Recent progress in immunobiology has led the way to successful host immunity enhancement against breast cancer. In triple-negative breast cancer, the combination of cancer immunotherapy based on PD-1/PD-L1 immune checkpoint inhibitors with chemotherapy was effective both in advanced and early setting phase 3 clinical trials. These encouraging results lead to the first approvals of immune checkpoint inhibitors in triple-negative breast cancer and thus offer new therapeutic possibilities in aggressive tumors and hard-to-treat populations. Furthermore, several ongoing trials are investigating combining immunotherapies involving immune checkpoint inhibitors with conventional therapies and as well as with other immunotherapeutic strategies such as cancer vaccines, CAR-T cells, bispecific antibodies, and oncolytic viruses in all breast cancer subtypes. This review provides an overview of immunotherapies currently under clinical development and updated key results from clinical trials. Finally, we discuss the challenges to the successful implementation of immune treatment in managing breast cancer and their implications for the design of future clinical trials.

Background: Triple-negative breast cancer (TNBC) is the subtype of breast cancer with the worst prognosis and is the subtype most often associated with germline mutations of BRCA1 as well as other genes. Alpha-lactalbumin (aLA) is a milk protein expressed in lactating breasts but not at other times or in other normal tissues. Expression of aLA is found in approximately 70% of TNBC (Cancers PMID: 27322324) so is an attractive immunologic target for TNBC based on the “retired protein hypothesis” (Semin Immunol PMID: 31926646). Pre-clinical studies have shown that vaccination with aLA inhibits the growth of established breast tumors and provides potent protection from development of autochthonous tumors in transgenic murine models of breast cancer and against 4T1 transplantable breast cancer in BALB/c mice (Nat Med PMID: 20512124). Specific Aims: We are conducting a Phase I trial of vaccination with an aLA vaccine in patients with early stage TNBC to demonstrate the safety of this approach and to document the ability to produce a relevant immunologic response to aLA. Trial Design: Patients are being entered into a Phase I trial of alpha-lactalbumin with GMP-grade zymosan adjuvant in Montanide ISA 51 VG vehicle. Subjects receive a total of 3 vaccinations administered once every 2 weeks. Toxic events of Common Terminology Criteria for Adverse Events (CTCAE) grade 2 or greater are considered dose-limiting. Dose levels being tested in the current protocol are alpha-lactalbumin/zymosan 0.01/0.01, 0.1/0.01, 0.5/0.01, 0.5/0.03, and 0.5 mg/0.06 mg. Patients are being monitored for toxicity until 84 days after the first vaccination or resolution of toxicity, whichever is later. Blood is being drawn prior to therapy and 14, 28, and 56 days after the first vaccination to assess cellular response using enzyme-linked immunosorbent spot (ELISpot) assays of interferon-gamma and interleukin-17 production in response to aLA. Humoral response to aLA vaccination is being assessed by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA). Eligibility Criteria: Patients with ER-negative, PR-negative, HER2-negative breast cancer of pathologic stage II-III or who had residual disease after standard pre-operative systemic therapy. Participants must be within 3 years of initiation of treatment and have no evidence of recurrence. Dose Selection: Doses are being escalated using a 3+3 trial design to determine the maximum tolerated dose, the lowest immunologic dose and the optimal immunologic dose Present Accrual and Target Accrual: Dependent on toxicity, 18-30 patients will be treated. Future Plans and Contact Information: After identification of the maximum tolerated dose and expansion of the dose levels associated with effective tumor immunity we plan to enroll 2 additional cohorts of patients: 1) patients who have completed pre-operative chemo-immunotherapy and are receiving pembrolizumab as standard of care therapy, and 2) patients without cancer planning to undergo prophylactic bilateral mastectomy. Interested parties may contact Dr. Budd at buddg@ccf.org. Funding Source: Department of Defense (W81XWH-17-1-0592 and W81XWH-17-1-0593) Citation Format: George Budd, Justin M. Johnson, Emily Rhoades, Halle Moore, Megan L. Kruse, Erin Roesch, Jame Abraham, Brenna Elliott, Elena Haury, Vincent K. Tuohy. Phase I trial of an alpha-lactalbumin vaccine in patients with operable triple-negative breast cancer (TNBC) [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the 2022 San Antonio Breast Cancer Symposium; 2022 Dec 6-10; San Antonio, TX. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Cancer Res 2023;83(5 Suppl):Abstract nr OT2-10-02.

