BACKGROUND:Glioblastoma (GBM), the most aggressive adult brain cancer, comprises a complex tumor microenvironment (TME) with diverse cellular interactions that drive progression and pathobiology. The aim of this study was to understand how these spatial patterns and interactions evolve with treatment. METHODS:To explore these relationships, we employed imaging mass cytometry to measure the expression of 34 protein markers, enabling the identification of GBM-specific cell types and their interactions at the single-cell protein level in paired primary (pre-treatment) and recurrent (post-treatment) GBM samples from five patients. RESULTS:We find a significant post-treatment increase in normal brain cells alongside a reduction in vascular cells. Moreover, despite minimal overall change in cellular diversity, interactions among astrocytes, oligodendrocytes, and vascular cells increase post-treatment, suggesting reorganization of the TME. The GBM TME cells form spatially organized layers driven by hypoxia pre-treatment, but this influence diminishes post-treatment, giving way to less organized layers with organization driven by reactive astrocytes and lymphocytes. CONCLUSIONS:These findings provide insight into treatment-induced shifts in GBM's cellular landscape, highlighting aspects of the evolving TME that appear to facilitate recurrence and are, therefore, potential therapeutic targets.
Background Glioblastoma (GBM) brain tumors lacking IDH1 mutations (IDHwt) have the worst prognosis of all brain neoplasms. Patients receive surgery and chemoradiotherapy but tumors almost always fatally recur. Results Using RNA sequencing data from 107 pairs of pre- and post-standard treatment locally recurrent IDHwt GBM tumors, we identify two responder subtypes based on longitudinal changes in gene expression. In two thirds of patients, a specific subset of genes is upregulated from primary to recurrence (Up responders), and in one third, the same genes are downregulated (Down responders), specifically in neoplastic cells. Characterization of the responder subtypes indicates subtype-specific adaptive treatment resistance mechanisms that are associated with distinct changes in the tumor microenvironment. In Up responders, recurrent tumors are enriched in quiescent proneural GBM stem cells and differentiated neoplastic cells, with increased interaction with the surrounding normal brain and neurotransmitter signaling, whereas Down responders commonly undergo mesenchymal transition. ChIP-sequencing data from longitudinal GBM tumors suggests that the observed transcriptional reprogramming could be driven by Polycomb-based chromatin remodeling rather than DNA methylation. Conclusions We show that the responder subtype is cancer-cell intrinsic, recapitulated in in vitro GBM cell models, and influenced by the presence of the tumor microenvironment. Stratifying GBM tumors by responder subtype may lead to more effective treatment.
BACKGROUND:Characterizing and quantifying cell types within glioblastoma (GBM) tumors at scale will facilitate a better understanding of the association between the cellular landscape and tumor phenotypes or clinical correlates. We aimed to develop a tool that deconvolutes immune and neoplastic cells within the GBM tumor microenvironment from bulk RNA sequencing data. METHODS:We developed an IDH wild-type (IDHwt) GBM-specific single immune cell reference consisting of B cells, T-cells, NK-cells, microglia, tumor associated macrophages, monocytes, mast and DC cells. We used this alongside an existing neoplastic single cell-type reference for astrocyte-like, oligodendrocyte- and neuronal progenitor-like and mesenchymal GBM cancer cells to create both marker and gene signature matrix-based deconvolution tools. We applied single-cell resolution imaging mass cytometry (IMC) to ten IDHwt GBM samples, five paired primary and recurrent tumors, to determine which deconvolution approach performed best. RESULTS:Marker-based deconvolution using GBM-tissue specific markers was most accurate for both immune cells and cancer cells, so we packaged this approach as GBMdeconvoluteR. We applied GBMdeconvoluteR to bulk GBM RNAseq data from The Cancer Genome Atlas and recapitulated recent findings from multi-omics single cell studies with regards associations between mesenchymal GBM cancer cells and both lymphoid and myeloid cells. Furthermore, we expanded upon this to show that these associations are stronger in patients with worse prognosis. CONCLUSIONS:GBMdeconvoluteR accurately quantifies immune and neoplastic cell proportions in IDHwt GBM bulk RNA sequencing data and is accessible here: https://gbmdeconvoluter.leeds.ac.uk.
