Ultra-reliable low-latency communication (URLLC) is specified in 5G New Radio to serve the applications and services with the strict requirements of reliability and latency. The URLLC operation is in licensed spectrum then extended to unlicensed spectrum to support new use cases in the industrial scenario. This requires new features in physical layer to make URLLC work with the strict requirements in both licensed and unlicensed spectrum. This paper focuses on the design of physical uplink shared channel (PUSCH) repetitions for URLLC. In PUSCH repetition, the nominal PUSCH repetitions might be segmented into the smaller actual repetitions due to uplink/downlink (UL/DL) directions in time division duplex (TDD) configuration or slot boundary. This segmentation causes a degradation of the URLLC performance due to a smaller number of valid symbols for PUSCH repetitions, a drop of the repetition in an orphan symbol and an increase of listen before talk (LBT) overhead. To enhance the URLLC performance, two schemes are proposed. The first scheme deals with segmentation due to UL/DL directions by dynamically switching the chosen semi-static DL symbols to UL symbols. The second scheme deals with orphan symbols by transmitting signal in these symbols in order to maintain a continuous PUSCH transmission and avoid an additional LBT. The results show an improvement of URLLC performance in licensed and unlicensed spectrum by applying these two schemes.
In unlicensed spectrum, a 5G device is required to access to a channel by using load based equipment (LBE) where it does channel sensing whenever it has data to transmit or frame based equipment (FBE) where it only does channel sensing per fixed period. The devices using LBE and FBE can coexist in the 5G network. Therefore, this paper provides a Markov chain model to analyze the system where the LBE devices and the FBE devices coexist. Subsequently, based on channel access time and transmission probability from the Markov chain model, we propose that the devices are able to switch dynamically from FBE to LBE to serve data with high priority such as Ultra-reliable low-latency communication or data with high arrival rate and from LBE to FBE to serve data with low priority such as Enhanced mobile broadband or data with low arrival rate. The numerical results show the benefits of the dynamic switch between LBE and FBE in reducing channel access time for high priority data and energy consumption for low priority data.
Ultra-reliable low-latency communication (URLLC) in 5G New Radio has been originally defined only for licensed spectrum. However, due to new use cases in the Industry 4.0 scenarios, URLLC operation is currently being extended to unlicensed spectrum in the ongoing Release 17 of the 3rd Generation Partnership Project. Although in such controlled environments we can guarantee the absence of any other technology sharing the channel on a long-term basis, the uncertainty of obtaining channel access through load based equipment (LBE) or frame based equipment (FBE) can impede with the latency requirements of URLLC. In FBE, the transmitters can be prioritized to support data with different requirements and have lower energy consumption and latency compared to LBE with a big contention window size. In this paper we analyze the performance of FBE in an unlicensed controlled environment through a Markov chain. Based on this analysis, we propose two schemes to improve the URLLC performance in FBE: The first scheme allows the transmitters to use multiple fixed frame period (FFP) configurations while the second scheme configures the FFP's starting point of each transmitter based on its priority. The simulations show the benefits of these schemes compared to the URLLC transmission of existing schemes.
The 3rd Generation Partnership Project (3GPP) has defined Ultra-Reliable Low-Latency Communication (URLLC) as one of the main objectives of 5G development to satisfy the applications with stringent requirements of latency and reliability. Uplink (UL) configured-grant (CG) transmission where the user equipment (UE) transmits a packet without scheduling request (SR) and UL grant is standardized by 3GPP Release 15 to reduce latency. The UE also transmits automatically a configured number of repetitions without feedback from the base station (gNB) to increase reliability.Nevertheless, the repetitions are not allowed to transmit outside the hybrid automatic repeat request (HARQ) process containing the first repetition. It might cause a smaller number of transmitted repetitions than configuration that is harmful to the performance of URLLC.This paper uses the reserved resources where the UEs can transmit the repetitions outside the original HARQ process until the configured number is reached. The scheme is developed further when the gNB is equipped with a successive interference cancellation (SIC) receiver so it can decode multiple repetitions of the different UEs in the same reserved resource. The use of reserved resources ensures the performance of UL CG transmission while SIC receiver minimizes the reserved resource’s consumption. The numerical results show a higher transmission reliability and lower reserved resource consumption of the proposed scheme compared to the related works.
