
In Italy, co-design processes are increasingly implemented in urban and social regeneration projects, fostering community empowerment in decision-making. This has unlocked the potential of empowering local communities in the decision-making process. However, limitations emerge from the point of view of the co-design regulation. To avoid co-design becoming a tick-box exercise, it is essential to rethink the top-down approaches to ethically setting and running co-design processes. Based on Reggio Emilia's Neighbourhood Common Good ('Quartiere Bene Comune') experience, this chapter defines a set of successful elements, shifting from models of representative democracy (political delegation to the ballot box) and deliberative democracy (listening and internalising the 'voice' of communities in public decisions) to a collaborative democracy that emphasises shared responsibilities in decision-making, resource allocation and evaluation. Starting from an analysis of the outcomes of the past decade (2015-2025) and the phases adopted during the process, this chapter identifies the key elements of a successful and ethical example of a collaborative democracy model, intending to answer the question 'What are the key features of Quartiere Bene Comune that have generated change and innovation in the co-design process experimented by the local authority?' The authors' findings provide an important tool for public policy to mitigate power imbalances through multi-actor partnerships, evidence-based regulations and renegotiating hierarchical practices to amplify bottom-up protagonism. This study highlights the importance of embedding these principles in policy and practice to create ethical and effective co-design frameworks. Local authorities can ensure that co-design processes achieve meaningful and sustainable impacts by fostering collaboration and equitable decision-making.
This chapter examines the case of Cavallerizza Reale in Turin, an extensive historical building complex that has been occupied and transformed into a site of artistic production and commoning experimentation. Drawing on long-term fieldwork, the authors' contribution focuses on this ephemeral but very revealing experience, which encapsulates many of the risks that commonly afflict commons. By outlining the tensions between two factions within this large community, the so-called politicians and the artists, and their divergent political visions of self-government, the authors expose two different conceptions of commoning. On the one side, the authors explore the community's relationship with local institutions, particularly the attempts to establish a commons-public partnership, and how a legalistic conception of the commons affects the role of rules in the everyday life of this community. At the same time, the authors will look closely at commoning practices among the 'artists', using the critical tools from the anthropology of art to highlight both their potential and their limits. In both cases, the authors emphasise the friction between the aim of carrying out processes of commoning within the community and the necessity of dealing with external urban actors, such as the municipality, the mainstream art world and other economic actors. Acknowledging that many members of the community perceived this experience as fleeting and fragile, the authors propose a perspective that overcomes the conventional success/failure dichotomy.
In the last 20 years, urban commons have been the foundation of many urban initiatives that have created community spaces for practicing collaboration, forms of shared social responsibility, imagining socially innovative practices and regenerating common spaces and places. A field of practices has sparked an increasingly structured debate that seeks to identify the perspectives and ambiguities of these processes to trace their 'contours' and boundaries. Some of these initiatives, such as community hubs and cultural centres, focus on the (re)generation of the commons and serve as experimental spaces for new forms of political subjectivation through commoning and self-governance. These practices span different areas of social action, with various origins and degrees of institutionalisation. This chapter explores, without claiming to provide definitive categories, the relationship between space, community and common goods, proposing some analytical trajectories that emerge from the reference literature and several years of research on urban commoning processes in the city of Bologna. Using three typical cases, this chapter provides a frame for the systematisation of urban commoning development, taking into account the following variables: the 'top-down-bottom-up' dynamics; the forms of space governance; the relationship between regenerated/managed space and the city in terms of access, accessibility and exchange; whether or not there is attention to a 'commoning' of resources and their regeneration in terms of commoning understood as a social practice.
Between 2012 and 2017, an abandoned barracks located in the Italian city of Bologna was squatted and renovated by a group of young people, culminating in the establishment of Lucha, a self-managed centro sociale (social centre). Within Lucha, a wide range of social projects (such as a kindergarten, a shelter for homeless people, a library, a pizzeria and a microbrewery) and public events (e.g. concerts, seminars, public screenings of movies and documentaries) were organised with the ambition "to give back a square to the city". Using ethnographic data, including field notes and interviews with activists, this chapter analyses Lucha as an example of a "utopia of care" (Fano Morrissey & Serughetti, 2024). In dialogue with studies on commoning, the analysis aims to shed light on the daily "practices of care" through which the space was managed, as well as to examine the use of "narratives of care" to defend the squatting and its activities. In this exploration, the chapter draws upon feminist perspectives to recognise care, love and solidarity as "cultural residuals of hope" (Lynch, 2022) and their key role in the everyday organising of prefigurative politics.
The Commons have been described both as an ethic of political action and as a political principle aimed at self-governance. This implies that they possess an ideological framework able to withstand the principal regulatory institutions of our times, that is: representative democracy, capitalism and neoliberalism. Despite more than two decades of existence, this counter-model has not reached its ideological goal. Conversely, the more the commons spread and multiply as an "empty signifier" within repertoires of collective action and among public opinion, the more that neoliberal forces colonise urban environments. A different, and less radical, theoretical approach (notably put forth by Arena) addresses urban commons as tools for reshaping the relationship among citizens and local administration which arises in "collaborative governance" ("shared administration") in Italy. This approach has also displayed is limits, particularly in terms of the depolitisation and bureaucratisation of urban ecosystems and citizens' activism. If the preceding assumptions are indeed correct, what are the empirical function of urban commons? The argument put forth in this chapter is that urban commons serve an "expressive" role for certain groups that may be considered "avant-garde" in terms of cognitive resources and critical weltanschauung. The aforementioned argument is validated through the analysis of case studies in the municipalities of Bologna, Rome and Naples.