Abstract AIMS The rapid recurrence of therapy-resistant glioblastoma leaves patients with a dismal 2-year survival rate of just 16%, highlighting the need to develop treatments that combat or prevent glioblastoma recurrence. Recently, glioblastoma patients have been stratified by their gene expression response to therapy. Specifically, genes with JARID2 binding sites in their promoter (JBS-genes) either become up- or down-regulated on progression from the primary to the recurrent tumour. Importantly, these two responses appear to employ different mechanisms of therapy resistance. Using gene expression data from primary tumours, we aim to predict the direction of JBS- gene dysregulation. Ultimately, this prediction could guide treatment decisions that prevent the acquisition of therapy resistance in glioblastoma. METHOD We used gene expression data from 84 primary glioblastoma tumours that had been labelled as either ‘Up’ or ‘Down’ responders based on the direction of JBS-gene dysregulation in matched recurrent tumours. We converted the RNA-sequencing data from the primary tumours to single-sample pathway scores, which were used to train several binary classification machine learning models. RESULTS A ridge regression model achieved an accuracy of 73.9% in predicting the direction of JBS-gene dysregulation in an independent set of 23 primary glioblastoma tumours. CONCLUSIONS Our classifier performs better than random chance demonstrating that gene expression data is informative and molecular features influence this gene expression response to therapy. However, there remains scope for improvement. This suggests further studies may benefit from integrating multiple data types such as genomics, epigenomics, tumour architecture, or clinical variables.
Abstract AIMS Treating glioblastoma (GBM) patients remains challenging as the current regimens result in the recurrence of a treatment-resistant and fatal tumour. We aimed to identify candidate pathways that, when mutated, confer treatment resistance. Targeting these pathways may improve GBM treatment effcacy. METHOD We performed WGS and WES on 46 matched primary and recurrent GBMs (the Discovery cohort) and used data from additional 188 samples from the Glioma Longitudinal AnalySiS consortium (GLASS: Validation cohort). First, we identified variants that were shared between primary and recurrent GBMs. We then highlighted those most likely to be involved in treatment resistance, i.e. with: 1) low allele fractions at primary and high in recurrent, 2) high allele fractions in both primary and recurrent. Finally, we performed enrichment analysis using these variants to identify pathways that may drive clonal expansion from primary to recurrent. RESULTS The analysis of variants that increased from primary to recurrent revealed three significant disrupted path- ways in the Discovery cohort; “Activation of BH3 Only Proteins” (Reactome), “P53 pathway” (BIOCARTA), and “Intrinsic Pathway for Apoptosis” (REACTOME). Six distinct genes caused the aberration of these pathways. The same pathways were significantly disrupted in the recurrent variants group of the Validation cohort but were solely caused by TP53 alterations. In the Discovery cohort, “Activation of BH3 Only Proteins” was altered in 24% of the patients. CONCLUSIONS Investigating how pathway mutations alter in GBM through treatment has led to identifying potential candidate mechanisms to be further studied in the laboratory.
Abstract AIMS Glioblastoma (GBM) is the most common primary malignant brain tumour in adults. Despite aggressive treatment, a resistant tumour recurs in practically all patients. We therefore aimed to better understand the mechanisms driving this treatment resistance through investigating changes in gene expression across pairs of primary and recurrent GBM tumours. METHOD We generated or acquired bulk tumour RNA sequencing data for primary and first recurrent tumours from 107 patients who received standard treatment. Differential expression analysis between primary and recurrent samples found that the most dysregulated genes were involved in neurodevelopment and neurodifferentiation. We therefore used a publicly available ChIP-seq database to identify DNA binding factors for which binding sites are enriched in the promotors of genes with the largest expression changes from primary to recurrent. RESULTS Jumonji and AT-Rich Interacting Domain 2 (JARID2) was the most strongly enriched for binding to promotors of dysregulated genes. 65 patients showed an up-regulation and 42 showed a down-regulation of genes bound by this protein. The same set of JARID2 bound genes were found to be dysregulated in each direction, and correlated with the largest source of variation between samples in their response to treatment. Further enrichment analyses indicated that ‘Up’ responders may resist treatment through reduced proliferation and increased interaction with the tumour microenvironment, whereas ‘Down’ responders instead rely on a shift to mesenchymal cell states. CONCLUSION These results indicate that GBM tumours can be split into two subtypes that transcriptionally reprogramme in different directions through treatment and may benefit from different treatment approaches.
