In salmon farming, the use of sterile triploids (3N) can mitigate the problem of escapees interbreeding with wild salmon. However, triploid salmon appear less tolerant to high water temperatures and low oxygen levels compared to diploids (2N). To investigate how the thermal performance and physiology of large (2.5 kg) triploid Atlantic salmon Salmo salar L. differs from those of diploids, both ploidies were subjected to water temperatures between 3 and 18 degrees C. The fish were exposed to reduced oxygen saturations (O-2 sat, 70%), termed hypoxia, at 6 and 18 degrees C. Triploids fed more than diploids between 3 and 9 degrees C and at similar levels at 12 degrees C. At 15 degrees C, the feed intake significantly dropped in both ploidies, although more in triploids. During hypoxia, feed intake was higher in triploids at 6 degrees C and equal to diploids at 18 degrees C. The overall feed conversion ratio was similar between ploidies. Muscle energy phosphates were generally lower in triploids than diploids, while muscle glucose, blood haemoglobin and haematocrit were lower in triploids than diploids at >= 12 degrees C. Plasma lactate levels tended to be higher in triploids and increased with increasing temperature and at hypoxia in both ploidies. Plasma cortisol increased in both ploidies at high temperatures and was highest in triploids under hypoxic conditions at 18 degrees C. Triploids had a higher cataract score at the start of the experiment and developed more cataracts throughout the experiment. The present findings show that large triploid Atlantic salmon perform better at colder water temperatures compared to diploids and differ in parts of their physiological expression at increasing and high temperature.
The use of sterile triploids in Atlantic salmon aquaculture would mitigate the environmental risks associated with introgressive hybridization between escaped farmed and wild Atlantic salmon. However, production of farmed triploid salmon is limited due to reports of poorer growth and higher mortality when compared to diploids, in particular under sub-optimal environmental conditions. To address these concerns, we monitored triploid and diploid Atlantic salmon post-smolts at temperatures between 3 and 18 degrees C and 100% oxygen saturation (O-2 (sat)), and additional periods of 60% O-2 (sat) (hypoxia) at 6 or 18 degrees C, respectively. Feed intake and oxygen consumption rate were monitored throughout the experimental period. Muscle and blood samples were collected at 100 and 60% O-2 (sat) at 6 and 18 degrees C for analysis of white muscle energy phosphates (creatine phosphate, adenosine triphosphate) and carbohydrate fuels (glucose, glycogen) as well as blood clinical chemistry (whole blood: hematocrit; plasma: Na+, K+, Cl-, glucose, lactate, pH, triacylglycerol). Mortality was similar between ploidies, but higher in triploids compared to diploids during reduced O-2 (sat) at 18 degrees C. Compared to diploids, triploids had higher feed intake (% biomass) at <= 9 degrees C, but lower feed intake at >= 15 degrees C. Feed intake peaked at 12 and 15 degrees C for triploids and diploids, respectively. Triploids progressively reduced feed intake with increasing temperature after peak feeding, indicating reduced scope for specific dynamic action with increasing water temperature. During hypoxia, triploids had lower feed intake than diploids at 6 and 18 degrees C. The difference in feed intake was not associated with any ploidy effect on body weight gain or feed conversion ratio, but triploids had greater body length growth compared to diploids. At >= 15 degrees C triploids consumed less oxygen than diploids. In the white musculature, the only observed difference between ploidies was a lower level of glycogen in triploids compared to diploids at 18 degrees C and 100% O-2 (sat). In the blood plasma, the concentration of ions was lower and glucose level higher in triploids compared to diploids at 18 degrees C and 60% O-2 (sat). The results of this study indicate that triploid Atlantic salmon post-smolts can substitute diploids, but are less tolerant to high seawater temperature and low O-2 (sat). For sea-cage farming of triploid salmon post-smolts, this would favour production areas with maximum temperatures of 15 degrees C and sufficient oxygen.Statement of Relevance: This study demonstrates that triploid Atlantic salmon post-smolts have lower temperature optima for feeding and growth than diploids, a similar physiological response to high temperatures, but higher mortality under suboptimal conditions. Consequently triploid Atlantic salmon post-smolts may be well suited for commercial farming in geographical regions with moderate water temperatures in the summer and autumn months. (C) 2017 Elsevier B. V. All rights reserved.