Background: Triple-negative breast cancer (TNBC) has a poor prognosis and may be associated with germline mutations. α-lactalbumin (aLA) is expressed in lactating breasts but not at other times or in other tissues. Expression of aLA is found in 70% of TNBC (PMID: 27322324) so could be an immunologic target for TNBC based on the “retired protein hypothesis” (PMID: 31926646). In pre-clinical studies vaccination with aLA inhibited growth of established breast tumors and provided protection from development of autochthonous tumors in transgenic murine models of breast cancer and against 4T1 transplantable breast cancer in BALB/c mice (PMID: 20512124). Methods: To determine the safety and immunogenicity of aLA, patients with early stage TNBC are being entered in a Phase I trial of aLA with GMP-grade zymosan adjuvant in Montanide ISA 51 VG vehicle. Subjects receive 3 vaccinations given once every 2 weeks. Events of Common Terminology Criteria for Adverse Events (CTCAE) grade ≥2 are considered dose-limiting toxicities (DLTs). Results: CTCAE toxicity by dose level is summarized below. All DLTs were injection site reactions, with ulceration and need for incisional drainage representing the grade 3 events. ELISpot assays to determine frequencies of T-cells producing IFN-γ and IL-17 in response to recombinant aLA and ELISA assays of antibody response to aLA will be available in December 2022. Conclusion: Dose level 2 appears to be the maximum tolerated dose. Accrual to dose levels 1 and 2 will be expanded to further define toxicity and immunologic effects. Accrual of patients with BRCA1 or PALB2 mutations planning to undergo prophylactic mastectomy is beginning in order to define the toxicity and immunologic effects in this group and to determine whether inflammatory changes from occult lactational foci will be produced. Funding Source: Department of Defense (W81XWH-17-1-0592 and W81XWH-17-1-0593) Worst Toxicity by Dose Level Dose Level aLAC (mcg) dose Zymosan (mcg) dose n Patients n Grade 0 n Grade 1 n Grade 2 n Grade 3 1 10 10 3 3 2 100 10 3 3 3 500 10 3 2 1 Original 2 100 100 1 1 Citation Format: George Thomas Budd, Justin M. Johnson, Emily Rhoades, Halle Moore, Holly Levengood, Megan Kruse, Erin Roesch, Jame Abraham, Brenna Elliott, Elena Haury, Rachel Swartz, Holly Pederson, Zahraa Al Hilli, Vincent Tuohy. Phase I trial of alpha-lactalbumin vaccine in high-risk operable triple-negative breast cancer [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the American Association for Cancer Research Annual Meeting 2023; Part 1 (Regular and Invited Abstracts); 2023 Apr 14-19; Orlando, FL. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Cancer Res 2023;83(7_Suppl):Abstract nr 3035.

Recent progress in immunobiology has led the way to successful host immunity enhancement against breast cancer. In triple-negative breast cancer, the combination of cancer immunotherapy based on PD-1/PD-L1 immune checkpoint inhibitors with chemotherapy was effective both in advanced and early setting phase 3 clinical trials. These encouraging results lead to the first approvals of immune checkpoint inhibitors in triple-negative breast cancer and thus offer new therapeutic possibilities in aggressive tumors and hard-to-treat populations. Furthermore, several ongoing trials are investigating combining immunotherapies involving immune checkpoint inhibitors with conventional therapies and as well as with other immunotherapeutic strategies such as cancer vaccines, CAR-T cells, bispecific antibodies, and oncolytic viruses in all breast cancer subtypes. This review provides an overview of immunotherapies currently under clinical development and updated key results from clinical trials. Finally, we discuss the challenges to the successful implementation of immune treatment in managing breast cancer and their implications for the design of future clinical trials.

Purpose Epithelial ovarian carcinoma (EOC) is the most lethal of all human gynecologic malignancies. We previously reported that vaccination of female mice with the extracellular domain of anti-Müllerian hormone receptor II (AMHR2-ED) in complete Freund’s adjuvant (CFA) generates AMHR2-ED specific immunoglobulin G (IgG) that provides prevention and therapy against murine EOCs. Although CFA is the “gold standard” adjuvant in animal studies, it is not approved for human use because it often induces painful granulomas and abscesses. Thus, the objective of this study is to identify an alternative adjuvant to CFA for use in our ovarian cancer vaccine clinical trials. Materials and Methods Because it has been used successfully without serious adverse effects in numerous human clinical trials, we selected the IgG-inducing squalene-based adjuvant, AddaVax™, for evaluation of its ability to facilitate vaccine-induced prevention and treatment of EOC in mice. To this end, we immunized female C57BL/6 mice with recombinant mouse AMHR2-ED emulsified with either AddaVax or CFA as adjuvant and compared the results. Results We found that formulation of the AMHR2-ED vaccine with AddaVax adjuvant induced high serum titers of IgG and significant inhibition of EOC growth with significantly enhanced overall survival of mice using both prevention and therapeutic protocols. These results were compared favorably with results obtained using CFA as an adjuvant in the AMHR2-ED vaccine. Conclusion Our data indicate that the AMHR2-ED vaccine formulated with AddaVax may be used in human clinical trials and thereby serve as a novel and effective way to control human EOC.

