
At the end of 17th century, probability calculus paved the way for the mathematization of moral certainty which led to a rethinking of the classical categories of certainty. Jacob Bernoulli's Ars Conjectandi (1713) outlined a new epistemological model based on the mathematical measurement of probability and a new way of approaching the problem of uncertainty of knowledge. Bernoulli's "art of conjecturing" posits probability as an irreducible property of certain fields and modalities of knowledge, but one that can be objectified through mathematical measurement and thus positively integrated into knowledge as an objective property. Between the practical field of decision-making for action and the theoretical field of natural philosophy, Bernoulli's art of conjecturing seeks to develop a new epistemological space that challenges these traditional disciplinary boundaries.
In early modern ethics, the presumption of goodness was seen as a solution to uncertainty about the personal qualities of others. What was sought at the time was an explanation of the proper meaning of goodness and what makes the presumption of goodness rational. These questions were discussed insightfully by Samuel Pufendorf, Christian Thomasius, and Christian Wolff. However, their discussions led to divergent conceptions of the proper meaning of goodness. Thomasius argued that considering the limits of human rationality favors limiting the presumption of goodness to the presumption of non-delinquency. Pufendorf and Wolff, on the other hand, argued that considerations concerning natural obligations indicate that ethical aspects should be included in the presumption of goodness. What makes these approaches commensurable is the use of common forms of knowledge : "commonplaces" in Pufendorf's case, "common sense" in Thomasius's case, and "common notions" in Wolff's case.