In order to maximize the growth potential of Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar L.) in the on-growing phase in open sea cages, the dissolved oxygen (DO, % of air saturation) level must exceed the minimum DO required for maximal feed intake (DOmaxFI). The main aim of this study was to determine the effect of temperature on this important threshold DO, and secondly, to provide aquaculturists with a model that estimates feed intake as function of both temperature and DO. Quadruple tank groups of Atlantic salmon post-smolts (~0.3–0.5kg) were kept at 7, 11, 15 and 19°C, and subjected to seven DO levels per temperature, ranging from ≈32–92, 42–102, 52–112 and 62–122% O2, respectively, for 42days. DO levels were changed every second day, in random order. Fish were fed a known amount of feed in excess twice daily, waste feed was collected and daily feed intake (DFI, % of biomass, BM, per day) estimated. The routine oxygen consumption rate (MO2 rout, measured in partially fasted and active fish) and the DO below which MO2 rout started to decline (termed the routine limiting oxygen saturation, LOSrout) was determined in fasted fish at all four temperatures at the end of experimentation, and the latter was used to estimate the “zero feed intake DO” in the DFI model. The data demonstrate sustained appetite with decreasing DO until a threshold level (DOmaxFI) is reached, at which point appetite gradually decreases. Both the maximal level of feed intake (DFImax) and the DOmaxFI were highly dependent on temperature, increasing from 0.47 to 0.88% of BM/day, and from 42 to 76% O2, respectively, within the temperature range tested. The LOSrout ranged from 24 to 40% O2. The present study is the first to present the pronounced effect of temperature on DOmaxFI, and results suggest that the DO requirement of A. salmon has previously been considerably over-estimated, particularly at lower temperatures.
A comparative experiment with Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar) and rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) postsmolts was conducted over 35days to provide insight into how growth, respiration, energy metabolism and the growth hormone (GH) and insulin-like growth factor 1 (IGF-1) system are regulated at elevated sea temperatures. Rainbow trout grew better than Atlantic salmon, and did not show reduced growth at 19°C. Rainbow trout kept at 19°C had increased blood hemoglobin concentration compared to rainbow trout kept at 13°C, while salmon did not show the same hemoglobin response due to increased temperature. Both species showed reduced length growth and decreased muscle glycogen stores at 19°C. Circulating IGF-1 concentration was higher in rainbow trout than in Atlantic salmon, but was not affected by temperature in either species. Plasma IGF-binding protein 1b (IGFBP-1b) concentration was reduced in Atlantic salmon reared at 19°C after 15days but increased in rainbow trout at 19 °C after 35days. The igfbp1b mRNA level in liver showed a positive correlation to plasma concentrations of glucose and IGFBP-1b, suggesting involvement of this binding protein in carbohydrate metabolism at 19°C. At this temperature muscle igfbp1a mRNA was down-regulated in both species. The muscle expression of this binding protein correlated negatively with muscle igf1 and length growth. The plasma IGFBP-1b concentration and igfbp1b and igfbp1a expression suggests reduced muscle igf1 signaling at elevated temperature leading to glucose allostasis, and that time course is species specific due to higher thermal tolerance in rainbow trout.
Sterilization by triploid induction prevents interbreeding between escaped farmed salmon and wild stocks, but reduced performance of triploids at high seawater temperatures has been reported. As high temperature may be followed by limited oxygen (O2) supply in net cages, this study compared the effect of reducing O2 from 100% to 70% of air saturation (termed hypoxia) on parameters of production performance (feed intake, growth, feed conversion ratio, mortality), and physiological status (plasma K+, Cl−, Na+, osmolality, glucose, creatinine (Cr), bilirubin, triacylglycerol (TAG) and alkaline phosphatase (ALP) concentrations) in triploid versus diploid Atlantic salmon kept at high seawater temperature (19°C). Two triplicate groups of diploid and two triplicate groups of triploid Atlantic salmon post-smolts were acclimated to 10°C and 100% O2 before experiment start up. During the experiment, temperature was maintained at 10°C for 10days, increased to 19°C over 9days and kept stable at 19°C until the experiment ended (day 51). From day 22 to 51, the O2 level was reduced from 100% O2 to 70% O2 in one diploid and one triploid group. The abbreviated group names are 2N100, 2N70, 3N100 and 3N70. Triploidy led to reductions of feed intake and growth, and this effect was amplified by reducing O2 from 100% to 70% O2. Analyses from blood samples drawn on day 51 show that plasma levels of Cl−, TAG, ALP and bilirubin were lowered in triploids in general, and that plasma Cr levels trebled and plasma K+ levels dropped in triploids subjected to 70% O2 for 29days. Mortality was also significantly higher in the 3N70 group. According to these effects, the following order of production performance is suggested at high seawater temperature (best to worst): 2N100>2N70≥3N100>3N70. An interesting difference in the behavior between diploid and triploid fish was observed during the experiment: triploids generally moved against the tank water current, ram ventilating, as opposed to diploids, which displayed normal gill ventilation and were in part moving along with the current. The inability of triploid Atlantic salmon to withstand high temperature in combination with moderate hypoxia could set limitations to the geographical distribution of triploid salmon farming.
