Offshore wind farms are increasingly being commissioned farther from shore, and high voltage alternating current (HVAC) transmission systems are preferred because of their maturity and reliability. However, as cable length increases, ensuring system stability becomes more challenging, making it essential to investigate shunt reactor compensation configurations and converter control strategies. This study examines three different shunt reactor compensation arrangements and two control strategies, grid-forming (GFM) and grid-following (GFL), across three cable lengths (80 km, 120 km, and 150 km). The systems were evaluated based on small-signal stability using disk margins for different active power operating points, and later for different short-circuit ratios (SCR) and X/R. The results demonstrate that the GFM is preferable for longer cables and enhanced stability. The most robust configuration includes a shunt reactor placed in the mid-cable with additional reactors at both ends of the cable, followed by an arrangement with reactors at the beginning and end. The GFM converter control maintained stability across all operating points, cable lengths, and configurations, whereas the stability of the GFL unit was highly dependent on active power injection and struggled under weaker grid conditions. Thus, for longer HVAC cables, it is necessary to employ GFM control units, and it is recommended to use shunt reactors at the cable start and end, as well as at mid-cable, for optimal stability.
The decarbonization of power systems poses unique challenges, especially in ensuring critical services such as black start, which may be delivered by renewable energy sources. However, the dynamics of these sources differ from traditional large inertia generators, requiring a thorough analysis of hardware limitations and capabilities to gauge the potential of renewable energy in such roles. This study investigates the ability of an offshore wind farm to provide top-up or anchor generator system restoration services in case a blackout and remain within a stable voltage operation area. The system here considered consists of an offshore wind farm connected via HVAC export cable to an onshore electrical grid. Findings reveal that variables such as export cable length, shunt compensation, and converter operation significantly influence the overall stability of the power system. Moreover, these factors play a pivotal role in the renewable sources ability to provide both active and reactive power to the electrical grid.
Grid-forming control (GFC) has seen numerous technological advances in their control types, applications, and the multitude of services they provide. Some examples of the services they provide include black start, inertial frequency response, and islanded operation capabilities with the possibility of re-synchronization without the need of additional support from other devices such as storage. State of the art literature proposes a variety of GFCs which can provide single or multiple of these services. However, study of these different GFCs for weakly-connected offshore wind power plants (WPPs) based on time-domain simulation and focusing on the large signal disturbance is not well covered. This paper reviews some of the most researched grid-forming control methods applicable to offshore WPPs and provides a comparative investigation and discussion of their stability properties and applicability, especially when connected to a weak-grid. The paper also provides a discussion on the prerequisites and challenges surrounding the comparative study of different GFCs.
There is an ongoing trend of reduction in short circuit power at the grid connection point due to decommissioning of synchronous generation plants causing system strength issues in wind power plants. Whereas wind power plant rating and export cable length are increasing, further weakening the system strength and accompanied by stability challenges. Under such a scenario, a grid forming control demonstrated to operate in a weaker system has value creation potential for application in wind turbine generators. In addition, the grid forming control can also enable a wind power plant to operate in islanded mode, provide inertially and phase jump active power support. However, the application of grid forming control has challenges because grid forming control applied to a power converter (GFC) has a voltage source behavior and does not stiffly control the grid side active power and thus requires a separate current limiting mechanism. However, there could be potential challenges in maintaining the synchronism of GFC when the current limit is triggered, particularly during the grid voltage phase jump event. Modeling and capturing such a phenomenon is a challenge in a wind farm with many wind turbines. To that end, this paper investigates the modeling adequacy of the aggregated GFC-WF to a single GF-WTG of total WF rating in capturing GFC-WF dynamics. The challenges related to loss of synchronization stability when one or more wind turbine generators enter current limited operation during a grid phase jump events are also evaluated in this paper.
Following from smaller-scale investigations of grid-forming converter control applied to wind turbines in 2017-2018, this study describes a much larger trial involving an entire wind farm, owned and operated by ScottishPower Renewables. To the authors' knowledge, this was the first UK converter-connected wind farm to operate in grid-forming mode, and the largest in the world to date. The 23-turbine, 69 MW farm ran in the grid-forming mode for 6 weeks, exploring inertia contributions between H = 0.2 s and H = 8 s. A number of unscheduled frequency disturbances occurred due to interconnector, combined cycle gas turbine (CCGT) and other trips, to which un-curtailed turbines were able to respond. In addition, several deliberate tests were carried out. The turbines were able to provide a stable and appropriate response at relatively high inertia levels to the frequency events commonly occurring today. The captured responses stimulated a debate as to whether external damping power might be required in a grid-forming converter, or whether internal damping is sufficient to allow stable and robust power-sharing with parallel devices in all grid event scenarios. Analysis in this study suggests that, practically, internal damping is probably appropriate, and that any deficiency in external damping power can be more than mitigated by reactance and/or droop-slope response-time management in the grid-forming converters.
The traditional electrical power system and electricity markets have been designed to work with SGs, and so these have traditionally provided various 'inherent' capabilities to the system critical to ensure the stable operation of the power systems during severe faults and even basic system survival during rare system splits. Due to the potential total absence of SGs approaches during periods of high penetration (HP) of PEIPS infeed, the wider industry has engaged in a closer examination of the lack of these system capabilities [4], [17], [31], [32]. Traditionally, the focus in the context of PEIPS has been on steady state and a limited number of dynamic (faster) aspects recently expanded to include PEIPS contributing fast fault current during system faults and extended contribution to frequency management (although this latter capability has been required from RES for more than 10 years in some countries). Demand side contributions in these contexts are emerging and have significant potential.