Microtunnelling within the Hawkesbury Sandstone of the Sydney Basin is commonly regarded as a relatively low-risk excavation environment due to the typically competent rock conditions. However, localised geological anomalies such as igneous dykes can result in ground conditions that are highly variable over very short distances. This paper presents the forensic investigation of a microtunnel stability incident approximately 10 m below ground level beneath a critical live Sydney transport asset. The microtunnel was excavated to enable the installation of a replacement sewer pipe. The incident was associated with the presence of a highly weathered igneous dyke. The dyke zone exhibited substantially reduced rock intact and mass strength relative to the surrounding sandstone, resulting in local stability issues during excavation. The paper documents the observed instability mechanisms, emergency response measures, and staged investigation and remediation works undertaken. Investigation techniques included targeted drilling, downhole imaging, remote imaging via close-circuit television, and three-dimensional reconstruction of the affected zone to define its geometry and quantify the failure extent. These investigations were used as the basis to develop a targeted stabilisation program by grouting, followed by verification of stabilisation and permanent remediation. The sewer pipe was successfully installed following the incident and stabilisation works, and the whole area remediated.
Collapse settlement in partially saturated engineered fill poses a severe geotechnical risk to overlying infrastructure upon post-construction inundation. This paper examines a residential subdivision case study where fill certified under controlled earthworks processes exhibited significant episodic surface settlement following major rainfall events. Forensic field investigations and groundwater monitoring established that localized pockets of collapsible fill remained within the landform due to construction defects, including excessive layer thickness, uncompacted buried batters, and unremoved temporary earthworks features. These localized zones were subsequently saturated by perched water tables generated through the interaction of stormwater infrastructure and a crushed concrete bridging layer. To address the challenges of post-construction risk assessment, this study evaluates the efficacy of Cone Penetration Testing (CPT). An empirical framework mapping cone resistance directly to volumetric collapse strain is presented and successfully validated against both undisturbed laboratory oedometer testing and field settlement monitoring data.
Forensic Science is the application of science to law, essentially an in-depth examination of evidence by the application of scientific methods, principles, techniques and expertise to investigate, analyze evidence and resolve legal disputes in law. In geotechnical engineering practice, there are seven main areas where a forensic approach may be required, Inquests and Inquiries, death or serious injury in the workplace, near-miss safety incidents, serious engineering failures or collapses, construction disputes, engineering reviews undertaken when actual post construction performance is at odds with design or expectations and finally where there are serious adverse environmental outcomes; and all of the above may have some legal ramifications. Although the field of forensic science is well established, there are no mandatory sets of rules or detailed guidelines to be followed in all forensic examinations. What is required in each circumstance is function of, the nature of the legal proceedings, the particular branch of science or engineering, the seriousness of the issue, the study brief or framework as laid out by the relevant government, legal organisation, corporate entity or controlling body; the setting, the scale of the problem, the history of the site and in geotechnical engineering practice most importantly the geology. This paper includes a general discussion of legal systems, forensics, forensic science and forensic engineering. Key investigation methodologies and the role of critical thinking are explained. Also addressed are the essential characteristics associated with forensic engineers and scientists, including the expert witness role. This is followed by a discussion on the anatomy of engineering failures. The Lane Cove Tunnel is then used as an example to illustrate some important elements. Where applicable recommendations on the approaches and methodologies that have proven successful are presented. The paper is based largely on the authors personal experience, gained from more than five decades working across a wide range of engineering settings and legal frameworks. This experience is supplemented by key references that the author has found assisted in navigating the complex nexus between science and the law.
This paper condenses the authors’ experiences in dispute resolution processes, investigating and assessing geotechnical factors in ground-related problems. The contexts have included, amongst others, land instability on major infrastructure projects, excavation impacts on adjacent properties, domestic foundation movements and earthworks. The collective experience provides a basis to provide some overall findings, for the different contexts, of common issues related to the cause of geotechnical related problems. The authors discuss issues arising from various or competing interpretations of AS2870, AS3798 and AS4678 and the extent to which recommendations are followed. Understanding these issues gives a basis on which to consider how to improve geotechnical risk management in design and construction and avoid problems at source.
