
Abstract This article responds to the eight essays of the special issue on The Critical Shusterman published in Contemporary Pragmatism 23:3 (2026). Building on the wide-ranging arguments presented in the eight essays, Shusterman’s response treats the topics of interpretation, affect, atmosphere, irony, embodiment, ethics and social criticism, art, pleasure, performance, gastronomy, and autobiography. In doing so, the article clarifies his key positions on pragmatism and somaesthetics, while offering fresh perspectives on the continuing value of experience for philosophy beyond the conventional epistemological frame, thus suggesting new directions for a neopragmatist philosophy of experience aimed at shared qualitative enrichment.
Abstract Shusterman’s philosophical proposal is one of the most original strands of contemporary aesthetics, owing to its ability to adapt to very different contexts and fields. My aim is to compare Shusterman’s proposal with another branch of contemporary aesthetics known as performative aesthetics, particularly as proposed by Erika Fischer-Lichte. This comparison allows us to highlight certain aspects of Shusterman’s proposal that have received less attention, yet merit further exploration. My paper is structured as follows. Starting with Shusterman’s definition of art as “dramatization,” I will analyze the possibility of introducing into somaesthetics the distinction between “ mise en scène ” (or staging) and “performance” as theorized by Fischer-Lichte.The aim is to show how the latter notion is more in line with somaesthetics, given the body’s inherently uncontrollable nature. Moreover, I will focus on the broader relationship between art and life in the two philosophical currents: I will argue that, while performative aesthetics remains on the threshold, somaesthetics crosses it in a more radical way. Finally, the relationship between art and life is linked to the question of understanding aesthetic experience. While performative aesthetics asserts that understanding must be confined to the outside of the performance, Shusterman emphasizes that aesthetic experience includes understanding, which he differentiates from interpretation. This does not imply that Shusterman is taking a step backwards in favour of a linguisticistic approach, but rather a step forwards towards a more holistic, integrated and continuistic conception of aesthetic experience, not limited to mere perception.
Abstract Anthologies rearrange the texts they preserve. They establish continuities between them, and occasionally bring into view trajectories that remained invisible while the essays stood apart. This paper examines what The Critical Shusterman accomplishes that Pragmatist Aesthetics and Thinking Through the Body did not, by focusing on the first four chapters of the collection. Read in their editorial sequence, these essays reveal the gradual emergence of a philosophical project that the original publications did not make visible: a pragmatist reconstruction of experience as a qualitative, transactional field, neither foundationalist nor textualist. “Foundation or Reconstruction?”, set in a central position, retroacts on “Beneath Interpretation” and projects forward onto “Organic Unity” and “Affective Cognition,” serving as an operator of retrospective coherence. The anthology thus renders visible the conceptual archaeology of somaesthetics: the moves by which experience was reconstructed as a qualitative field, unity given a pragmatic sense, and cognition grounded in affect. In doing so it transmits these foundations to those already building on them.
Abstract This article examines the argument from indiscernibles in Richard Shusterman’s “The End of Aesthetic Experience.” While Shusterman deploys the case to critique interpretivist reductions of aesthetic experience, we argue that its structure deviates in instructive ways from Arthur Danto’s indiscernibility arguments. After diagnosing this deviation, we draw on Bence Nanay’s account of aesthetic experience as interaction to reconceive the case in terms of activity and engagement.
Abstract This article focuses on Richard Shusterman’s contributions to the art and ethics of social criticism. It situates Shusterman’s writings within a tradition of pragmatic and pluralistic philosophers who have thought deeply about the historical and cultural terms of philosophical inquiry, especially John Dewey. Particular attention is given to Shusterman’s analyses of embodiment, aesthetic and moral value, and philosophical pluralism. The article demonstrates how Shusterman’s contributions are evident across the following themes: his philosophical vision, his topography of methods and morals, and his aesthetic touch (or philosophical style). It further shows how Shusterman’s way of pursuing these topics is instructive for the future of pragmatic philosophy.