critical issue for achieving steady-state scenarios in magnetically confined fusion devices. The current preferred method to achieve this goal is cryogenic pellet injection (PI). PI's are now installed in most medium- and large-sized fusion devices. In this paper, recent results from PI experiments in the stellarator TJ-II are reported. Of particular interest is the influence of fast electrons. Whilst edge populations of such electrons do not affect PI in the TJ-II, fast electrons residing in its hot core have significant influence on both pellet ablation and fuelling efficiency. If present in the core, their radial location can be determined from the light emission profile produced by an ablating pellet as it traverses the plasma and confirmed from the power spectral distribution spectrograph of the total secondary beam current collected by a scanning heavy ion beam probe system. Moreover, it is found that if a pellet is subject to excess ablation due to core fast electron impacts, the resultant pellet efficiency (deposited particles/delivered particles) increases by up to 50% with respect to injections into similar, fast-electron free, plasmas. This is consistently found for microwave-heated plasmas, where pellet penetration is shallower than the magnetic axis in TJ-II, when such a population is present, as well as for neutral beam created and heated plasmas in which fast-electrons, generated during magnetic field ramp-up, persist in the core along a discharge. Similarly, when polystyrene pellets (TESPEL) are injected into the same machine sector, an analogous increase in post-injection particle deposition is seen. It is postulated that vaporization of the pellet through heating by fast electrons modifies normal neutral cloud and plasmoid development and hence affects outwards drifting that is inherent to magnetic fusion devices.
The four-barrel, two-stage gun Ignitor Pellet Injector (IPI) was developed in collaboration between ENEA and ORNL. The prototype injector is presently located at Oak Ridge (TN, USA), and is normally operated locally through a control and data acquisition system developed in LabVIEW. More recently, a remote-control system has been set up, based on RealVNC (R), which allows to operate the IPI from a control room in Italy. Tools for data transfer and storage into ENEA ICT area have also been provided. A Staging, Storage and Sharing system, named E3S, developed using OwnCloud as architectural component, is used for file synchronization and sharing of the data acquired by the diagnostic systems. It provides a homogeneous platform able to store and share heterogeneous data produced by many data acquisition systems in large nuclear fusion experiments. This paper reports about the implementation of the IPI remote control, and presents the application of E3S to this specific case, allowing easy storage and sharing of experimental data onto a wide-area distributed file-system, as well as remote data access via web-services based on MDS+ tool, integrated with MySQL metadata. A performance analysis of the architectural components is also introduced.
Pellet injection represents to date the most realistic candidate technology for core fueling of a demonstration fusion power reactor tokamak fusion reactor. Modeling of both pellet penetration and fuel deposition profiles, for different injection locations, indicates that effective core fuelling can be achieved launching pellets from the inboard high field side at speeds not less than ~1 km/s. Inboard pellet fueling is commonly achieved in present tokamaks, using curved guide tubes; however, this technology might be hampered at velocities ≥1 km/s. An innovative approach, aimed at identifying suitable inboard "direct line" paths, to inject high-speed pellets (in the 3 to 4 km/s range), has recently been proposed as a potential complementary solution. The fuel deposition profiles achievable by this approach have been explored using the HPI2 simulation code. The results presented here show that there are possible geometrical schemes providing good fueling performance. The problem of neutron flux in a direct line-of-sight injection path is being investigated, though preliminary analyses indicate that, perhaps, this is not a serious problem. The identification and integration of straight injection paths suitably tilted may be a rather difficult task due to the many constraints and to interference with existing structures. The suitability of straight guide tubes to reduce the scatter cone of high-speed pellets is, therefore, of main interest. A preliminary investigation, aimed at addressing these technological issues, has recently been started. A possible implementation plan, using an existing Italian National Agency for New Technologies, Energy and Sustainable Economic Development-Oak Ridge National Laboratory facility is shortly outlined.
