
The reformed EU fiscal framework represents a fundamental shift from the previous Stability and Growth Pact by anchoring fiscal surveillance on medium-term debt sustainability considerations rather than short-term structural balance targets. This paper examines how the framework’s flexibility mechanisms and implementation choices shape future adjustment requirements and, consequently, may impact the aggregate euro area fiscal stance. Using debt simulations that replicate the Commission’s methodology, we show that the framework’s “memory” creates intertemporal linkages between current policy choices and future consolidation burdens. Looking at the implications of using the fiscal framework’s flexibility, we find that, notably for high-debt countries, future adjustment requirements can remain high and persistent. At the same time, higher potential output growth represents a powerful pathway to accelerating debt reduction, substantially reducing the required adjustment. Our findings suggest that clear communication about intertemporal trade-offs as well as their regular monitoring are important. It would help achieve compliance going forward and thus strengthen the framework’s credibility as it enters its crucial first implementation cycle.
This paper examines the role of stock-flow adjustments (SFAs) in shaping public debt dynamics and explores their implications for debt sustainability analysis (DSA). As DSA typically focuses on deficits, growth, and interest rates, SFAs are often ignored in projections of public debt. We explore empirically how SFAs have contributed to the development of public debt and analyze their time-series properties in EU member states over the last 28 years. The results show that average SFAs are not zero in several countries, contribute substantially to the development of the debt-GDP ratio over time, and represent a major source of the volatility of the debt-GDP ratio. In many cases, they also exhibit significant contemporaneous comovements with fiscal and macroeconomic shocks. These findings suggest that SFAs are an important challenge for projections of public debt and DSA. In order to improve the realism of debt projections, forecasters could take account of both expected SFAs as well as the covariance structure of SFA shocks.
Properly measuring the extent of over-allocation requires constructing a meaningful counterfactual. We propose an approach that exploits a policy change in the allocation of certificates in 2013, when the third phase of the European Emissions Trading System (ETS) started. From then onward, electricity producers were no longer granted free allocations, in contrast to all other installations endowed with certificates. By comparing these groups, we assess how installations would have behaved in Phase 3, had they still received freely allocated certificates as the control group did. Compared to Phase 2, electricity producers in Phase 3 held, on average, 424,680 fewer certificates, while emissions, sales, and purchases did not change. We interpret these findings as being indicative of over-allocation. Relative to the number of certificates awarded to the electricity-generating installations in Phase 2, over-allocation amounts to 64 %.
We develop a behavioral model that generates wealth-driven bubbles in speculative asset markets whose fundamental value is zero. These dynamics arise from a feedback loop between asset prices and speculators' wealth: rising prices increase their wealth, leading them to demand more of the asset, which pushes prices even higher. Bubbles burst when prices become excessively high, prompting speculators to lose confidence and reduce their market exposure. The market may subsequently experience another bubble or collapse to its fundamental value, terminating the dynamics.