Ultra-reliable low-latency communication (URLLC) is one of the main services in 5G New Radio (NR) to serve the applications with the strict requirements of latency and reliability. Increase of mobile traffic and bandwidth requirements for new applications have resulted in a shortage of licensed spectrum so that even URLLC services are deemed to be running over the unlicensed spectrum. This may require a significant re-design of channel access, transmission and reception procedures over the unlicensed spectrum and is currently being investigated in The 3rd Generation Partnership Project (3GPP) Release 17.This paper focuses on the channel access mechanism for URLLC services over the unlicensed spectrum. It provides an analytical analysis of current channel access procedures, listen before talk (LBT). LBT states in random duration channel access are modeled through Markov chains which help characterize the closed form expressions for average channel access time. These expressions are evaluated using the parameters from currently standardized channel access priority classes. The evaluation shows the total inability of several current channel access classes to support URLLC services over the unlicensed spectrum even under low load conditions.The insights gained from this analysis lead the proposal of new channel access priority classes where new special classes are introduced for URLLC services. The results are provided demonstrating the improved performance of URLLC services in the unlicensed spectrum with the proposed changes in the channel access procedures.
Ultra-reliable low-latency communication (URLLC) is one of the new service categories specified by The 3rd Generation Partnership Project (3GPP) that will be used for the applications with the strict reliability and latency requirements. To satisfy these requirements in Release 16, URLLC downlink (DL) transmission can be scheduled in the semi-persistent scheduling (SPS) resources to reduce control overhead and a retransmission if necessary is triggered by hybrid automatic repeat request (HARQ) feedback transmitted in uplink (UL) resources. However, in time division duplex (TDD) mode, HARQ feedback is dropped when there are no available UL resources for physical uplink control channel (PUCCH) in the indicated slot/sub-slot because that slot/sub-slot contains DL symbols in semi-static TDD configuration or flexible symbols updated to DL symbols in dynamic TDD configuration. Dropping the feedback results in a degradation of DL SPS quality of service (QoS) and may not be acceptable for URLLC based services and applications. This paper provides a scheme to guarantee the transmission of HARQ feedback and potential data retransmission when there is UL-DL slot/sub-slot conflict at the indicated feedback resource. The scheme comprises a dynamic indication of feedback resource without using an associated downlink control information (DCI). An acknowledgement (ACK)-only feedback protocol is proposed to best suit the scenario in question. The combination of dynamic indication of feedback resource and ACK-only feedback structure guarantees higher reliability and brings flexibility to the transmission of HARQ feedback as confirmed by the simulations.
Ultra-reliable low-latency communication (URLLC) has been introduced in 5G new radio for new applications that have strict reliability and latency requirements such as augmented/virtual reality, industrial automation and autonomous vehicles. The first full set of the physical layer design of 5G release, Release 15, was finalized in December 2017. It provided a foundation for URLLC with new features such as flexible sub-carrier spacing, a sub-slot-based transmission scheme, new channel quality indicator, new modulation and coding scheme tables, and configured-grant transmission with automatic repetitions. The second 5G release, Release 16, was finalized in December 2019 and allows achieving improved metrics for latency and reliability to support new use cases of URLLC. A number of new features such as enhanced physical downlink (DL) control channel monitoring capability, new DL control information format, sub-slot physical uplink (UL) control channel transmission, sub-slot-based physical UL shared channel repetition, enhanced mobile broadband and URLLC inter-user-equipment multiplexing with cancellation indication and enhanced power control were standardized. This article provides a detailed overview of the URLLC features from 5G Release 15 to Release 16 by describing how these features allow meeting URLLC target requirements in 5G networks. The ongoing Release 17 targets further enhanced URLLC operation by improving mechanisms such as feedback, intra-user-equipment multiplexing and prioritization of traffic with different priority, support of time synchronization and new quality of service related parameters. In addition, a fundamental feature targeted in URLLC Release 17 is to enable URLLC operation over shared unlicensed spectrum. The potential directions of URLLC research in unlicensed spectrum in Release 17 are presented to serve as a bridge from URLLC in licensed spectrum in Release 16 to URLLC in unlicensed spectrum in Release 17.