This study investigated the production performance of the Atlantic salmon postsmolt (Salmo salar L.) subjected to cyclic oxygen reductions (hypoxia) of varying severity. Triplicate groups (N = 955) were kept at constant 80% O-2 (control) or subjected to 1 h and 45 min of hypoxia (50, 60 or 70% O-2, termed 80: 70, 80: 60 and 80: 50 groups) every 6 h at 16 C for 69 days. Feed was provided in normoxia. One third of the fish were kept further for 30 days in normoxia to study possible compensatory growth. Cyclic hypoxia did not alter the oxygen uptake rates of fish, measured in night-time. Fish subjected to 50% and 60% O-2 reduced feeding by 13% and 6% compared with the controls, respectively, with corresponding reductions in specific growth rates. Feed utilization was not reduced. Compensatory growth was observed in fish from the 80: 50 group, but full compensation was not achieved. The main conclusions were that feeding in normoxia does not fully alleviate negative effects of cyclic hypoxia on feeding and growth, when oxygen is reduced to 60% or below in hypoxic periods, that feed utilization is maintained, and that compensatory growth may lessen negative effects.
Underwater anti-maturation-lights have recently been exploited to position sea-caged Atlantic salmon (Salmo solar L.) deeper at night in an effort to reduce infections by salmon lice (Lepeophtheirus salmonis) in surface layers. However, anti-maturation-light use is impermanent because lighting during decreasing day-lengths stimulates sexual maturation which is detrimental for fish welfare, growth and meat quality. The effects from lights on maturation are related to both light intensity and light spectrum. Here, we explored caged salmon depth use in response to lights of four low intensities (0.01, 0.10, 1.0 and 10.0 mu E as measured 1 m from the lamps) and seven different colours (broadband white LED lamp and narrow spectrum violet, blue, green, yellow, red and deep red LED lamps). Triplicate sea cages (12 x 12 m and 11 m deep) holding approximately 5000 fish of 1.5 kg were exposed to each light positioned at 10 m depth for one night. Echo sounders registered fish vertical positioning on nights of light treatments and no light (control nights) before and after each light exposure. Results showed that submerged lights generally caused fish to maintain their day-time swimming depth near 10 m (light depth) during the night, as opposed to the typical migration of salmon to upper cage depths at dusk observed on control nights. Quantities of fish staying deep decreased with lowered light intensity, but even 0.1 mu E had effects. All light colours, except deep red, significantly affected swimming depth, with a trend of increased effect at lower wavelength colours. Temperature stratification strengthened light effects when warmer water was near the lamps and weakened effects in the case of warmer water near the surface. This study opens up the potential of using low intensity lights at decreasing day-lengths that may not affect sexual maturation and remain suitable for guiding salmon away from surface waters rich in lice infective stages. (C) 2014 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
A semantic model for overall welfare assessment of Atlantic salmon reared in sea cages is presented. The model, called SWIM 1.0, is designed to enable fish farmers to make a formal and standardized assessment of fish welfare using a set of selected welfare indicators. In order to cover all welfare relevant aspects from the animals' point of view and to create a science-based tool we first identified the known welfare needs of Atlantic salmon in sea cages and searched the literature for feasible welfare indicators. The framework of semantic modelling was used to perform a structured literature review and an evaluation of each indicator. The selected indicators were water temperature, salinity, oxygen saturation, water current, stocking density, lighting, disturbance, daily mortality rate, appetite, sea lice infestation ratio, condition factor, emaciation state, vertebral deformation, maturation stage, smoltification state, fin condition and skin condition. Selection criteria for the indicators were that they should be practical and measureable on the farm, that each indicator could be divided into levels from good to poor welfare backed up by relevant scientific literature. To estimate each indicator's relative impact on welfare, all the indicators were weighted based on their respective literature reviews and according to weighting factors defined as part of the semantic modelling framework. This was ultimately amalgamated into an overall model that calculates welfare indexes for salmon in sea cages. More importantly, the model identifies how each indicator contributes (negatively and positively) to the overall index and hence which welfare needs are compromised or fulfilled.
Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar L.) experience periodic drops in dissolved oxygen (O2) inside aquaculture sea cages. In order to evaluate whether fish function or welfare is compromised during such drops in O2 (termed hypoxia), it is necessary to establish the limit for acceptable O2 reductions; the hypoxia tolerance threshold. In the present study, effects of temperature (6, 12 and 18°C) and hypoxia acclimation (33days of hypoxic periods down to 50% O2 occurring every 6h at 16°C) on the routine oxygen consumption rate (ṀO2) and the limiting oxygen saturation (LOS, defined as the hypoxia tolerance threshold) were investigated in undisturbed, fed fish kept in groups with the aim of resembling commercial aquaculture conditions. ṀO2 was measured using open respirometry where a progressive decline in O2 was caused by fish O2 consumption during a period of low water turnover. LOS was defined as the O2 below which fish were no longer able to uphold routine ṀO2. Both ṀO2 and LOS were found to increase exponentially with temperature (Q10=2.7 for ṀO2 and 1.8 for LOS), but no effect of hypoxia acclimation was found. The mean (±SE) LOS at 6, 12, 16 and 18°C was 30±1, 39±1, 47±1 and 55±2% of air saturation respectively. The variation in LOS within and across temperatures was to a large extent explained by variation in ṀO2 (R2=0.93), suggesting that LOS increases with any factor that raises the metabolic rate of Atlantic salmon. This study provides aquaculturists and legislators with a lower limit for acceptable drops in O2 at temperatures relevant for the on-growing phase in Atlantic salmon aquaculture, and discusses the variation in LOS that can be expected at a given temperature.
The present study investigates vertical distribution of fish size in three 12 m x 12 m wide and 14 m deep sea cages stocked with Atlantic salmon of average weight from 3.5 to 3.7 kg, at commercial densities between 15.6 to 16.2 kg m(-3), in Norway. For each cage, individual fish weight were estimated by three 0.6 m x 0.6 m measuring frames as fish swam through. The frames were positioned at 3, 6 and 9 m depth. Recordings were carried out over five days per cage in succession, and during relatively stable environmental conditions in late autumn 2010. In all cages, measured fish were 15-25% smaller at 3 m compared to the average weights at 6 and 9 m depth. Largest average weight difference between depths within one cage was 0.995 kg. The average weight at 6 and 9 m was higher at night-time compared to daytime. Fish at the lower end of the weight spectrum were predominantly registered at 3 m, while fish at the higher end of the spectrum were mostly registered at the greater depths. Fish of average size were well represented at all three depths. The fact that smaller fish swam shallower may be ascribed to natural behavioural traits and introduce an important consideration in representative sampling within commercial sea cages. In biomass estimations and sea lice counts size-dependent vertical stratification needs to be accounted for.
In order to investigate the effects of hypoxic periods on the feeding behaviour and physiology of Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar L.) post-smolts (237±7g), fish were kept at constant 90% O2 (control) or subjected to cyclic reductions in oxygen, from 90% O2 (termed normoxia) to 40, 50, 60 or 70% O2 (termed hypoxia) for 2h every 6h for 23days at 16°C (groups are denoted as 90:40, 90:50, 90:60, 90:70 and 90:90). Fish were fed to satiation three times per day, twice in hypoxia and once in normoxia. Blood samples were drawn during hypoxic periods on day 0, 7, 14 and 21 and analysed for haematocrit, haemoglobin concentration and plasma cortisol, chloride, lactate and glucose concentrations. During first exposure to hypoxia (day 0), plasma lactate was increased in 90:60, 90:50 and 90:40 groups, plasma cortisol was increased in 90:50 and 90:40 groups and plasma chloride was increased in the 90:40 group, indicating oxygen shortage and stress at oxygen saturations below 60% O2. On day 7, 14 and 21, there were no signs of stress, but plasma lactate levels remained increased in hypoxic periods in 90:40, 90:50 (all the days) and 90:60 groups (day 7 and 14), suggesting that the stress response was down-regulated in spite of a persisting oxygen shortage. Feed intake was reduced according to hypoxia severity in groups subjected to 40–60% O2 during the first meal of the day, and in all experimental groups (40–70% O2) during the third meal of the day. The effect of hypoxia on feed intake persisted throughout the experiment, but total daily feed intake was substantially increased in 90:40 and 90:50 groups during weeks 2 and 3 due to compensatory feeding in the normoxic feeding period. Present results suggest that 70% O2 may represent a threshold for reduced growth and that 60% O2 represents a minimum O2 saturation considering the welfare of Atlantic salmon post-smolts subjected to cyclic hypoxia at 16°C.