Plasma core fuelling is a key issue for the development of steady-state scenarios in large magnetically-confined fusion devices, in particular for helical-type machines. At present, cryogenic pellet injection is the most promising technique for efficient fuelling. Here, pellet ablation and fuelling efficiency experiments, using a compact pellet injector, are carried out in electron cyclotron resonance and neutral beam injection heated plasmas of the stellarator TJ-II. Ablation profiles are reconstructed from light emissions collected by silicon photodiodes and a fast-frame camera system, under the assumptions that such emissions are loosely related to the ablation rate and that pellet radial acceleration is negligible. In addition, pellet particle deposition and fuelling efficiency are determined using density profiles provided by a Thomson scattering system. Furthermore, experimental results are compared with ablation and deposition profiles provided by the HPI2 pellet code, which is adapted here for the stellarators Wendelstein 7-X (W7-X) and TJ-II. Finally, the HPI2 code is used to simulate ablation and deposition profiles for pellets of different sizes and velocities injected into relevant W7-X plasma scenarios, while estimating the plasmoid drift and the fuelling efficiency of injections made from two W7-X ports.
43 spectral emission lines from F-like to Li-like sulphur ions have been identified in the wavelength range from 17.5 to 50 nm in spectra obtained following tracer injection into plasmas created in a magnetically confined plasma device, the stellarator TJ-II. Plasmas created and maintained in this heliac device with electron cyclotron resonance heating achieve central electron temperatures and densities up to 1.5 keV and 8 × 1018 m−3, respectively. Tracer injections were performed with ≤6 × 1016 atoms of sulphur contained within ∼300 μm diameter polystyrene capsules, termed tracer encapsulated solid pellets, using a gas propulsion system to achieve velocities between 250 and 450 m s−1. Once ablation of the exterior polystyrene shell by plasma particles is completed, the sulphur is deposited in the plasma core where it is ionized up to S+13 and transported about the plasma. In order to aid line identification, which is made using a number of atomic line emission databases, spectra are collected before and after injection using a 1 m focal length normal incidence spectrometer equipped with a CCD camera. This work is motivated by the need to clearly identify sulphur emission lines in the vacuum ultraviolet range of magnetically confined plasmas, as sulphur x-ray emission lines are regularly observed in both tokamak and stellarator plasmas.
We report on the first demonstration of dissipation of fully avalanched post-disruption runaway electron (RE) beams by shattered pellet injection in the DIII-D tokamak. Variation of the injected species shows that dissipation depends strongly on the species mixture, while comparisons with massive gas injection do not show a significant difference between dissipation by pellets or by gas, suggesting that the shattered pellet is rapidly ablated by the relativistic electrons before significant radial penetration into the runaway beam can occur. Pure or dominantly neon injection increases the RE current dissipation through pitch-angle scattering due to collisions with impurity ions. Deuterium injection is observed to have the opposite effect from neon, reducing the high-Z impurity content and thus decreasing the dissipation, and causing the background thermal plasma to completely recombine. When injecting mixtures of the two species, deuterium levels as low as ∼10% of the total injected atoms are observed to adversely affect the resulting dissipation, suggesting that complete elimination of deuterium from the injection may be important for optimizing RE mitigation schemes.
Future large tokamaks, such as ITER, will require a reliable technique for rapid energy dissipation to mitigate harmful effects from disruptions. Two main methods developed for disruption mitigation are massive gas injection and shattered pellet injection (SPI). Argon and neon are favorable materials for both injection methods. When launching pellets with SPI, it has proven difficult to launch intact pellets of pure argon and/or neon owing to their high material strength at cryogenic temperatures. In this work, we compare two methods of launching relatively high-Z pellets. An electrothermal plasma source is an experimental alternative to the fast opening, high-pressure, gas valve. The electrothermal source was used to launch Lexan (TM) pellets with approximately the same size and mass of comparable mixed gas (D-2 and Ne) cryogenic pellets launched by gas guns. We describe comparisons of achieved pellet velocities, energy efficiencies of each system, and the implications of implementing each respective method on an operating tokamak.
