
Since the mid-2010s, research on autocratization has expanded rapidly. This research has produced a dense family of overlapping terms, competing measurement instruments, and largely self-contained literatures on different classes of causes. This review argues that many of the field’s apparent disagreements are based on prior conceptual and methodological commitments that often remain implicit. The concept of democracy adopted determines what constitutes a decline. The chosen measurement strategy and thresholds determine how much autocratization is observed and where. Where a driver is located in the causal process determines what it can explain. The review classifies competing terms by scope and implied endpoints, traces contested empirical claims to the measurement choices that produce them, and organizes causes and drivers into structural, socioeconomic, political, institutional, societal, and international factors. Finally, it proposes how these four types of factors relate to one another and identifies the remaining unresolved conceptual and methodological problems.
This article examines how populist discourse is articulated and regionalised in two structurally similar but institutionally distinct ‘left-behind’ regions: Tees Valley in the UK and Duisburg in Germany. Through a mixed-method approach combining content analysis of regional newspapers and critical discourse analysis of mayoral speeches, the study explores how populist themes, anti-elitism, people-centrism, and anti-immigration, manifest differently across subnational contexts. In Teesside, populism is constructed through anti-elite rhetoric, regional pride, and infrastructural delivery, mobilised by an insurgent Conservative mayor. In Duisburg, an incumbent SPD mayor articulates a more technocratic and exclusionary discourse focused on immigration. These divergent patterns illustrate how populist discourse is shaped by national agendas, regional political traditions and media framing. Rather than treating populism as a monolithic or top-down phenomenon, the study conceptualises it as a territorially embedded and institutionally modulated discursive strategy. The findings contribute to the literature on populism, political communication, and territorial inequality by revealing how populist narratives travel across actors and arenas, adapting to local political opportunity structures and cultural repertoires.
Ein Großteil der Diagnosen einer Krise der Demokratie basiert auf Daten von Demokratiemessungsprojekten wie Varieties of Democracy (V-Dem). Doch innerhalb der Politikwissenschaft gibt es sowohl Kritik an den Messverfahren von V‑Dem als auch an den dahinterliegenden Demokratieverständnissen. Dieser Literaturbericht systematisiert die unterschiedlichen Kritiken an V‑Dem und zieht daraus anschließend Schlüsse für die breitere Debatte über eine (vermeintliche) Krise der Demokratie. Abschließend werden Ansätze skizziert, die die Demokratieforschung selbst demokratisieren möchten, indem sie die Demokratieverständnisse der Bevölkerung ins Zentrum politikwissenschaftlicher Demokratiemessung rücken.