Epithelial ovarian carcinoma (EOC) is the most prevalent and lethal form of ovarian cancer. The low five-year overall survival after EOC diagnosis indicates an urgent need for more effective ways to control this disease. Anti-Müllerian hormone receptor 2 (AMHR2) is an ovarian protein overexpressed in the majority of human EOCs. We have previously found that vaccination against the ovarian-specific extracellular domain of AMHR2 (AMHR2-ED) significantly inhibits growth of murine EOCs through an IgG-mediated mechanism that agonizes receptor signaling of a Bax/caspase-3 dependent proapoptotic cascade. To determine if a single monoclonal antibody (mAb) could inhibit growth of human EOC, we generated a panel of mAbs specific for recombinant human AMHR2-ED and characterized a candidate mAb for humanization and use in clinical trials. We found that our candidate 4D12G1 mAb is an IgG1 that shows high affinity antigen-specific binding to the 7-mer 20KTLGELL26 sequence of AMHR2-ED that facilitates induction of programmed cell death in EOC cells. Most importantly, the 4D12G1 mAb significantly inhibits growth of primary human EOCs in patient-derived xenografts (PDXs) by inducing direct apoptosis of EOC tumors. Our results support the view that a humanized 4D12G1 mAb may be a much needed and effective reagent for passive immunotherapy of human EOC.

Despite the enormous success of childhood prophylactic vaccination against diseases caused by pathogens, there is currently no similar preventive vaccine program against diseases confronted with age like breast cancer and ovarian cancer. With the exception of the annual influenza vaccine, current recommendations for adult vaccination are for either primary vaccines not received during childhood or for booster vaccinations to maintain the immunity against pathogens already induced during childhood. Here we describe a strategy to provide prophylactic pre-emptive immunity against the development of adult onset cancers not associated with any definitive etiopathogenic agent. We propose that safe and effective pre-emptive immunity may be induced in cancer-free subjects by vaccination against immunodominant tissue-specific self-proteins that are 'retired' from expression in normal tissues as part of the normal aging process but are expressed in tumors that emerge with age. Primary immunoprevention of adult onset cancers like breast cancer and ovarian cancer represents a great challenge and an even greater unmet need for our current healthcare.

Epithelial ovarian carcinoma (EOC) is the most prevalent form of ovarian cancer in the United States, representing approximately 85% of all cases and causing more deaths than any other gynecologic malignancy. We propose that optimized control of EOC requires the incorporation of a vaccine capable of inducing safe and effective preemptive immunity in cancer-free women. In addition, we hypothesize that ovarian-specific self-proteins that are “retired” from autoimmune-inducing expression levels as ovaries age but are expressed at high levels in emerging EOC may serve as vaccine targets for mediating safe and effective primary immunoprevention. Here, we show that expression of the extracellular domain of anti-Müllerian hormone receptor II (AMHR2-ED) in normal tissues is confined exclusively to the human ovary, drops to nonautoimmune inducing levels in postmenopausal ovaries, and is at high levels in approximately 90% of human EOC. We found that AMHR2-ED vaccination significantly inhibits growth of murine EOC and enhances overall survival without inducing oophoritis in aged female mice. The observed inhibition of EOC growth was mediated substantially by induction of AMHR2-ED–specific IgG antibodies that agonize receptor signaling of a Bax/caspase-3–dependent proapoptotic cascade. Our results indicate that AMHR2-ED vaccination may be particularly useful in providing safe and effective preemptive immunity against EOC in women at high genetic or familial risk who have the greatest need for a preventive vaccine and ultimately in cancer-free postmenopausal women who account for 75% of all EOC cases. Cancer Prev Res; 10(11); 612–24. ©2017 AACR. See related editorial by Shoemaker et al., p. 607