Due to global and local climate changes, farmed salmon may experience periods of elevated sea temperatures. An experiment was conducted to examine endocrine and dietary effects of high sea temperatures in adult (2.0 kg) and sexually immature Atlantic salmon, Salmo salar L Groups of salmon were exposed to 19 degrees C while others were kept as controls at 14 degrees C. The experiment lasted for 56 days, and fish were given iso-nitrogenous diets with either a normal (335 g kg(-1); L34) or a lower lipid level (298 g kg(-1); L30). Fish held at 19 degrees C had a reduction in the daily feed intake, growth and feed utilization of more than 50% compared to the controls. Fish at 19 degrees C retained little ingested fat, and high maintenance cost lead to depleted endogenous energy body reserves. Circulating ghrelin concentration and stomach ghrelin-1 and hypothalamus growth hormone secretagogue receptor la-like receptor (GHSR1a-LR) mRNA levels were significantly reduced in salmon at 19 degrees C. An increasing number of fish kept at 19 degrees C had empty gastrointestinal tract after 21 days (11-67%) and 56 days (56-100%), with the highest numbers in fish fed the 134 diet. We suggest that lower circulating ghrelin during negative energy homeostasis induce down-regulation of GHSR1a-LR, neuropeptide V. and anorexigenic factors at transcriptional levels in the hypothalamus, which over time lead to a voluntary anorexia development in adult salmon held at 19 degrees C. Reduction of feed intake and growth may be an important coping strategy for salmon during elevated temperatures. (C) 2011 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
We compared behavioural and physiological responses and recovery time after different acute environmental challenges in groups of salmon parr. The fish were prior to the study conditioned to a flashing light signalling arrival of food 30 s later to study if the strength of Pavlovian conditioned food anticipatory behaviour can be used to assess how salmon parr cope with various challenges. The effect on anticipatory behaviour was compared to the effect on feed intake and physiological responses of oxygen hyper-consumption and cortisol excretion. The challenges were temperature fluctuation (6.5C° over 4 h), hyperoxia (up to 380% O(2) saturation over 4 h), and intense chasing for 10 min. Cortisol excretion was only elevated after hyperoxia and chasing, and returned to baseline levels after around 3 h or less. Oxygen hyper-consumption persisted for even shorter periods. Feed intake was reduced the first feeding after all challenges and recovered within 3 h after temperature and hyperoxia, but was reduced for days after chasing. Food anticipatory behaviour was reduced for a longer period than feed intake after hyperoxia and was low at least 6 h after chasing. Our findings suggest that a recovery of challenged Atlantic salmon parr to baseline levels of cortisol excretion and oxygen consumption does not mean full recovery of all psychological and physiological effects of environmental challenges, and emphasise the need for measuring several factors including behavioural parameters when assessing fish welfare.
In this study we evaluated Pavlovian conditioned food anticipatory behaviour as a potential indicator for stress in groups of Atlantic salmon, and compared this with the physiological stress responses of cortisol excretion into water and hyper-consumption of oxygen. We hypothesised that environmental stress would result in reduced feeding motivation. To assess this, we measured the strength of anticipatory behaviour during a period of flashing light that signalled arrival of food. Further, we expected that fish given a reduced food ration would be less sensitive to environmental stress than fish fed full ration. The fish responded to an acute temperature fluctuation with hyper-consumption of oxygen that decreased in line with the temperature, and elevated cortisol excretion up to 1h after the stressor. These physiological responses did not differ significantly between the food ration groups. The anticipatory behaviour was significantly reduced after the stressor and returned to control levels after 1 to 2h in the reduced ration group, but not until after 3 to 4h in the full ration group. Our results show that acute stress can be measured in terms of changes to feeding motivation, and that it is a more sensitive indicator of stress that influences the fish over a longer time period than measures of change in cortisol excretion.
A bite-and-pull demand-feeding system was introduced to groups of cultured cod (Gadus morhua). For half of the groups trigger actuations were rewarded with food, while actuations were unrewarded in the other groups. Initially, cod responded with frequent triggering, irrespective of whether triggering was rewarded with food or not. The high initial curiosity-driven triggering rate declined rapidly, and was almost perfectly described by an exponential decay model with a decay rate of 7% min− 1. After 3 h, the triggering frequency of the rewarded fish diverged from that of unrewarded fish, and it remained higher throughout the 9 days of the experiment. The initial curiosity-driven triggering allowed the cod to establish the relationship between action and reward in a short time. It is inferred that the time trajectory of action frequency of rewarded fish is the result of several factors and that operant learning can only be verified by comparing action frequencies of rewarded and unrewarded fish, and not by the temporal development in action frequency of rewarded fish alone.