To meet the strict requirements of Ultra-Reliable Low-Latency Communication in the uplink, grant-free uplink transmission has been specified, allowing the UE to transmit data in a random-access fashion without first transmitting a scheduling request and then waiting for a uplink grant from the gNB. To further increase the reliability, these grant-free uplink transmissions can be repeated without waiting for HARQ feedback from the gNB. However, these repetitions have to happen within a certain interval to avoid a confusion in HARQ IDs of different HARQ processes. When a UE starts transmitting late in the interval, it, therefore, can not exploit all the possible repetitions and thus reliability and latency decrease. In this paper, a scheme based on reserved resources is proposed to ensure the number of repetitions in a specific period. The size of each reserved resource is optimized depending on its position so as to reduce resource consumption. The scheme evaluated by theoretical analysis and numerical results shows its benefits to system performance.
In Ultra-Reliable Low-Latency Communication (URLLC), the user (UE) can be configured to transmit in grant-free/configured-grant (GF/CG) resources for uplink (UL) transmission that does not require the UE to transmit scheduling request (SR) and receive UL grant to reduce latency. In addition, the UE is also configured to transmit automatically a specific number of repetitions without waiting feedback. However, these repetitions are only allowed to carry out in an interval with period P to avoid identity (ID) confusion in a Hybrid automatic repeat request (HARQ) process. Thereby, there is a chance that the UE cannot transmit all repetitions as configured if data arrives late and it leads to a drop of reliability. Two approaches are proposed in this paper to cope with this problem. This first approach requires an usage of the explicit HARQ feedback structure and the second one is related to an additional SR transmitted by the UE in parallel with data. The numerical results show the benefit of these two methods in increasing system performance in case of less configured repetitions made when they help the system to avoid or reduce packet loss due to Demodulation Reference Signal (DMRS) miss-detection.
In uplink (UL) transmission, the Ultra-Reliable Low-Latency Communication (URLLC) users (UEs) might be assigned the grant-free (GF)/configured-grant (CG) periodic resources to transmit data straightaway instead of sending scheduling request (SR) and receiving UL grant. However, when these resources are not in use by the URLLC traffic, the base station (called gNB) can dynamically schedule the Enhanced Mobile Broadband (eMBB) UEs to transmit in the GF resources to increase the resource efficiency. This may lead to potential collision and detrimental QoS for URLLC as some of the URLLC UEs may become active and try to use the same resource assigned to an eMBB UE. In this paper, a two-step strategy containing an overlap indication and explicit Hybrid automatic repeat request (HARQ) feedback is proposed to improve URLLC performance in multiplexing with eMBB. Besides the explicit HARQ feedback structure, a scheme with an additional SR is also presented. Simulation results show that these two schemes help achieving URLLC requirements by reducing error probability due to Demodulation Reference Signal (DMRS) miss-detection while allowing better resource efficiency.
5G will be supporting new services that have remarkably higher requirements than LTE 4G and Ultra-reliable and low-latency communication (URLLC) is one of those emerged categories. Although various techniques have been proposed to improve the data reliability, there has been a gap in how to improve the reliability of control/scheduling information pointing to the scheduled data. In this paper, we propose an intelligent combining of retransmissions of physical downlink control channel (PDCCH) and the physical downlink data channel (PDSCH). In the proposed scheme, the downlink control information (DCI) on PDCCH already indicates the location of a potential retransmission of the corresponding PDSCH. Moreover, the retransmitted DCI can be combined with the first transmission so that resource consumption and latency are reduced compared to the conventional scheme. Theoretical calculations and simulation results show a decrease of resource consumption.