The factors driving therapy resistance in diffuse glioma remain poorly understood. To identify treatment-associated cellular and genetic changes, we analyzed RNA and/or DNA sequencing data from the temporally separated tumor pairs of 304 adult patients with isocitrate dehydrogenase (IDH)-wild-type and IDH-mutant glioma. Tumors recurred in distinct manners that were dependent on IDH mutation status and attributable to changes in histological feature composition, somatic alterations, and microenvironment interactions. Hypermutation and acquired CDKN2A deletions were associated with an increase in proliferating neoplastic cells at recurrence in both glioma subtypes, reflecting active tumor growth. IDH-wild-type tumors were more invasive at recurrence, and their neoplastic cells exhibited increased expression of neuronal signaling programs that reflected a possible role for neuronal interactions in promoting glioma progression. Mesenchymal transition was associated with the presence of a myeloid cell state defined by specific ligand-receptor interactions with neoplastic cells. Collectively, these recurrence-associated phenotypes represent potential targets to alter disease progression.
Biobanks provide a window of opportunity to store and add value to material from rare cases allowing their future use in biomedical research. One such example is the opportunityto obtain good quality tissue from patients undergoing gender re-assignment. Following patient agreement to donate tissue samples to our biobank we catalogued the histological appearance, defined the expression of the hormone receptors ERα, PR, AR and the proliferation marker Ki67, and generated and characterised primary cell cultures in a female to male (FTM) transgender patient referred to our unit for surgery. Immunohistochemistry was performed for ERα, PR and AR and the proliferation marker Ki67. Hormone receptor expression was confined to epithelial cells lining the breast ducts. Ki67 immunoreactivity was sparse indicating little proliferation of luminal epithelium, consistent with normal mammary gland. Cultures of epithelial cells and fibroblasts were derived from surplus tissue. The latter lacked expression of epithelial markers and hormone receptors but exhibited expression of vimentin. Culture of the former on Matrigel saw an outgrowth of more rounded "epithelial-like" cells. Immunofluoresence characterisation showed a mixed phenotype with expression of vimentin and both myoepithelial and luminal epithelial markers. Sporadic weak ERα expression and moderate PR expression was seen. In summary, as well as routinely collecting tissue and blood samples, we have characterised and stored tissue and cells from a FTM transgender patient, adding value to this resource which,available from the Breast Cancer Campaign Tissue Bank for those interested in further studying the biology of FTM transgender tissue.
Pathological reporting of breast cancer has evolved alongside scientific advances. Such advances have led to recognition of different molecular classes of breast cancer resulting in improved disease management. The aim of this study was to establish whether these advances could be applied to archival breast cancer cases dating from the 1940s to assess historical trends. Important observations included the marked differences in pathological reporting, size of tumour and in ERα expression throughout the decades.
Models considering breast cancer complexity cannot be easily or accurately replicated in routine cell line or animal models. We aimed to evaluate the practicality of organotypic tissue slice culture in breast cancer. Following ethical approval, 250 µm thick sections from surplus breast tumours (n=10) were prepared using a vibrating blade microtome. Triplicate tissue slices were placed in 6-well plates and cultured for up to 7 days±tamoxifen (1 nM) or doxorubicin (1 µM). Tissue slices were fixed and embedded before sectioning for morphological evaluation and immunohistochemistry. H&E showed good preservation of tissue morphology. Collagen production was evident. Biomarkers of proliferation and apoptosis could be evaluated using immunohistochemistry and used as surrogates to quantify drug effects. In summary, breast cancer tissue slices can be cultured in vitro as organotypic models. Nevertheless, although simple in concept, the delicacy of the model with regard to handling makes subsequent analytical processes challenging.
Male breast cancer remains understudied despite evidence of rising incidence. Using a co-ordinated multi-centre approach, we present the first large scale biomarker study to define and compare hormone receptor profiles and survival between male and female invasive breast cancer. We defined and compared hormone receptor profiles and survival between 251 male and 263 female breast cancers matched for grade, age, and lymph node status. Tissue microarrays were immunostained for ERα, ERβ1, -2, -5, PR, PRA, PRB and AR, augmented by HER2, CK5/6, 14, 18 and 19 to assist typing. Hierarchical clustering determined differential nature of influences between genders. Luminal A was the most common phenotype in both sexes. Luminal B and HER2 were not seen in males. Basal phenotype was infrequent in both. No differences in overall survival at 5 or 10 years were observed between genders. Notably, AR-positive luminal A male breast cancer had improved overall survival over female breast cancer at 5 (P = 0.01, HR = 0.39, 95% CI = 0.26–0.87) but not 10 years (P = 0.29, HR = 0.75, 95% CI = 0.46–1.26) and both 5 (P = 0.04, HR = 0.37, 95% CI = 0.07–0.97) and 10 years (P = 0.04, HR = 0.43, 95% CI = 0.12–0.97) in the unselected group. Hierarchical clustering revealed common clusters between genders including total PR–PRA–PRB and ERβ1/2 clusters. A striking feature was the occurrence of ERα on distinct clusters between genders. In female breast cancer, ERα clustered with PR and its isoforms; in male breast cancer, ERα clustered with ERβ isoforms and AR. Our data supports the hypothesis that breast cancer is biologically different in males and females suggesting implications for clinical management. With the incidence of male breast cancer increasing this provides impetus for further study.