High-speed injection of solid fuel was first proposed in 1954 as a possible solution to the problem of transporting fresh fuel across the confining magnetic fields into the plasma of a fusion reactor. While it took a few decades, the use of cryogenic pellets (typically H-2 and D-2) on fusion experiments became common place; most tokamaks and stellarators are now equipped with a pellet injector(s). These devices operate at low temperatures (similar to 10 to 20 K) and most often use a simple light gas gun to accelerate macroscopic-size pellets (similar to 0.4-to 6-mm diameter) to speeds of similar to 100 to 1000 m/s. Before the advantages of pellet injection from the magnetic high-field side (HFS) of a tokamak were recognized in 1997, development focused on increasing the pellet speed to achieve deeper plasma penetration and higher fueling efficiency. The HFS injection technique typically dictates slower pellets (similar to 100 to 300 m/s) to survive transport through the curved guide tubes that route the pellets to the plasma from the inside wall of the device. Two other key operating parameters for plasma fueling are the pellet-injection repetition rate and time duration-a single pellet is adequate for some experiments and a steady-state injection rate of up to similar to 50 Hz is appropriate for others. In addition to plasma fueling, cryogenic pellets have often been used for particle transport and impurity studies in fusion experiments (most often with neon pellets). During the past two decades, a few new applications for cryogenic pellets have been developed and used successfully in plasma experiments: (1) one for edge-localized mode mitigation, (2) one for plasma disruption mitigation (requires large pellets that are shattered before injection into the plasma), and (3) another in which pure argon pellets are used to trigger runaway electrons in the plasma for scientific studies. In this paper, a brief history and the key developments in this technology during the past 25 years are presented and discussed.
Disruptions are sudden unplanned terminations of tokamak plasmas that can lead to high thermal loads and runaway electrons (REs). Unmitigated disruptions in ITER are predicted to dissipate up to 350 MJ of thermal energy and generate several MA of multi-MeV runaway electrons. This intense heat and energetic particle beams can cause localized melting of the plasma facing components. Reliable and fast acting disruption mitigation (DM) techniques are therefore a critical requirement for ITER to safeguard the machine from damage. The proven method for DM centers on injecting a large quantity of impurity particles into the plasma to quickly increase density and radiate the thermal energy to mitigate thermal effects. Additionally, if the particle injection can achieve sufficient density, it can create collisional drag which suppresses the formation of REs. Shattered pellet injection (SPI) has proven to be the most effective method of particle injection thus far attempted and is planned for the DM system on ITER. Recently, a new three-barrel second SPI (SPI-II) system has been developed for use on DIII-D to study injection effects from multiple toroidal locations and pellet timing. The three pellets can be formed and fired individually or simultaneously. The SPI-II has provisions for making and firing pure species pellets with deuterium, neon, or argon and also deuterium layered pellets with a core of neon and mixtures of neon and deuterium.
Cryogenic pellet injection is a widely used technique for delivering fuel to the core of magnetically confined plasmas. Indeed, such systems are currently functioning on many tokamak, reversed field pinch and stellarator devices. A pipe-gun-type pellet injector is now operated on the TJ-II, a low-magnetic shear stellarator of the heliac type. Cryogenic hydrogen pellets, containing between 3 x 10(18) and 4 x 10(19) atoms, are injected at velocities between 800 and 1200 m s(-1) from its low-field side into plasmas created and/or maintained in this device by electron cyclotron resonance and/or neutral beam injection heating. In this paper, the first systematic study of pellet ablation, particle deposition and fuelling efficiency is presented for TJ-II. From this, light-emission profiles from ablating pellets are found to be in reasonable agreement with simulated pellet ablation profiles (created using a neutral gas shielding-based code) for both heating scenarios. In addition, radial offsets between recorded light-emission profiles and particle deposition profiles provide evidence for rapid outward drifting of ablated material that leads to pellet particle loss from the plasma. Finally, fuelling efficiencies are documented for a range of target plasma densities (similar to 4 x 10(18)- similar to 2 x 10(19) m(-3)). These range from similar to 20%-similar to 85% and are determined to be sensitive to pellet penetration depth. Additional observations, such as enhanced core ablation, are discussed and planned future work is outlined.