Ultra-dense small cell networks will require sophisticated user association algorithms that consider (i) channel characteristics, (ii) base station load, and (iii) uplink/downlink (UL/DL) traffic profiles. They will also be characterized by high spatio-temporal variability in UL/DL traffic demand, due to the fewer users per BS. In this direction, Dynamic TDD is a promising new technique to match BS resources to actual demand. While plenty of literature exists on the problem of user association, and some recent on dynamic TDD, most works consider these separately. In this paper, we argue that user association policies are strongly coupled with the allocation of resources between UL and DL. We propose an algorithm that decomposes the problem into separate subproblems that can each be solved efficiently and in a distributed manner, and prove convergence to the global optimum. Simulation results suggest that our approach can improve UL and DL performance at the same time, with an aggregate improvement of more than 2×, compared to user association under static TDD allocation.
Operators, struggling to continuously add capacity and upgrade their architecture to keep up with data traffic increase, are turning their attention to denser deployments that improve spectral efficiency. Denser deployments make the problem of user association challenging, and much work has been devoted to finding algorithms that strike a tradeoff between user quality of service, and network-wide performance (load-balancing). Nevertheless, the majority of these algorithms typically consider simple setups with a single type of traffic, usually elastic non-guaranteed bit rate (GBR). They also focus on the radio access part, ignoring the backhaul topology and potential capacity limitations. Backhaul constraints are emerging as a key performance bottleneck in future networks, partly due to the continuous improvement of the radio interface, and partly due to the need for inexpensive backhaul links to reduce capital and operational expenditures. To this end, we propose an analytical framework for user association that jointly considers radio access and backhaul network performance. Specifically, we derive an algorithm that takes into account spectral efficiency, base station load, backhaul link capacities and topology, and two traffic classes (GBR and non-GBR) in both the uplink and downlink directions. We prove analytically an optimal user association rule that ends up maximizing either an arithmetic or a weighted harmonic mean of the achieved performance along different dimensions (e.g., uplink and downlink performances or GBR and non-GBR performances). We then use extensive simulations to study the impact of: 1) traffic differentiation; and 2) backhaul capacity limitations and topology on key performance metrics.
Operators, struggling to continuously add capacity and upgrade their architecture to keep up with data traffic increase, are turning their attention to denser deployments that improve spectral efficiency. Denser deployments make the problem of user association challenging, and much work has been devoted to finding algorithms that strike a tradeoff between user quality of service (QoS), and network-wide performance (load-balancing). Nevertheless, the majority of these algorithms typically consider only the radio access part, and ignore the backhaul topology and potential capacity limitations. Backhaul constraints are emerging as a key performance bottleneck in future heterogeneous networks, partly due to the continuous improvement of the radio interface, and partly due to the need for inexpensive backhaul links to reduce CAPEX/OPEX. To this end, we propose an analytical framework for user association that jointly considers radio access and backhaul performance. We derive an algorithm that takes into account spectral efficiency, base station load, backhaul link capacities and topology, and uplink and downlink traffic demand, and prove it converges to an optimal solution. We then use extensive simulations to study the impact of (i) backhaul capacity limitations and (ii) backhaul topology on key performance metrics.
We study in this paper the problem of binary power control in interference channels with single-antenna nodes. In many practical scenarios, letting transmitters (TXs) exchange the locally available channel state information (CSI) is unpractical. In such cases, coordinating the power allocation is a difficult problem and we propose in this work a novel binary power control policy for maximizing the ergodic sum-rate when each TX has only access to the instantaneous channel realization of the direct channel to its own user. We prove rigorously the intuitive result that the optimal binary power control policy consists in letting each TX transmits with full power if and only if the realization of this direct channel is above a threshold. The power control policy obtained with the algorithm is a “best-response” power control policy and allows to achieve benefits of coordinated power allocation at a low cost in terms of backhaul resources and complexity.