In this study, we investigated the effects of ectopic estrogen receptor (ER)β1 expression in breast cancer cell lines and nude mice xenografts and observed that ERβ1 expression suppresses tumor growth and represses FOXM1 mRNA and protein expression in ERα-positive but not ERα-negative breast cancer cells. Furthermore, a significant inverse correlation exists between ERβ1 and FOXM1 expression at both protein and mRNA transcript levels in ERα-positive breast cancer patient samples. Ectopic ERβ1 expression resulted in decreased FOXM1 protein and mRNA expression only in ERα-positive but not ERα-negative breast carcinoma cell lines, suggesting that ERβ1 represses ERα-dependent FOXM1 transcription. Reporter gene assays showed that ERβ1 represses FOXM1 transcription through an estrogen-response element located within the proximal promoter region that is also targeted by ERα. The direct binding of ERβ1 to the FOXM1 promoter was confirmed by chromatin immunoprecipitation analysis, which also showed that ectopic expression of ERβ1 displaces ERα from the endogenous FOXM1 promoter. Forced expression of ERβ1 promoted growth suppression in MCF-7 cells, but the anti-proliferative effects of ERβ1 could be overridden by overexpression of FOXM1, indicating that FOXM1 is an important downstream target of ERβ1 signaling. Together, these findings define a key anti-proliferative role for ERβ1 in breast cancer development through negatively regulating FOXM1 expression.
AIMS:Characteristics of the stroma around tumours are critical in defining the behaviour of cancers. β-Catenin is well established as a critical regulator of carcinogenesis, acting as a transcriptional co-activator in the nuclei of epithelial cancer cells. We have examined the prevalence and influence of nuclear β-catenin within the stromal fibroblasts of breast cancer. METHODS AND RESULTS:We examined β-catenin expression in 201 breast cancers and adjacent normal tissue. Fibroblasts expressing nuclear β-catenin were present in a significantly greater proportion of tumour tissues than normal tissues. The presence of fibroblasts with nuclear β-catenin in tumours correlated with survival; tumours with prevalent positive fibroblasts were associated significantly with relatively good prognoses. Functional studies to examine influences of fibroblasts with nuclear β-catenin, showed fibroblasts transfected to allow overexpression of β-catenin were capable of inducing increases in both proliferation and invasion of breast cancer cell lines. CONCLUSION:The presence of fibroblasts with nuclear β-catenin in tumours is a good prognostic indicator, although in the context of tissue culture models these cells can increase the growth and metastatic potential of cancer cells. These apparently paradoxical observations underline the complexity of epithelial-stromal signalling within tumours and highlight an area for further study.
Estrogen receptor (ER) action is modulated by posttranslational modifications. Although ERalpha phosphorylation correlates with patient outcome, ERbeta is similarly phosphorylated but its significance in breast cancer has not been addressed. We investigated whether ERbeta that is phosphorylated at serine 105 (S105-ERbeta) is expressed in breast cancer and assessed potential clinical implications of this phosphorylation. Following antibody validation, S105-ERbeta expression was studied in tissue microarrays comprising 108 tamoxifen-resistant and 351 tamoxifen-sensitive cases and analyzed against clinical data. S105-ERbeta regulation in vitro was assessed by Western blot, flow cytometry, and immunofluorescence. Nuclear S105-ERbeta was observed in breast carcinoma and was associated with better survival (Allred score > or =3), even in tamoxifen-resistant cases, and additionally correlated with ERbeta1 and ERbeta2 expression. Distinct S105-ERbeta nuclear speckles were seen in some higher grade tumors. S105-ERbeta levels increased in MCF-7 cells in response to 17beta-estradiol, the ERbeta-specific agonist diarylpropionitrile, and the partial ERbeta-agonist genistein. S105-ERbeta nuclear speckles were also seen in MCF-7 cells and markedly increased in size and number at 24 hours following 17beta-estradiol and, in particular diarylpropionitrile, treatment. These speckles were coexpressed with ERbeta1 and ERbeta2. Presence of S105-ERbeta in breast cancer and association with improved survival, even in endocrine resistant breast tumors suggest S105-ERbeta might be a useful additional prognostic marker in this disease.