The injection of cryogenic pellets from the low field side (LFS) has long been in use for core fuelling of fusion devices, but injection from the high field side (HFS) has proved to provide a more effective core particle deposition, despite the severe limitations imposed to the pellet speed (<= 300 m/s) by inboard accessibility. In the future, an alternative approach may be that of injecting high-speed pellets from the HFS, through suitable "free-flight" paths, eliminating curved transfer systems. Furthermore, the expected length of the plasma discharges will require steady-state repetitive systems. ORNL and ENEA have been collaborating on high-speed injectors since 1990; they successfully realized a high-speed repeating pellet injector (2.55 km/s at 1 Hz). Since then, good progress has been achieved on both fronts of steady-state extruders, and operation and reliability of two-stage guns. A comprehensive R&D program is therefore proposed to investigate how far speed limits and repetition rates of combined two-stage guns and steady-state extruders technologies can be extended. Simulations results are presented showing pellet penetration for several injection locations on a tokamak under construction such as JT60-SA, on the basis of one set of design plasma parameters. (C) 2017 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Injection of multiple large (similar to 10 to 30 mm diameter) shattered pellets into ITER plasmas is presently part of the scheme planned to mitigate the deleterious effects of disruptions on the vessel components. To help in the design and optimize performance of the pellet injectors for this application, a model referred to as "the gas gun simulator" has been developed and benchmarked against experimental data. The computer code simulator is a Java program that models the gas-dynamics characteristics of a single-stage gas gun. Following a stepwise approach, the code utilizes a variety of input parameters to incrementally simulate and analyze the dynamics of the gun as the projectile is launched down the barrel. Using input data, the model can calculate gun performance based on physical characteristics, such as propellant-gas and fast-valve properties, barrel geometry, and pellet mass. Although the model is fundamentally generic, the present version is configured to accommodate cryogenic pellets composed of H-2, D-2, Ne, Ar, and mixtures of them and light propellant gases (H-2, D-2, and He). The pellets are solidified in situ in pipe guns that consist of stainless steel tubes and fast-acting valves that provide the propellant gas for pellet acceleration (to speeds similar to 200 to 700 m/s). The pellet speed is the key parameter in determining the response time of a shattered pellet system to a plasma disruption event. The calculated speeds from the code simulations of experiments were typically in excellent agreement with the measured values. With the gas gun simulator validated for many test shots and over a wide range of physical and operating parameters, it is a valuable tool for optimization of the injector design, including the fast valve design (orifice size and volume) for any operating pressure (similar to 40 bar expected for the ITER application) and barrel length for any pellet size (mass, diameter, and length). Key design parameters and proposed values for the pellet injectors for the ITER disruption mitigation systems are discussed.
A cryogenic pellet injector (PI) and tracer encapsulated solid pellet (TESPEL) injector system has been operated in combination on the stellarator TJ-II. This unique arrangement has been created by piggy-backing a TESPEL injector onto the backend of a pipe-gun-type PI. The combined injector provides a powerful new tool for comparing ablation and penetration of polystyrene TESPEL pellets and solid hydrogen pellets, as well as for contrasting subsequent pellet particle deposition and plasma perturbation under analogous plasma conditions. For instance, a significantly larger increase in plasma line-averaged electron density, and electron content, is observed after a TESPEL pellet injection compared with an equivalent cryogenic pellet injection. Moreover, for these injections from the low-magnetic-field side of the plasma cross-section, TESPEL pellets deposit electrons deeper into the plasma core than cryogenic pellets. Finally, the physics behind these observations and possible implications for pellet injection studies are discussed. Copyright (C) EPLA, 2018
Shattered pellet injection (SPI) is one of the prime candidates for the ITER disruption mitigation system because of its deeper penetration and larger particle flux than massive gas injection (MGI) (Taylor et al 1999 Phys. Plasmas 6 1872) using deuterium (Commaux et al 2010 Nucl. Fusion 50 112001, Combs et al 2010 IEEE Trans. Plasma Sci. 38 400, Baylor et al 2009 Nucl. Fusion 49 085013). The ITER disruption mitigation system will likely use mostly high Z species such as neon because of more effective thermal mitigation and pumping constraints on the maximum amount of deuterium or helium that could be injected. An upgrade of the SPI on DIII-D enables ITER relevant injection characteristics in terms of quantities and gas species. This upgraded SPI system was used on DIII-D for the first time in 2014 for a direct comparison with MGI using identical quantities of neon.This comparison enabled the measurements of density perturbations during the thermal quench (TQ) and radiated power and heat loads to the divertor. It showed that SPI using similar quantities of neon provided a faster and stronger density perturbation and neon assimilation, which resulted in a lower conducted energy to the divertor and a faster TQ onset. Radiated power data analysis shows that this was probably due to the much deeper penetration of the neon in the plasma inducing a higher core radiation than in the MGI case. This experiment shows also that the MHD activity during an SPI shutdown (especially during the TQ) is quite different compared to MGI. This favorable TQ energy dissipation was obtained while keeping the current quench (CQ) duration within acceptable limits when scaled to ITER.
