
Pedagogical content knowledge (PCK) is considered one of the key professional competencies of a teacher. In the PISA-Ceco study accompanying the Program for International Student Assessment 2022 (PISA 2022), a short scale consisting of six items was implemented to assess PCK among mathematics teachers. We examined the relationship between PCK and both teachers' level of knowledge regarding the German Bildungsstandards (educational standards; BiSta) and their attitudes toward them. Further, we investigated the role of PCK and BiSta variables for the design of cognitively activating instruction. Various operationalizations were employed to measure cognitive activation, including teachers' and students' evaluations as well as corresponding coding of collected classroom tests. The findings indicate that PCK is significantly related to the level of mathematical argumentation perceived by students in the classroom, although this effect is moderated by the type of school. Attitudes toward the BiSta do not show comparable effects.
Both PISA-Ceco 2022 and COACTIV 2003/04 measured the pedagogical content knowledge of mathematics teachers as well as aspects of instructional quality in PISA classes. The complex transformations that took place in the nearly 20 years between studies-such as the introduction of standards for mathematics instruction and teacher education, as well as factors such as migration, the COVID-19 pandemic, and digitalization-provided a rationale for monitoring potential changes in educational quality. We found no significant differences between the two large-scale studies in terms of teachers' pedagogical content knowledge. Regarding cognitive activation and classroom management, students rated teachers more highly in the COACTIV study in 2004, whereas constructive learning support was rated significantly higher for teachers in the PISA-Ceco study in 2022.Given the replication crisis in the social sciences, we deemed it reasonable to ask to what extent the correlations found in the earlier COACTIV study between pedagogical content knowledge and aspects of instructional quality, as well as findings that were surprising at the time-such as differences across school types regarding pedagogical content knowledge in favor of academic-track teachers, or the lack of correlation between pedagogical content knowledge and professional experience-could be replicated using the later PISA-Ceco data. We successfully replicated key findings from the COACTIV study, using pertinent constructs and established instruments. This is an encouraging sign-not only for this study but also for empirical educational research in general.
Der frühzeitige Berufsausstieg frühpädagogischer Fachkräfte stellt angesichts des Fachkräftemangels und eines teilweise ungedeckten Betreuungsbedarfs eine zentrale Herausforderung für die frühkindliche Bildung dar. Entscheidend für die Ableitung wirksamer Gegenmaßnahmen ist ein Verständnis der Ursachen für den Berufsausstieg. Die vorliegende Studie untersucht daher auf Basis einer quantitativen Befragung von 1566 ehemaligen frühpädagogischen Fachkräften in Österreich die Gründe für ihren Berufsausstieg sowie deren Zusammenhänge mit der subjektiv eingeschätzten Rückkehrwahrscheinlichkeit in das Berufsfeld. Es ließen sich acht zentrale Dimensionen der Ausstiegsgründe identifizieren: unzureichende strukturelle Rahmenbedingungen, Personalmangel, gesellschaftliche Rahmenbedingungen, fehlende Weiterbildungsmöglichkeiten, Aspekte der Organisationsqualität, Probleme in der Zusammenarbeit im Team und mit dem Träger, gesundheitliche Belastungen sowie persönliche Gründe. Dabei zeigte sich ein kumulatives Zusammenspiel verschiedener Faktoren: Fachkräfte, die strukturelle Gründe angaben, nannten häufiger auch gesundheitliche Gründe für ihren Ausstieg. Gesundheitliche Belastungen sowie fehlende Weiterbildungsmöglichkeiten waren zudem signifikant mit einer niedrigeren Rückkehrwahrscheinlichkeit assoziiert. Diese Befunde erweitern den bisherigen Forschungsstand um eine quantitative Perspektive auf tatsächlich erfolgte Berufsausstiege und verdeutlichen, dass insbesondere strukturelle Verbesserungen, attraktive Weiterbildungsangebote sowie gezielte Maßnahmen der Gesundheitsförderung zentral sind, um frühpädagogische Fachkräfte im Beruf zu halten bzw. zurückzugewinnen.
This article addresses the question of how organizations (co-)organize the conditions of growing up and how this (co-)organization can be ethnographically investigated. From an organizational-pedagogical and practice-theoretical perspective, it argues that organizations, as socialization arrangements for children and adolescents, negotiate and shape these conditions locally in a dynamic interplay of institutional regulations and organizational practices. To explore this interplay, the article proposes a heuristic concept that focuses on organizing as a local boundary space of trans-organizing between educational organizations as an analytical unit. Methodologically, a multi-positional ethnographic research strategy is developed, combining multi-sited ethnography, institutional ethnography, and various positions within and related to the field. Empirical examples demonstrate how this approach can be used to make co-organization visible.
The interdisciplinary project 'Schools in time of change' studies the transformation of school and teaching cultures in Germany between the 1970s and 2020s. It is based on data from the so-called 'Three-State Study' of 1978/79 by Helmut Fend (Fend b) and a follow-up survey of 2023 at the same schools with largely original questionnaires and tests. Changes in school culture (e.g. participation, achievement expectation, pedagogical orientations), teaching culture (e.g. support, structure, adaptivity) and learning outcomes are analyzed.Among the dimensions of school culture, the largest change is seen in achievement expectations, which decreased-except in the Gymnasium track. Teachers' orientation towards 'discipline and control' has increased, while their cooperation decreased. Differences between school types decreased with respect to school culture but increased with respect to academic composition and level of achievement. The results are contextualized from the perspective of the history of education.