
This article invites mainstream language policy research to discover the potential of normative political theory to help stimulate new thinking on matters of linguistic justice, specifically in the context of the linguistic integration of newcomers in a multilingual world. Further developing the “normative language policy” framework, devised to bridge empirical research in sociolinguistics and applied linguistics and ethical debates in normative political theory, it examines three key questions: (i) To what extent should host societies’ language policymaking take the interests of newcomers into account?; (ii) How might the demands of linguistic integration be reconciled with efforts to protect and promote established minority or minoritised languages?; and (iii) Is there a legitimate role to be played by English as a lingua franca (ELF) to facilitate integration in non-anglophone contexts? Aiming to foster the development of shared epistemologies related to language, power and ethics, the article makes the case for a new interdisciplinarity in language policy research, with a view to offering a constructive, practical and principled pathway for devising more just language policies in integration contexts and beyond.
Abstract This article invites mainstream language policy research to discover the potential of normative political theory to help stimulate new thinking on matters of linguistic justice, specifically in the context of the linguistic integration of newcomers in a multilingual world. Further developing the “normative language policy” framework, devised to bridge empirical research in sociolinguistics and applied linguistics and ethical debates in normative political theory, it examines three key questions: (i) To what extent should host societies’ language policymaking take the interests of newcomers into account?; (ii) How might the demands of linguistic integration be reconciled with efforts to protect and promote established minority or minoritised languages?; and (iii) Is there a legitimate role to be played by English as a lingua franca (ELF) to facilitate integration in non-anglophone contexts? Aiming to foster the development of shared epistemologies related to language, power and ethics, the article makes the case for a new interdisciplinarity in language policy research, with a view to offering a constructive, practical and principled pathway for devising more just language policies in integration contexts and beyond.
While acknowledging the innovative thrust of the sociolinguistics of globalization as a dominant branch of sociolinguistics in the first quarter of the 21st century, this paper questions some of its sweeping generalizations when it comes to portraying the contributions of 'older' branches of sociolinguistics (including so-called 'Fishmanian sociolinguistics') to the advancement of the study of language in society. By respectfully drawing on the work of a variety of scholars, it seeks to highlight how a systematic historiography of the ideas, beliefs, and conceptual frameworks that have shaped and continue to shape sociolinguistics can help to offer a richer and more nuanced sense of its colorful past as a basis to face some of the societal challenges ahead. It is argued that such an approach could be particularly beneficial for language policy and planning as a field of study that seeks to bridge the divide between academia and real life.
This article tests how Kazakhstan’s onomastic status-planning works in practice by asking: (RQ1) how coherent are the governing instruments — laws, decrees, registries, commissions — and how are responsibilities allocated; and (RQ2) how closely do public labels align with canonical forms. We code instrument coherence from legal texts and audit 17,846 deduplicated State Catalogue settlement entries against OpenStreetMap populated-place features. Results show that goals are specified, but procedures for interoperability and catalogue-platform synchronization are only partly operationalized. The broad linkage model yielded 6,439 linked OSM populated-place features against 17,846 deduplicated State Catalogue settlement entries. Among the 5,104 linked features carrying a Kazakh name:kk label, 2,899 (56.8%) matched the State Catalogue exactly. We propose low-cost operational measures — routine catalogue change records, character-encoding guidance, and regional monitoring — to raise alignment during Kazakhstan’s script transition. The design is replicable for other toponymic standardization regimes.