A compact pellet injector is operating on the TJ-II stellarator.It is a four-pellet system equipped with a cryogenic refrigerator for in-situ hydrogen pellet formation, a fast propellant valve system for pellet acceleration (!1200 m/s), in-line diagnostics for determining pellet velocity and mass, and injection lines to the magnetically confined plasmas (n e (0) !5x10 19 m -3 , T e (0) !1 keV, B(0) = 1 T, average minor radius = 0.22 m) created in this heliac device.Although the primary purpose of this system is to perform plasma fuelling studies, it is well suited as an active diagnostic for studying suprathermal electron populations, magnetic field orientations, and rational surfaces.For this, optical fibre coupled silicon diodes (or avalanche photodiodes), installed outside of nearby viewports, record the Balmer H" light (# = 656.28nm) emitted from the neutral cloud that surrounds a pellet as it crosses the plasma.In this way, it is possible to follow the temporal evolution of the pellet ablation.In addition, an ultrafast-frame CMOS camera, equipped with a bifurcated coherent fibre bundle, has been set-up to obtain multiple images of the neutral cloud.Finally, additional plasma diagnostics, e.g.Thomson Scattering, broadband bolometer arrays, Heavy Ion Beam Probes, are combined to make the overall system a very powerful tool for plasma studies.
An instrument was developed using digital holographic reconstruction of the wavefront from a CO2 laser imaged on a high-speed commercial IR camera. An acousto-optic modulator is used to generate 1-25 μs pulses from a continuous-wave CO2 laser, both to limit the average power at the detector and also to freeze motion from sub-interframe time scales. Extensive effort was made to characterize and eliminate noise from vibrations and second-surface reflections. Mismatch of the reference and object beam curvature initially contributed substantially to vibrational noise, but was mitigated through careful positioning of identical imaging lenses. Vibrational mode amplitudes were successfully reduced to ≲1 nm for frequencies ≳50 Hz, and the inter-frame noise across the 128 × 128 pixel window which is typically used is ≲2.5 nm. To demonstrate the capabilities of the system, a piezo-electric valve and a reducing-expanding nozzle were used to generate a super-sonic gas jet which was imaged with high spatial resolution (better than 0.8 lp/mm) at high speed. Abel inversions were performed on the phase images to produce 2-D images of localized gas density. This system could also be used for high spatial and temporal resolution measurements of plasma electron density or surface deformations.
A tracer-encapsulated solid pellet (TESPEL) injection system for the TJ-II stellarator was recently developed. In order to reduce the time and cost for the development, we combined a TESPEL injector provided by National Institute for Fusion Science with an existing TJ-II cryogenic pellet injection system. Consequently, the TESPEL injection into the TJ-II plasma was successfully achieved, which was confirmed by several pellet diagnostics including a normal-incidence spectrometer for monitoring a tracer impurity behavior.