BACKGROUND:Testicular cancer is the most common male neoplasm occurring in men between the ages of 20 and 34. Although germ-line testicular tumors respond favorably to current standard of care, testicular stromal cell (TSC) tumors derived from Sertoli cells or Leydig cells often fail to respond to chemotherapy or radiation therapy and have a 5-year overall survival significantly lower than the more common and more treatable germ line testicular tumors.METHODS:To improve outcomes for TSC cancer, we have developed a therapeutic vaccine targeting inhibin-α, a protein produced by normal Sertoli and Leydig cells of the testes and expressed in the majority of TSC tumors.RESULTS:We found that vaccination against recombinant mouse inhibin-α provides protection and therapy against transplantable I-10 mouse TSC tumors in male BALB/c mice. Similarly, we found that vaccination with the immunodominant p215-234 peptide of inhibin-α (Inα 215-234) inhibits the growth of autochthonous TSC tumors occurring in male SJL.AMH-SV40Tag transgenic mice. The tumor immunity and enhanced overall survival induced by inhibin-α vaccination may be passively transferred into naive male BALB/c recipients with either CD4+ T cells, B220+ B cells, or sera from inhibin-α primed mice.CONCLUSIONS:Considering the lack of any alternative effective treatment for chemo- and radiation-resistant TSC tumors, our results provide for the first time a rational basis for immune-mediated control of these aggressive and lethal variants of testicular cancer.

We have proposed that safe and effective protection against the development of adult onset cancers may be achieved by vaccination against tissue-specific self-proteins that are "retired" from expression at immunogenic levels in normal tissues as we age, but are overexpressed in emerging tumors. α-Lactalbumin is an example of a "retired" self-protein because its expression in normal tissues is confined exclusively to the breast during late pregnancy and lactation, but is also expressed in the vast majority of human triple negative breast cancers (TNBC)-the most aggressive and lethal form of breast cancer and the predominant form that occurs in women at high genetic risk including those with mutated BRCA1 genes. In anticipation of upcoming clinical trials, here we provide preclinical data indicating that α-lactalbumin has the potential as a vaccine target for inducing safe and effective primary immunoprevention as well as immunotherapy against TNBC.

Perhaps we can now hope that primary immunoprevention of cancers that are engaged as people age may receive the attention, support, and legitimacy that will soon result in similar breakthrough stature.

Multiple sclerosis (MS) is widely viewed as a prototypic human autoimmune disease involving proinflammatory T cells that induce lesions in the central nervous system (CNS) in response to myelin self proteins. Although the impact of sex hormones on MS is well recognized, the converse effects of autoimmunity on sex hormones are still unclear. The current study was designed to assess the impact of CNS autoimmunity on female reproductive physiology. In order to identify subtle hormonal disturbances as a result of autoimmunity, we analyzed the estrous cycle in SJL/J mice after active induction of experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE), an animal model with substantial similarities to MS. Here we show that CNS autoimmunity significantly shortens the murine estrous cycle. This shortening of the estrous cycle is characterized by a dramatic decrease in the length of the metestrus–diestrus luteal phase partially offset by a highly significant but less dramatic elongation of the proestrus–estrus follicular phase of the uterine cycle. Thus, our study provides experimental evidence for a direct causal link between CNS autoimmunity and disruption of the homeostatic balance of the uterine cycle often observed in women with MS.

Anti-Müllerian hormone receptor, type II (AMHR2), is a differentiation protein expressed in 90% of primary epithelial ovarian carcinomas (EOCs), the most deadly gynecologic malignancy. We propose that AMHR2 may serve as a useful target for vaccination against EOC. To this end, we generated the recombinant 399-amino acid cytoplasmic domain of mouse AMHR2 (AMHR2-CD) and tested its efficacy as a vaccine target in inhibiting growth of the ID8 transplantable EOC cell line in C57BL/6 mice and in preventing growth of autochthonous EOCs that occur spontaneously in transgenic mice. We found that AMHR2-CD immunization of C57BL/6 females induced a prominent antigen-specific proinflammatory CD4+ T cell response that resulted in a mild transient autoimmune oophoritis that resolved rapidly with no detectable lingering adverse effects on ovarian function. AMHR2-CD vaccination significantly inhibited ID8 tumor growth when administered either prophylactically or therapeutically, and protection against EOC growth was passively transferred into naive recipients with AMHR2-CD-primed CD4+ T cells but not with primed B cells. In addition, prophylactic AMHR2-CD vaccination of TgMISIIR-TAg transgenic mice significantly inhibited growth of autochthonous EOCs and provided a 41.7% increase in mean overall survival. We conclude that AMHR2-CD vaccination provides effective immunotherapy of EOC with relatively benign autoimmune complications.