Oestrogen receptors (ERs) are critical regulators of the behaviour of many cancers. Despite this, the roles and regulation of one of the two known ERs – ERβ– are poorly understood. This is partly because analyses have been confused by discrepancies between ERβ expression at mRNA and proteins levels, and because ERβ is expressed as several functionally distinct isoforms. We investigated human ERβ 5′ untranslated regions (UTRs) and their influences on ERβ expression and function. We demonstrate that two alternative ERβ 5′UTRs have potent and differential influences on expression acting at the level of translation. We show that their influences are modulated by cellular context and in carcinogenesis, and demonstrate the contributions of both upstream open reading frames and RNA secondary structure. These regulatory mechanisms offer explanations for the non‐concordance of ERβ mRNA and protein. Importantly, we also demonstrate that 5′UTRs allow the first reported mechanisms for differential regulation of the expression of the ERβ isoforms 1, 2 and 5, and thereby have critical influences on ERβ function.
Owing to its rarity, large-scale retrospective studies in male breast cancer have suffered from the small numbers of cases available for study from any one center. Here we describe our experience in establishing a large collection of male breast cancers in tissue microarray format suitable for biomarker analysis by immunohistochemistry.
One hundred and thirty-three female patients admitted to a neurological ward were fully investigated for the presence of organic neurological disease, and assessed for psychiatric disorder and illness behaviour, using the Clinical Interview Schedule (CIS) and the Illness Behaviour Questionnaire (IBQ). The likelihood of the presenting symptoms being due to organic disease was expressed by the neurologists on a visual analogue scale and the psychiatrists used a similar technique to describe whether the symptoms could be the result of psychiatric disorder. Many patients either had clear organic disease or somatic presentation of psychiatric disorder 'somatization', but one-third fell between these two extremes and either had a complex mixture of the two types of illness or could not be accurately diagnosed. The IBQ scores were raised in those with psychiatric disorder but did not help to explain why some patients present to the neurologists with symptoms that are unexplained by either organic disease or psychiatric disorder. Close liaison between neurologists and psychiatrists increases the detection of psychiatric disorder but some patients would require long-term follow-up to understand the true nature of the underlying disorder.
Ninety three female neurological in-patients were assessed in a collaborative neurological and psychiatric study. An overall prevalence of definite psychiatric disorder of 34% was found, depression being the most common diagnosis. Psychiatric morbidity was most common when the neurologist felt that the presentation could not be explained by a neurological disorder. The majority of such patients had symptoms which could be explained by the psychiatric disorder but a substantial number could not be given a definite diagnosis. The General Health Questionnaire was not found to be a useful screening instrument in this setting.
Lettersbe included among various disorders associated with triphasic waves.The pathogenesis of the waves in these disorders is not known, Triphasic waves in Moliaret's meningitis although impairment of dopaminergic system5 and abnormal cerebral glucose Sir: Triphasic waves are recognised findings metabolism4 have been proposed.In met- in EEGs of patients with metabolic encepharizamide encephalopathy, metrizamide in lopathy and Alzheimer's disease;' they are the cerebrospinal fluid is thought to interfere also known to occur in cerebrovascular acci-with the sodium-potassium ATPase cation d,ents,2 acute hyperthyroidism3 and met-pump and competitively inhibit glucose rizamide encephalopathy.'We now report a metabolism.4Mere presence of inflam- patient with Mollaret's meningitis whose matory cells in the cerebrospinal fluid is not EEG showed triphasic waves during likely to be related to the appearance of exacerbations.This association has not pre-triphasic waves because viral, bacterial and viously been described.tuberculous meningitis are not associated A 72-year-old female presented with acute with such waves.It appears that different fever and vomiting.Neurological exam-aetiologic factors (including the "agent" ination showed only neck stiffness.Cere-responsible for Mollaret's meningitis) pro- brospinal fluid was clear and revealed 103 duce dysfunction of a final anatomical or white cells (62% polymorphonuclears, 20% neurochemical mechanism at subcortical lymphocytes and 18% monocytes/mm3), level, resulting in triphasic waves.protein of 1 04 g/l (normal: 0-2 to 0-4) and Finally, we wish to emphasise that the glucose of 4 3 mmol/l (normal: 2 8 to 4.5); presence of triphasic waves in the EEG of bacterial, fungal and viral studies were nega-patients with acute encephalopathy does not tive.There was no laboratory evidence of necessarily indicate a metabolic aetiology.renal or hepatic dysfunction or hypoxia. MBM SUNDARAMEIxtensive work-up for any "hidden" septic P SIEMENS focus was negative.EEG showed frontally