Introduction Rabies remains a persistent public health threat in India, while gaps in surveillance and coordination of control measures undermine progress towards ending human rabies deaths. The WHO advocates a One Health approach, combining mass dog vaccination, postexposure prophylaxis (PEP) and Integrated Bite Case Management (IBCM). IBCM is not yet incorporated into India's national rabies action plan for rabies elimination. This study seeks to generate robust evidence on the effectiveness, cost-effectiveness, feasibility, facilitators and barriers of IBCM implemented within Kerala's Rabies Control Programme.Methods and analysis This implementation research adopts a stepped-wedge cluster randomised controlled trial (RCT) design. IBCM will be implemented across six administrative blocks in Thiruvananthapuram District, Kerala, across diverse rural and urban settings and including tribal population representation. The IBCM intervention includes stakeholder training and support and active animal surveillance aligned with WHO guidance. Suspect or probable rabies exposures presenting at selected health facilities will be identified via a community-based hotline. This will trigger investigations and responses including dog vaccination and sensitisation. Prior to IBCM implementation, baseline data will be collected on management of dog bites, bite patient incidence and healthcare seeking behaviours. Hospital-based event tracking of bite cases will be conducted at enrolled public health facilities before and during IBCM implementation. The resulting RCT data will be used to model the impacts and cost-effectiveness of IBCM, including the potential for cost savings through judicious PEP if scaled across Kerala. To understand the barriers and facilitators to IBCM implementation, we will use in-depth interviews and focus group discussions with stakeholders. There is an urgent need to strengthen rabies surveillance, including coordination across health and animal health sectors and outbreak responses to accelerate rabies elimination. IBCM is expected to lead to improved PEP completion, increased detection and laboratory confirmation of rabid dogs, strengthened dog vaccination coverage and targeted outbreak responses in high-risk areas. This RCT will provide critical evidence to inform policy, support scale-up, generate insights into contextual barriers and facilitators for IBCM implementation, and guide India's One Health rabies elimination strategy. This study will evaluate a health-sector-initiated IBCM approach that identifies cases through dog-bite patients presenting to health facilities, supporting comprehensive One Health integration and improved patient care.Methods and analysis This implementation research adopts a stepped-wedge cluster randomised controlled trial (RCT) design. IBCM will be implemented across six administrative blocks in Thiruvananthapuram District, Kerala, across diverse rural and urban settings and including tribal population representation. The IBCM intervention includes stakeholder training and support and active animal surveillance aligned with WHO guidance. Suspect or probable rabies exposures presenting at selected health facilities will be identified via a community-based hotline. This will trigger investigations and responses including dog vaccination and sensitisation. Prior to IBCM implementation, baseline data will be collected on management of dog bites, bite patient incidence and healthcare seeking behaviours. Hospital-based event tracking of bite cases will be conducted at enrolled public health facilities before and during IBCM implementation. The resulting RCT data will be used to model the impacts and cost-effectiveness of IBCM, including the potential for cost savings through judicious PEP if scaled across Kerala. To understand the barriers and facilitators to IBCM implementation, we will use in-depth interviews and focus group discussions with stakeholders. There is an urgent need to strengthen rabies surveillance, including coordination across health and animal health sectors and outbreak responses to accelerate rabies elimination. IBCM is expected to lead to improved PEP completion, increased detection and laboratory confirmation of rabid dogs, strengthened dog vaccination coverage and targeted outbreak responses in high-risk areas. This RCT will provide critical evidence to inform policy, support scale-up, generate insights into contextual barriers and facilitators for IBCM implementation, and guide India's One Health rabies elimination strategy. This study will evaluate a health-sector-initiated IBCM approach that identifies cases through dog-bite patients presenting to health facilities, supporting comprehensive One Health integration and improved patient care.Ethics and dissemination The study was approved by WHO Ethics Committee (2024.9.Ind), Kerala University of Health Sciences (AX04/SOP07A/V2) and the ethics committee of Government Medical College, Thiruvananthapuram (HEC No.12/06/2024/MCT); informed written consent will be obtained from all participants, analysis will be limited to de-identified data, and findings will be disseminated through peer-reviewed publications and policy-relevant platforms.Trial registration number CTRI/2024/08/073117.