
Abstract This article argues that personal and ecclesial formation were mutually dependent in Watchman Nee’s account of Christian maturity. Reading The Spiritual Man and The Normal Christian Life alongside his lesser-known instructions for converts and workers and his writings on church life, it traces how Nee’s anthropology connected the reordering of the believer’s faculties with participation in the body of Christ. The anthropological framework of spirit and soul, and the account of sanctification flowing from it supplied criteria for judging the speech and conduct of less mature believers with the goal of individual growth realisable only within the corporate body. Spiritual judgement thus emerges as a practice through which Nee’s anthropology was intended to shape congregational life. The article also considers a possible difficulty within this practice. Despite Nee’s considerable restraints upon delegated authority in his teachings, if resistance to a judgement of spiritual immaturity could itself be treated as evidence of further soulish independence in the same person, this could short-circuit the potential to examine whether or not the initial judgement itself arose from greater spiritual light.
Abstract Many theologians and philosophers defend the claim according to which significant human free will is compatible with divine determinism. This article seeks to contribute to the development of theological compatibilism by examining the relationship of agential phenomenology and divine determinism – an issue which is often overlooked in the literature. We are especially interested in how divine deterministic causation is experienced in the process of coming to faith. We draw from Augustine’s letter ep . 2*, where he makes interesting remarks about agential phenomenology and the divine will. The argument is that Augustine’s view opens up significant new options for compatibilists, where the agent might experience her mental actions as her own despite the fact that they are deterministically caused by God. We will begin the article by outlining the basic issues and terms. We will then go on to articulate Augustine’s account of free will and divine will, which we consider compatibilist in nature. Then, we will examine Augustine’s views in ep . 2* and their rhetorical context. Finally, we will consider some objections to Augustine’s account.
Abstract This article develops a constructive pneumatological theology of the Eucharist in conversation with Wolfhart Pannenberg. It takes Pannenberg’s reflections on the relationship between the Holy Spirit and the Lord’s Supper as a point of departure for exploring the pneumatological interrelation of eucharistic presence, anamnesis, ecclesial communion, transformation, and eschatological anticipation. By bringing Pannenberg’s theological insights into conversation with biblical texts and broader Christian traditions, the article argues that Christ’s eucharistic presence can be understood as mediated through the Spirit, who unites believers with the risen Christ and constitutes the church as his body. Eucharistic participation thereby emerges not merely as sacramental remembrance, but as a transformative and hermeneutical event in which the Spirit shapes the church’s perception of Christ and draws the community into God’s eschatological future. Pannenberg’s eschatological pneumatology finally provides resources for extending this account toward the renewal of creation. The Eucharist thus appears as a pneumatological participation in God’s coming renewal of humanity, community, and creation.
Abstract This article critically reassesses the Orthodox-Lutheran agreed statements of Crete 1987 and Sandbjerg 1993, with particular attention to their conception of Tradition and its relationship to the ecumenical councils and Scripture. While acknowledging the substantial theological convergence achieved in these documents, the article argues that important conceptual ambiguities remain concerning the nature of Tradition itself. It suggests that these ambiguities arise not merely from the dialogue between the two traditions but also from the neopatristic conceptualization of Tradition reflected in the agreed statements. Through a theological analysis of the dialogue documents, the study examines the implications of understanding Tradition primarily as the life of the Church in the Holy Spirit and identifies several unresolved questions concerning its relationship to Scripture and its concrete historical expressions, including the ecumenical councils. It then explores Sergius Bulgakov’s conception of Tradition as a constructive theological resource for addressing these questions.
Abstract This paper examines how Emmanuel Levinas and Sri Aurobindo – writing under political captivity in a Nazi labor camp and a British colonial prison respectively – transfigured imprisonment into a site of ontological transformation. Employing critical realism and comparative hermeneutics, it treats their canonical works as primary sources while situating their visions within twentieth-century Europe and colonial India. The paper argues that both thinkers locate the divine encounter in the crucible of suffering: for Levinas, ethical awakening before the face of the Other; for Aurobindo, the descent of the Divine into matter. Their prison writings converge on a shared structure of redemptive suffering, wherein transcendence reveals itself through immanence and freedom is redefined as inner participation rather than negation of finitude. This comparative insight positions both thinkers within an intercultural religious thought of transformation – one that views historical suffering not as rupture, but as the medium through which the sacred becomes manifest in human consciousness.