Obtaining accurate Channel State Information (CSI) at the transmitters (TX) is critical to many cooperation schemes such as Network MIMO, Interference Alignment etc. Practical CSI feedback and limited backhaul-based sharing inevitably creates degradations of CSI which are specific to each TX, giving rise to a distributed form of CSI. In the Distributed CSI (D-CSI) broadcast channel setting, the various TXs design elements of the precoder based on their individual estimates of the global multiuser channel matrix, which intuitively degrades performance when compared with the commonly used centralized CSI assumption. This paper tackles this challenging scenario and presents a first analysis of the rate performance for the distributed CSI multi-TX broadcast channel setting, in the large number of antenna regime. Using Random Matrix Theory (RMT) tools, we derive deterministic equivalents of the Signal to Interference plus Noise Ratio (SINR) for the popular regularized Zero-Forcing (ZF) precoder, allowing to unveil the price of distributedness for such cooperation methods.
This paper studies the Gaussian half duplex relay channel, where the relay node can not transmit and receive at the same time. The main contribution lies in showing that both Partial-Decode-Forward and Compress-Forward achieve the CutSet upper bound to within a constant gap regardless of the channel parameters. This provides a closed form characterization of the Generalized Degrees-of-Freedom (gDoF) of the channel, which for certain channel parameters is strictly smaller than the gDoF of the full duplex channel. Half duplex channels can convey information through the random switch between the receive and retransmit phases; this work shows numerically that random switch achieves larger rates compared to deterministic switch, which is usually considered in the literature.
This paper studies the Gaussian interference channel with unilateral generalized feedback, a system where two source-destination pairs share the same channel and where one full-duplex source overhears the other through a noisy in-band link. A superposition coding scheme is shown to achieve a known outer bound to within a small number of bits for a subset of the weak interference regime, outside which more sophisticated coding techniques based on binning are conjectured to be needed. By using the generalized Degrees of Freedom (gDoF) as performance metric, unilateral generalized feedback is shown to strictly increase the gDoF region compared to the non-cooperative case only when the strength of the cooperation link is larger than a threshold, thus providing an indication on when cooperation among users is beneficial in practical wireless systems.
This paper studies the two-user interference channel with unilateral source cooperation, which consists of two source-destination pairs that share the same channel and where one full-duplex source can overhear the other source through a noisy in-band link. Novel outer bounds of the type 2R1 + R2 and R1 + 2R2 are developed for the class of injective semi-deterministic channels with independent noises at the different source-destination pairs. The bounds are then specialized to the Gaussian noise case. Interesting insights are provided about when these types of bounds are active, or in other words, when unilateral cooperation is too weak and leaves some system resources underutilized.
This paper considers the two-user Gaussian causal cognitive interference channel (GCCIC), which consists of two source-destination pairs that share the same channel and where one full-duplex cognitive source can causally learn the message of the primary source through a noisy link. The GCCIC is an interference channel with unilateral source cooperation that better models practical cognitive radio networks than the commonly used model which assumes that one source has perfect noncausal knowledge of the other source's message. First, the sum-capacity of the symmetric GCCIC is determined to within a constant gap. Then, the insights gained from the study of the symmetric GCCIC are extended to more general cases. In particular, the whole capacity region of the Gaussian Z-channel, i.e., when there is no interference from the primary user, and of the Gaussian S-channel, i.e., when there is no interference from the secondary user, are both characterized to within 2 bits. The fully connected general, i.e., no-symmetric, GCCIC is also considered and its capacity region is characterized to within 2 bits when, roughly speaking, the interference is not weak at both receivers. The parameter regimes where the GCCIC is equivalent, in terms of generalized degrees-of-freedom, to the noncooperative interference channel (i.e., unilateral causal cooperation is not useful), to the non-causal cognitive interference channel (i.e., causal cooperation attains the ultimate limit of cognitive radio technology), and to bilateral source cooperation are identified. These comparisons shed light into the parameter regimes and network topologies that in practice might provide an unbounded throughput gain compared to currently available (non cognitive) technologies.