Immunotherapy invited leading experts in the field to share their thoughts on two key immunotherapeutic strategies in the field of breast cancer research, vaccines and checkpoint inhibitors. Interviewed by Ellen Clarke (Commissioning Editor, Future Science Group). Historically breast cancer has been considered immunologically silent. Patients have had limited access to the types of immunotherapy available to melanoma and lung cancer patients, but this could all be set to change as recent preclinical and clinical studies have highlighted the potential of immunotherapy for breast cancer. Breast cancer is now one of the major cancer types for which new immune-based treatments are being developed.

We propose that optimized control of adult-onset cancers requires the incorporation of a defense-based strategy in the form of preemptive immunity induced in healthy cancer-free subjects prior to the appearance of tumors. However, development of such prophylactic immunity has traditionally targeted etiopathogenic agents. We propose that in the absence of available cancer-inducing pathogens, safe and effective protection against the emergence of tumors may be achieved by inducing targeted immunity against tissue-specific self-proteins that are retired' from expression at immunogenic levels in normal tissues due to the normal aging process, but are expressed in emerging tumors. Thus, retired' self-proteins may substitute for unavailable pathogens as targets for developing prophylactic immunity against tumors we confront with age like breast, ovarian and prostate cancer. Our current efforts involve testing this primary immunoprevention' strategy in clinical trials focused on prevention of the more aggressive and lethal forms of breast cancer.

Abstract Testicular cancer mainly affects men between the ages of 20 and 39, but it is the most common neoplasm in men between the ages of 15 and 34. The National Cancer Institute states that localized testicular cancer has a recurrence rate of 15-20%, and those tumors, including Sertoli or Leydig cell derived, do not respond well to chemotherapy or radiation treatment. My summer research was centered on the effort to better characterize the immune response to a testicular tumor. This was accomplished through the use of different immunology techniques such as proliferation assays, immunohistochemistry, ELISA, and ELISPOT. My lab experience inspired me to design a unit curriculum which will help elucidate the various physiognomies of tumor growth. Students first learn and apply the essential techniques of cancer cell culture. The testicular cancer cell line I-10 (CCL-83, ATCC) is used to familiarize students with routine feeding and maintenance, subculturing, counting, and cryopreservation. I-10 cell RNA is converted to cDNA and qualitatively analyzed for inhibin-alpha gene expression, which serves as a tumor marker, using RT-PCR. Then, they analyze previously formalin-fixed, paraffin embedded murine testes (normal and cancerous) using H&E staining and immunohistochemical staining for CD3, inhibin-alpha, and IgG. Upon completion of this unit, students demonstrate these learned skills in a combined written and practical examination.

Sunitinib, a protein tyrosine kinase inhibitor is the frontline therapy for renal and gastrointestinal cancers. We hypothesized that by virtue of its well documented tumor apoptosis and immune adjuvant properties, combination of Sunitinib with anti‐tumor immunotherapeutics will provide synergistic inhibition of tumor growth. Our study was designed to evaluate the impact of Sunitinib on immunotherapy mediated anti‐tumor immune responses and evaluate its efficacy as a combinatorial therapy with tumor targeted immunotherapeutic vaccination. Mice immunized with recombinant α‐lactalbumin, a lactation protein expressed on majority of breast tumors were treated with 1 mg of Sunitinib for seven consecutive days beginning (1) concurrently, on the day of α‐lactalbumin immunization or (2) sequentially, on day 9 after immunization. Ten‐day lymph nodes or 21 day spleens were tested by ELISPOT assays and flow cytometry to evaluate responsiveness to α‐lactalbumin immunization in presence of Sunitinib and distribution of cells involved in T cell antigen priming and proliferation in different lymphoid compartments. In addition, therapeutic efficacy of the α‐lactalbumin/ Sunitinib combination was evaluated by monitoring tumor growth in the 4T1 transplanted tumor model. Our studies reveal that concurrent administration of Sunitinib with active vaccination against a targeted tumor antigen inhibits priming to the immunogen due to a drastic decrease in CD11b+CD11c+ antigen presenting cells, leading to failure of vaccination. However, sequential delivery of Sunitinib timed to avoid the priming phase of vaccination results in the desired vaccination mediated boost in immune responses.

Despite the success of childhood vaccination against infectious diseases, vaccines are lacking against diseases that occur with age. We are developing a vaccine to prevent breast cancer. This article explains the vaccine strategy, how we think the vaccine will work, and how we plan to move forward through clinical trials.